Member Reviews

I sincerely cannot recommend this book enough. If I could give seven stars to this incredible novel, I would!

Wallace Price is not a kind man. As an uptight lawyer, he is well-accustomed to ignoring feelings in order to get down to the cold, hard facts. Firing a struggling woman with a crumbling family and daughter in college- no problem for Wallace. Aside from the fact that she won't stop crying in his office, of course.

Imagine his surprise when he finds himself a visitor at his own funeral. Believing it to be some kind of prank, Wallace desperately wants to get back to the office and back to work. It isn't until his Reaper, Mei, brings him to a funky tea shop in the woods that he finally begins the process of accepting what he really is- dead.

The tea shop houses a few other quirky characters besides Mei. There are two ghosts, an old, mischievous man named Nelson and his sidekick dog Apollo, and there is Hugo, the ferryman meant to prepare Wallace for what comes next. This quirky collection of characters teach Wallace how to live and love, which are unfortunate revelations seeing as Wallace is already dead. It doesn't help matters that he is falling hard for the kind and oh, so handsome ferryman.

This story will have you laughing out loud on one page and crying the next. You'll never want to put it down after getting to know this wonderful people, but when you eventually do, your heart will be so full.

If you enjoyed The House in the Cerulean Sea, you will undoubtedly love Under the Whispering Door. I'm already preparing to reread!

Special thanks to NetGalley for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange for my honest opinions.

Was this review helpful?

I have heard of TJ Klune but never read his books previously. I absolutely adored this! It is clever and sweet and for half the book all I could think was- how did the author come up with this fantastically interesting idea, and execute it so well? I was rooting for our characters the entire way, even when our hero starts out as a pretty despicable living being. The more he progressed (as a non-living being) the more I appreciated the narrative of change and growth from whereever we are. Bonus points for a slow burn romance, fantastic side characters, and so much heart. I will be recommending this to my school's book club, and eventually my son. This was a perfect read for fall, and especially for this lover of mythology I appreciated the touches of modern myth-making. Five deliriously happy and sweet stars!

Was this review helpful?

What can I say about this book? My favorite book of the year so far is hands-down House in the Cerulean Sea, so as soon as I found out about this I knew I needed to read it. I will admit I was a little scared of going into this because I didn’t want to be disappointed with how much I loved his other book but I can say I was not. This book was everything I was hoping it would be.

This book has trigger warnings for different types of death, but if you can handle that then this is definitely worth the read.

Mr. Klune really knows how to write his characters. Similarly to Cerulean Sea, he writes a main character that is just so unlikable because of his grumpy and overly important demeanor. He thinks everybody should worship the ground he walks on and doesn’t know how to enjoy anything in life because he thinks it should be only about work. He doesn’t care about having personal relationships or building connections with people and instead he enjoys making his clients cry and he stays away from feelings. You can’t help but dislike Wallace, but then by the end of the story he has grown on you so much that you don’t want to see the book end. TJ is amazing at character development and making you have mixed feelings on whether you should like them or not.

I did have one little issue with this book that annoyed me enough that it is something I feel I should bring up. I felt like there was a lot of stuttering in this book. For some reason he wrote most of the characters as people who are often unable to finish sentences, as they are just left hanging and incomplete. I was OK with it happening a few times but it happened very often. I was left confused as to why this was necessary. If he was using a particular plot device it was lost on me.

This was the only major flaw I found with the book, however that and the fact that I didn’t like it as much as Cerulean Sea brought this down to ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.💫

Special thanks to @netgalley and @torbooks for the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

I had weeks to read this before the release date last week but life got away. I finally sat down with it & when I did, I was sad it took me so long to get to it.

TJ Klune is back with this charming & heartwarming story. Klune has a way of making you fall into an enchantment with his endearing characters. Even the grumpy ones! I feel like hypnotized me into being their BFFs. One thing I love about this book is that just makes you want to be all warm and cozy. He continuously pulls me into this world of magic. With that said, this story is dark. But in typical Klune fashion, where there is dark, there is light. He beautifully encapsulates the life and hope of the world but is realistic enough to showcase the grief and despair that goes with it. Please check the trigger warnings for this book. Klune puts a warning at the beginning of the book.

Was this review helpful?

Be prepared to be blown away. TJ Klune knows how to tug on your heart strings. I loved the characters in this book.. The lessons learned are numerous and this book is so much more than words on a page.

Was this review helpful?

THERE WILL BE NO MORE PAIN. THERE WILL BE NO MORE SORROW. YOU'LL KNOW PEACE BECAUSE YOU'LL BE TOGETHER - hugo freeman

• First, I loved the humour injected into this. Things can get heavy when you're talking about death, so the humour balanced it.
• Wallace's delusions were so funny
• GODDAMN CHILI 🌶
• Oh the gardener. The thirst is real 🥵
• I already knew that I'll love Mei just with her intro alone. She's fierce and funny. 🔪🔪
• IF WE WORRY ABOUT THE LITTLE THINGS ALL THE TIME, WE RUN THE RISK OF MISSING THE BIGGER THINGS
• Nelson's and Apollo's intro. 🤣
• Oh Hugo. Wallace swooned immediately. 😍
• HE MOVED WITH GRACE, EVERY ACTION DELIBERATE, ALMOST AS IF HE WERE DANCING
• Pacing is a bit slow at first. This is a character driven novel so it made sense.
• Omg Apollo's backstory was so pure, it got me so emotional. 🥰
• HE WASN'T THE ANSWER TO EVERYTHING, BUT IT WAS A START
• Wallace torturing Mei and then Nelson castigating him. 🤣
• I loved their nightly pseudo-intellectual talks as Hugo put it.
• Nelson was such a loveable grandad. He was a good mentor to Wallace, and he never lost his sense of humour despite being dead.
• Wallace in bikini, and Hugo complimenting his legs. 😆
• HINDSIGHT IS A POWERFUL THING
• I loved the development of Hugo and Wallace's relationship. It was slow and quiet.
• It was the smallest things that made me giddy like a small smile or aquick glance. Also, Wallace simply being there for Hugo even without talking, just tap tap tapping.
• MULTITUDES
• Wallace's wardrobe mishaps were so funny. That skeleton spandex with that imprint. Oh honey, Hugo's thrist was real 🥵
• Then came Lea's and Nancy's story 😭😭
• "YOU SHOULD HAVE UNEXPECTED IT" - a good life advice 😆
• I love the relationship of Wallace and Nelson.
• It was so frustating that Hugo and Wallace cant touch each other. UUGHHH
• "ITS EASY TO LET YOURSELF SPIRAL AND FALL" "IT IS, BUT ITS WHAT YOU DO TO PULL YOURSELF OUT OF IT THAT MATTERS MOST"
• Cameron's story was so hard to take in.
• Omg when Hugo asked Mei to hug Wallace for him, I died and came back. 🥰🥰
• I love that Hugo and Wallace were honest with each other.
• When Hugo asked the "right" question and Hugo answered yes, I screamed.
• blossoms in shades of ochre and fuschia, cerulean and scarlet, canary and magenta
•  A QUEER HOUSE MADE UP OF MANY DIFFERENT IDEAS
• The Manager was such a character. He was funny and snarky.
• The 7 days deadline broke me. 😭😭
• Wallace had a great arc. He was very selfish at first,  but through the help of Hugo and the others, he leared how to be selfless. He used his remaining time in helping Nancy find peace, and in helping Cameron come home.
• When Wallace asked Mei to hug Hugo for him, my heart jumped in happiness. 🥰🥰
• WE DON'T NEED YOU BECAUSE THAT IMPLIES YOU NEED TO FIX SOMETHING IN US. WE WERE NEVER BROKEN. WE WANT YOU, WALLACE
• I screamed when they went to Hugo's room. It was so tender how they talked about their feelings about each other; the way they both imagined what could have been. 🥲🥲
• It was roller coaster of emotions when Wallace let go and was going to the fourth floor. All of them rushing to catch up and to stop him.
• The Manager bringing Wallace back to life - I gagged
• And of course the first thing Hugo did was to kiss the love of his life 😍
• That epilogue was so peaceful but still painful
• Lastly, I just wanna say that I really love this one. I love how affected I am with the characters. They made me laugh with them, then crying the next. I highly recommend this one. 💙💙💙

Was this review helpful?

T.J. Klune’s new novel Under the Whispering Door is pure, heartwarming magic. I loved this story so much that I know nothing I write here is going to convey just how special this book is. I’m going to try though so bear with me.

The story follows Wallace Price and it actually begins with his death. Wallace was apparently such a jerk while he was alive that only four people show up for his funeral — his ex-wife and his three partners from his law firm — and based on their comments, they all clearly did not like him. Also in attendance at the funeral, is Wallace himself, or rather the ghost of Wallace. He’s somewhat in disbelief that he’s actually dead and mad because he still had so much work to do, cases to prepare for, etc. He’s also furious about the nasty comments the funeral attendees are making about him.

Wallace is distracted by all of this, however, when he realizes that a mystery woman who is also attending the funeral can actually see him in his ghost form. She introduces herself as Mei and explains that she is a Reaper who has come to collect his soul and help him to cross over to the afterlife. Instead of taking him directly to the afterlife, however, Mei instead leads the reluctant Wallace to a tea shop located in a small, remote village. There she introduces him to Hugo, the owner of the tea shop who also happens to be a ferryman to souls who need to cross to the afterlife. Wallace insists he isn’t ready to leave his life behind and thus begins a journey with Hugo that allows him to fully discover and explore all the things he missed out on in life while he was so fully obsessed with work and power, including love, kindness, and family, just to name a few biggies.

This story is filled with laugh out loud moments as Wallace adjusts to his “life” as a ghost and particularly as he is constantly teased by Mei and punked by another resident ghost, Hugo’s grandfather. Hugo’s grandfather steals every scene he is in, as does Hugo’s loyal ghost dog, Apollo. Aside from being hilarious though, Under the Whispering Door is also just an all around moving, emotional story because of its focus on love and loss, and living life to the fullest. It explores death and how we all deal with loss and grief differently, and I guess maybe because I had just lost a loved one right before I read this book, that aspect of the story really resonated with me. I cried just as much as I laughed, especially because Wallace grows so much throughout the story that I went from hating him and thinking he was the worst person ever to absolutely adoring him and never wanting him to pass on and leave Hugo and Mei, his wonderful found family, behind. That’s a pretty powerful transformation for a character to make and T.J. Klune does it in such a beautiful and realistic way.

I could go on and on about everything I loved about this book, but you’ll really want to experience all of its magic yourself. Under the Whispering Door is a book that’s going to stay with me for a long time and it has definitely placed T.J. Klune on my list of auto-buy authors.

Was this review helpful?

Have you ever known from the moment you met a character that the book your are reading is about to break your heart? This happened with the characters in Under the Whispering Door, but not in the way I thought they would. I did cry though. A lot! Not for sad reasons though, just an ‘all the emotions’ reason. My favourite kind of book!

This is the first TJ Klune novel I have read, and after this I will definitely be looking for other novels of his. From the first page I already had a feeling I would love this novel and it’s characters, by the end of chapter one I was hooked entirely. There is something beautifully warm about the way that Klune has written this novel, like a warm hug or a cup of tea on a cold day. I couldn’t get enough. So much so that I just wanted to read it all over again the moment I finished it.

The concept for this novel is so wonderfully unique, and beautifully executed too. It delves into concepts of death, loss and grief, as well as love, acceptance of self, and personal growth. Each of these are carefully written, and teased out in such a way that they make you really think deeply and reflect on your own life.

The characters in this novel are all delightful. Each one of the main group I would love to be able know them myself. Something else who h is really beautiful within this novel is the journey of growth and understanding the main character Wallace goes through. It is subtlety (and not so subtlety) threaded throughout the novel as he realises the person he was, and who he has the potential to be (and wants to be).

The romance in this novel was the most delicate slow burn. While I had a feeling that this was going to be the case, it still seemed to take me by surprise in the best way possible. The pair are gentle with each other and really listen to each other. This is one of those relationships which was meant to be, but the timing was wrong for one half. This difficulty of the situation was heartbreaking, but beautiful to read.

Under the Whispering Door was such a wonderful read. It handled the darker themes with care, but not so much that they didn’t hold weight throughout the story. It was heartfelt and filled with beautiful characters and a funny, quick witted humour which I loved. I recommend this book to anyone who loves a well written, character focused story with a tender slow burn queer romance. This was definitely a favourite read for this year.

Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for sending me this free eARC, I am leaving this review voluntarily. This title was published 21st September 2021.

Was this review helpful?

“Death is only their beginning.”

Well, TJ Klune has done it again! I just adored The House in the Cerulean Sea so I had very high hopes for his newest novel and I was not disappointed. Swipe for the synopsis.

Under the Whispering door is a beautiful written, wholesome contemporary fantasy with all the humour and quirkiness I have come to expect from Klune. This book explores life and death and everything between. Full of hope, grief, happiness and sadness, this book explores what it means to live and will have you experiencing all the feelings!

Klune expertly crafts the characters in his stories, giving them each unique personalities that shine throughout the book. Although heartbreaking, this book also felt like a warm hug at the same time, showing us that even after death, it is never too late to change your life.

Although this one wasn’t quite as good as the Cerulean Sea, I still loved it and highly recommend everyone picking up this book.

Under the Whispering door is released on September 28th here in Australia.

Thank you to Pan Macmillan Australia and TOR publishing for my gifted copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

TW: This book is based around accepting death and moving on, so please keep this in mind before picking up this book

Was this review helpful?

This book is incredibly charming. I would say this is a mix of Cerulean Sea and A Christmas Carol. We have the charming, cozy, tea house where Wallace learns that he didn't live much of a life. Hugo gets to help him learn in a short amount of time. I loved the found family feel to everyone there in the tea shop. That's where the Cerulean Sea vibes came in for me.
This book made me laugh, and it made me thing. This book does deal a lot with death, grief, and many other hard topics, so please tread cautiously if those are triggers for you.
This one didn't quite live up to Cerulean Sea for me, but it is still a solid read. Would recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I’m not sure TJ Klune can write a bad book, honestly. This book had everything I would expect from one of his books. Warmth, smiles, grade A humor, subtle but meaningful life lessons, queer romance, and the perfect found family.

This book is perfect for spooky season, especially for those like me who prefer “spoopy” over spooky. The ghosts and after-life elements of this book made it very fitting for the end of September, but the light hearted-ness of the story and characters kept it from being creepy. It was actually way more emotional than I was originally expecting. You will definitely finish this book with a great appreciation for life and the time you have with loved ones.

My favorite part of this book was the found family aspect. I love getting to see the characters connect and the love they had for each other by the end. And the fact that they really did look at each other like family. It was very heart warming and gave me the same feeling I had when reading House in the Cerulean Sea.

This is a must read for any fans of TJ a Klune, but especially anyone who loved House in the Cerulean Sea.

Was this review helpful?

The House in the Cerulean Sea was perhaps the best book I read in 2020, and is a book that I think about quite often so the minute I saw that this book was available I knew I needed to have it.

This book took me a little bit to get into. I started and stopped a few times and the first 50% took me quite a while to get through There wasn't anything wrong with it, I just wasn't as invested as I wish I would be. But then I sat and read the entire second half of the book in one setting, getting completely swept up in the characters, setting, and story.

So while it took me a little bit to get invested by the time that I was I needed to know more and more. I fell in love with the characters swiftly and once I was truly in their world I didn't want to leave.

This book explores the important ideas of death, life, and what happens when we die. It talks about the people that we leave behind, but it also talks about what happens to us. It examines the baggage that we bring with us everywhere we go and how that affects us now.

This is a book that I am excited to pick up again and again, because I think that it has a lot more to teach me.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my God. I didn't know how T. J. Klune could top The House in the Cerulean Sea. But they did.
Under the Whispering Door is so beautiful and sad. It's going to make you cry both happy and sad tears. It's going to make you think and probably have an existential crisis as well.
I loved every part about the tea shop and I wish it was a real place.

Was this review helpful?

And the Love/Hate relationship with Mr. @TJKlune continues. #EvilAuthor #ThereWereSoManyTears

If you’ve been here before or are a frequent reader of my reviews from other venues, you already know that if you see this author’s name attached to anything I’m about to review it’s going to be a rambling mess. If not, prepare yourself. I just can’t seem to be concise and to the point when it comes to writing a review about any book by any author that leaves me in awe. It’s pretty much guaranteed that when I pick up one of his books, that’s going to be the case, so consider yourself warned.

Another thing that’s pretty much guaranteed when I pick up a book by this author is that I’ll experience some type of emotion. Long time readers of T.J. Klune have learned the hard way to limit their public reading of any of his works. He has a tendency to catch readers off guard with fits of uncontrollable laughter or have them reduced to a blubbering mess. Given the description I was pretty sure which way Under the Whispering Door was going to go on the emotion scale. I wasn’t wrong, but I wasn’t totally right either.

I’m kind of ashamed to admit that Under the Whispering Door started a little slow for me. I think I was impatient to get to the good stuff. And to be totally frank, there wasn’t a lot of “good” surrounding Wallace. He was, to be blunt, a total jerk. I’ll let you meet him and form your own first impression without describing what made me come to that conclusion. Honestly, I didn’t see how he could be redeemed into a character that I would eventually care about. I thought once I met Hugo, Mei, Nelson and even Apollo that they would be the characters that stole my heart and drove the story. Although that’s true, Wallace definitely took me by surprise. ❤

I also have to say that I was quite surprised that it took me until almost somewhere between chapters 17 and 18 to turn into a blubbering mess. Considering that Under the Whispering Door consists of 22 chapters plus the epilogue, that’s pretty impressive. 😉 (FYI – that doesn’t include the tears that were induced by the dedication…) Not all those tears were sad. A lot were happy tears and some were simply heartfelt. One thing that I’ve come to expect from any book from this author is that I’m guaranteed to feel something. For the record, Under the Whispering Door did not disappoint.

I was extremely lucky to score an ARC of this book, but since I knew I was going to read it regardless, I also made sure to pre-purchase the hard cover. You know, to complete my growing TJ collection. 😉

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of Under the Whispering Door. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

TJ Klune's latest novel, Under the Whispering Door (Macmillan-Tor), just came out last week.

This novel is about a man who is picked up at his own funeral by a reaper and taken to a tea shop where he meets a man who will help him "cross over." Our main character has to not only accept his death but go through all the stages of grief, twice actually.

The story starts with all the hope of the whimsy that Klune gave us in Cerulean Sea, but he just didn't keep it up. For that reason I just didn't love it, because it wasn't the style of writing I was looking for. And maybe that's unfair as it is a completely different work.

He does nicely work through acceptance and the stages of grief, and the character goes through quite the journey. The romantic relationship in the book again felt forced to me as it did in Cerulean Sea, but not quite as badly. This one ended up at least having some ground to stand on.

Should you read it? Do you want to read book that has a sad undertone the entire time? If so, then go for it. Check trigger warnings first as the book does discuss multiple paths to death.

A copy of this book was provided to me for review by Netgalley in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

This was my first time reading T.J. Klune but I’ll definitely be picking up their other work after this one! I found this book funny, heartwarming and even sometimes a little bit sad.
We follow Wallace Price, a workaholic attorney who has little regard for the people around him. When he unexpectedly has a heart attack in his office he finds himself trapped, wandering out of his body until a woman called Mei turns up to find him. Mei is sent to bring Wallace to a quirky little tea-shop where Hugo the ferryman is waiting to help him pass over into the afterlife. It’s time for Wallace to do some self-reflecting whilst he still has a chance.
Even though at the start he’s an unlikeable character, Wallace is such an easy character to care for and become invested in. The group of characters at the tea-shop are all likeable in their own way but are also all flawed beings. I could have stayed reading about the tea-shop and the people who passed through for even longer, it felt so cosy and safe. This was a really strong novel and I’m so excited to see what this author does next.
If you enjoyed ‘They Both Die at the End’ by Adam Silvera then this has similar themes about seizing the day but has a lighter, more humorous tone throughout.

Was this review helpful?

I was grateful to be gifted a copy of this book in return for an honest review.

I devoured this book in one day, in just a couple of sittings. It was so easy to read, and Klune has a wonderful, natural writing style. The story seems to be both plot-driven and character driven at the same time. It was great.

At the beginning I was getting major A Christmas Carol/It’s a Wonderful Life/Midnight Library vibes, but as I read on it evolved into so much more. Comparing it to other stories (even though they are amazing) just doesn’t do the book justice.

TJ Klune manages to interweave humour, sadness, grief and love effortlessly. The queer representation was also effortless. It didn’t feel forced at all, but totally natural, helped by the slow burn nature of the relationship.

At points I was a bit confused about how it all worked and what exactly was happening, but that’s okay. The book shows us it’s okay to not always have the answers, haha! I did, however, predict the ending. That didn’t frustrate me or take anything away from the story though; it was still enjoyable and a very satisfying conclusion.

It’s publicised as a fantasy book. I’m not a fantasy fan at all, but really enjoyed this as it’s not *too* fantasy - so hopefully this won’t deter anyone!

Definitely a 5* for me and I’ll be recommending it to everyone.

Was this review helpful?

This book was better than I thought it would be. I loved the character development of Wallace thru his afterlife experience. I loved how he figured out how to love others and give of himself in the utmost way. This book does not follow the beliefs I know to be true, but I am able to look past that and appreciate the creativity and thought that went into this novel, the characters, the possibilities of life after death. I grew to love Wallace, Hugo, Mei, Nelson, and Apollo - and also to make connections with each of them. I give this book 4.75 stars. I would give it 5 if it weren't the discrepancies between this storyline and my belief in God.

Was this review helpful?

There are certain elements of the human experience we know to be universal: love and death.

If they come in that order, most of us would say that life is good. But what if death came first?

What I Liked
This is a beautiful exploration of the ideas many of hold around love and death. With it’s gorgeous, memorable character development and a setting so clear and cozy you felt like you were right there, this book drew me in from the very first page.

There are places you will laugh, get infuriated, sigh with satisfaction, and be truly touched by the genuine emotion the author inspires.

What I Wish Had Been Different

I have just one small critique. Toward the end of the book, the pacing slowed a bit for me. I was incredibly vested in the characters, however, so it wasn’t a struggle to finish this book. In fact, I couldn’t read the last few chapters fast enough.

For its imaginative plot, its courageous exploration of love after death, and for the kind of characters that are so likeable and memorable that you almost hate that the book ended, I give this book 4.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

I'm not sure what it is about TJ Klune's writing but the two books I've read by him have made me cry like no other. (In a good way, if that's possible.)

Under the Whispering Door follows Wallace, a big time, all-work-no-play lawyer who must confront the gaps in his life when he suddenly dies of a heart attack. He's taken to a quirky tea show run by a ferry man named Hugo, where he's allowed to stay as a ghost until he's ready to cross over.

Much like The House in the Cerulean Sea, this is a funny and whimsical book that packs a big punch. It discusses death and and grief and regrets and learning to let people in. I really adored the supporting characters in this one, especially Nelson. I also loved the tenderness between Hugo and Wallace and how much they were able to grow over the story. I think this will definitely appeal to fans of The House in Cerulean Sea and The Midnight Library and I highly highly recommend it!

Thanks so much to Tor Books and NetGalley for the digital review copy.

Was this review helpful?