Skip to main content

Member Reviews

❝The only thing worse than making another champion your enemy is making them a friend.❞

Murder, magic, teens fighting to the death, betrayals... All of Us Villains was one of my most anticipated reads of 2021. The premise and characters, this sounded brilliant especially as it was pitched as the next The Hunger Games I was so excited!

Unfortunately this failed to deliver for me, it felt kind of lacklustre? The threats didn't feel as high as they were meant to, the murder was dialled down to about 2/10, and the two girls' narratives (Briony and Isobel) were quite similar so it was sometimes hard to discern which perspective I was reading from.

Don't get me wrong, this had some great moments that stood out. I loved the relationship between Alastair and his brother Hendry. I liked the relationship between Alastair and Isobel. I liked how Alastair was such a rich character, he had many sides to him and he's not quite the villain you expect. (Can you tell who my favourite was yet? lol) I liked how most of the characters had their own motives and felt well fleshed out. I wonder why the authors decided to only include the perspectives from four contestants (Alastair, Briony, Isobel and Gavin) and then there were three others that I didn't really care about, we don't get to read from their viewpoint so we don't get to connect with them unfortunately.

❝Monsters couldn't harm you if you were a monster, too.❞

The plot was good, I liked the pacing and the drama does build but it didn't feel like high stakes. There were some shocking moments, such as the lengths some families and people will go to in order to win this tournament. I really enjoyed the aspect of magical jewellery containing spells and curses, this was one of my favourite parts of the book and the use of magic was explained well. I liked the romance between certain characters, it has the 'only one bed' trope and a suggestive 'make me' comment among many other cute moments, which I enjoyed!

I liked the world-building but it felt a bit rushed at times, I wanted more. Some families houses were described in a lot of detail, whereas others felt like it was just brushed over.

❝Full of dark-stained pine wood and iron candlebras, it was where maidens pricked their fingers on spinning wheels, where every fruit tasted of poison and vice.❞

All of Us Villains is half of a duology, and this ends on a big cliffhanger. I was left with more questions than answers at the ending and this left me unsatisfied. I will read the next instalment to see how it ends as I need answers to my questions.

3 out of 5 stars overall.

*Thank you to the publishers for allowing me to read this in exchange for an honest review

CW/TWs:
•murder
•toxic relationships
•violence
•blood
•death
•grief
•emotional abuse
•emetophobia
•generational trauma

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars, rounded up

I'm not usually one for villain stories. Even morally grey characters aren't always my jam. But I ended up enjoying this.

I think that the characters and the world both get an equal amount of time to shine. Maybe occasionally the two main female character's POVs sounded a little similar and I'd have to take a moment to remind myself who was narrating, but they were both still good characters. The two main male characters felt different enough and were both interesting.

I really liked the magic Hunger Games setting. It definitely felt Hunger Games-y, but had enough to set it apart.

Also, even though it's definitely Hunger Games-esque, this felt unique enough to stand out in a crowd of overwhelmingly similar YA fantasies. I actually think I'll still remember enough from this one that I won't have to read a recap when the next book in the series comes out. (although I do kinda wish it had been a standalone....)


Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan-Tor/Forge for the advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

It's not the journey that mattered but the villains we met along the way.

Full review at A Book Shrew

First off, I had extremely high expectations for this book. Like, sky high. I vowed I would give a limb to read this early and I'm fairly certain half my soul was taken in return for the physical ARC I now hold (shoutout to Raincoast Books and Amanda Foody for that). And somehow, despite all that, this book still shattered every one of my expectations. AoUV is incredible. As far as dual-author books go, this was such a compelling and cohesive story. The writing style is impeccable, the story beautifully crafted with multi POVs, and full of so much emotion poured directly into the characters at its heart.

This book did not come to play. It is dark and ruthless thanks to the cursed tournament that has taken place every 20 years for the last eight centuries. When the Blood Moon appears, the seven major families of Ilvernath have one month to prepare their champion before the Blood Veil falls, and the games begin. The Tournament can only end one of two ways. Either one champion kills the other six with the magic at their disposal or through brute force, or all seven die at the end of three months. The prize for the winning family: control of high magick, the most powerful and rare type of magic known to man. This year, the Tournament has been thrust into the international spotlight after a book was published spilling all the gory details of the town, the families, and the curse. The government is trying to intervene where they can, reporters tail each champion, and people are desperate to know these reluctant celebrities.

Like I said, the characters at the center of this story are what made it sing. Each champion is so thoughtfully created, and not a single one of them enters the Blood Veil without something wrong or unexpected happening beforehand. The stakes were truly unparalleled. Seven are trapped inside the Blood Veil, but only four matter to us.

Alistair Lowe is arguably my favourite. The Lowes have won the Tournament the most, and Alistair is the most dangerous, the most powerful, the most villainous of the champions. He knows it too, even though he wishes he weren't sometimes.

Isobel Macaslan is my second favourite. She never wanted to be her family's champion, but somehow became the international face of the Tournament. She is not locally liked, though, thanks to her magic-scavenging family, which could prevent her from getting cursemaker sponsorship.

Gavin Grieve is from the weakest and least liked family in Ilvernath, a problem not helped by the fact that an anonymous Grieve has been credited with publishing the damning tell-all. He has zero hope in winning the Tournament, and he is determined to prove everyone wrong.

Briony Thorburn is the most ambitious of the champions. Her entire life she has trained to be her family's champion, but when her sister is named as champion instead at the government's request, she spirals hard.

The villain angle is so fascinating because of these characters and their motives. Alistair is fashioned as THE villain but I think the true villain is actually [REDACTED] Each character has their own questionable reasons for their behaviour, but they also have seriously solid ones that stem from their individual families, their childhoods, and the expectations that have been set both by themselves and their families, all in the name of glory. It's hard to stay good in the face of all that and death.

I don't know how I'll be able to wait until the next book. I was very curious how this would carry on as a duology, but know that Foody and Herman have laid out some fabulous stepping stones for what promises to be an explosive conclusion.

Was this review helpful?

This creepy tale of magick pits friends, loved ones, and enemies against each other in a quest for control and power. A powerful curse forces a group of young people to fight to the death every 20 years to see who gets to control the the magick that rules the world. Can the curse be broken?

I enjoyed reading this book and look forward to the next installment.

Was this review helpful?

I love both of these authors, so I knew I had to read this. I was not disappointed! There really isn't much to say about it other than if you like Hunger Games and usually root for the villain, this is 100% the book for you.

Was this review helpful?

The world building, and creation of both the magical system and the magical competition combined with the great writing made this a "couldn't put down read for me". It was probably a 4 to 5 Star read for me up until the last 25%. I definitely had a little bit of a love/hate thing going on here. Not going to lie, the last quarter wiped me out emotionally. I was so into it and then....ooofta, the two characters I actually cared about turned directions and I kind of wanted to throw the book across the room. Which is a good sign that the authors definitely had me -I got all whipped up and was so excited and then (bwahaha authors cackling) kaboom they wiped me out - and now i'm still picking up my little sentimental bits off the floor...
**Thank you to both NetGalley and TOR Teen for an eARC of this in exchange for my honest review**

So its hard for me to accurately rate this one. Once I can read a sequel and move past this downer part of the story might I look back on the first book without so much disappointment? Possibly, and more than likely. It definitely might be one of those series that's better for me to read once the sequel has come out so I don't have to dwell in this depressing ending and not be able to move on yet to better things. I know its trendy currently to end a book with a character entering their "dark night of the soul" arc, but I hate it, and if the next book isn't currently available I dislike it even more. And here we had several characters all heading into that arc at the same time so...yeah not my favorite ending - all I have to say is if at least one of those two doesn't have a redemptive arc (and stop being an idiot) in the next book then I am definitely throwing that book across the room.

All that being said there's plenty of people who will eat this up, and be far less traumatized emotionally than I (particularly Teen and NA audiences). Hence why I still gave it a 4 Star rating, I fully recognize my emotional response/irritation will probably not be the typical one (I'm not gonna lie I don't do well when authors add bad things onto bad choices, onto more bad things happening, onto more bad choices etc. I need a rainbow in there somewhere:)

Was this review helpful?

I'm really torn about this one. All of Us Villains has a slow but intriguing start, and we're nearly half-way through by the time the Hunger Games comparisons start to really come into play. However, I was engrossed the whole way through - I enjoyed learning more about these characters, and the last half is much more action packed, with plenty of twists and turns.
There are some flaws here though. Despite being a huge fan of novels with multiple POVs, I didn't always feel that the different characters had solid enough personalities to make it work in this case. I sometimes had difficulty keeping track of who was who.
Ultimately, the biggest let-down here was the very abrupt ending, which dragged my rating down from a solid 3.5 (with moments of 4), to a 3. Everything felt quite rushed, and there was no feeling of conclusion at all. I was once sent an incomplete ARC by mistake, and this honestly felt like that - I get that there's a second book (although I foolishly assumed this was a standalone going into it), and can appreciate the decision to end the first installment at this point, but it didn't feel like a fully formed cliffhanger either. I want to know what happens next, but I'm not sure if I'll remember everything that happened by the time the sequel comes out. I can see myself picking it up, as I certainly had a great experience reading this book until its climax, but my ultimate feeling is sadly one of disappointment.
Thanks to Orion and Netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely enjoyed this book - honestly when I started it I didn't realize it was a series and was getting really worried as I neared the end of the book with some very major plot points still outstanding!

The vibe is absolutely The Hunger Games with magic and at times... the results of that magic was quite gory which I loved! This title is absolutely fitting for the novel as well - it's hard to determine who I was cheering for most but Alistair seems to hold a special place in my heart.

I hope we get more villainy in the second installment but what a great start to a new series!

Thank you for the opportunity to read early!

Was this review helpful?

This was so much fun to read! It lost me at some point around the middle but then it picked up and the ending was great.

I would have liked it to be a bit more villain-y to be honest but I enjoyed it anyway and I'll be waiting (FOREVER) for the next book.

Was this review helpful?

This is one of my favorite books of the year and I cannot wait to get my hands on a physical copy.

Every 20 years, the Blood Veil falls over the town of Ilvernath and 7 champions are forced to compete in a cursed fight to the death in order to claim the last bit of high magic left in the world. These champions, known as the Slaughter Seven, come from 7 different families—the Lowes (the most vicious and mysterious of them all; notorious for the most amount of kills and wins, and currently the holders of the magic hoard), the Macaslans (known for their connection to the dead and the dirty way they made their fortune—by taking it from the dead at their funerals), the Darrows (known for their knowledge and wisdom), the Paynes (known for their no-nonsense attitudes and haughtiness), the Grieves (a family known for their failure to ever win and their alcoholism) and the Thorburns (known for their wealth and love for the spotlight, they are the sweethearts of the competition).

I have read some excellent books so far, but I am really expecting big things from this one. It had a Hunger Games-feel to it that I loved, but it added in magic. There was the dark enemies-to-lovers romance and one-bed trope (no smut though, which is good for YA). There were a whole lot of morally gray characters and a bit of the found family trope mixed in. I had 822 highlights to sift through because there were so many parts of the book that were just too good. I absolutely loved this book!

Was this review helpful?

I would rate the book a 3.5 but it won't let me go there! This story had interesting world-building and characters you weren't sure if you liked or hated. The characters came across as flawed and real with no real "hero" or "heroine." It is told from multiple points of view and yet there is one character whose POV is left out which I found odd. Revelations about each character's motivations and who they are as the story unfolded constantly changed your opinion. I liked how the authors spun magic and its use - there was a different take on magic which was interesting. The story ends with MAJOR cliffhangers and it is uncertain how a full book could come from wrapping the story up.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to lobe this book, but just could not get into it. It took me forever to get through and while I'm glad I pushed myself to finish, it wasn't worth it for me.

Was this review helpful?

If you identify with the hero riding in on a white horse to save the day, don't bother with this book. The characters are broken. They have been lied to, sacrificed for their families' honor, made to feel 'less than' and 'more than they could ever be.. There are curses and magically spell rings., There are betrayals and forbidden love. There is EVERYTHING and more actually and I could not put it down until the last curse fell.

Was this review helpful?

I was intrigued by the comparison to previous works - Hunger Games, but with magic. This first installation seems to fall short, however. The multiple perspectives, when done well, build an intricate and rich ensemble of characters - this story seems to dumb down the mechanic, leaving us with flat, one-dimensional personalities. The gruesome nature of the society was too much for me personally, feeling gratuitous. Also, WHY WOULD YOU END IT THERE? The cliffhanger felt too abrupt, with no resolution to carry a hope for satisfaction into a second installment.

Was this review helpful?

This will be the perfect book for readers looking for the next Hunger Games/Testing series. The families that essentially rule Ilvernath and their magic are very clearly defined, the mythology surrounding the tournament less so (the Relics and the Monuments, how things started, etc..). There are pacing issues that were a little surprising since this is a series and they could have been smoothed over. The Alister/Briony/Isobel team has a lot of promise and I'll be interested to see what happens next.

eARC provided by publisher via Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

There were many things that I liked about <i>All of Us Villains</i>. The magic system is fascinating and not quite like one I’ve read or seen before so that was refreshing. As well as the curse itself upon these seven families and all of their histories, I mostly enjoyed getting to know where everyone stood in the scheme of things. So, I can see people really enjoying it but overall I was underwhelmed. As always with anything that has multiple points of view there were some characters I preferred reading from far more than others, mostly Alistair and Isobel, as they themselves were not only layered but their families were the most interesting in the dark ways.

But what really let me down was how long it took to actually get into the action, we’re talking like 30-40% of the way in before we’re even in the curse/tournament/arena/whatever. There was far too much set up - I got the gist of the families within each of the characters first POVs and the magic system didn’t take too long to grasp.

It’s interesting that this is a duology, I think it would have actually benefitted from being a standalone and I would have felt more satisfied. At least going into the second book everything will already be set up so it shouldn’t take too long to get into but I don’t know if I care enough about everyone to read it at this point.

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this book to review from Netgalley and all opionins are my own.
This book is definitely not suitable for younger readers and perfect for those who are fans of dark fantasy, with its cast of morally grey characters and bloody scenes. The writing is incredibly atmospheric with the odd quip thrown in here and there to prevent the writing from becoming overly melodramatic. The characters are well developed and complex, each with intricately detailed and explained back stories. The story has plenty of twists and turns, some of which are truly shocking. With its breathtaking cliffhanger, I can't wait to read more about this story.

Was this review helpful?

What an absolute amazing book. I could not put this book down once I got into it. It has everything I look for in a young adult series. I would say this series is much better then several well known series as the twists are not predictable as other book series. I am so excited to find out what happens next. Leaving me at a cliffhanger has me needing the next book ASAP.

Was this review helpful?

This book, these characters!!! I am in love!

This story is told from multiple POVs. Includes magic, interesting/likable characters and a competition to the death.

Once I started reading this book I couldn't stop. The twists and turns, the world building, the characters, everything about this book is amazing and I felt genuine excitement, just wanting to know what would happen next.

Was this review helpful?

In a world where common magick is weak but plentiful, most believe that high magick has disappeared from the world entirely due to humanity’s greed and lust for power. But in the town of Ilvernath, hundreds of years ago, seven families fought over who would control Ilvernath’s high magick. A compromise was reached- a curse that they cast upon themselves. Every generation when the Blood Moon rose, each family would pick a champion to enter a tournament. Only one champion would survive, and that family would control the high magick until the next tournament began. This was kept a secret for hundreds of years…until now.

With the Blood Moon rising and a bestselling tell-all book published by a mysterious writer detailing the families’ secrets, paparazzi descend on Ilvernath to witness the tournament. Told from the perspective of four of the champions, All of Us Villains begins a tale of survival, magic, love, and mystery. Who will survive, and is there any way to break the curse and end the tournament for good?

This book was a page turner! Between the mystery of who penned the tell-all, to the conundrum of how to break a centuries old curse while you were right in the middle of it; I didn’t know which one I wanted answered more. Some of the characters seemed like stereotypes at the beginning of the book, but as the story unfolded and you got inside (some) of their heads, they became so much more than that. Each character was complex, with varying motivations and feelings about the tournament.

I also liked the way the tournament was set up. 7 relics, 7 landmarks, one for each champion. The last champion standing is the winner. If after 3 months more than one champion is still alive, they all die and the high magick goes unused until the next tournament. The whole premise of this book really worked for me.

This book was bloodthirsty and badass and a little romantic. A winning combination. I’m ready for the sequel already.

Was this review helpful?