Member Reviews
After a horrific accident, Rose "Pip" Appleby returns home with her 'tail between her legs'. She worked hard to become one of the top human rights attorneys in London, leaving her small town life in the rearview mirror. To return to the life she thought left behind is, for her, a step down and humiliating.
Now working as a sales clerk at a local thrift store, Pip happens upon an old diary. She begins to read it and sees some commonality with the writer and her current situation. She later finds out the owner of the diary is a once actess, and local, named Evelyn Mountcastle. She also learns that Evelyn still resides there in town. What is there for Pip to do but seek Evelyn out and return her diary and see if she is willing to talk to her about the words written on the pages. Can speaking with Evelyn help heal her heart and ease the guilt she feels?
Well this is another one that wasn't quite what I expected and one I ended up enjoying. It's about life and accidents that happen and how those accidents can sometimes define us. After a while though, there are choices to make .. do we let the accidents keep defining who we are and let the pain and guilt run our lives? Or do we find a way to dig deep and heal. Do we heal alone or try to reach out and share our hearts .. our fears .. and let others help in that healing. Friendships, even unexpected ones, are a wonderful addition to life. They can make life bearable and the craziest moments seem like a memory.
This was a delightful read and one I wholeheartedly recommend. I appreciate the publisher and NetGalley for providing me a copy of this E-Book. All opinions expressed herein are mine and mine alone.
Hard work, a successful career, a nice home, and a handsome boyfriend don't always guarantee a happy ending. When Pip is involved in a fatal accident, her world comes crashing down and she heads home to the country. She discovers a diary written years previously by an actress who has dropped out of sight. When they finally meet, they have more in common than Pip expected, and form a friendship that helps them both to move into a happier future.
Another beautifully told, heart-tugger of a story from Imogen Clarke.
Two women, two generations apart, linked by tragedy: human rights barrister Pip and actress Evelyn. Both returned under a cloud to their small-town roots from the success and bright lights of London. Both, burdened by guilt, stuck in a void, unable to face the future.
Their separate stories are told in two timelines — Pip’s in the present and Evelyn’s in the late 1970s (and through her diaries) — and are equally compelling. But it’s when their two paths meet and merge into one that the real depth of the narrative emerges, as the two women face their demons and find in each other kindred, damaged spirits who can heal together.
Ultimately, this is, I feel, a story about friendship. About how it can crop up in the unlikeliest of places and between the unlikeliest of people. And Clarke explores this notion with a warmth and insight that is a delight to read.
But there are other layers, too. Other themes that are equally as thought provoking: the idea of “home”, where it is, what it is. Is it a physical place, or a feeling? A place to escape from, or a place to run to?
And the “Me too” movement: how perceptions of socially acceptable behavior can change dramatically in the space of one or two generations. As a contemporary of Evelyn, there was so much of this that I could relate to, and I applaud Clarke for understanding this and handling it so sensitivity.
I love a reading journey that winds up in a place where you can close the book with a contented sigh. But one, too, that stays with you a while, hovering on the edge of your subconscious, nudging you to ponder and reflect. And this was just the ticket.
Two women fighting for breaking their ties s with their hometown and wanting to succeed in London. But tragedy bring them back to town and they feel trapped. Can they help each other break free from their fears and struggle and have a second chance in life? A really wonderful story.
A maybe /ought to read for any parent of a reluctant returner or the reluctant returner themselves ( as a parent of two boomerang returners ). However most do so for more prosaic reasons than our Reluctantly Home Pip who has a very upsetting reason of her own that led to a devastating effect on her work, social, romantic and most of all her mental health.
A chance find in the charity shop she volunteers in leads to her subsequent return to a happier frame of mind and life. On the way she realises how supportive and wonderful her parents are ( hurrah ) and not the over protective busybodies she felt them to be previously ( thanks Imogen, from a supportive not over protective mum ). An altogether nicely put together story which will hold your interest from start to finish, thank you Netgalley, author and publisher for the opportunity to read this in exchange for an honest review.
Pip Appleby is a success by anyone’s standards. She has an enviable job as a human rights barrister, a model-handsome boyfriend, and an address in Shoreditch. Everything has lined up perfectly for her...until an accident takes everything away in a second. She shelves her expensive red-soled heels and retreats to her family’s farm. Her new life is a far cry from her old one—surrounded by farmland, and relegated to selling items in a charity shop. Her life is now lived in fear and although she is surrounded by family, she feels lost.
Evelyn Montcastle was once a rising actress, whose past is shrouded in mystery. Her diary is found by Pip in the charity shop and it opens up a mystery for her. Who is the mysterious Evelyn whose life seems tragic, and sad, and somehow parallels her own? The women meet and they start to unravel the mystery of each other’s past. Then slowly each woman gives the other what she needs to help understand the past and move into the future.
I loved this book of exploring the past and facing the future. The characters were also well-written and it was hard not to love both Pip and Evelyn. So many lessons in this book, and beneath it all the thread of the friend who accepts you for who you are (despite your past) and supports you.
I really enjoyed this book. While there weren't really any surprises with the plot, I appreciated the story nonetheless. I felt the recognition and healing of two broken people very keenly as I read this book.
Sometimes the strongest friendships arise from the unlikeliest of circumstances.
Damaged, fragile Pip has returned to her childhood home in exile while she takes time to mentally recover from a tragic, traumatic accident. In the course of her job at a thrift shop, she finds a diary that changes her life and facilitates her healing. The more Pip learns about the author, the more determined she is to find her. Of course, the author of this diary has her own story.
Evelyn, the diarist, has her own rather traumatic story that she must come to terms with. I found both of these women engaging and realistic. Their situations were all too real and I found it totally believable the way in which each dealt with their situation. As their friendship developed, you can't help but pull for them both to come out on top of their troubles.
A lovely book, a serious book, with a strong message of support, love, friendship, and healing. Thank you to Imogen Clark, NetGalley, and the publisher for the ARC.
I struggled with the first half of the book and thought about not finishing it. But once I got to the second half of the book, I fell in love with it and wanted that section to be even longer.
I really enjoyed the characters of Pip and Evelyn.
Thanks so much to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own.
This is a well written and well described book. Pip’s life was built on a stack of cards and when one of them was pulled by a hideous tragedy, the whole lot came down and she had to return to the life she had tried to escape. The same occurred with Evelyn but in a different way and time. This is a story of hope and friendship and how talking will always help. Would recommend.
In RELUCTANTLY HOME, Imogen Clark shares the story of Pip and Evelyn. Reluctantly, Pip has returned to the small town, the farm and the family that she abandoned years ago for an exciting life in London as Rose, successful barrister and perfectly turned out woman. A terrible, unavoidable accident for which Pip blames herself has reduced her to an incapable wreck, prone to panic attacks and unable to connect, to feel, to think for herself. The chance reading of a diary of an aspiring actress who has also returned to that tiny village and lived shut up and isolated for decades leads to the meeting of Pip and Evelyn, two broken women who share their stories and together create new perspectives that allow them to return to the world of the living as their fullest, most creative, and loving selves. This was a propulsive read, fluid and wonderfully rendered with the different points of view and timelines that create a vibrant and enjoyable world. Kudos to Clark for yet another wonderful novel. I received an advance reader copy of this novel from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for my unbiased review.
I hadn't expected this book to be quite so light and frothy. It is a rather sweet, feel-good book, which will appeal to a lot of people. However, I found it full of cliche, with rather shallow characters who are all either good or bad. Perhaps I have just been unlucky with all the barristers I have ever worked with, but none of them have been anywhere near as sweet as Pip.
At first I thought this story might be a bit too gentle for my tastes but instead I found it was a clever exploration of how people can be trapped by the stories they tell themselves rather than how others would see the same set of circumstances.
I was drawn to the book because it features a diary and I can't resist the opportunity to nose inside a diary, fictional or not! When this particular diary falls into the hands of Pip, former barrister currently working in a charity shop, she starts to read.
The diary belonged to Evelyn Mountcastle who had also had to return to Southwold back some forty years previously. Finding out about her life helps Pip come to terms with the changes to her own.
A satisfying tale that warmed my heart.
Pip and Evelyn both returned from London to Southwold after tragedy= Pip in 2019 and Evelyn in 1979. Pip. who had left Southwold behind without a look back- she even changed her name- has come home and is trying to heal. She finds Evelyn's diary in a box of books, reads it, and seeks her out. Evelyn was an actress until....No spoilers from me. The two women eventually meet and discover that they can help one another. Thanks to netgalley for the ARC. It's a good generous read.
Poignant Story of Surviving Incredible Loss
This novel is the story of two women, a generation apart, who have both had to face incredible loss. And neither is dealing with it well. Many parts of their stories will leave the reader teary-eyed. Other parts will leave you raging angry. But the end will leave you wanting more. I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys women's fiction. I received this ARC book for free from Net Galley and this is my honest review.
This is the story of Pip and Evelyn. Pip was a barrister in present day London before an accident leaves a little boy dead and Pip wracked with guilt. Evelyn was an actress in London in the 70s before losing a child to tragedy herself and has been self-imprisioned in her home ever since. These two meet when Pip finds one of Evelyn's diaries in the charity ship she works in and develop a relationship that is mutually beneficial.
The story starts out very quickly and abruptly with a flashback to the accidental death of the young boy. It was a rough way to make Pip's acquaintance. It then dragged a bit as both stories developed, with some awkward transitioning between the two story lines. It did pick up some in the second half, but honestly I feel like this part is where the story should have focused and it should have been far more developed. I think the author almost gave too much away right at the beginning as she introduced both characters, and it lead to less suspense or emotional connection when they revealed things to each other.
Overall, I felt I just wanted more from this book. More story, more development, more relationship between the two women.
Thank you to Netgalley for my ARC of this book - all opinions are my own.
Pip Appleby is a successful lawyer in London and living the life she always dreamed of until tragedy strikes one day on her way to court. Pip does not see the young boy step in front of her car until it is too late. Dealing with the guilt of what has happened, Pip retreats to her childhood home in the English countryside and begins spending her days by helping in a charity shop. One day while sorting through a box of books that has been donate, Pip comes across a diary of actress Evelyn Mountcastle. As Pip reads through the diary she begins to feel a connection with Evelyn and decides to track down the reclusive actress to find out what ended up happening to her.
A story of family, loss, and dealing with unforeseen tragedies to eventually forgive oneself. Highly recommend this book.
I have just spent about twenty four hours with Pip and Evelyn. Pip found Evelyn's diary, and discovered that even though there is thirty plus years between them, their lives almost mirror one another. They both escaped small town claustrophobia and experienced a sense of freedom, and both had to return home through tragedy and consequence. Through this unexpected friendship they learn that guilt can not be your anchor, and that life is for living..
A beautifully written tale about how easy it is to become victims of our circumstances. A book full of lively and sad characters who are looking for hope.
Reluctantly Home is a highly engaging story told from the point of view of two women.
Pip, a London lawyer, has returned to her childhood home as she recovers from a traumatic event. When she comes across the journal of Evelyn Mountcastle, Pip is intrigued by the woman and uncovers a bit of mystery, causing her to seek out Evelyn. Evelyn has become a recluse, due to her own tragic history, and resists the idea of engaging in conversation with Pip.
I absolutely adored the pairing of Pip and Evelyn. These two women come from very different backgrounds, yet find they have quite a bit in common. This unlikely pairing also finds that there is healing in finding someone who recognizes your pain and accepts you for who you are.
The book has endearing characters, intrigue and an insightful look at working through trauma. This was my first story by author Imogen Clark and I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Thank you to the Lake Union and the author for the opportunity to read an advance copy via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This is a delightful story about two women living in different times but so very alike who befriends each other later in life. It is a pretty good story & I recommend it to anyone who enjoys historical fiction.