
Member Reviews

I liked that the mystery includes both the grandmother and her thirteen-year-old grandaughter, a new take on amateur sleuthing. Most of the interest for me is in the personalities of the two and their relationship, very much of people in two different generations.
The plot itself is not as clever or unusual in my opinion, and I could at one point see where it was going. I think the book relies on the personalities of the two sleuths rather than on any plot or story interest.

Where Everything Seems Double is the seventh book in the Gina Gray Investigation series by Penny Freedman but my first book to read by this author – but certainly not my last as I will have to read the other six now since this one was so good. Loved Gina, the main character. Great read. #WhereEverythingSeemsDouble #NetGalley

This book had a great plot but I didnt connect with the characters or the writing style. I found it ended rather quickly.

Fantastic! Nothing to complain about here - good story, characters, dialogue and pace. So tempted to flick to the back page as I was so desperate to get to the resolution to the mystery but the dialogue helped me keep my discipline! Great relationships between characters, not all of whom are very likeable, and a sharp, descriptive style.

Where Everything Seems Double was a very enjoyable read. From the start I liked the character Gina -- probably because I'm of a similar age and it's rare to find books about 60+ women that does not portray them as old ladies.
Gina's relationships with her children and grandchild Freda are convincingly portrayed, in particular that walking-on-eggshells feel of dealing with the ups and downs of a moody teenager who every now and then reverts back to being gran's favourite girl..
There is a strong sense of place: you easily imagine the scenes around the hotel and lake where the story is set, as well as the ferry and town. The characters are equally distinctive. It all helps to pull you into and get invested in the story.
'Where Everything Seems Double' is a clever title: just about everything in this novel allows for a 'double' interpretation. You're left guessing about who is really what they seem and who is hiding what. Is what apparently happened what actually happened? It's intriguing and keeps you hooked.
I like that the story is not deeply twisted and strange: it's just obscure and odd, and hard to figure out (like moody teenagers, I suppose!). It's more cozy mystery, but with a modern twist. There's nothing terribly complex about this novel, but what it sets out to do it does very well. A perfectly good scone.
It's well written, well observed and nicely plotted. And charming. Gina can definitely be accused of recklessness in bringing her 13 year-old granddaughter along with her on a sleuthing mission, but it makes for an engaging and entertaining novel. I look forward to reading more by Penny Freedman.

Penny Freedman introduced us to her amateur sleuth, Gina Gray, over a decade ago. Now, six novels later, she's back, in the company of her thirteen-year-old granddaughter Freda.
Gina and Freda are in the lake district to help an old friend of Gina's. It is no longer the innocent idyll of Arthur Ransome's Swallows And Amazons. A teenage girl is missing.
This is a beautifully written mystery, with well-drawn characters, deserving of one's empathy. I love all the literary references in the text. An absolute pleasure to read.

Where Everything Seems Double is a cozy mystery featuring Gina Gray, the seventh in a series with Gina and her love interest DCI Scott. In this book, Gina is asked for help by a former friend from the past whose husband got into trouble for unknowingly helping the murder in All the Daughters, her second book. A young girl has gone missing and Colin, the woman's husband, is suspected of being involved. The friend is still angry and the letter is a demand for redress, but Gina decides to help anyway even though her young granddaughter is coming for a visit.
And here is where she lost me. Knowing that the missing girl is about the same age as her granddaughter, Gina not only brings her anyway, she actually suggests she investigate by making friends with the missing girl's friends. Who does that?
I suppose, on one hand, you could say she was smart since her granddaughter figures out the answer before she does, but seriously? Gina's blithe "All's well that ends well" attitude has me more in sympathy with her daughters than her. Sorry, not sorry.
The mystery and its solution were fair and relatively well-constructed, and yes, it's a good mystery, but I doubt I will read more in the Gina Gray series. It's not that I disliked Where Everything Seems Double, I disliked Gina. From the moment she decided to drag her granddaughter along to infiltrate the young people who knew the missing girl, she seemed incredibly irresponsible. It was interesting to see the narrative switch from Gina to Freda and back from chapter to chapter, but Freda's voice seemed less like a teen and more like an adult approximation of a teen. The inclusion of Freda's artwork had a purpose but contrary to being gifted as described in the story, her drawings look more like what an eight-year-old would draw, not someone who is thirteen with talent. It was a good enough mystery, but I doubt I will read more in the series.
I received an e-galley of Where Everything Seems Double from the publisher through NetGalley.
Where Everything Seems Double at Matador |Troubadour

Thank you Netgalley for the advance reader copy of Where Everything Seems Double by Penny Freedman in exchange for an honest review. Gina receives an email from Eve saying that Gina has ruined Eve and Colin's lives with her meddling. Gina had discovered that Colin had lied to the police about the murder of a 13 year old girl. Gina then heads up to Cumbia, in the Lake District. Gina and her granddaughter, Freda, ride the train up there.
This was an interesting story. I enjoyed the many layers of family and friend relationships. I find it so curious to see the difference in people's public and private faces.

Where Everything Seems Double was a compelling read. And one that had me flipping through the pages. I enjoyed this book alot. The writing was just spot on loved the writing and the characters I was hooked.
A really good book!