This is a tough one to review.

I was shocked to learn this was set in the US, because none of the characters sounded American. At one point we have a character that says, "What's a ghost's favorite berry? Booberries." It's a cute joke, but Booberries are a seasonal cereal here, almost any American could tell you that. It's weird no one made reference to it. The tea shop doesn't make a ton of sense either. Coffee is vastly more popular in the US and also comes in as wide a variety which could have been applied in the same way.

For the most part I felt uncomfortable reading this. The first half feels very claustrophobic. Information is withheld from Wallace, he has almost no agency. To me it seemed he was basically manipulated into everything. I didn't like how cagey and jokey everyone was being toward him. On top of that, nothing really happens. Wallace's personality shifts rapidly and it doesn't feel backed up by the events in the book, as few as those events are.

I don't think the ending was earned. It felt really arbitrary.

I guess I liked it. I mean, I finished it, I didn't get too bored to go on at any point. My eyes did glaze over during the inane conversations about death. Whatever, it's fine.

Wow.
I could stop here and have said everything I needed to. No more to add.
But I won't. I will also tell you that as soon as I turned the last page, I went right back to the beginning and started all over again. What a journey. Thank you TJ Klune.
I had high hopes after reading and loving The House in the Cerulean Sea and I was not disappointed. Someone asked me how Under The Whispering Door compared, and I answered that is was the same and very different at the same time. Obviously the writing is very similar... the tone, the wit, the characters you just cant help but fall in love with (Mei is my favorite and if there was ever a spin off all about here I would buy it no questions asked!) But then, the subject matter is more... mature... for lack of better term. I want to say dark, because in parts it is, but on the other hand it is also warm and fuzzy, heartbreaking and hopeful. It is a roller coaster of emotions, and I am better for having gone on this beautiful journey.
This book will stay with me forever, both emotionally and physically, for when I am (hopefully) old and gray and on my death bed you will find this book on my nightstand, pages frayed, witness to a life well lived.

5 out of 5 stars for Under the Whispering Door by TJ Klune!

After reading The House in the Cerulean Sea last year, it quickly became my top book of 2020, if not of all time. I immediately downloaded The Green Creak Series by Klune and read The Extraordinaries right away. I've loved every single book I've read by Klune, and Under the Whispering Door was no different.

Under the Whispering Door contains Klune's classic whit and humor, but dives deeper into darker topics like grief and suicide. I can't tell you how much I appreciated Wallace's story of reflection and growth even after death. In life, Wallace was not a kind person. He had no patience or empathy for others, and his work was his life. In death, Wallace recognizes that he did not live fully, but he has another chance in death.

I can't say enough good things about the characters in this book. Wallace, Nelson, Hugo, Mei, and Apollo are the found family of my dreams. Their love and care for each other showed Wallace what it means to really be loved and to love in return.

I absolutely loved the ending of this book. I don't usually cry while reading books, but this was different. My emotional attachment to these characters was unmatched, and I cried both happy and sad tears through the course of reading. I highly recommend you add Under the Whispering Door to your TBR!

Thank you so much to Tor and NetGalley for the ARC of this book!

Wallace Price is very important. He's a high-power attorney with absolutely no time for frivolities and no compassion to spare. When he finds himself dead and no one mourning his demise, he's somehow shocked. When a reaper comes to collect him and takes him to a strange-looking tea shop of all places, Wallace adamantly refuses to accept that he's dead. Hugo, the ferryman in charge of making sure he crosses over when he's ready, is patient and kind and everything Wallace never knew how to be. Over the course of his stay in the tea shop, Wallace has to take a hard look at how he lived his life and accept the regret he holds for the things he can now never have.

I was expecting something Cerulean Sea-Esque with this book, and I was both right and very, very wrong. It has the same emotional gut punch as HITCS, the same sense of family and love. It's funny because I always tell people HITCS is like a warm and cozy cup of tea, and Under the Whispering Door revolves around a tea shop and a ferryman who serves the dead warm cozy cups of tea. That's about where the similarities end, aside from TJ's signature humor and emotion-infused writing.

Under the Whispering Door is so full of grief. It's exploring life and death of course, but in this book, grief isn't only for the living. Of course, we've heard the moral before. Live your life well/we only have so much time/take those chances while you still can. But this goes deeper, taking hold in your chest until it spreads like so many roots: love comes in many different forms, and we are worthy of it. We have the capacity to feel so much for other humans and to let it bloom from those roots in our chests and it's just as much for us as it is for others.

We see Wallace's growth throughout this book. His anger and denial, his regret over how he lived his life and how he treated people he once loved. We see him turn his anger into determination. We see him desperate to help others ease their pain and move forward with their lives because he knows what it's like to spend your life blind to joy. Wallace finds his humanity after his death, and that's really something to ponder. We are not alone on this life journey and we are not sealed in a vacuum. Our pain is worse than others, not as bad as some, but it's universal.

I don't want to give too much away with this review or get too deep into the intricacies of the plot, but please believe me when I say it's a beautifully written book full of sadness and anger and hope and joy and acceptance. Another absolute stunner from TJ Klune.

5+ Stars....I'm not one bit surprised by this rating!

This will be my favorite book of the year! Perfect for book clubs. Please do yourself a favor, and pick up this book, and give your family members an extra hug and kiss goodnight! This was beautiful!

Under the Whispering Tree was my most anticipated book of the year and it didn’t disappoint! Every time someone has asked me “What’s been your favorite book of the year so far?”, I’ve had to look at my phone app to even try and remember the books I’ve given 5-star ratings to. (They just didn't have that lasting effect like my other favorite books) I’ve read a lot of good books this year, but nothing has stood out in my memory as a potential favorite of the year. I haven’t had one yet this year when I finished the last sentence I *JUST KNEW* it was going to be my favorite book of the year, until I read this one. There were time throughout reading this book that I convinced myself that if I didn’t finish the book, these characters would get to live in this house forever and that their story would go on for eternity. I wished this with my entire heart.

This book is very different from “The House in the Cerulean Sea,” and honestly, I don’t even think people should compare them, but because “The House in the Cerulean Sea” was everyone’s favorite book of 2020, it’s inevitable that people are going to ask how this one compares. My answer goes like this…This book is just as good as his other books, and it will come down to personal reading preferences and enjoyment levels to give his book a ranking order. I know…it’s a cop out answer, but this book hit different emotions and was a little darker and sadder (even though there were moments I laughed out loud), so I don’t want to compare the books since they were meant to be written for different reasons and purposes. This book made me laugh, broke my heart, and made me give my family an extra hug and kiss at the end of the night. I won’t miss out on my opportunities.

This book follows Wallace Price, a big-wig lawyer who has spent his entire life working and being a jerk. He doesn’t have any friends, and the only reason people do what he asks is out of fear, not friendship. Wallace passes away unexpectedly, and as his funeral he sees a woman he’s never met before. She ends up being a reaper, and her mission is to accompany Wallace to tea shop at Charon’s Crossing so he can meet with a ferryman named Hugo. Hugo’s job is to help people who are afraid of crossing over to what comes after death. During his stay with Hugo, Wallace figures out that he missed out on so many opportunities while he was alive, and while he’s on his own self-discovery mission, he comes across other ghosts that also need help.

This book has A Wonderful Life feel to it at the beginning of the book as we are introduced to a man who didn’t live his life to his greatest potential. He gets a glimpse of the “could haves, would have, and should haves” while living as a ghost at Charon’s Crossing. There were times while I was reading this book that I wanted a happy ending for these characters more than any other wish I’ve made when reading books, but at the same time I didn’t want the ending to be like “A Wonderful Life” or something that “has been done before.” I’m not going to say too much more about the plot of this book because it needs to have the same awe and mystery to it as I had when I read this book, but this book pulled at my heart and hit the entire range of emotions in the process.

I personally loved how this book approached the topic of death and grief and TJ Klune’s message at the beginning of the book sets the tone perfectly for this book.

“This story explores life and love as well as loss and grief. There are discussions in different forms- quiet, unexpected, and death by suicide. Please read with care.”

So many times, people are afraid to talk about these topics, but this book opened up many questions about living life to your fullest and how death can affect people differently. During the book, we had characters that died from illness, natural causes, murder, and even suicide. And every death was handled differently and the idea of “everyone needs something different” is part of their grieving process. It was beautiful and of course it was absolutely heartbreaking.

I read somewhere that TJ Klune became a writer because he wanted better LGBTQ representation in books, and I’m so glad he is writing for his purpose, but I’m so dang happy be became a writer; whatever his reasons were! His books mean so much to me. I want to be friends with every character he’s ever written (I loved the Green Creek series for this reason), and I never want the stories to end when I’m emersed in his books. They are so magical and layered, and I couldn’t imagine not having these stories with these relationships and friendships out there for people to read. This book was about two people finding each other after life. One was alive, and one was dead, and their relationship was about making each other a better person. It was a beautiful romance, but of course it was so much more than physical love because they couldn’t even touch each other. They fell in love with the person and their ideas…this was the definition of a stunning slow burn romance.

I’m so thankful that I got to read this book early, and I hope everyone gets a chance to pick this book up. I already have my copy pre-ordered and ready to add to my collection. Have your tissues ready…you’ve been warned!

This was exceptional.
There's really no way to describe it.
I laughed, cried, laughed some more and now I want a cup of peppermint tea.
Amazing writing, story, characters.
So many feelings. Painful in a delicate way.
Yep, this is Klune. I love it.

I requested this book because I ADORED TJ Klune's last offering, The House in the Cerulean Sea. I tried one of Klune's back titles, Wolfsong, and enjoyed it but didn't love it. Under the Whispering Door seemed in the same vein as The House in the Cerulean Sea. In a way, it is. Klune's writing style is engaging and fun. The beginning hooked me immediately, but it did not hold my attention. There are some funny moments in this book about death and dying. As is characteristic of Klune, the cast of characters inhabiting the Tea Shop where Wallace ends up after his untimely demise are full of wit and personality. But, somehow I didn't really connect with Wallace as a character. At the start, Wallace is a terrible person, and after his death, the book is about his journey towards becoming someone better. I didn't really feel that transformation. It felt like one moment he was terrible and the next he was a good person, but I had somehow missed the trip he took to get there. The other issue with the love interest, Hugo. Hugo is the ferryman at the Tea Shop tasked with helping Wallace and other dead people move to the other side. Klune does a great job with the fantasy element and the whole idea is painted with vivid detail. However, I also didn't connect with Hugo. The reader is told that the patrons of the tea shop love Hugo, and obviously Wallace quickly comes to love Hugo, but I felt that I didn't know anything about him and I really struggled to care about him one way or another. The result was that I didn't care much about the plot in general. For a book about a heavy topic- death and dying- it was slow-moving and lacked conflict. I think had I greatly enjoyed either Hugo or Wallace I would have been happy just spending time with them regardless of the amount of conflict. The blurb also makes it seem that there is more conflict than there is. The blurb indicates that the manager (some higher being in charge of all death-related activities) shows up in the middle of the book to create trouble for Wallace and Hugo. That doesn't really happen until the last 10% of the book and it felt misrepresented to me.

Review from my 13-year-old daughter:
"The House in the Cerulean Sea" was one of my favorite books of last year, so I had extremely high expectations for this one. Although I didn't love "Under the Whispering Door" quite as much, it was still beautiful and enjoyable.

This story follows Wallace Price, an emotionless and selfish lawyer who doesn't care about anyone but himself. When he unexpectedly passes away, he meets a Reaper who takes him to a tea shop, where he meets a ferryman who will help him move on to the afterlife. But soon he finds himself growing to love Hugo, Mei, and Nelson, the people/ghost who live in the tea shop, as well as Apollo, the ghost dog.

There were only a few issues I had with this book, and they were mostly in the beginning. The magic system didn't seem entirely fleshed out, and you just kind of had to go with it until things get explained later on (although other things just aren't ever explained). Also, although Hugo becomes more interesting later on, he seemed extremely boring in the beginning, which I found odd considering he was one of the most important characters as well as the love interest. But my biggest issue with this book, the one that caused me to give it only four stars instead of five, is the pacing. Although the pacing felt natural in the second half of the book, in the first half it felt off. I felt like it was just one long conversation after another, and nothing was happening in between. The difference in pacing between the two sections almost seemed like a change in tone. And my last issue isn't really a problem with the book, but more so with the summary. It makes you think that the Manager comes very early on and Wallace going through his final week of life is going to be the main plot, but we don't even meet the Manager until around 75%. I feel like that piece of information should not have been included in the summary, as it took away some of the surprise and the emotional impact.

But despite being rather bored in the first half, I loved the second half. I found Wallace to be an interesting main character and his character arc to be extremely well done. Mei was probably my personal favorite out of the characters, although I found them all to be realistic and life-like. Also, the writing and the story were similar to "The House in the Cerulean Sea," as it reminded me almost of a fairytale.

Overall, I extremely enjoyed this book and will continue to read whatever T.J. Klune writes.

I LOVED THIS BOOK SO MUCH. Okay focus. This was my first TJ Klune, and I am so happy it was. This story follows Wallace, who is, let's be honest, kind of a dick. He is unkind to his employees and basically everyone he meets. His ex-wife has nothing good to say about him, and he basically just works and sleeps. And then he dies. What follows next is the story of how he comes to grips with being dead, and learns to be a better person in the process. We meet Hugo, the ferryman, and Mei, the reaper. It takes Wallace a while to come to accept what has happened to him. As he does, he gets to know Hugo and the rest of the inhabitants of the Tea Shop, and realizes all the things that were missing from his life. I know that sounds cheesy and it TOTALLY is but in the most amazing way. I saw someone describe it as a “warm hug” and that is EXACTLY what it is.

There is so much else that is happening in this book I couldn’t even begin to describe the rest, but it is so much better if you go into it not knowing. If Klune’s other books are like this I AM SO EXCITED TO KEEP GOING! I loved the writing style, and it was all just amazing.

I was given an advanced reader's copy via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own

Under The Whispering Door by @tjklunebooks

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"The first time you share tea, you are a stranger. The second time you share tea, you are an honoured guest. The third time you share tea, you become family"

When I reviewed it earlier this year, you never would have been able to convince me that I'd love another book quite as much as I did The House in the Cerulean Sea. Well TJ Klune, even without Chauncey in this one to steal my heart, you've done it again!

Under The Whispering Door is, quite simply, one of the best books I've ever had the pleasure of reading. It's a very thought provoking, moving and intelligent look at life, death, grief, family and love. I couldn't put it down. Klune will have you laughing hysterically, while simultaneously crying happy tears and gut-wrenching ugly sobbing. It's all the feels at once, and it's perfect for it.

As always with Klunes books, the characters are the best part. They're all well conceived, rounded and individual, even the side characters add nothing but value to the plot. Wallace reminds me somewhat of Scrooge from Dickens' A Christmas Carol, a mean spirited but successful man who, upon his death, goes on a journey of self discovery to become a better person before moving on. Hugo is a tea shop owner and the Ferryman assigned to help Wallace come to terms with his life, his death and whatever comes next. Then there is my favourite, Nelson, Hugo's grandad, himself a ghost not quite ready to go through the whispering door. He is the mischievous spirit that brings the light relief to the story and the laughter into Wallaces life.

I'm a huge fan of a found family trope, and once again, Klune hits the spot precisely. Seeing the love blossom between Hugo and Wallace is lovely, but seeing Wallace slowing becoming a member of the Freeman family was absolutely beautiful.

This is a wonderfully heart warming, funny and original take on life, death and faith, a book that will leave you thinking about it for a long time to come. Keep doing what you're doing TJ Klune, the world is a nicer place thanks to your art..

A massive thank you to Net Galley and Tor for this advance copy of the book in exchange my my honest review.

All right, TJ Klune, you got me. Stayed up far too late last night finishing this and boy oh BOY, was it a doozy. I read and loved "The House in the Cerulean Sea", so I was supremely excited to find out I was auto-approved for this title.

Where "Cerulean Sea" has the over-arching theme of kindness and acceptance, "Whispering Door" is, at its core, about grief. It is still about kindness and acceptance, but...in a different way. I cried at "Cerulean Sea" but mostly because I was touched, and happy, and felt like I was getting a big ole hug. I SOBBED at "Whispering Door" because I felt like grief had punched me in the gut. It wasn't pretty (in fact, it was the snotty, chest pain, dog-had-to-check-on-me kinda crying.)

Thanks SO MUCH to NetGalley and the publisher for a review copy of this book.
The House in the Cerulean Sea was my number one favorite book of 2020. In many ways it got me through the craziest part of the lockdown. I LOVED it so much! I requested this as soon as I saw it on NetGalley but just now got it read.
OK. Here is the lowdown. It is NOT The House in the Cerulean Sea. It may take part in the same world (couldn't really tell) but it shares very little directly with this book. So. There is the thing I have against it. It is NOT The House in the Cerulean Sea.
That said, this book was beautiful. Technically it is about a man who is kind of an asshole lawyer who suddenly dies and goes to a waystation with a ferryman where he is supposed to come to terms with his death and pass over to the other side.
But really, this book is about . . . love. And how to live a life. And how to learn how to give, and what we gain when we do learn. And . . . about the healing properties of . . . tea. And how pure dogs are. And . . . so, so much more.
I can't tell you you will love this like Cerulean Sea. But I can tell you this book is very worth your time, and deserving of the five stars I am giving it.
Highly recommended.

I received a copy of this book for free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest and unbiased review.

It took me a bit to get into this one but once I was in, I was hooked. Hooked, get it? You will when you read it! Klune once again gives readers the novel they didn't know they needed. A must read for everyone, be prepared to laugh and cry and love it.

Thank you to Netgalley, and to the publisher and author for providing me with an electronic copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

TJ Klune's writing has always fascinated me. He seems to jump between genres so easily, and each fits him like a glove, but the one thing that connects every book he writes, that I've read, is this sense of found family. It saturates every page.

Under the Whispering Door reminds me more of The House in the Cerulean Sea than any other book that TJ Klune has written (that I've read) in that the focus is on the softness of relationships and friendships, but it doesn't ignore the prickly parts. The plot is absolutely there, and it's fantastic, but the focus is on the characters and character growth. Both books are about humanity, and hope, and finding yourself, trusting others, making a home.

I lost my grandma about a month ago, and at first I wondered if it was a good time to pick up a book about death, but what I found more than anything else is that this book is more a celebration of life, of the connections we can make. Sometimes people make bad decisions, sometimes people aren't "nice" in the strictest sense of the word, and Under the Whispering Door explores themes of self improvement and the kindness of strangers, without fear.

It's really hard to review a book like this, because all I want to do is sit in a corner with it and cry a little bit when I think about it. Sometimes those tears are sad and sometimes they're happy, but reading this book was a cathartic experience for me in the aftermath of my grandmother's funeral and I think I read it at the exact right time.

AMAZING!! This book was above and beyond anything I was expecting. It was funny, heartfelt and extremely entertaining. I loved all the characters in the book and found the story to be highly enjoyable. TJ Klune has a remarkable way of writing which makes me feel like I"m watching a movie instead of reading a book. This is one of those rare books where I'm sad I won't be able to read it for the first time ever again. I would highly recommend this book!

Thank you NetGalley and Macmillan-Tor/Forge for allowing me to read this story in exchange for an honest review.

Just call me the the Grinch because I swear my heart grew a size with every chapter. This is honestly one of the most wholesome books I have read in a very long time.

It reminded me a lot of ‘A Monster Calls,’ as this is also a whimsical story that so gently and lovingly explores grief and how to cope with loss. But in the same vein as ‘The Midnight Library’ and ‘The Five People You Meet in Heaven,’ this also insightfully shows what it means to live a good life, who to live it for, and how it is never too late to make it mean something.

This is my first book by TJK, but it will not be my last. Only a special author can create a story that radiates so much heart and warmth.

TJ Klune writes the most charming books. This one had me laughing and crying, sometimes simultaneously. I adored it and recommend it to everyone I meet.

Wallace was hard working. Wallace was precise. Wallace was correct. Worst of all, Wallace was an attorney. Being dead did not fit into his schedule.

Instead of finishing up his tidy work at the practice one Saturday afternoon, Wallace finds himself in a little tea shop in the woods where a cheeky woman who calls herself a reaper, a calm and empathetic young man, a very enthusiastic dog and a tenacious old ghost dwell. Together, they struggle to understand death and loss and what it means to have time.

Like most books by TJ Klune, this one is not terribly exciting, but it's somehow incredibly compelling all the same. The characters are carefully woven from threads of diverse backgrounds, unique history, unexpected health and mental health conditions and believable opinions. Add in the twist of what it might be like to die and find the way to the hereafter along with a touch of hipster culture and a dash of adorable gay romance, and you get a book that's difficult to put down. There are definitely some thought-provoking scenes and a few places that are bound to make anyone cry, but overall, this is a cozy reflection on what makes a person human and what it means to really live. It's certainly one of the first things I'd turn to on a rainy Saturday afternoon, but it's not something I'll be able to stop thinking about anytime soon.

Wallace wasn’t expecting to die. He still had so much work to do at the office. Lo and behold, that wasn’t a priority for anyone but Wallace. When he comes to, at his funeral, he’s flabbergasted to realize that no one in his life liked him. When he is brought to Hugo, a ferryman, Wallace must figure out if he’s ready to go to the afterlife as he is or if he can change for the better.
Under the Whispering Door by T.J. Klune is poignant, moving and absorbing. Klune is a master at characterization. He managed to make you hate Wallace immediately only to completely fall in love with him a short while later. Every character is so well rounded and delightful, even the cranky ones. Wallace and Hugo were so surprised by the relationship they were forming, it made me root for them. I loved this book so much.

This book was amazing! It is a wonderfully entertaining and heartwarming story with a delightful alternative take on reaper mythology and a beautiful exploration of the stages of grief and the age old question of the meaning of life. There were time when this story was hilariously funny, beautifully heartwarming and gut wrenchingly tragic. Like House on the Cerulean Sea, this book sat with me for hours after I finished reading it. It was simply beautiful.