Member Reviews
Dan Jones crafts a vivid, marvelously researched and fascinating look at the Middle Ages--a history book with the rich pacing of a great novel. Highly recommended.
Many thanks to Penguin Viking and to Netgalley for the opportunity and pleasure of the read.
First line: In the sixteenth century the English historian John Foxe looked over his shoulder at the great sweep of the near, and distant, past.
Summary: Dan Jones’ newest history of the medieval ages covers the period from the end of the Roman empire to the rise of Protestantism. He covers major players, battles and nations giving his readers a look into a world that was constantly changing.
My Thoughts: Dan Jones is a wonderful historian. He covers many of the people and time periods that I am interested in. He makes his topics easy to read and learn from. This one was no different. I know some about the Middle Ages from other readings of authors like Alison Weir and Philippa Gregory but this gave me much more of an insight into other parts of the world than just England.
He brought in major players like Genghis Khan, who I knew very little about. Learning about this warlord’s life before and his rise to power was all new to me. I never really think about how Asia and Europe had lots of interactions during this time due to the crusades and religion.
And during the chapter on the crusades they even mentioned something I had never heard about but was related to my family history. There was a Wendish Crusade where powers in Germany against a Slavic group called the Wends. My Pohlenz family were part of the Wendish community in Germany and lived in heavily populated Wendish towns in Nebraska after emigrating. I had never heard of this crusade against them but I instantly had to read more about this little known piece of history.
Jones does a great job of laying out his storyline. He goes chronologically but breaks each time into important factors like crusaders, knights, Arabs, Mongols, merchants and more. It gave me a feeling that the time was definitely broken into different parts and governed by these persons for their span of time but as the world changed so did the leaders of the time.
FYI: A concise but wide spread look at a time that covers hundreds of years. Great for people looking to learn more about the Middle Ages.
Superb and very approachable history of medieval times. Mainly concentrates on Europe, but also includes some aspects of Asia and the Middle East. Very well written, and organized by major elements of society. I also liked how the author connected issues of importance in medieval times with similar issues our society faces today.
I received a free digital ARC from the publisher via NetGalley.
(I complained on Twitter about not getting approved or denied so maybe Dan Jones told them to give me a copy just so I would shut up about it.)
Rating ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I know, I know.
I obviously can't be objective because it's Dan Jones, is what you're all thinking.
Well, I CAN!
This book is just THAT GOOD.
Literally all of my favorite people, places, and things from history, in one ginormous volume, covering roughly 1,000 years of everything that happened from the Fall of Rome to those Tudors coming in and shaking things up.
We're talking this one might be rivalling The Plantagenets: The Warrior Kings and Queens Who Made England as my most fave Dan Jones book. That's HUGE. I first learned about Eleanor of Aquitaine from The Plantagenets so Dan Jones basically named my baby. (Side note: I always remind Eleanor that she is so lucky that I learned about Eleanor of Aquitaine BEFORE Boudicca, or she might have a very different name.)
BUT THIS ONE IS SO GOOD.
You also might be thinking, "Do we need ANOTHER book about the Middle Ages?"
Again, the answer is yes.
What Jones has managed to do once again is combine his massive amount of knowledge, tying it all together across place and time, and present it in a highly informative yet highly readable way.
I was lucky to have teachers who really made history come alive for me, even going back to middle school. History has been my love for as long as I can remember. I get that non-fiction is not for everyone. A lot of people don't even give it a chance because history was taught to them in a boring recitation of facts and dates and names.
This book though, is something different; an extraordinary feat that Jones should 100% be proud of. (And I assure you he is, because who wouldn't be?)
He brings these historical figures to life and makes them real once more. It's hard sometimes to think about people this way, to imagine them living and working and dying in a world so different from our own. But Jones has the skill to share this knowledge and research in such an engaging way that you feel as though you could actually reach back in time and walk along Hadrian's Wall (which you actually can do if you're in the UK, which I am not and that is sad), to sit in a Great Hall and take in all the sights and sounds and smells of life at a royal court, to race along the Asian Steppes with Genghis Khan, watch as Rome is sacked time and again (six altogether in this span that Jones covers), and more.
SO MUCH MORE.
Really, truly. I was actually nervous about how I was even going to write up this review because there is so much material to address. Otherwise I would have had it up days ago.
Just for fun, let's take a look at all of my Goodreads shelves I added this book to, so you can get an idea of everything you'll find. I am selective in how I add non-fiction texts to my various shelves. If something is mentioned in passing and gets barely more than a paragraph, then no it does not qualify. If it is discussed in-depth or is used in a way that makes more clear the topic at hand, on the shelf it goes. They are as follows:
Ancient Rome Medieval Europe Middle Ages Roman Britain Asia
Eastern Europe Goths/Visigoths/Ostrogoths Byzantium Plague Middle East
Military History Islam France and the French Carolingian Dynasty
Merovingian Dynasty Vikings Christian History Plantagenets King Arthur
Wales The Crusades Eleanor of Aquitaine Spain and the Spanish
Mongols and Mongolia Russia Business and Leadership Anglo-Saxon England
Castles and Palaces Christian Holy Places and Relics Climate Change
Medicis Joan of Arc Architecture Art Explorers Mexico Popes
Germans and Germany Tudors Gauls and Franks
Quite a bit of information, no?
And if that's not enough, there are plenty more topics that would probably have justified the creation of a new shelf to accommodate it, but I chose not to. I couldn't even list all the labels on my blog post because there is a character limit.
I really love how Jones divided up each section. First there is Imperium, Latin for what amounts to absolute power, which Rome once had, which covers 410-750. Here we find chapters on the Romans, Barbarians, Byzantines, and Arabs.
Next comes Dominion, spanning 750-1215, with sections entitled Franks, Monks, Knights, and Crusades.
Third is Rebirth, 1215-1347, detailing the time as it related to the Mongols, Merchants, Scholars, and Builders.
Last comes Revolution, 1348-1527. We learn of Survivors, Renewers, Navigators, and Protestants.
As you might expect, there is an extensive section of notes and from Jones you should expect no less. The text ended at 77% in my advanced digital copy, with notes taking up the next 13% of the content. Primary sources cover another 4%, with journal articles and theses ending at 96%. The remainder right up to 100% is footnotes.
I can promise that if you pick this one up and settle in for a good bit of reading time, you will not be disappointed. Powers and Thrones: A New History of the Middle Ages is the new standard against which to measure all others books covering the same topics.
Without a doubt, this is the best book of 2021 for me and I don't believe that anything the rest of the year can top it.
Highly, highly, highly recommended.
Dan Jones has done an amazing job at telling the story of the Middle Ages from the fall of Rome to the Age of Exploration. The reader is given the story in a wondrous way that combines deep scholarship, which is evident with Jones' bibliography on primary sources and the dialogue he engages with in the footnotes, and the narrative quality of his story whether it is Romans, Goths, Byzantines, Arabs, monks, or Mongols is evident as he portrays his massive cast of characters as the human beings that they are. If you are looking for a sweeping narrative and a fascinating interpretation of this rather popular era, I would highly recommend this book.