All That is Secret by Patricia Raybon is a thrilling chase through historical political strife as the hunt for justice as dead bodies pack up. The plot touches on the historical racism of the time. Not in a horrifying way, but a realistic punch to what occurred during the time. The story does feature the Ku Klux Klan, but it is realistic part of America’s dark past. As a reader, I felt like I was watching the story unfolded in the important moments of history. It rang true to my amateur mind. Annalee was a brave, educated woman who loves Sherlock Holmes with a heart for the downtrodden. Holmes is a huge love of mine. I enjoyed suspense stories, so throw in a little history, and the author grabs my attention. Rayborn definitely does this. A little bit of romance. Not overwhelming at all. On the other hand, there is one issue that I had with the plot. Internal dialogue. There are numerous incidents in the story where Rayborn would stop the action by freezing the characters so that Annalee could think through things. Sometimes her thoughts would go on for pages. A little too much for my taste. I wanted to know what was happening on around her. Overall, All That is Secret by Patricia Raybon is a historical mystery with touches of reality. I’m interested in reading book two since there will be more stories featuring Annalee.

I received a complimentary copy of All That is Secret by Patricia Raybon from Tyndale Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.

Thank you to Net Galley and Tyndale Publishing for the chance to read and review this book. The opinions expressed are my own.
All That Is Secret is a mystery that takes place in the winter of 1923. Professor Annalee Spain is called to Denver to find out who murdered her estranged father. Along the way she meets Eddie, a young white boy who is looking for his father. She also becomes involved with Jack, a handsome pastor. Eddie and Jack help Annalee uncover some hidden secrets and figure out why and who murdered her father.
I liked this book! It had some action as well as some surprises. I also liked the religious aspect of this story. I highly recommend to all mystery lovers!

Synopsis: Invited by her hometown reverend to investigate her father’s untimely death, Bible professor Annalee Spain returns home to begin making inquiries. Inspired by Sherlock Holmes and aided by the reverend (as well as an orphan boy), Annalee goes undercover to research the local suspects. Set in the 1920s, this well-researched historical novel also provides insight into the real-life atrocities of the resurgence of the KKK in Colorado.

*I received a complimentary e-ARC of the book through the publisher and NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review.

Overall Impression

I was surprised, and very impressed, to learn that this was Raybon’s debut novel. Wow! The writing is stellar, the plot well-paced and intriguing, the message insightful. Even though I don’t usually gravitate toward historical fiction, I really enjoyed the novel.

The Writing

Raybon’s writing is excellent. Whereas some books make up for in plot what they lack in writing, Raybon’s storytelling demonstrates skill and ease. I was not surprised to learn that the author previously won awards for her nonfiction memoir. I also found that the book’s endorsements rang true.

In my opinion, Raybon’s writing stands out because of its lyrical quality. To my observation, strong writing often demonstrates a poetic quality, and Raybon certainly delivers. I noted at least one passage that read like a poem, with its descriptiveness and symbolism.

Raybon also demonstrates a knack for voice, crafting a believable and engaging narrative through Annalee’s eyes.

Premise and Genre

One of the reasons I was drawn to this book was due to its unique perspective and premise. Historical romance novels, particularly in the Christian fiction genre, are often/usually written from a white perspective, and it was refreshing to read an #OwnVoices novel by a black author with a black protagonist, which acknowledged the presence of members of other races. I also really appreciated the fact that, although the book was set during Prohibition, it was not all about flappers and Speakeasies. Raybon deftly navigates the period setting, seamlessly incorporating historical elements, without falling prey to period cliches. While the details clearly conformed to the time and place of the setting (as detailed in the Author’s Note), historical elements felt effortlessly integrated, rather than self-consciously placed. I didn’t feel like I was being bombarded with reminders that the book was set in a different time period, but the historicity was sharp. While the book was educational, I didn’t feel like I was being forced to learn— and that is something I look for in historical fiction.

Romance

The romance was both light and tasteful, and I was impressed that the romance plot was a subplot. I would categorize the novel, first, as mystery, then as historical fiction— with a thread of romance. While the romance added to the plotline, it wasn’t the reason I kept reading. Plus, the content was clean 🙂

Content Disclosure

One piece of content I would like to note is that there were several instances where the character would use the term “Lord,” in her thoughts. I think this was more colloquialism than prayer.

Spiritual Elements

Beautiful. This book was full of gems in its exploration of Annalee’s faith and relationship with God. I bookmarked multiple meaningful passages throughout the text. While I recommend some titles more because they are “clean” than because they are uplifting, this was an instance in which I can recommend the book on both grounds.

Favorite Quote:

“Absolutely nothing random… in God’s doings. Not just letting things unfold, drifting along, hoping to get to where you’re aiming and struggling to go.”

Patricia Raybon

ALL THAT IS SECRET by PATRICIA RAYBON is a very well written historical thriller that takes place in Denver in 1923 at the height of KKK activity in the area. The story is based on this verse in Luke 8:17, "For all that is secret will eventually be brought to light and be made known to all."
Annalee Spain, a young coloured professor of theology, returns to her home town of Denver to find out the truth about her father's death. Eddie Brown junior, a grubby white boy, who is also looking for the truth about his father and who saved her life on the train from Chicago, makes up one part of her detective team, the other one being the handsome Reverend Jack Blake.
I really like this author's writing style, her references to Sherlock Holmes, and the depth of the Christian message on which the story is based. One of my favourite quotations in the book is "So prayer is where God meets us - if we stay strong in it. On purpose", and another is "solving a murder is not about crime, its about finding fear and greed and, well, about lust."
As Annalee bravely faces all that is stacked against her in this world of power hungry, wealthy and unscrupulous men and women, she uncovers racism and class distinction at its worst.
The story is fast paced, the plot is exciting and the characters are unforgettable. It is altogether a great read and one I highly recommend.
I was given a free copy of the book by NetGalley from Tyndale House Publishers. The opinions in this review are completely my own.