Member Reviews

First of all, I must express my eternal gratitude to NetGalley and Tor Books for allowing me to read one of my most anticipated books of the year early by granting me this ARC. I usually read multiple books at any given time, but when I was granted access to this title, I stopped reading everything else and lost myself in this story.

This book is absolute perfection! Reading this book at the end of the day was like wrapping myself up in a favorite blanket with a warm cup of tea (of course) beside me . Everything TJ Klune writes hits straight to the heart, and this story was definitely no different.

Wallace Price was not a good man by anyone’s definition. He was a cold hearted snake of a man. He was an attorney and he treated everyone in his life (personal and professional) like garbage. He did whatever it took to get ahead. When he dies suddenly from an unexpected heart attack, he is surprised to find himself a ghost at his own funeral. A funeral that only a few people are attending and none of them have anything good to say about him. There he meets Mei, a Reaper who will take him to meet The Ferryman. Hugo Freeman is that ferryman- helping the dead grow accustomed to their new state of being and helping them to cross over to whatever waits beyond our world when they are ready. Along with Mei, his ghost grandfather Nelson and ghost dog, Apollo, Hugo runs a tea shop that does a lot more than serve tea and baked goods. When Hugo and Wallace meet, Wallace is determined to return to the living and continue on as he was. Hugo explains how that is not possible and begins to help Wallace get ready to move on. Yet as the days go by, the two grow closer and learn more about one another, and fall in love.


I legitimately wept throughout most of this book. I’ve suffered a lot of loss in my life (some quite recently) so the themes of grief and love going hand in hand, knowing when to let go and when to hold on really got to me. Wallace’s character arc was done so well. It was gradual and I appreciated that it didn’t come to him instantly. I loved watching him realize that maybe he wasn't a very good person when he was living, and thus he strived to be better in death.

As much as I cried, I equally laughed OUT LOUD at this book. I honestly cannot remember the last book that had me roaring with laughter, my family giving me side eyes wondering if I had lost my mind. Nelson Freeman (Hugo’s ghost grandfather) was so funny in his interactions with Wallace, especially when teaching Wallace how to change clothes as a ghost (but I won’t go too far into that to avoid spoilers!) .

There are a lot of lessons taught with so much love and nothing but respect in Tj Klune's books, and this one is no exception. I love how Klune makes the reader think about things that are difficult or painful without coming off as condescending or having a holier-than-thou attitude. His ‘voice’ is just very human, very gentle as these themes are presented to us. Even the content warning (for suicide, death and grief) was the single most eloquent warning I have ever come across. The author knows he is holding our hearts in his hands and wants us to know it could hurt at times.

Just like The House in the Cerulean Sea, the cover of this book is breathtaking and tells the story without saying a word. There is nothing more I can say except READ THIS BOOK! You will not regret a single moment you spend with these characters and this author.

Was this review helpful?

Under the Whispering Door
By TJ Klune
Pub Date: September 21, 2021

First and foremost, thank you times a million to NetGalley and Tor Books for gifting me the ARC of this book. I wished with all of my might to be granted early access to this book and my dream came true!

I can barely put into words...this book. I had super high expectations as The House in the Cerulean Sea has been a STANDOUT favorite of mine since I read it. This book did not disappoint.

I literally cried - in the Epilogue, it was almost to the point of random sobs! This book has a beauty that you don't expect in a book about death. This is a heavy book about life, death, acceptance, grief, and reflection. I cannot state enough that the trigger warning/content warning in the beginning pages of this book is so necessary, but also, so appreciated that it was even included. Death is a fickle subject - it's inevitable in life, and the subject in a book is a hard one to balance. There is no fantasizing death in this book, but rather, the notion that death is not the end-all be-all of existence. There is no religious heaven or hell, no denomination of belief here, and I think that is really hard to do when discussing death. Well done, TJ Klune.

This book was funny, unexpected, poignant, and wonderful. 5-stars from me.

Was this review helpful?

I really loved TJ Klune's The House in the Cerulean Sea last year, so I was really excited about his upcoming novel Under the Whispering Door . With its beautiful cover design and interesting premise, I was ready for the tears! The story focuses on Wallace Price, a brutally insensitive attorney with a heart made of glass who ends up having a heart attack and becoming a ghost. Wallace is extremely apprehensive and resistant about the process, but is assigned a Reaper who will help him be able to cross over. His Reaper, Mei, enlists the help of the ferryman to help him cross. The ferryman, Hugo, takes Wallace and Mei to a small village and moves Wallace into a unique multi-story tea shop. At the tea shop, Wallace learns about meaningful lessons that he's ignored during his time in life. Once time begins to run out, Wallace tries to pack in the most life lessons before it's too late.

Under the Whispering Door is very different from what you would expect after reading The House in the Cerulean Sea, but it does have some teachable moments that you'd come to expect from TJ Klune's stories. I felt like the story in Under the Whispering Door was a bit slower and more predictable than I expected, but overall it's still a solid read. Break out the Kleenex, because this book will hit you hard. I definitely think this book has important themes that are sprinkled throughout the narrative (love, acceptance, life or death, friendship) and it definitely gets you thinking.

Was this review helpful?

I was gifted this book from NetGalley to read and review before it's released. Let me start by saying... The House in the Cerulean Sea is one of my all-time favorite books. Like Goodreads mentions, Under the Whispering Door is a "contemporary fantasy with TJ Klune's signature "quirk and charm" about a ghost who refuses to cross over and the ferryman he falls in love with."

Under the Whispering Door has similarly lovable side characters, and a grumpy main character, although it isn't as whimsical as Cerulean Sea. It deals with death in a way that not many books I've read have approached it. I enjoyed this read, but didn't find myself attached to the book, "couldn't put it down" like I was with Klune's other book. It follows a similar storyline, but I did feel it was lacking in the middle and on the character development. I will say this book did make me cry (because what book doesn't, honestly). I think I had massively high expectations because of how much I loved Cerulean Sea. If you're new to Klune's books, I think you'll enjoy this!

I would suggest looking up trigger warnings, and the book does have them listed in the front, which is incredible!

#UndertheWhisperingDoor #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

TJ Klune always writes amazing stories. Stories that make you feel deep down in your chest…the romance is never overbearing but always wrote in such a beautiful way.

Was this review helpful?

Wallace Price is a thoroughly odious man, and when he drops dead of a heart attack, the only people who show up to his funeral are his ex-wife, who goes on a rant about how awful he was, and the partners at his law firm, who are there for form's sake only. Mei, a Reaper, takes Wallace in his ghost form to a lovely, quirky tea shop, where he is supposed to adjust to being dead and eventually enter the door to what lies beyond. The owner of the tea shop, Hugo, is a ferryman, there to help Wallace with his crossing. Hugo's grandfather and dog also live at the tea shop, but like Wallace, they are both ghosts. As Wallace learns to care about more than himself and actually become a decent human being, he's faced with the looming deadline of needing to open the door. This is an absolutely lovely, sad, uplifting book about grief and found family. My only quibble is that the romance between Wallace and Hugo needed more development; it felt like I was told rather than shown their feelings. I loved the story and all the characters. My thanks to NetGalley, T.J. Klune, and Macmillan-Tor/Forge Publishing for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my heart. This book was everything I hoped it would be plus more. It is beautifully written and it’s one you will not want to put down. Under the Whispering Door is about life, death, grief, love, hope and healing. It’s an emotional story that will make you want to live life to the fullest.

I absolutely loved the characters! Each one of them brought something special to the story. Wallace started off being a selfish jerk who only cared about himself. Throughout the book you see him change his ways little by little. His character growth was incredible. Hugo was literally the sweetest. He was so kind and had a big heart. He put so much thought into everything that he did. There is no denying that he is the perfect person for the ferryman job. Then there was Mei, Nelson and Apollo…wow, they were fantastic! Mei and Nelson were protective, funny and ornery. Apollo was the happiest ghost dog in the world.

I had tears rolling down my face as I finished reading this book. I definitely think this story will stick with me for a long time. I’m excited to have a finished copy on my shelves. TJ Klune is such a gifted writer and I cannot wait to see what he writes next!

Was this review helpful?

Like many people, I read and loved The House in the Cerulean Sea. It was a fantastic book and very much needed. I was excited to read this and I was also apprehensive because how could it be as lovely and magical?

But it was. And it might even be better.

It's profound and sweet and heartbreaking and very much necessary. I don't want to get into specifics because anything would possibly spoil something. This definitely needs to unfold at its own pace and in its own time but it is the best, most special journey.

Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Under the Whispering Door is the latest fantasy from TJ Klune, an author that I find has an unmatched talent for producing stories that feel like being wrapped in a gentle hug.

Whispering Door is about death, and I found it more of a slow burn that some of the other novels Klune has written. However, once I was hooked there was no going back. I'd recommend reading this book with a few tissues in reach (although there are so many laughs as well) since it will leave you a mess.

I received a copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

If you’re reading this book in hopes of the wholesome content that was The House in the Cerulean Sea, then boy are you in for a shock. Under the Whispering Door is a story about grief, death, and what comes after. As dark as it seems, it’s set in a small tea shop run by a ferryman, someone who sees spirits to the other side. It’s cozy while being sad and it will 100% break your heart a hundred times over, but it’s worth it.

*thank you to the publisher for sending me an advanced copy of this book

Was this review helpful?

I had high expectations for this book and it did not let me down. Similar in the style of The House In The Cerulean Sea which I thoroughly enjoyed but different enough to stand on its own. Wallace Price frustrated me for the first quarter but I loved watching his character grow and learn. As per usual for T.J. Klune, the characters and their relationships were what made this book shine. Personally, if the characters aren't well written and have good interpersonal relationships, I just don't love the book in the same way. Fortunately, this is one aspect that I feel T.J. Klune excels in, and so I was quickly attached and sucked into the story (Hugo, I love you and never change). Highly recommend this and looking forward to what T.J. Klune puts out next.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars. Under the Whispering Door was a very pleasant surprise, you’ll laugh and you’ll cry! This was my 1st book by TJ Klune and I definitely will read more!

Wallace Price is a selfish workaholic disliked by everyone who knows him. When he suddenly finds that he is a ghost at his own funeral, his Reaper takes him on a journey to a quirky little tea shop to meet the Ferryman who will help him cross over - Hugo. Wallace quickly realizes the mistakes he made in life and uses his time as a ghost to really life and make some amends.

The book is full of amazing characters and is a really beautiful journey of finding yourself even in the most unlikely time or place. Combined with some really quirky and witty writing - definitely worth a read!

Thanks to TJ Klune, #NetGalley, and Tor Books for the e-ARC of #UnderTheWhisperingDoor in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 ⭐️ — It was obvious from the summary that this was going to be an emotional read, and I knew already that TJ Klune has a way of tugging at heartstrings even when you least expect it, but this book still managed to take me by surprise in just enough ways. I wouldn’t say that it was thrilling or deeply shocking, and I think that’s exactly as it should be. There was just enough going on to keep the plot from falling flat, while still being laced with comfort, humor, and the found family angle the Klune has famously done so well.

It took me a while to get my roots into this story, and at around the 25% mark I was growing worried that my expectations had been set too high, but once I started to really learn about the characters, their dynamics, and watch the growth of our main ‘hero’, Wallace, my enjoyment increased rapidly for the remainder of the book. Klune is as adept at tear-jerking as he is at making you laugh at the most unexpected moments, and though it would be easy for such moments of humor to cheapen or ruin the sentimental scenes, they’re done so well that it never feels that way, balanced just right.

As the front of the book thoughtfully warns, this story contains a lot of difficult subject matter and I’d advise asking a friend who’s read it or reading the inside cover (upon the book’s official release) before deciding whether or not to dive in. The book never felt to me as if it was being cruel for the sake of being cruel, but take care of yourself as a reader nonetheless ♥️

[Vague spoiler ahead!] As Casey McQuiston once said in the acknowledgments of their beautiful book One Last Stop, this book is an “unbury your gays” story, as quick to make you cry as it is to build a tale of optimism and second chances. It’s a trope-builder as well as a trope-breaker, so if you like found family, seemingly doomed romance, and long-overdue hope, I’d recommend giving this one a shot.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with an early copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Under the Whispering Door is a story about grief, death, and what comes after. As dark as it seems, it’s set in a small tea shop run by a ferryman, someone who help spirits cross to the other side.
Right from the very beginning, I knew that this book was going to be an amazing, heart wrenching book. You can't write a story about a ghost and a ferryman falling in love and not anticipate some tears. Wallace Price is a jerk, and it was hard to like him, but the more he grows as a person, the more likable he becomes. Hugo was perfection, and I loved him from the start. This book is full of amazing characters and it's found family.
Hugo and Wallace are so cute together, it wasn’t insta-love at all, their relationship takes a while to form and it grew into something they both never expcted.

Was this review helpful?

Do you ever just discover a new author and after only reading one of their books you're automatically like .. YUP! NEW FAVOURITE AUTHOR OVER HERE! Because that is how I am feeling right now towards T.J. Klune.

I LOVED THIS BOOK. I had no expectations whatsoever going into this story, as I haven't read House in the Cerulean Sea yet (I know, I know, I've been living under a rock). I found this story so beautiful and so magical. I laughed out loud, my heart was breaking at times, my eyes got a tad watery during one particular scene... emotional rollercoaster I tell ya, phew!

THE CHARACTERS. Oh my gosh, the characters. I adored every single one of them. I felt like I was right there with them in this little tea shop. T.J. Klune's writing style is so charming and well-formed, I simply couldn't put the book down. This was another one of those books where once I finished I just had to sit there and process what I read and just wanted to give the book a big old hug. The ending definitely left me smiling and I couldn't imagine a more perfect way of tying off the story.

I definitely recommend this one if you are looking for a very creative contemporary fantasy fiction and a story unlike anything you've read before. So good! Job well done T.J. Klune!

Was this review helpful?

THE BOOK OF THE YEAR!!! TJ Klune has done it again.

This was a heavy read for me, as Under the Whispering Door explores so many real life events that are not talked about enough, in an open manner. So please be aware when reading this book, as it talks about Mental Health issues, suicide and grief/loss. Despite these topics being the foundation, it is written in such an amazing way. It explores the ups and downs and has a beautiful way (if that’s possible) of talking about these subjects.

Under the Whispering Door follows the MC, Wallace, as he explores these issues himself. Wallace finds himself in a strange home with even stranger things living there. Throughout Wallace’s journey, he learns to find himself, to help others, to love but most importantly, he learns how to live.

Was this review helpful?

It is impossible not to love this book. I dare you to try.

This is the story of Wallace, a lawyer who dies from a heart attack and is brought to Hugo who lives in a "tea shop" where Wallace will cross over with Hugo's help. Wallace wasn't the very best person when alive, let's just say. But now as he lives in the tea shop with Mei (his reaper) , Nelson (hugo's grandfather), Hugo, and Apollo (hugo's dog) he learns more about life and how to live than he ever did while he was alive.

As with TJ Klune's other novels, these characters wind their way into your heart and never let go. The story is deep, joyful, meaningful and deeply heartfelt. If you let yourself feel it, there's no way this story will not warm your heart and make you feel deeply grateful.

I loved every minute I spent with it.

with gratitude to netgalley and Tor Books for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I've only rad one book by TJ Klune and I loved it! Fantasy fiction is not my go to genre but I will read anything by TJ Klune!

Under the Whispering Door tells the story of Wallace, a lawyer who has passed away. Wallace isn't the most likable person. Suddenly, he is whisked away by a reaper and taken to a tea shop. Wallace meets Mei, Nelson, Hugo, and Apollo. They are trying to help Wallace "crossover."When all is said and done, Wallace will fall in love with one of these people. Is it too late for Wallace to change? The characters he meets don't think so!

I loved the overall message of this book. Under the Whispering Tree deals with death, acceptance, grief, love, and change. Although the story centers around death, it's also about living and how life can be beautiful when we just "let go" and allow ourselves to be vulnerable.

Was this review helpful?

Wow... I assumed I was going to like this book, but I wasn't quite sure what to expect. The tone is definitely a bit darker than The House In the Cerulean Sea. And T.J. Klune has been very vocal that this book IS NOT the same as The House In The Cerulean Sea, and asks readers not to expect the same tone/plot.

I think I may have actually liked Under the Whispering Door more than Cerulean Sea. For the last 30% of the book, I was mostly crying and sometimes sobbing. The majority of the book is quiet and contemplative which really kicks you in the feels by the end of the book!!

The trigger warnings, listed below, make the book sound much darker/depressing than it truly is. The main character is a ghost...and is coming to terms with the way he lived his life (which was not great). However, the FOUND FAMILY he finds in Mei (his Reaper), Hugo (the ferryman an tea shop owner), Nelson (ghost, Hugo's grandfather), and Apollo (GHOST DOG!) give him new perspectives and reasons to want to "live" even in death.

I recommend this for fans of The Midnight Library by Matt Haig and all of Becky Chambers' works. It is very much a character driven story, with plot revolving around the main character's development and relationships with others. I'm rating this an enthusiastic 5 stars and will be trying to get everyone I know to preorder this book. It will absolutely be one of my best books of the year!

TW: Death (the vast majority of this book is about death and is quite heavy, while still being uplifting. But please be prepared for extensive discussions about death), murder, suicide (off page at first but then somewhat shown on page later in the book), unexpected death due to heart attack, ghosts, cold and cruel employer/workplace situations, poor relationship with parents, grief, death of a child due to cancer (off page), anxiety attacks (on page), depression.

Note- I received a complementary digital arc of this title from the publisher, through Netgalley, in exchange for an honest review. This did not influence my review.

Note to Publisher- I will also be featuring this book on my IG (@monstrouslybookish) and have already posted about it twice in my stories. One as a reading update at 82% saying how much I loved it, and the second showing me literally crying after finishing the book and telling everyone to preorder it immediately).

Was this review helpful?

Like the other book I read by Klune (House in the Cerulean Sea), this was sweet, whimsical, and heartwarming. I personally did not connect with this novel as much as the previous one and I could see may of the same beats as House in the Cerulean Sea, but it was still enjoyable. It hit many truths that we try not to think about and I could see this being a very big comfort to readers who are facing death or watching a loved one die. There are some triggers of death of a loved one and suicide, but the author is aware this might be a problem and gives a warning at the beginning. This was a really good and thought provoking and solidified T.J. Klune as an author I will continue to keep my eye on.

Was this review helpful?