I loved this book from the very start, both narrating characters are rich and their emotions seep through the pages in a way that makes you want to keep them safe as they navigated their journeys. The romance was the sweetest, and at least to me, the plot was unpredictable since the characters frustrations were displayed as different scenarios and you truly didn't know how the other characters would react. It was always a surprise.
This is a feel good book for sure, and the ending is open and hopeful.

I loved this book, but the cover is so boring and doesn't convey the boy band aspect of this book at all! I love a boy band, and there aren't very many novels with boy band members as characters. Part of me wishes that this had just been pure romance instead of having the subplot about drug abuse, but I think the authors were trying to paint a larger picture of the issues with the entertainment industry.

I enjoyed this, but it felt quite predictable. It was a nice short read and I did enjoy it, but it's one I would give away after reading once.

This was so much fun! I can't say I'm aware of any boy band fandom, but hey, I'm a big fan of a lot of small fans and it was intriguing to think through the relationships the members all have with each other, and especially the way that they themselves can be marketed and sold.

While I really enjoyed the characters and the message behind this book it felt so slooooooow. While I do appreciate the slow burn romance I think this definitely had a similar fault to other books written by two authors. They just feel long as heck.

I did really love this though and ended up crying some sappy tears quite often. Reuben and Zach are the cutest and I just love John to death.

This is a really beautiful book. The story is so intriguing, and the dual POV sucks you in fast. I could easily read another 300 pages of Zach and Ruben, especially the discussion behind sexuality and labeling and defining oneself.

I wish there was a bit more of a resolution with Ruben and his toxic mother, but it also felt more realistic to have it open ended. I think a lot of teens will find it relatable to as Ruben struggles to establish boundaries, while still being a bit dependent on his parents.

Sophie Gonzales has done it again--this book completely stole my heart. (And I was not familiar with Cale Dietrich's work before reading this one, but suffice to say I will DEFINITELY be reading more of it going forward.) I never went through a boy band phase, but boy oh man was I obsessed with this fictional one; if Saturday was a real group, I feel like I would totally pay for tickets to one of their shows. I can't even handle how much I loved this story.

Ruben and Zach are both flawed characters, incredibly messy and terrible at communication, like so many of Sophie's characters (Darcy Phillips, I'm looking at you...)--and like so many actual teenage boys. I know some people hate miscommunication tropes, and they can be hit-or-miss for me but in the context of these two, I think it worked really well, and the agonizing tension prior to them getting together was enhanced by the sheer frustration of knowing that they both had strong reasons to not admit their feelings.

And once the two got together, the other overarching theme of the book--the pressures of celebrity and being a teenager in the public eye, particularly when others are dictating who you are and how you're supposed to act--was really able to shine (though it initially came up earlier!). Seeing those pressures applied to all four members of Saturday--Angel rebelling with drugs and partying, John dreading his sexualized front-man status, Ruben longing for the chance to stand out, and Zach not being able to write his own songs--really highlighted how even glamorous celebrity life can be draining and actually amplify the difficulties that all teens face. These boys are all on the cusp of adulthood and trying to navigate the growing pains of finding their identities in a world that has long ascribed other identities to them, and I appreciated that viewpoint as well.

Some other amazing things you can look forward to in this book:
- a Bisexual Disaster Boy (tm), including the "wait...am I bi???" moment
- discussion of toxic parent/child relationships (doesn't use the word "emotional abuse" but that's clearly what it is, and as someone who has had an experience with a similar--though less-severe--situation, Ruben's internal conflict over establishing boundaries was very realistic to me)
- super healthy parent-child relationships (please let Zach's mom be my mom too?)
- kissing by a canal in Europe
- so. much. banter. I literally laughed out loud multiple times.
- friends-to-lovers, an underutilized trope
- ALL THE ANGST.
- well-handled anxiety rep (again, as someone with anxiety, this was beyond relatable to me)
- solid and supportive friendships weathering even some really shitty situations
- sweet, cute, fluffy moments galore
- lawsuits???

One of my only "complaints"--if it could be called one--is that this book is a standalone. I think that, with how the many characters' issues all concluded, it would have been easy, and even advisable, to have a second book where Zuben can navigate their new relationship now that all their issues are out in the open, where Angel's new sobriety could be further explored, where Ruben's attempt at putting up boundaries with his mom could be explored, and where we could get a little more insight on John as a whole, especially how he will act now that he's out from under his father's thumb.

But honestly, that is such a negligible issue, maybe even a non-issue. I freaking loved this book, and I can't recommend it enough!

The feels. I absolutely adored this book and honestly, I was surprised with how charmed I was by this story. The characters are truly delightful and I felt an unexpected connection to a few of them. The pacing was also great and I quickly found myself swept up in these characters lives and their conflicts. The authors have also done a great job of crafting a narrative around the pressures and downsides of being in the spotlight - definitely a thought starter. A sweet romance coupled with great characters is what keeps you hooked.

This was a great read, I found it difficult to put down even though it touched on some topics that were kind of heavy.
This was my first book by either of these authors, but it certainly won't be my last.

this is a fun ya read that also deals with a lot of issues like homophobia, internalised biphobia, and forced closeting. i liked how each member of the band was easy to sympathise with (honestly - being in a boyband seems like a nightmare) and i enjoyed the way each character got their own little development arc. i think fangirls who loved one direction will totally love this, and i did find it enjoyable, but there are also some shortcomings with this book with the way it handles it’s subject matter.

had to DNF because after a certain point it felt too much like a one direction fanfiction and while that is not necessarily a bad thing I think as someone who grew up in that sphere and watched how a lot of those things affected the boys in these bands and how uncomfortable it made them when people suspected their sexualities it was weird for me to read. I think the writing is super solid and its a fun read but I was overthinking it the whole time so i feel he need to pass

I love this book so much because it’s show readers about behind the scene of music industry. This book is so much different then other books because two queer boys are in love with each other and they are in same boyband. Everyone loves boyband specially me growing up seeing boy bands and fangirling over them. It’s best friend to lover trope and forbidden love mix together which make very good combinations. I love this book so much specially when I shipped member in band.(1D)

I love this so much. It's really sweet, but also super angsty! It feels a bit more like a YA book for adults than for teens, but I do think a lot of teens will also enjoy it. I think it will be popular where queer YA romances are popular, especially sad ones like They Both Die at the End.

This was such a great queer read! I have read from both authors separately and didn't love their books, but this book with them as a team worked beautifully!

I preordered it as I was reading the ARC. Came out the day after my birthday, and this was everything I could have wanted from a boy band love story! Ong of my favourite reads of the year.

3.5 stars rounded down to 3

Many thanks to Wednesday Books and NetGalley for the early copy! All opinions are my own.

If This Gets Out is about two boys in a boy band. They start dating each other, but their management team will not let them come out as gay and bi. The story is about the struggles they face as they continue in the band with their friends (one of whom has a drug addiction).

I enjoyed reading this one! It wasn't "wow" worthy, but it was quite enjoyable. I felt for Zach and Ruben throughout the whole book. Their struggles were portrayed in a way that you could empathize with them greatly. I do kind of hate Chorus for what they did to them. There is a happy ending (in a way), but it's left open so the reader can assume what the boys did as a band.

Agh, I am so bummed about this book - it just didn't live up to my expectations. I didn't feel any chemistry between Ruben and Zach at all, I felt that the characters were pretty flat and two-dimensional, and I felt that a lot of the pointless inter-band drama made the book much longer than it should have been.

As a huge One Direction fan and former avid reader of everything H/L related on AO3, I've seen the depth and breadth of absolute talent from writers talking about relationships like this. I've read the most dramatic of the drama, the fluffiest of fluffy, the angst, slow burn, pining, alternate universe, you name it. So I suppose it's a little unsurprising that this didn't live up to what I thought it would be. Maybe it's impossible to create fictional characters that I feel as attached to as a real life band that shaped so much of my high school experience - I don't begrudge the authors for that, but the chemistry really was lacking for me.

The parts that I did like were about the harsh reality of what it's like to be famous, scrutinized, under pressure, and young (the boys are supposed to be just around 18-19), while somehow still living your dream. Some of this felt like a caricature of what fans think when they imagine management dictating everything the boys can do and breathing down the boys' neck, but other parts felt real - like dealing with addiction issues or intense pressure from parents.

Overall, the book just felt "meh" to me - it felt a bit shallow, not really saying much, but certainly had a premise that reeled me in. Thank you to St. Martin's Press for the ARC via Netgalley.

I have no words for the absolute beauty that this book was. Though this book followed very successful people, you got to see each of them learn about themselves and the world around them. The characters made this novel so amazing. The relationship between the two boys never failed to put a smile on your face, while the tragedy of their realization of the world was relatable and horrifying. No doubt, 5 stars.

I'm a big fan of Sophie Gonzales and her writing. I really enjoyed this book and her and Cale's collaboration. I absolutely loved the premise of two boy banders that fall for each other and it didn't disappoint. The friendship between the band members was great and I liked that Ruben and Zack's relationship started as friends. It added depth to their story. The inside look to the entertainment industry was fun and added so much to the boys and their dynamics. Definitely recommend this one.

I loved this story. Now I have a young niece who is obsessed with One Direction and she ships them so hard. I don't put much stock into it, but it was obviously a bit reminiscent of that. I did love the characters of Ruben, Zach, Jon and Angel. Ruben and Zach were the main POVs and they each had their own distinctive voice. I thought their relationship was really sweet and I enjoyed watching Zach's growth and his struggle to come to terms with his sexuality and what HE wanted, as opposed to what their management company wanted. I did agree with some of the other reviewers that the pacing started to drag just a little in the middle, but truthfully, I was still just as engrossed in the story. This was fantastic!