Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for this advanced reader's copy and the opportunity to read this early. Review has been posted on Waterstones and Amazon.

Unique twist on a traditional tale

The story introduces us to Évike, an outcast in her pagan village due to her lack of magical abilities and mixed heritage, which the villagers view as corrupt. When soldiers from the Holy Order of Woodsmen arrive to take a pagan girl as a blood sacrifice for the king, Évike is betrayed by her own people and chosen as the offering. However, things take a turn when their journey is interrupted by monstrous attacks, leaving only Évike and the mysterious, one-eyed captain, Gáspár Bárány, as survivors. As it turns out, Gáspár is not just any Woodsman but a disgraced prince with his own agenda.

The plot takes readers from a dense, enchanted forest to a grim, politically charged capital, weaving through battles with mythological creatures and encounters with ancient magic. The atmosphere is dark and brutal, fitting the tone of a world where survival is a constant struggle.

I must admit, that the writing style was a bit of a struggle for me. While the prose is undeniably rich and descriptive, I found it teetering on the edge of being overly indulgent. There were times when I felt like I was wading through a forest of metaphors and vivid descriptions that slowed down the pacing significantly. I’m someone who loves a lush, atmospheric setting, but in The Wolf and the Woodsman, it often felt like the narrative was losing itself in the details, at the expense of forward momentum.

Another aspect that stood out was the heavy reliance on mythology and folklore. Reid pulls from a blend of Hungarian and Jewish mythological elements, creating a unique and diverse world that feels fresh in the fantasy genre. However, I couldn’t shake the feeling that there was just too much mythology being thrust at the reader. Every few pages, the characters would pause to recount tales of gods, magic origins, or legends, which, while intriguing, caused the main plot to drag for me. I found myself wanting to get back to the actual story instead of being sidetracked by yet another mythological anecdote. This might be a delight for readers who adore a fairytale-esque narrative with rich lore, but for me, it felt like it detracted from the story’s urgency.

I did enjoy the characters, particularly the way Reid handled their complexities and backgrounds. Évike’s journey as an outcast learning to harness her own identity and power was compelling, and Gáspár’s conflict between his duty, heritage, and personal convictions added depth to his character. However, I wasn’t a fan of the romance between Évike and Gáspár. It felt very much like instalove—there’s this sudden, intense attraction that didn’t feel fully earned. I would have preferred a slower burn, especially given the darker tone of the book.

Overall, The Wolf and the Woodsman is a dark and gritty fantasy tale that excels in atmosphere and cultural depth but falls short in pacing and plot execution. I appreciate the ambition behind Reid’s debut and the way she brings underrepresented mythologies to the forefront of fantasy literature. It’s brutal, filled with creatures that don’t tell stories but devour you whole, and it’s unapologetically cruel in its portrayal of a world divided by magic, religion, and power. If you enjoy books that are rich in folklore this one might be worth picking up. However, if you’re looking for a fast-paced fantasy or a well-developed romance, this might not quite hit the mark.

Another mythological read, something that normally works super well for me, and yet I think the romance in this was what lead it to fall slightly short of the mark I wanted it to hit. I did however really like the characters and the allegories to real life politics. The religious aspects in particular were really powerful.

I definitely like Reid's writing style and will be checking out more from her in the future.

"The Wolf and the Woodsman" by Ava Reid is a dark and evocative tale that weaves together elements of folklore and history into a rich tapestry of narrative. Reid's debut novel draws on the cultural heritage of her Jewish background and Hungarian history, infusing the fantasy genre with a refreshing perspective.

Set in a world reminiscent of a medieval Eastern Europe, the story follows Évike, a young pagan woman with no magical powers in a village of forest-dwelling worshippers. When the feared Woodsman comes to take a girl to the capital, Évike is betrayed and handed over. The tale unfolds as she is thrust into a journey fraught with danger, religious persecution, and political intrigue.

It offers a unique twist on the traditional fantasy novel, grounding fantastical elements in a world that feels lived-in and real. It is a story that does not hesitate to delve into the complexities of identity, faith, and the struggle against oppression.

"The Wolf and the Woodsman" may tread through dense thematic forests at times, the journey is ultimately rewarding for those who appreciate a fantasy that does not gloss over the grimmer aspects of its world. Reid's novel is a promising start that will leave readers looking forward to her future works.

Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review.

GoodReads Review poseted: 11 Sep 2021

TW:
Gore
Torture
Self harm
Animal death
Antisemitism
Culture genocide and ethnic cleansing
Physical abuse by parents and parental figures

"They don't have to go to the effort of striking you down if you're already on your knees"

Filled with Hungarian history and Jewish mythologythis was a stunning debut novel from Ava Reid. With rish world building, complex characters, pagan magic, slow burn enimies-to-lovers and forbidden romance, what's there not to love?

2.5 stars

Évike lives in a village in the middle of the forest, where the women all have magical powers. All, that is, apart from Évike who is treated as an outcast.
The cruel king takes a girl from the village for their powers, and this time Évike is taken away by the king's Woodsmen.
When Évike and the Woodsmen are attacked on their journey, only Évike and one of the Woodsmen survive - Gáspár, the disgraced prince whose fanatical half-brother is scheming to take over the throne.
The duo reluctantly agree to work together, and will encounter many dangers on their journey.

The blurb for this really intrigued me and I was looking forward to reading it. However, I ended up disappointed.
Évike was an OK protagonist - I liked her but I didn't connect with her or feel invested in what happened to her.
None of the characters particularly stood out to me, but Évike did have some interesting relationships with other characters.
The concepts of the magic and the different gods/religions were interesting.
The plot was enjoyable to begin with, but after a while I started to lose interest and I did consider stopping reading.
I'm disappointed that I didn't enjoy this more, but I can see other people enjoying this more.

Overall, this was a mixed read.

I had high expectations of this book but sadly, this was not the book for me.
Too much gore, mutilation. I was not sold on the romance. The characters came off as immature and underdeveloped. We get Jewish rep in a fantasy setting, but I am not Jewish and can't really evaluate it. The overall story was unsettling for me and I couldn't enjoy it.
I found the exploration of the conflicts and similarities between religions and paganism interesting but the execution was not very good.

I really enjoyed the Jewish mythology woven into the story, however I had difficulties connecting with the characters, as I felt they were quite ‘standard’ and lacking a bit of depth.

I had to DNF this at 50% as it just wasn't gripping me. I'm not sure if it was the writing or just the characters but I wasn't feeling any connection to the main characters. It's such a shame as I was so excited for this book and I would have loved to enjoy this.

Thank you to the publishers for a free copy in exchange for an honest review.

I really enjoyed this. I liked the fairytale style of writing and the idea of magic requiring a sacrifice. The romance was great too, a lovely slow burn enemies to lovers and lots of chemistry between Evike and Gaspar. The plot was great too, with plenty of tension and opportunities for betrayal.

I received an ARC of this book via netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Compared to books such Spinning Silver and The Bear and the Nightingale ought to have made me think about reading this one; neither of those books filled me with the love of a good book. The former author has written many much better books. This one has no real lyricism to the writing that would take you from one event to the next. Instead it feels like a constantly changing narrative with too many characters and too many inter- nicene battles. I never really got hold of the complexities, who had what gift or who had who's support. It was a very difficult and laborious read. The ending in particular was seriously uninspiring with little seeming to have changed.

This was very much a book of two halves for me. I found the first half a bit slow and found my attention wavering whilst I was reading. However, once the story moved to the city, I found the narrative much more engaging. I loved all of the folkloric tales woven into the narrative and thought that these really added to the atmosphere. Unfortunately, I didn't find the relationship between the main characters particularly interesting and this contributed to the slowness in the first half. Overall, I think this was a good book with some fascinating commentary on religion, but the pacing was a problem for me.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for a fair and honest review.

It was painfully slow and uneventful, DNFed halfway through. Despite an interesting background, the plot itself dragged horribly. I was initially really intrigued by where the events were leading, but at some point I stopped caring - it seemed all that was happening was walking from place to place, and the stops along the way failed to grab my attention. There was no tension, just another "obstacle" to check off.
The main characters didn't particularly earn my affection - moreover, their romance followed a classic "we hate each other, but the lust is just too strong", which is the flavor of enemies-to-lovers that I personally can't stand.
Overall, wasted potential.

Firstly, a huge thank you to Del Rey UK and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.

I hate that it has taken me so long to get round to reading this book, but I'm so pleased I have finally had the time to read it! I adored this book and completely understand why everyone had been talking about the novel on Twitter for months before, and after, its release! It's definitely one that is going to stay with me for a long time and I will closely be following Reid's future works. Reid's writing is simply superb, from the characters to the descriptions, to the dialogue, everything simply felt right and all flowed together wonderfully. The balance between the unsettling moments and characters with the hints of romance was just right and a joy to read.

Our protagonist, Évike, was brilliant she was feisty and flawed which had me fall for her instantly. Unlike the other pagan women, she doesn't have the ability to use 'magic' yet instead of pining for this power, she learned that it was a blessing in disguise as it meant she would never be taken by the Woodsmen. Well, until now that is. I loved how complex each character was, regardless of how much we would see them throughout the novel. Each character we're introduced to has such a strong presence which I really enjoyed, even if the character wasn't likeable.

When it comes to the characters, the way that Reid has written how they interact with each other made them feel like genuine people and it became so easy to become absorbed into their world. Of course, I can't talk about character interaction without mentioning Évike and the quiet, broody, Woodsman Gáspár. I loved their dynamic; the pacing of their relationship was so well done, you slowly see them grow and develop but never abandon who they are as individuals and their own values. They complemented each other so well in temperament and in their beliefs.

Reid expertly navigates the different beliefs and cultures that are introduced in this novel, not only as their own entities but also as parallels to religions in our own world. Not only did these parallels further captivate me and pull me into the world as it made the world feel even more real, especially because of the little details that are brought to each one; but it also did a brilliant job of building the intense tension of fear and unease that many characters, of differing cultures, felt at the hands of Gáspár's cruel brother.

Overall, there are so many more things I could say about this novel, however, none would be able to do this novel the justice it deserves. This book is a definite must-read for those who like the darker side of folktales. I'm thrilled I've finally experienced this novel, however, I'm sad that I will never be able to read it for the first time again.

An excellent novel drawing on Jewish folk lore, unlike anything I've read before. This is a claustrophobic tale of acceptance and finding your family, even though they might not be who you think they are.

A perfect debut by a marvellous author. The Wolf and The Woodsman is good book that everyone who likes a good story. Ava Reid is a author to be watched.

This was beautifully written, and I wanted to learn more about the lore and mythology of this world, but sadly the main characters made that impossible for me; they simply got on my nerves and I found myself rolling my eyes at their actions at times. However I'd still be interested in reading Ava Reid's future works.

Spoiler alert/

Somehow the second book I've read this month where blood right turns out to be a sexy theme and makes me go D: In this one our prince is being overtaken in every way by his more charming more popular half brother who obviously is also super evil to facilitate Gaspar's sexily legitimate claim to the throne. The book is also about belonging & the difficulties of mixed heritage which is always a theme I appreciate reading about but it ends up feeling really clumsy in this book because they talk about race in (fantasy-appropriate) terms of "blood" and they talk about right to the throne in terms of "blood" and...perhaps you can see where this is going. It is heartwarming that Evike comes to this realisation: "For so long I’d thought my mixed blood a curse, blamed it for the absence of Isten’s magic. [Now] I think that blood cannot be either blessing or curse. It can only be." And it would work way way better if the literal previous page hadn't had Gaspar answering the question "By what right do you claim the throne" with "Birthright. Blood." Please didn't someone notice this. It ruins your themes! Is blood a neutral quantity with no bearing on you or is it a symbol of divine right to rule! It can't be both! Oh my god. I think I need to start avoiding royalty books. I'm frothing at the mouth

For a story that so explicitly makes itself about - among other things - where its protagonists Belong, there's remarkably little done with the theme. Towards the end of the book I actually became convinced that Evike would end up resettling with her father in the Yehuli part of town not necessarily because she had gone on a journey of learning her heritage & carving out a place for herself (she goes to temple 1 time) but because it was the only other place open to her and I was sure she wouldn't end up back in her hateful hometown. Surprise, she ends up in her hateful hometown! She even mentions that her peers still dislike her and want to call her names! They don't though because she's a war hero now. Gaspar definitely seemed unhappy in the capital city but at the end of the book has been crowned and is still in the capital city. I don't get the feeling that either of them have found any sense of belonging or peace, only that they've proven themselves useful and thus aren't treated like crap by everyone around them anymore. Which is not quite the resolution I was hoping for!

My final point of contention with this book was with its magic, mostly that it existed so tangibly. The empire is exporting their gods to its subjects, and resisting them are the pagans in nature and the Yehuli who are extremely unambiguous fantasy Jewish people. Which is fine except all the gods are real -- the pagan gods, the Yehuli god, and the empire gods all coexist, apparently, and each group can do different magic through their worship. This one boggled me, actually. I really feel like you can't import earth world religious persecution to a fantasy land where all the gods are real and worshipping them has real, tangible results. Am I being unfair?? I've never been religious, I'm coming at this like an alien. I can see the argument that faith-based belief wouldn't be affected by the presence or absence of actual miraculous action so persecution would be the same but I have a hard time believing it.

Anyway look. I didn't hate this book. I thought it was fine. I liked that there was Jewish inspired fantasy! I really slowed down at the end because that's when all these themes were coalescing into a shape I disliked but a book has every right to do that. If nothing else I did truly feel like the text was trying to express its various ideas throughout and that was enough to keep me engaged and at least somewhat interested. I am glad to be done though

Oh how I adore the fantasy books that have come out this year! It has honestly been almost overwhelming how many good books made their appearance, which is why I took longer to get to The Wolf and the Woodsman than I intended to. But oh how my patience was rewarded. I honestly couldn't have asked for anything more during the one cold, dark winternight in which I read this book. Thanks to Random House UK, Cornerstone and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

The Wolf and the Woodsman is a novel about differences and whether they can be bridged. Religion plays a major role in this book, both in the organized and in the personal sense. We get aspects of nation-building, extremism, and the propaganda required to keep those two going. While this novel depicts these things, it is in no way an endorsement or understanding participant in these. Reid unflinchingly shows the dark side of these undertakings, the way in which it not just victimizes minorities but actively persecutes them. These are heavy themes, but they are important to address in fiction, specifically in a genre like Fantasy which has so often, at times unconsciously, peddled in racist caricatures and positive representations of imperialism. The Wolf and the Woodsman is a great example of how fiction can help readers consider and address these themes, without overwhelming them.

Évike is a wolf-girl, except... not really. She has no powers to speak of and her father was an outsider to the village, a Yehuli taxman. After her mother is taken by the Woodsmen, she grows up under the begrudging tutelage of Virag, ignored or bullied by the rest of the village. So when someone has to be handed over to the Woodsmen as tribute no one blinks an eye when Évike is offered up. So begins an adventure in which Évike is forced to confront her own concepts of herself, her origin, religion, and her role in the larger scheme of things. The Wolf and the Woodsman is a novel full of powerful questions and themes which are always at play under the surface yet never entirely overwhelm the plot. While the stark differences between Évike and Gáspár consistently cause angst and confusion, they also contirbute to the delicious tension that runs throughout the novel. I adored Évike, with her stubbornness, her aching desire to fit in, and her blazing passion. Gáspár is a great foil for her, with a more quiet, if no less fiery, passion and an awareness that strength must sometimes be hidden until the right moment. The wider set of characters each brought something vital to the story and felt like fully realized people, with their own thoughts, emotions and histories. A slight exception may what we could call the "main villain", but as we don't get a real perspective into their mind that may be expected.

I absolutely adored Ava Reid's writing. The way she incorporates tales into her story, as well as the focus on understanding one's self through the tales we tell. It is how I read books, in an attempt to put my own feelings and thoughts and ideas into words. Seeing this reflected on the page is beautiful. As someone who grew up religious and steeped in mythology and fairy tales, I found much to connect with. What really stood out to me in The Wolf and the Woodsman is the beautiful world-building. Reid mixed Hungarian, Scandinavian and Jewish mythology to create a world that feels lived in, but also a world of stark differences. I loved the extensive and loving portrayal of the Yehuli, who represent the Jewish people, and the care taken in showing their traditions and beliefs. The marketing compared this novel to The Bear and the Nightingale and they do share a similar tone, in that folklore and mystique hums throughout the entire novel. A mild warning, this novel does contain scenes of violence and abuse, physical and emotional, both by others and by people to themselves. Ava Reid herself described it as a "magic system based on body horror" (Source). I do believe this is well-explained and worked into the story, in the sense that there is a reason for it and it is contextualized well, but it may be triggering to people nonetheless. I can't wait to read more by Ava Reid, I am utterly in love.

The Wolf and the Woodsman was absolutely worth me waiting for the right time to read it. I devoured it in less than 24 hours, utterly bewitched and enchanted, but also wiser after reading. Treat yourself this Christmas, while the nights are still dark.

I loved this so much more than I can put into works. I think this world was one of the best fantasy worlds I have ever read. These characters were absolutely amazing, the love between the two main characters made my heart swell. I loved it.