The book itself is probably a 3.5 and only rounding down on this review due to the narrator (aka a automated voice). The book itself has an interesting premise that I’ve never seen done before, however it felt a little confusing at times. There were almost too many characters to keep up with, and they all got a little confusing (especially while listening via audiobook).

Clem was a very cool protagonist, and I loved that she was able to stand up for herself and wasn’t just a damsel in distress-type character. Phelan was a relatively okay character, but I never really felt too much for him or his relationship with Clem.

The main plot point sort of felt rushed towards the end, maybe if it had started a little sooner in the book it wouldn’t have felt QUITE so rushed. But overall, I rather enjoyed it!

I was drawn to this book because it stated it was perfect for readers who loved The Night Circus. But I do not see the similarities. However, it is still a great story! I loved the concept of nightmares coming to life. I do wish there were more instances in the story so we could see how powerful the magic system was.

The romance was a slow burn which I didn’t mind since it was not the main plot. I liked that the mystery was not overpowering and easy to follow. Overall, it was a good YA fantasy!