Member Reviews

Honestly this book just wasn’t for me. I tried to start it a few times but struggled to get into it. It wasn’t what I was expecting. I can see how some would enjoy it!

Was this review helpful?

Georgiana Ellers, who spends most of her time with her nose stuck in a book, gets sent to live with her aunt and uncle. She’s desperate for a bit of excitement, and her wishes seem to come true when she meets Frances, the daughter of Lord and Lady Campbell, at a dull dinner party. Frances introduces Georgiana to her inner circle of wealthy friends, and she gets swept up in a world full of extravagant parties and drunken debauchery.

I struggled to get into this book at first, but I’m so glad I pushed on because I ended up really enjoying it! Despite several heavier issues, which I felt the author handled really well, this was a fun and witty read and it definitely gave me Mean Girls vibes! Although she frustrated me at times, I felt for Georgiana and I loved how she came into her own and learned to stand up for herself. I adored Thomas, but Betty was hands down my favorite side character! We could all use a Betty in our corner! This was a highly entertaining, quirky, fresh and fun debut!

Was this review helpful?

Mean Girls, but make it English history.

Although I did end up enjoying this book, and it had some important messages about the ethnic make up of Britain and the way reputation can work for or against anyone, there were sections that drew it out a little too much.

Was this review helpful?

A very fun book historical ya contemporary about a group of mischievous girls who don't really love upper societies rules. I look forward to reading more from Lex Croucher and maybe more in this series?
Thank you to netgalley and the publishers for providing me with an arc for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Young people behaving debaucherously in the Regency period?! I'm already obsessed.
Reputation pulled me in from its first few pages, pulling readers along with Georgiana as she enters into the orbit of Frances Campbell and her friends, and a live of excess. Georgiana gets swept up in this world but even as her choices became more and more chaotic, I loved her all the same. The story lets her fall hard but it also lets her get back up, following such a wonderful character arc through the whole book. This book also isn't afraid to face the darker elements of the life these characters are swept into, full of alcohol and drug abuse, predatory young men not willing to accept no for an answer, and even simply the way their behavior as a group fueled much cruelty towards anyone not deemed "important" enough for their circle.
I'm tempted to call this a Regency Mean Girls story (and there are some fantastic MG references in the book!) but I do want to emphasize that this book really feels like its own story and very much stands on its own two feet. I also appreciated the author's decision to pull in queer rep and some racial diversity amongst its main characters, pointing to a history that media tends to whitewash but was far more complex and diverse than is often acknowledged.
Lastly, a just want to say how much I LOVED Thomas Hawksley!!!! Honestly, the romantic subplot burning its way through this book was just so good, and fit in so well with the rest of the story. Georgiana and Thomas have such a good dynamic together and I loved every scene that they shared.
In short, I highly recommend this one. I truly loved reading it and would absolutely return to it again.

Was this review helpful?

The Regency “in” crowd—darkly beguiling! Surprising!

I puzzled over what sort of Regency romance I’d wandered into, but the life of Georgiana Ellers goes from a throughly uninspiring season sponsored by her aunt, to rackety doings with bored young things in a nanosecond. This was a delight. Austen like observations combine with commentary that both terrifies and stimulate. I kept waiting for George to come to her senses. I was both shocked and enamoured by her need to be more, her unusualness being led down a potentially ruinous path.
Talk about the “walk of shame”. This has it all. Like the Lost Boys, the lost wealthy children playing often vicious games come as a shock to Georgiana. The daring Frances Campbell—a style setter, both daring, friendly and vicious, hiding unhappiness by attacking. But then when you so want to be part of the “in” crowd, to move in these incandescent heights of society, you join in and dampen your conscience. Which is just what Georgiana did, until she couldn’t anymore. I did feel like I was moving more in the flapper society of the thirties than Regency times. Certainly Wickham would be more at home here than others I could mention. Then we rarely cross into those more debauched places when dealing with sweet young things during the Season. No Almanacks and insipid lemonade here. Rather it’s drugs and cognac. Sapphic encounters and rape. Coming of age sucks, especially when seeking adventure, to be part of the “in” crowd at any cost—sharpened stakes and all.
I know at the end I was standing on a church pew cheering Georgiana’s bravery and the daringness of Miss Betty’s adroitness. And then there’s the hidden hero. Mmm! Thomas Hawksley is a joy!

A St Martin’s Press ARC via NetGalley
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)

Was this review helpful?

It's hard to believe this is a debut novel, but it is! If I had to describe Reputation I would definitely say it's rom-com meets regency Mean Girls. There are parts that had me laughing out loud, but there is also bullying, rape, toxic relationships, drug and alcohol abuse, societal pressure and other hard topics in this book. It had me hooked from the start and I was all the way in and couldn't put it down!

Georgiana Ellers has been dumped on her aunt and uncle for the foreseeable future, while her parents go off on their own. She's thoroughly bored until she meets Frances Campbell at a party and becomes instantly enamored by her wealthy, and seemingly-care-free friend.

They spend the summer getting up to all sorts of mischief, from un-chaperoned parties and weekends away, to excessive drinking and experimental drugs. Things start to go pretty wrong though and Georgiana starts to wake up to the truth of what is really going on. Can she change course before it's too late?

Was this review helpful?

Reputation is billed as being “Bridgerton meets Gossip Girl” and I couldn’t agree with that more. I could run down the friend group in this book and name the character from Gossip Girl that they are minus an actual “Gossip Girl”. Our heroine, Georgiana (to be referred to as George from now on) is the Jenny of the group. She has been recently abandoned by her parents and left to the care of her Aunt and Uncle. She strikes up an unlikely friendship with Frances (the books version of Blair) who comes from a wealthy family and is thrust into her world of parties and impropriety. However, George’s station in life does not afford her the shield of wealth and status that it does her friends and she is desperate to hold on to them at all costs.

It took me about half the book to care about George because I found her desperation to be friends with Frances and her group to be off putting. Because of her desire to fit in with them she behaves in ways that make her unlikeable, especially when she is cruel someone that her new friends find beneath them. While I didn’t particularly care for her, I did enjoy the different view of society that we get from the typical historical fiction. The turning point for me was when George’s crush on Thomas started to turn into a friendship with him. Until that point it had just been a story of George and her friends getting drunk and/or high and it was refreshing to get a different aspect of the story. Along with the addition of more Thomas in the story Croucher also starts to infuse more heart and reflection into things which is when I started to see George in a different light.

I was surprised by what this story ended up being and I admired the stand the author took when it came to the subject of sexual assault. I also respect how Croucher had space in her story to show how different women handle different things that happen to them and doesn’t condemn anyone for how they choose to cope. George truly came full circle in this book and I loved her character arc. I do wish Croucher had spent some time earlier in the story humanizing George because I was way more invested in what was happening when I felt a connection to her.

This is a book that I think a fan of modern romances might enjoy if they want to dabble their toes into the historical side of things. However, if you are already a lover of historical romance I don’t think this is one you will enjoy. Reputation feels like someone took an historical romance and modernized it rather than writing a historical romance. The synopsis of this book refers to it as a romantic comedy and while I didn’t find it that humorous, I do think it has the lighthearted feel of a rom com. Which would make this the perfect book for the beautiful spring days we are (hopefully) having.

Was this review helpful?

Reputation is a Regency-era historical romantic comedy from a hilarious new British voice, Lex Croucher. This book was described as Bridgerton meets Gossip Girl with a dash of Jane Austen, so naturally, I had to pick it up. I had high expectations for this book, and I was honestly disappointed. I would describe this book as edgier than expected, but not necessarily well-written. The dedication says it all. “For Jane Austen. Sorry, Jane.” Because any true regency lady would be completely shocked by the sordid behavior in Reputation.

Croucher’s next book should possibly be set in a more modern era, which would allow room for the heavy drinking, drug use and the women’s empowerment movement. There are just so many details that are wrong for a historical fiction. It is definitely one of the less realistic Regency fictions I have ever read. Croucher tries to make the story readable for modern audiences by attempting to tackle some big topics (TW: rape, SA), but unfortunately the characters come across as spoiled brats instead of empowered young women.

So don’t read this if you are a stickler for historical accuracy, because you won’t find it here. I appreciate what this book is trying to do for diversity, but there are some passages that are just plain bad and positively inaccurate for any century.

I can see where the work drew inspiration from Jane Austen’s works. The romance between Georgiana and Thomas give me a very Lizzy & Darcy vibe, but Georgiana is Darcy in this tale. And in the spirit of Emma, our MC is haughty, unimpressed by everyone, and borderline rude. I started to dislike her and her “friends” around chapter five. Georgiana does get a few set-downs through the novel, though they do little to humble her. “You’d do better to apply that mind of yours to the improvement of yourself and those around you, rather than letting your cleverness fester into cruelty.”

Was this review helpful?

Reputation had me thinking of Mean Girls meets Bridgerton. Truly a nice, light period read. Georgiana is sent to love with her aunt and uncle when she meets Frances Campbell at a party. The two become good friends very quickly and Georgiana finds herself in all types of a situations that a young women in that era should most definitely NOT be in. All the while, she has her eyes on Thomas Hawksley, whom she always seems to stumble across when she's not exactly at her best.
I truly enjoyed the lightheartedness of this book and will have to look for more books by this author!
Thanks to Net Galley and St Martin's Press for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I LOVED this book. The characters were all so great, the story line had me hooked from the very beginning.

Was this review helpful?

I have mixed feelings about Reputation after finishing it. On the one hand, I am fully in support of reading things that make you a bit uncomfortable and are out of your comfort zone, but I can’t make up my mind on whether I liked the protagonist because she wasn’t a typical main character and was unreliable or if I was just extremely annoyed at her and her actions. I was really looking forward to this book and how it would be subverting the prim-and-proper view of society and its members that is portrayed most often in historical fiction, but I think it went too far the other way in that it was unrealistic in many ways and created plot holes because of it. The protagonist, Georgiana, did not have very much common sense, and for someone who had such limited life experience she was extremely judgey and impertinent about basically everything. She put herself into bad situations over and over again due to peer pressure and a want to belong, and her “friends” were continually making me angry.
I did enjoy how the novel resolved itself in the end in terms of friend relationships and how it clearly brought to light the dangers and issues with aristocratic society, but I think it could’ve been done in a better way. The slightly uncomfortable feeling I had while reading it could have been part of the point though, in order to emphasize how easy it is to slide into a lifestyle that is harmful and destructive and if that is the case then it was done very well. I had high expectations for this book, but I am conflicted on if it was executed well and I just personally didn’t enjoy the characters, or if it had structural problems.

Was this review helpful?

Reputation is pitched as a Bridgerton meets Gossip girl with a dash of Jane Austen. This is a Regency-era historical romance 'with a twist of feminism'.

Georgiana is forced to move in with her boring aunt and uncle the Bartons when her mother becomes ill. But when George goes to a boring party with her boring aunt one day, she meets Miss Frances Campbell, the beautiful, charismatic, and free soul she has always wanted to be. Frances shows George a whole new world, in parties and riches. Frances shows her what friendship is and what it means to let go of what others consider 'polite company'
One day when George is attending a party she trips, only to be saved by the handsome Mr. Thomas Hawksley. which she then insults his wealth and way of living, but neither of them can deny the connection that has begun.

Reputation was a party, it was a fun time, there were definitely some hard things that were dealt with within the book. There was a slow burn romance, there were laughs and there were tears (not literally).

If the beginning of this book were just a little faster getting into the main story, I think I would have given this book a 4 stars, I did genuinely enjoy this book, and I'm not a party person.

If you love Bridgerton, Gossip girl, Mean girls, or any of the regency-era-themed romance books, you will probably love this book.

If you want to see my live opinions on this book please check out my vlog to come on 4/9/22
at filling the bookshelves on youtube.

TW: possible rape, domestic abuse, substance abuse,

I received my copy of this ebook through Netgalley.
All of my opinions are my own.
Thank you to Lex crouched and the Publisher for sending this to me.

Was this review helpful?

Georgiana Ellers is staying with her aunt and uncle, Mr. and Mrs. Burton because her mother is ill and her father has taken her to the coast for better air.

Georgiana is bored silly as her aunt and uncle spend their days inside and go to bed early. So, she is pleased when they are invited to a neighbor’s home for the evening. However, the place is so dark from a lack of candles, that she can only hide in a corner. Then, a young woman named Frances Campbell finds her and she shares her flask of cognac with Georgiana. Frances’s parents, Lord and Lady Campbell, are very wealthy. Her father is white and her mother is dark-skinned. Frances and Georgiana end up hiding away and laughing all evening until Frances’s mother finds them and orders her to leave with them.

At another party, Georgiana meets some of Frances’s friends who all seem to live life as they want and also indulge in lots of alcohol and smoking some substance. Georgiana indulges in the smoking and the next morning wishes she had not. She meets a handsome and wealthy man from India named Mr. Hawksley and is fascinated by him.

At yet another get-together she meets a shy young woman who is overweight and can’t seem to stop talking. The group ends up laughing at the poor girl, embarrassing her.

This book irritated me as I read more and more pages. First of all, I cannot imagine that any young girl in this time period could get away with the things this group did. It’s ridiculous to think that a reader would believe that. Frances is a brat with too much money. We see that today in current times. Are readers supposed to be impressed by her? Her followers are stupid and I did not find anything humorous about this book. I was hesitant to even request reading it and I wish I had gone with my first instinct. I do not recommend it at all.

Copy provided by NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Georgiana Ellers is chafing against her aunt’s strictures. Georgiana has been left with her relatives whilst her mother and father move into a new home by the sea so her mother’s health can improve. Georgiana is feeling abandoned, and bored. Then, she meets the very wealthy and Frances Campbell, and is happily drawn into the daring, fascinating, unconventional, biracial young woman’s orbit, and her equally unconventional and thrill-seeking, wealthy friends.

Georgiana is utterly captivated by Frances, and the bookish, quiet Georgiana cannot fathom why Frances likes her, but Georgiana is willing and up for anything Frances and her circle get up to, whether it’s drinking to excess, smoking, taking mind-altering substances, saying terrible things about other people, mistreating servants, experiencing thrilling and forbidden intimacies ….

Georgiana also encounters the, by contrast, seemingly dull Thomas Hawkesley at one of the same parties she and Frances attend. Georgiana is immediately attracted to Thomas, though he is much less taken with Frances and her circle of mean friends.

Georgiana is also somewhat uncomfortable with the group's uncaring and frequently nasty attitude towards everyone else. Georgiana is especially reticent to call them on their behaviour to those beneath them (i.e., lower on the economic class) as that would point out Georgiana's own strained financial situation. Another thing Geogiana must pretend she knows nothing about is how abusive Frances' father is to her Black mother.


I found Georgiana’s new experiences and her fascination with these young people deliberately flouting convention and behaving provocatively and recklessly to be somewhat dismal. She’s not got healthy relationships in her life at this point with which to compare with the mean group. Georgiana is uncritical of their actions, and just so happy to be included. This speaks to her parents’ years of neglect, and Georgiana's loneliness, and lack of social experience. Despite her aunt’s and uncle’s attempts to figuratively embrace their niece, her aunt’s adherence to the forms and structures of class leave Mrs. Burton little room to show her niece the real warmth and kindness she needs (till later, when it really counts). And Georgiana is smart, too well read, and too used to being in her own head to see her aunt and uncle trying to be kind.

Georgiana makes a lot of mistakes over the course of the book, but, thankfully, when things start falling apart, she takes stock of herself and takes real steps to repair the damage she creates over her summer of debauchery. One of the biggest mistakes, then later a rewarding change in her life is her developing friendship with Betty Walters. Though Georgiana is slow to appreciate Betty, I thought the young woman was a hoot. Betty’s nervous, nonstop babbling when she appears in any scene, though disgusting to the mean group, was actually observant and quite funny, and Betty proves to be a much more stalwart friend than the very troubled Frances, as Georgiana soon learns.

Though labelled as a romantic comedy, I really liked how author Lex Croucher dealt with a lot of heavier themes of abuse, rape, racism, the slave trade, gender inequality, the danger of being queer, and parental neglect. This was an unexpectedly enjoyable read, and I look forward to what Lex Croucher writes next.

Thank you to Netgalley and to St. Martin's Press for this ARC in exchange for my review.

Was this review helpful?

If Fleabag and Bridgerton had a baby, it would most definitely be Reputation. What a fun read! Definitely one to add to your spring TBR!

Was this review helpful?

Ever read Jane Austen and though you love the sugary sweetness of the love story, you know in the back of your mind no matter the era people have always found ways to have a little more risqué fun. Under the long skirts and bustles and corsets some gentleman and even ladies knew how to have a good time. This book is that version. And it was a treat!

Georgiana has been sent to live with her aunt and uncle because simply put, her parents are tired of parenting. Shes at the age where she's ready to court and look for a husband. Her aunt and uncle however are childless and don't seem to do much more than take long walks and work on their needlepoint. Worried shes going to never leave the house again, she meets Frances by chance at the most boring party she's ever attended. Frances is rich, beautiful, popular and everything Georgiana has always wanted to be. Pretty soon, Georgiana is pulled into her orbit. She has new friends and attends parties she never thought possible. She's also introduced to drinking and drugs and a whole bunch of other things that are exciting and foreign to her. While its all fun at first, Georgiana quickly realizes not everything that glitters is gold. Behind the money and facade of beauty, there's also a dark downside. She quickly learns who her real friends are, but most importantly, who she is as well. This is the perfect naughty Regency era read!

⭐⭐⭐⭐/5

Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martins Press, and Lex Croucher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Heat Factor: It gets pretty steamy, but not remotely with the romantic couple.
Character Chemistry: They end up kind of being a balm for the rest of the very difficult to like cast of characters
Plot: It’s an Emma/Mean Girls mashup, essentially. Georgiana is the impoverished new girl in town, who catches the interest of wild child Frances and her rich group of friends. On the periphery of the friend group, Georgiana meets Mr. Hawksley, who is actually a good person, etc.
Overall: I almost DNF’d it three times. I struggled with this one because it was good but it was really uncomfortable to read and if that makes me a goody-two-shoes nerd, then so be it.

So, I will say flat out that the book is well-written. Although there are a lot of characters swimming around in alcohol and drugs in this book, they are packed with so much personality and detail that it’s impossible not to be able to follow. The plot swells to the point of being almost unbearable in tension and bad decisions, then right when you think you can’t take it any longer Georgiana does something redeemable and you can hang on a little longer. But.

I’m not sure this book counts as a romance. To begin, Georgiana and Mr. Hawksley barely have any development between the two of them, and they certainly aren’t kindling things up for the majority of the book. In addition, most of the characters are not good people, and I wasn’t rooting for them. At all. Rooting for Georgiana was difficult, because she was a pretty horrendous person for almost the entire book. Also, this is touted as some kind of comedy–and I thought Mean Girls was funny, but I didn’t laugh once during this book at all. I was mainly a little ill and really, really stressed out.

Essentially, Georgiana is dumped at her Aunt’s house and is bored out of her mind when she meets Frances, ultra-wealthy and intensely full of life. Georgiana gets sucked into Frances’ orbit, where she meets a crew that Frances barely seems to like, and who she treats horribly, but they somehow continue to stick around. Georgiana is introduced to getting absolutely hammered and high at parties, and I think a lot of those parts are supposed to be funny? But almost every one of the parties is messed up in some way. She’s either getting harassed or the incredibly precarious position she’s in is clearly pointed out and she ignores it, there’s the aftermath of a rape scene, Georgiana is very nearly raped. So like, honestly? Before I read the publisher’s blurb I would have called the book “suspenseful” and “intense”. After I read it? I was honestly kind of grossed out. None of it is funny.

I labeled this as “smut adjacent” simply because although Georgiana’s relationship with Mr. Hawksley is a driving motivator for change and self-awareness, the focus of the story and most of the plot revolves around her relationship with Frances. And when their relationship fractures and Georgiana’s life is in shambles, Frances doesn’t seem to ever actually feel any remorse or learn any lessons. It’s lightly suggested she’s made a few marginally okay decisions in the interim? And I sincerely think the general message in the end is, Georgiana isn’t a total innocent here, they’re all hurting and have pretty good reasons to be miserable, reckless, drunks–so she’s able to find her happiness with good people in the end.. But when characters are this deeply flawed, I’m just so relieved they’ve reached some level of homeostasis and stopped hurling themselves head first into tragedy that I don’t care about the romance as much. And that’s why I don’t think this worked as a genre piece.

Now. If you’re interested in reading a book in one sitting and feeling really conflicted but utterly sucked into a book where the characters are all screaming with desperate personality and kind of dancing around drunkenly on a knife’s edge of fun/traumatic experiences, just rife with constant deception and hurtful comments, well. Here you are. I stayed up very, VERY late reading because I couldn’t put it down. And I don’t know what that really says about the book without the lens of a romance reviewer–because I can say with certainty that it will stick with me and that I keep thinking about it. And normally that’s what I’d consider a pretty interesting read. It was effective–but I can’t say that I enjoyed the experience very much.

I voluntarily read and reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own. We disclose this in accordance with 16 CFR §255.

Was this review helpful?

As soon as I heard this book was basically Regency-era Mean Girls, I was in. I couldn't wait for the toxic friendships and the bad behavior set in a time where girls were so tightly bound in how they were supposed to look and act. You do have to suspend your disbelief a bit, of course, if you are an avid historical fiction or HR reader, because our MCs absolutely flout the rules and get away with it to an extent which seems like it shouldn't be possible.

Our MC, Georgiana, just wanted to be wanted. She had parents who left her, boring, if sweet, relations that took her in. She wanted to be young and have fun, but mostly she wanted for the people around her to want to be with her and that was what made her easier to connect to than I thought she would be as the "Katy Heron" of this story.

It's a little dark, a lot sarcastic, and full of witty banter with a love story to bring it back around. It's a coming-of-age story which is always my favorite kind. We watch all of these people try to become adults while trying to feel important and autonomous. I think the great thing in the end is getting to see and know that they're all human, even the worst of them.

The rep is also great! The book is full of queer characters and characters of color.

I can't wait for more from Lex Croucher! Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for my ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Reputation by Lex Croucher has been hyped as “a classic romcom with a Regency-era twist, for fans of Mean Girls and/or Jane Austen,” the marketing for this book seem very pointed aimed at this book being the pick-me of Regency romance (she’s not like other girls!), but does it hold up?

Reputation is ambitious in trying to maintain those familiar notes and threads of a romance, while clearly trying to amp up the drama to soap opera levels. I’m not necessarily a fan of the “naive character gets caught up with rich friends and learns hard lessons” plot (unless it’s the pure wannabe-Gothic thrill of Northanger Abbey), but I did find myself charmed by moments of sensuality and swept up into the complex relationships between certain characters.

The audiobook is definitely worth checking out, and the narrator (Bessie Carter, known for her role as Prudence Featherington in Bridgerton) sounds like Lady Mary from Downton Abbey when she reads certain characters. It just adds a layer of snobbery to some of these characters.

The book (spoilers ahead)

Maybe I’m nitpicking, but I don’t think the apt comparison is Mean Girls. It feels like Emma, Northanger Abbey, Gossip Girl, Atonement and even some Vanity Fair mixed in. With a big splash of Gilmore Girls (the seasons when Rory goes off to be a shitshow with Logan). There’s high stakes society drama, there’s drinking, there’s bright young things pushing against the constraints of the upper class rules, there’s sex (and there’s non-consensual moments as well, FYI! Please check out the CWs on Goodreads before reading).

Even after reading it, I still don’t know how I feel about it. I don’t love it, that’s for sure though.

Georgiana Ellers, the middle class girl staying in town with her aunt and uncle (absentish parents really solidifies this Northanger Abbey vibe), makes fast friends with the wealthy Frances Campbell (think Isabelle Thorpe but actually popular). Georgiana is swept up into the rich kid circle, think Gossip Girl here, and she quickly learns she’s gotta tiptoe around feelings, because despite her lack of income making her soooo not a threat to these girls, they circle her like harpies, waiting to bite when she doesn’t follow all their little rules.

This gets intense and heavy in a way Mean Girls only hints at IMO. The drinking and drug use lean more toward the harshness of disenchanted teen dramas than pretty, pink commentaries. Much like Northanger, Georgiana is in very real, very severe danger in many ways.

There is a sapphic romance happening, but it’s not the main plot. I almost wish the main character had been one of the ladies in that romance, but here we are. We get other queer characters throughout and I hope if the author is writing more, we get to focus on more intriguing characters. There are also BIPOC characters in this story, but in terms of “good representation” well… that is up for debate. I really think I would have felt differently if they’d been the heroine or hero we followed as the POV character.

Ultimately I think this book tries to do a lot of things, while still staying in the lane of a traditionally Regency romance, but there’s just too much going on in terms of the writing. It felt like the author couldn’t decide what she wanted this book to be, who she wanted to be most interesting. I do think there were interesting relationships and identities to explore, but it felt like so much was crammed into the end that you could blink and miss some wrap-ups.

What you should drink with this: Rosé until you feel so hungover for the characters, then grab a coffee.

Who should read this: Fans of Gossip Girl, Atonement, and high drama. Rory Gilmore’s Logan years.

Was this review helpful?