Member Reviews

GREAT sequel! I didn't think I could possibly adore anything more than the original, but oh my gosh I loved this book! Such loveable characters and fun animations.

Was this review helpful?

The Okay Witch is such a great graphic novel series! I love Moth Hush so much! Witch stories are one of my favorite subgenres! I highly recommend this graphic novel series to everyone!

Was this review helpful?

It is so good to have Moth back! This series of graphic novels that deals with bullying, racism, and other issues that kids face in school and growing up is a great choice for upper middle grade readers. I love the different expressions of magic throughout this book and I love Moth as a relatable and lovable character.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great MG Graphic Novel! It was fun to revisit the characters from the first book, with a new adventure. Overall, I would definitely recommend!

I received an e-ARC from the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

Great read for children and adults!! I had a lot of fun reading this book and would pass on to people of all ages to enjoy.

Was this review helpful?

Book 2 in the okay witch series, and it comes off just as strong as the first volume. Moth - which all things aside is such a cute character name - is a girl like any other just trying to make it through school, except - you know- with magic. After volume one, Moth is trying to balance living in the human world while still being true to her witchy side. But its hard to find that balance when you are being made fun of by those around you. Moth just wants to fit in.

It doesn't help that her mother, Cal, is dating the dorkiest teacher in the whole school. Moth knows that her mother deserves to be happy. They both know that the chances of her father recovering from the memory spell and reuniting with them are slim to none...its just that her life would be a little less embarrassing if he did (though I have the vaguest suspicions that the dorky teacher might actually be her real dad...only time and more volumes will tell).

Things change though when Moth finds a pendant/necklace that, with a little magic, makes her the better version of herself. A version of herself that everyone loves and adores and wants to be friends with. But magic shouldn't be used lightly and when her friend Peter comes through from Hecate to tell her the truth about the necklace - it might just be too late. The demon inside might already be too powerful to stop.

I know I say this about most of the graphic novels I read here, but the art style for this series is really really adorable. I think both the art and the story work well for the age group. I want to keep reading about Moth and Charlie and the magical shenanigans that they get in and out of. There are so many good themes expressed throughout: love, family, friendship, acceptance (from both others and of ourselves), etc. It is truly an inspiring series that I hope there will be many more volumes of. 10/10 Would highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful sequel to a witchy graphic novel that I really loved. Sequels are always hard because there's so many expectations tied to them but I think this one hit it out of the park.

Was this review helpful?

Really cute squeal to the Okay Witch vol.1 As the story continues we learn a lot more about the characters and how the young witch navigates life after the discovery of her powers.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed the continuation of this series, and my students are so excited to finally see what happens to Moth next!

Was this review helpful?

After reading The Okay Witch and it being one of my favorite graphic novels, I was super excited to see that there was going to be a sequel and it did not disappoint. This sequel follows lovable Moth Hush and her family as she begins to discover more about her witchy family history. This was a great sequel because we got to get more of a glimpse into the witchy world and the characters. I enjoyed the plot and the lesson that went along with the story, of not being afraid of who you are and accepting everything that you are. Once again I enjoyed the illustrations, they pop out of the page, and all the new characters just fit right into the story perfectly. I'm excited to see what is next in The Okay Witch series.

Was this review helpful?

A really great continuation of the series. The characters are really likable and the story is so fun and interesting. I hope there is more in this series!

Was this review helpful?

Oh my goodness, this was such an amazing read with a brilliant commentary! I’m so impressed with this book, sequel to the original <I>The Okay Witch</i>. This is definitely a story worth reading and one I imagine many young readers will relate to and learn a lot from. It’s even better than the first book!

I’ve recommended this series to some students of mine and all I can say is, please keep them coming!!

Full review to come.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review

This was a great sequel to "The Okay Witch". In this follow up, Moth's journey being bullied in school is very real and relatable. She tries to change herself with magic, but at what costs? This is a great lesson in loving yourself and being true to yourself!

Was this review helpful?

This sequel to The Okay Witch is just as good as the original! Hand this to student who loved Okay Witch, Snapdragon or Beetle and the Hollowbones.

Was this review helpful?

"The Okay Witch and the Hungry Shadow" is a fantastic follow up to "The Okay Witch." Moth learns that magic can't solve everything when she relies on a spell to help her with bullying at school. The graphic novel contains an honest, realistic look at bullying and systemic racism that teens face in school every day.

Was this review helpful?

I was over joyed to see a second book in this series! Moth is back and doing pretty well with her witch studies, but being bullied at school is rough and who wouldn't want to have a more confident version of themselves to face said bullies? Moth's journey in this novel is very relatable. Not knowing how to talk about your feelings, anxiety, being overwhelmed, very real issues. Emma Steinkellner handles all of this AND magic shenanigans with amazing artwork and a lot of heart. I will be reading the Okay Witch over and over again.

Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is a perfect follow up to The Okay Witch. Moth is coming to terms with her powers but still struggling with the bullying she faces at school. When she receives a magical charm that turns her into a more confident and popular version of herself, she is unable to resist the temptation.
I loved Moth and her friendship with Charlie and her relationship with her mother. The artwork is beautiful and the story is fantastic.

Was this review helpful?

Moth Hush is a witch, but she’s not allowed to do magic at school. She gets teased at school, and it would be easier if she could just use a spell to make herself more likable. The bullying gets worse when her mom starts dating one of her teachers. Then, Moth discovers a magic charm necklace that can make her popular. But every kind of magic has a price.

This graphic novel started out with a recap of the first book. I was really glad to see that because it’s been a while since I read the first book. It was told by her talking cat, Lazlo, who is a hilarious character. I appreciated seeing this brief recap at the beginning of the book.

Moth faced bullying in her school. Her classmates were quite mean. Moth felt like an outsider since she had just discovered she was a witch, but she couldn’t tell anyone except for her best friend. Using a magic charm didn’t solve her problem. It masked it for a while, but it ended up causing a bigger issue in the end. Rather than fighting back or changing what kind of person she was to please her classmates, Moth had to learn how to be herself.

The Okay Witch and the Hungry Shadow is a great middle grade graphic novel!

Thank you Simon and Schuster for providing a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The plot of this book relies pretty heavily on knowledge of the first book. You might be able to reason through it on it's own but it will be a better experience if you read both. We have an interesting blend of the inherent risks of magic used for personal gain and the pressures of popularity.

Was this review helpful?

The Okay Witch and the Hungry Shadow is the second book in the Okay Witch graphic novel series by Emma Steinkellner. Released 6th July 2021 by Simon & Schuster on their Aladdin imprint, it's 272 pages and will be available in hardback, paperback, and ebook formats.

This is such a wonderfully engaging story. The characterizations are all strong and with Moth, the protagonist, we get a sympathetic and understandable character on top of everything else. It's easy for readers to put themselves in Moth's shoes, and even though she's an actual magic using witch from a long line of powerful witches, she still deals with feelings of insecurity and inadequacy. She wants to fit in and not be geeky, not be bullied, and not be "dorky". When she acquires a powerful magical amulet she decides to change her story herself; what could possibly go wrong?

This book is wonderfully well plotted and such a good tale. It's certainly an engaging story, but there are worthwhile deeper takeaways as well: the meaning of true friendship, kindness, compassion, heart, found family (and the biological kind as well), honesty, and love.

I love that the adults who care about Moth aren't perfect, but they are good role models and they genuinely care about her. I like that she's a person of color, and it's not a huge deal in the story (it is mentioned in passing and it does have some relevance to the plot - but it's not harped on). I like that there are healthy (and unhealthy) friendship models included.

The art deserves its own review. It's simple and so open, but the expressiveness of the characters is amazing. The facial expressions and emotions are conveyed so deftly. It supports and enhances the narrative perfectly.

I also adore Mr. Laszlo (the cat). He's just pure 100% distilled wonderfulness.

Five stars. This is a worthwhile all-ages read. It would be good for public or school library acquisition, and personal library. I really hope there are many more stories to come.

Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.

Was this review helpful?