Member Reviews
Juliet Marillier weaves her story as if by magic. She engages your emotions and plays on your heart strings. Once you enter her world you have no wish to leave it. May there be many more such tales with their element of the fey. It has all the elements I look for in a good book; characterization, plot, moral lessons, adventure, excitement & a satisfying conclusion.
Full review on my YouTube channel.
I adored this series!! It definitely has the older fantasy, kind of fairytale-esque feel. This was my first series by Juliet Marillier and I look forward to reading some of her backlist in the future.
This latest novel in the “Warrior Bard” series will delight Marillier fans. After the events in The Harp of Kings and A Dance with Fate, everyone seems to have settled happily. Liobhan, who is both a skillful musician and an elite Swan Island warrior, is with her sweetheart, nobly born Dau, although by tradition they are not allowed to go on missions together. Her half-fey brother, Brocc, has retreated to the Otherworld with his fey wife and infant daughter, whom he adores. Swan Island continues to train young warriors and provide their special blend of espionage, counsel, and martial prowess. Then, of course, everything falls apart. Brocc’s attempts to establish a truce with the vicious Crow Folk lead to his and his daughter’s expulsion into the mortal realm. Dau’s latest mission puts him at risk of encountering the brother who tortured him and Liobhan, and a crown prince has gone missing and is possibly dead. Disparate story lines gradually weave together as the true menace emerges, along with the alliance that will defeat it.
I enjoyed A Song in Flight very much, especially the chance to spend more time with my favorite characters, watch Dau and Liobhan recover from the traumatic experiences of the last book, and delve the mysterious origin of the Crow Folk. Without having read the previous two books, however, much of this one would have been confusing. This is an issue every author who writes multi-volume series faces. If you put in enough background to fully orient a new reader, you risk losing faithful fans through repetition and boredom. Marillier does a fine job reminding the reader without bashing over the head, but in the end, it’s best to read the previous volumes in order.
I am struggling a little with my review for this book. If you liked the first two, as I did, for the most part, I think you'll probably like this one too. But I had some issues that kept me from loving it.
The story here basically follows Brocc as he tries to send the Crow people back home and Liobhan and Dau's attempts to find a missing prince --and later, to save Brocc from an Evil Lady who wants to use his musical abilities for a military advantage.
I still like Liobhan and Dau. Unfortunately, they are apart for the lion's share of the book. And their romance is very...sweet. There is a lot of perspective jumping, which was ok, I guess. I think my biggest issue was with the deus ex machina feel of solving the crow problem and the evolution of... well... Brocc's whole story, really, where everything happened for Convenient Reasons.
For instance, what was his wife's underlying issue? His exile from Fairy felt built on such flimsy ground. I mean, the final straw was legit, but I never really understood her damage--about Brocc and their kid and pretty much everything. It was like she was only there to give him his daughter so the child could play her role in the story. Even worse--the means of communication with the crow folk and the storyteller... and everyone else who did not speak with words. The clicking of rocks or moving them around to tell stories that everyone just seemed to understand for no good reason. I had a very hard time with my suspension of disbelief there.
It didn't feel real. And yes, I know it's fantasy, but there are plenty of books with worldbuilding and magic that manage to convey an underlying true feeling within the scope of the story.
The ending was good and the main characters got the HEAs I wanted for them, but I found it all a little... beige.
Of course, your mileage may vary.
This one has been sitting on my to read pile for ages. I keep starting it and just setting it down again. I think, personally, it is because I just don't want to see this story come to an end. I highly enjoy all the characters along with the magic of this world. This is just a personal problem and I am sure others will adore this book.
When a prince goes missing, the Swan Island Warriors are tapped to find him. This tale weaves magic and myth and is wonderfully told. Great world building and characters. Perfect addition to the series.
I was not a fan of this installment of the series. I really struggled to get through A Song of Flight. The plot did not keep me engaged. I don’t think all the different narratives helped either. Many of the narrators proved to be weaker and less interesting than others. Aolu’s chapters, especially, felt entirely unnecessary. The story was much stronger once they all joined up again towards the end. But by then, the book was over. The ending just felt rushed.
Also, the crow people plot line was always my least favorite thing about the series, and, unfortunately, it was the main plot point for A Song of Flight. I far preferred the second installment.
I’m sad I didn’t enjoy this one. Marillier’s books are consistently great reads, but this one just did not do it for me.
Song of Flight is the final book in the Warrior Bards series and I believe it is a satisfying conclusion to the trilogy tying up the story lines of the mysterious Crow Folk; how they came to be in this world, why they are here, what they are searching for and how to save them.
Liobahn and Dau have found their way to one another and while living on an Island of warriors trained to run secret missions isn’t totally conducive to a having a relationship, they are figuring out what it means to them. They are also finding out how hard it is to be separated when they have to go on missions separately.
Liobahn is training one of the new Swan Island warriors, but as always, she lets instinct guide her, even when it goes against all of the Swan Island trainings. She has a knack for getting into trouble but she also is great at going with her intuition and seeing where it takes her. This time it will take her to the origin story of the Crow Folk and how she can help to set them free.
Dau has been sent to look for the prince who has gone missing. He is undercover n a court trying to find out if some lore of the land might lead him to a door to the fae realm where the prince might have ended up. What he finds is a terrible plan that will use the Crow Folk for war and sever any hope they have of finding the redemption they need.
Brocc ah my poor Brocc, I feel the most for this character caught between two worlds and just trying to find a way to save both his child and the Crow Folk. He has an arduous trial ahead of him and risks all he has left in order to fulfill his destiny. He will lose much in the path the fates have set before him.
A few of the new characters the Prince Aulo and Liobahn’s other brother Galen also get much page time in the story. The best part of that is we get to go back to Liobahn’s home and see Blackthorn and Grimm. I have missed them since their story ended and I loved seeing the life they built together and what it looked like years later.
This is a story of sacrifice and redemption. Old enemies come back to cause trouble and new ones arise and all of our characters will play a role in making right some old wrongs. Highly entertaining and a well thought out conclusion to the story.
A great conclusion to The Warrior Bards trilogy!
In this final book we continue to follow our three main POVs of Liobhan, Brocc, and Dau as they search for a missing prince, try to figure out the mystery of the Crow Folk, and discover a more sinister plot than they expected.
********************
A prince has disappeared under mysterious circumstances involving the Crow Folk and a group of unknown men. Galen, Liobhan and Brocc’s older brother and the prince’s guard, was injured in the attack and is determined to find the prince.
The Swan Island warriors are brought in to find the prince. As they follow a lead which forces Dau to go undercover, he becomes more convinced that the uncanny may be involved in the disappearance. Meanwhile, Liobhan is tasked with training a new member of Swan Island, and Brocc is struggling to balance his family in the Fae world with his mission to understand and connect with the Crow Folk.
As always Marillier’s writing is beautiful, atmospheric, and magical as she draws both characters and settings with care. I loved getting to catch up Blackthorn and Grim and learning more about their lives and family since their series. And we get to meet Galen! I wish that Galen had been in the story more (the prince too) because, although the prince’s disappearance and their search for him is the catalyst for the story, it ends up taking a backseat to the Crow Folk plot and feels a little disconnected. That being said, I almost wish the Galen/prince plot had been its own book because I think there was enough there and likable enough characters to have their own story.
In this book the three main characters are split up for the majority of the book which meant we didn’t get as much interaction between those main characters which I missed. However, it did mean we got to see the various pieces, plots, mysteries, and motives slowly come together as we discover how everything is connected. Which is always satisfying!
We also got more of a focus on Dau and Brocc’s POVs and I’m glad we did! In the previous books I found Brocc a little boring, but his character really came alive in this one as we got to see him struggling with his conflicting priorities. We also get to learn more about the Crow Folk who have been very mysterious up until this point.
In comparison to the other books in the series, the second book is still my favorite as it is the darkest and most emotional of the trilogy, but A Song of Flight is a great conclusion the trilogy! I gave it four stars.
I received an eARC from the publisher via Netgalley (although I bought and read my own physical copy). All opinions are my own.
I have been a fan of Juliet Marillier's Warrior Bards series since the first book, The Harp of Kings. I give thumbs up to the world-building, the character development, the challenges posed to characters, and journeys taken. This third and final book in the series concluded well, and may have even been a skosh more gripping than its predecessors. And as with Marillier's Blackthorn and Grim series, the Warrior Bards can easily lead into a series starring the next generation -- with Brocc's half-human, half-fey daughter, Niamh leading the charge. I'm all in.
[Thanks to Berkley Publishing Group and NetGalley for an opportunity to read an e-ARC of this book in exchange for my opinion.]
I am such a sucker. I prefer to project a life of easy happiness on my favorite characters. But this author pulls that rug out from under me every time. This time Brocc and his baby daughter are kicked out of their home all because he was trying to bridge a very wide communication gap with the Crow Folk.
At the same time, the Prince of Aolu disappears while in the company of Galen (Brocc’s brother.) It is up to the Swan Island Warriors, to find the prince. Galen and Brocc’s sister Liobhan is one such warrior as is her lover Dau. So, as you can see, this story will be a story of family.
And much more. As these adventures go, paths will cross. Old enemies will emerge, new enemies will arise. The Crow Folk, will begin to be understood. An old tale reveals a curse that may explain much. A Song of Flight has so many things going on. Master storyteller Juliet Marillier does a very fine job of weaving all the threads together.
Blackthorn and Grimm (parents of Galen, Brocc and Liobhan) have small roles in this story, which I love because I am such a fan of the Blackthorn and Grimm series.
Intrigue had me imagining all varieties of outcomes – terrible and wonderful! And all through the story, the characters emotions tugged at my own heart. I always want Liobhan and Dau to be together and Brocc needs his happy ending. But as a reader of fantasy, I know they will have to overcome many challenges before they get to that point. I love, love, love this enchanting story and the series!
Thanks his book was phenomenal!
A young warrior who wields both the power of her music and the strength of her sword faces a grave threat in this enthralling historical fantasy.
Bard and fighter Liobhan is always ready for a challenge. So when news arrives at Swan Island that the prince of Dalriada has gone missing after an assault by both masked men and the sinister Crow Folk, she's eager to act.
While Liobhan and her fellow Swan Island warriors seek answers to the prince's disappearance, the bard Brocc, Liobhan's brother, finds himself in dire trouble. His attempts to communicate with the Crow Folk have led him down a perilous path. When Liobhan and her comrades are sent to the rescue, it becomes clear the two missions are connected--and a great mystery unfolds.
What brought the Crow Folk to Erin? And who seeks to use them in an unscrupulous bid for power? As Liobhan and Brocc investigate, it will take all their strength and will to continue pursuing the truth. With the safety of their loved ones in the balance, the risks they must take may cost them everything.
Another beautiful installment to Juliet Marillier's Warrior Bard trilogy! I am a huge fan of Juliet Marillier's work and have thoroughly enjoyed this latest trilogy from her. This final book in the trilogy, A Song of Flight, was the perfect conclusion and couldn't have done a better job of continuing these characters' journeys and relationships with one another. I have loved watching all of them grow, and it is all done in such a captivating way via Marillier's beautiful, rather elegant prose that carries the story easily, whether it's a fast-paced, high-action scene or a complete opposite and calmer moment. This series is absolutely lyrical, and I am so glad I was able to read this entire trilogy and follow all of my favorite characters along for the ride. I can't wait to read even more Marillier!
Juliet Marillier's writing is absolutely stunning, and this book was no exception. I loved seeing the entire family adn solving the mystery. The world building is phenomenal. I cannot wait to read more of her work!
I have to admit that it took me a little longer then usual to get through this book, just because I was in the wrong mindset for the series at the time the ARC came out. However, this was a purely personal issue and has nothing to do with the book itself, which is as lyrical and emotional as I've come to expect from Juliet Marillier. "A Song of Flight" is a satisfying conclusion to the Warrior Bards trilogy, brining back all of the major characters (and even including some glimpses of Blackthorn and Grim).
The book starts off with a missing prince, and a request for Swan Island to investigate. We also finally reach the climax of the storyline about the Crow Folk, which gives Brocc some much needed time to shine (since he sometimes felt like an afterthought or a side character in the previous books). As in all Marillier works, the ending is emotionally satisfying and answers all major questions raised in the series. I might have to go back now and start a reread from the beginning.
Beautifully written and atmospheric! Juliet Marillier never disappoints. Seriously, read all of her books you won't regret it. My only complaint about this particular serious is that it seems a little more dense than some of her other novels. A lot more description, thicker prose, slower action. It is still beautiful and worth your time!
I've enjoyed this trilogy right from the beginning, and this book was no exception. I ended up loving the characters so much. I think Marillier does an excellent job with her characters, from the humans down to the little fae creatures that inhabit her books. I especially enjoyed getting to see Blackthorn and Grim from her previous series again. I really liked how both series dealt with the individual struggles each of the characters had. I felt like Blackthorn and Grim had an overall message of redemption and forgiveness, and this series seemed to have an overarching theme of being true to oneself, and I enjoyed that very much.
I liked Brocc's story the most in this book. He remained stalwart through all the trials and disappointments he went through and I felt for him. I admired his devotion to doing what he felt was right, and the love and care he had for his daughter was heartwarming. The thing with Eirne was incredibly sad to me, although not really surprising considering what happened in the last book. I struggled to understand her character, as she felt distant to me, but I'm wondering if that wasn't the point.
Liobhan and Dau were still my favorite characters of the series and I liked the way the author showed how they struggled to be apart while on their separate missions. I also thought their story-line ended perfectly in the book. The resolution with the crowfolk was also nicely done. It was nice to be able to come to understand them and what was happening with them.
This was a good conclusion to the trilogy. I think everything was wrapped up nicely, although there is definitely more room to expand on this world if the author chooses. I'm looking forward to whatever she writes next.
Thanks to NetGalley and Berkley Publishing Group for providing me with and ARC of this book.
Warrior Bards #3. The continuing story of Liobhan, Dau and Brocc. The Swann Island warriors are called in when a prince disappears and is believed to be kidnapped. Meanwhile, when Brocc's daughter is kidnapped, a conspiracy forces him to "manipulate" the Crow people - or so they think.
Even though Brocc's situation is quite dire, the story does not seem as dark as previous books. You can feel all the threads coming together, all the characters gathering, all the questions about to be answered - that air of expectancy keeps the mood much lighter than before. And it all does come together in a most satisfying manner, and all is explained. And there is plenty of room for future tales if our author so desires (and we do, don't we?)
Highly recommended.
One Sentence Summary: A prince has gone missing and Dau has been sent to help the effort to recover him while Brocc has been working on a dangerous mission to understand the feared Crow Folk.
May contain spoilers for the first two books.
Overall
A Song of Flight follows Liobhan, Dau, and Brocc as their lives change and merge while two work to find a missing prince and one works to figure out the Crow Folk. As usl, I really enjoyed the characters and loved how much music played into their lives. Each of them faced their own trials, and some of it broke my heart a little. It was wonderful to see how their decisions from the first two books impacted them in this third one. While the first half was slow and I felt the set up took a little too long to unfold, the second half was fast-paced and hardly seemed to stop. Overall, this is a solid third book and offers a great ending point for Liobhan, Dau, and Brocc.
Extended Thoughts
On Swan Island, Liobhan has been assigned to train a new warrior, but has difficulties getting to know her. Elka is from a very different part of the world and culture, but her knowledge may hold an important key to a mission Dau has been sent on. Closer to her parents’ home, the prince of Dalriada goes missing and his protector, Liobhan’s brother, severely injured. But Dau is sent to investigate and find the prince. There, he uncovers unsettling information that might involve the Crow Folk, and is sent to the widowed chieftain Lady Almha, whose advisor has a plot up her sleeve.
In the Otherworld, Brocc’s child has been born and is the light of his eyes, but his secret mission involving the Crow Folk endangers his place in his wife’s court. Warnings are sent to Liobhan as his mission and Dau’s seem to be on a collision course.
A Song of Flight appears to be the last in the series and offers a fitting conclusion for all of the major characters. It follows the same formula as the first two books with a slow first half that equally slowly unfolds the set up and rises to the climax and a faster, more thrilling ride during the second half when everything comes together. It’s easy to get mired in the first half as the Otherworld is simply dismissed, though, by this point, I suspect readers have already guessed it will play a huge role. But it is slow and almost cumbersome and I had a hard time not checking on my progress to see how close I was getting to the more exciting second half. Still, A Song of Flight delivers a solid story and wonderful conclusions to the stories of Liobhan, Dau, and Brocc.
I adore the characters in this series. Liobhan is so strong in mind and spirit. She’s always ready and willing to jump in, but her family has more of a hold on her heart than Swan Island does. Still, she’s a capable and dedicated Swan Island warrior. I found I had the most fun reading about her through Dau’s eyes, especially since, for the first time in the series, they’re separated during most of the book. Dau has come a long way from haughty nobleman and it was so nice to see just how human he was. I’ve loved how his character has deepened and changed over the past three books. While I was a little dismayed by how quickly their relationship progressed, it makes sense if this is a trilogy, and it’s been fun to watch them develop as individuals and a couple. As usual, Brocc kind of felt like a third wheel to me. I love his character and his huge heart and his story made my heart twinge for him, but Liobhan and Dau have the stronger story even if Brocc’s is centered around the ever-present Crow Folk. I do like him and his softer soul and the things he was put through was dreadful, but I found myself wanting to jump back to Liobhan and Dau more.
It was wonderful to get to know Liobhan and Brocc’s family and more Swan Island warriors. They all really helped fill in the story, giving it both personal and professional stakes. I thought Elka was a delightfully complex and fascinating woman even if Liobhan had a hard time getting to know her. I loved all the surprises that came from her and all of the new things she brought to Liobhan and her team. It was also fun to see Liobhan’s brother Galen involved in the story. He didn’t feel quite as fleshed out as I would have liked, but his relationship with the prince was absolutely lovely and heartwarming. I loved everything about it.
A Song of Flight, unlike the first two books, has the characters traveling further afield. There are more places to see in both realms, but Elka’s homeland was the most unique. While both share many ideas related to magic, they’re viewed differently and it was interesting to see the differences and similarities and how it impacted her and Liobhan’s relationship. But I really enjoyed getting to travel around more with the characters, especially as it’s Celtic-inspired and involves so much of the Otherworld. While I wanted more from the fae, I did enjoy how the Crow Folk, and their mythology and history played a huge role. While they’ve previously just been ferocious, murderous beings, they’re cast in a different light in this book. It all did seem to escalate and change rapidly, but it was also really nice to reflect on the progression across all three books.
As with the first two books, A Song of Flight offers a layered, albeit somewhat simple, story. It’s inevitable that the paths of Liobhan, Dau, and Brocc will cross, that their missions and lives will intertwine well before the end of the book. It’s fun to see their paths merge and to come to realizations throughout the story, and a lot of fun to see how they manage to get out. But there aren’t many complications and the character pool feels a bit limited, making it easy to predict what’s going to happen and who is going to be involved. I did like that there aren’t too many characters, but it also keeps the story simple.
A Song of Flight is a quick fantasy with a simple story and fun characters. I love everything about the Celtic-inspired setting and how strong of a role music has. Even though the first half was predictably slow and the second half predictably something of a never-ending roller coaster, it was an enjoyable installment in the series and I really liked how it left off the characters.
Thank you to NetGalley and Ace for a review copy. All opinions expressed are my own.
This review was originally posted on <a href="http://booksofmyheart.net/2021/09/21/a-song-of-flight-by-juliet-marillier/" target="_blank"> Books of My Heart</a>
<i>Review copy was received from . This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.</i>
I am always a bit worried these days when starting a new book with rich world-building and character development, because I may feel overwhelmed with the details. It also can be hard when one read the last book a year ago and may not remember details. Happily, I started <strong>A Song of Flight</strong> and it was easy!
Juliet Marillier is an author I always enjoy. Now we have the complete <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/series/215913-warrior-bards" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><em><strong>Warrier Bards</strong></em></a> trilogy. I would not read these alone or out of order. I do feel I enjoyed these books more because I read the <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/series/101029-blackthorn-grim" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><em><strong>Blackthorn & Grim</strong></em></a> series first, which I LOVED, but you wouldn't have to read it first, only because it is amazing.
The trilogy encompasses all three of the Blackthorn & Grim children, but I would say we get more from Liobahn's perspective than the others. Brocc and Dau get nearly as many chapters as Liobahn. But, we only get one chapter from Galen's viewpoint. A new point of view is Aolu, the prince of Dalraida. Galen is a lifelong friend and guard to Aolu. They now have a more personal relationship it seems.
Without being spoilery, Liobahn and Dau are settling in to their new situations. Liobahn is training Elka which I enjoyed. Brocc loves his daughter, Niamh, who is almost two. His wife is violently against the Crow Folk, but he is trying hard to communicate with them. Our story begins with the prince going missing and Galen being injured and left for dead. Dau is sent as part of the mission to find him
Liobahn continues her training, wishing she could go but she is too close to the people involved. Eventually, when they believe Aolu must be in the Otherworld, she is brought into the search since she has the most experience because of Brocc. She learns Brocc is having his own struggles. As usual, Liobahn doesn't do what she was told, but her instincts are solid gold.
We see some villains from previous books, and there are new evils. But there are also new friends. I was happy to see Brocc make a real connection with the Crow Folk and try to improve their lot. There was more time at Winterfalls with Blackthorn & Grim which is always a pleasure.
I felt on edge with the suspense over finding Aolu, helping Brocc and the Crow Folk, Dau was in some tight spots, and Liobahn seems to always in the thick of the worst of things. I would happily read more in this world with its beloved characters, rich magic systems and political maneuvering. <strong>A Song of Flight</strong> was a joy to read and a satisfying conclusion to the trilogy.