Member Reviews
A book that really goes after the history of the Black cowboy from the West and the contributions that those men made not just to the Calvary, but to the West and to the rodeo as well. The men describe and brought to life on these pages have never been talked about or if had read their names somewhere I never put them together how they were. A good book of history and one that I will make sure that I keep reading again.
A great introduction for me to the history of black cowboys in rodeo. The history was amazing and the stories of the cowboys were very interesting. So glad to see that the stories have been captured and are being shared so that we all understand the impact of each of the cowboys to the rich history of the West and the Rodeo.
My only issue was that it did get to be a bit much throughout the entire book with switching from one person to the next consistently; though that might just be me! I had a bit of trouble with the kindle version- it erased the letters F and I, and the chapters ran together.
I loved this book so, so much! I love history, and I love rodeo/cowboy culture (especially the 101) and this was a wonderful blend of the two. It taught me a lot and gave me a few more things to add to my bucket list, specifically making a trip to see The Black Cowboy Museum in Rosenberg, TX.
I liked how the writing flowed from story to story, though it did get to be a bit much throughout the entire book with switching from one person to the next consistently; though that might just be me! I had a bit of trouble with the kindle version- it erased the letters F and I, and the chapters ran together. That was my only issue with the book, honestly. Other than that I really enjoyed it!
Black Cowboys of Rodeo is a collection of one hundred years of stories, told by these revolutionary Black pioneers themselves and set against the backdrop of Reconstruction, Jim Crow, segregation, and the civil rights movement. The legacies of their pursuits intersect with those of America’s struggle for racial equality, human rights, and social justice. Keith Ryan Cartwright brings to life the stories of such pioneers as Cleo Hearn, the first Black cowboy to rope professionally in the Rodeo Cowboy Association; Myrtis Dightman, who became known as the Jackie Robinson of Rodeo after being the first Black cowboy to qualify for the National Finals Rodeo; and Tex Williams, the first Black cowboy to become a state high school rodeo champion in Texas.
I really enjoyed this book. I had not heard these stories before and appreciated the perspective. I also appreciated the timeline at the beginning of the book.
The proof I read had missing info and letters, which made it hard to read. A corrected proof is an asset for any library.
You may have seen Lil Nas X highlighting Black cowboy culture in his Old Town Road music video, but Black cowboys have been largely ignored in media representation and history books. Actor Danny L. Glover does a great job of summing up the importance of this book in his introduction:
"At its core, Black Cowboys of Rodeo seeks to capture the stories of Black cowboys as they endured and resisted racism, violence, and discrimination as the United States grappled with its congenital contradictions about race throughout the twentieth century."
This book is primarily about Black cowboys who competed for belts, big bucks and respect in rodeos. The author, Keith Ryan Cartwright, has written another book about rodeo and his expertise is evident, to the point where this book could be challenging for a reader with no rodeo knowledge. I learned a lot through context cues, but I would have appreciated more hand-holding.
I commend Cartwright for investing what appears to have been A LOT of time interviewing these cowboys for firsthand accounts of rodeo history. And where that wasn't possible, he interviewed loved ones and close contacts. There was also a bit of difficulty pinning down details that comes from interviewing people about events that happened decades ago. I can only imagine this was a tough book to pull together and edit down.
While I appreciate that the book is organized into sections dedicated to individual Black cowboys and their stories, the format lent itself to repetition due to the overlapping nature of people's lives and work. And because of the restricted format, some people's stories started to read like a laundry list of names in a family story featuring a bunch of relatives you just can't keep track of. Clearly, each of these people could have entire books written about them. I'm sure this book will prove to be an important reference for anyone looking to learn more about any of these individuals, and I hope it inspires more people to shine a light on Black cowboys, past, present and future.
For those willing to dig into this compendium, there are real treasures. The pictures alone, are worth buying this book for. So many of the rodeo fashions would have been right at home on the red carpet of the 2021 Met Gala.
As much as these stories center around rodeo competition, being a cowboy is a way of life. One of my favorite stories is about Bailey's Prarie Kid (aka Taylor Hall Jr.), whose father "packed his firstborn son in the saddle with him, tucked a warm milk bottle in his chaps, and rode out into the pasture."
"With his son's little legs sticking out to either side, he would push him in tight under the front of the saddle horn, so Taylor Jr. was facing the back of the horse. If he started to lean too far backward, the horse's neck was there to hold him upright. His daddy's ol' horse took care of him from the time he was a baby until he was able to handle a horse of his own, as young as four or five."
I voluntarily obtained a digital advanced reader copy of this book free from Netgalley and University of Nebraska Press in exchange for an honest review.
Although this history of African Americans cowboys of rodeo may be interesting, it was so poorly transcribed to kindle edition as to almost be unreadable. Many missing or half spelled words, and misplaced paragraphs. A shame since I might have found it interesting but I gave up about 20 pages in and could not finish
First, yes, there were and are MANY black cowboys. Who knew the most about working with horses and cattle before the Civil War? The people charged with that work every day. This book has innate value for getting that in popular conciousness and celebrating some of the people involved. It also showcases this long history and its intersection with wider history of the time.
I read this hoping to find some engaging pieces, or the whole book, for my rural students to engage with African-American migration to the West after the Civil War and its legacy. I was pleasantly surprised to learn about histories in New York and Los Angeles! That said, it was interesting the first time, but by the time it was mentioned the fifth time, I had completely lost engagement. Even small details were repeated over and over, such as James Caan stopping by El Fig stables when working on The Godfather. Then individuals featured earlier in the book were introduced later like they were brand new. It's very much like each bio was farmed out to individuals or they were separate blog posts thrown together with little to no editing. A good editor could have saved this from itself, organizing the bios in a more intuitive way and taking a red pen to all that repetition. Without that, it was very much a slog. I'll be finding more engaging material for my students. And here's hoping that it's a catalyst for others who don't know this history to learn more about it!
Thank you to Keith Ryan Cartwright, University of Nebraska Press, and Netgalley for an advanced ecopy in exchange for an honest review.
This book is amazing. The combination of the myths surrounding cowboys and the real life stories is completely enthralling.
This is a overhaul of the beliefs that many Americans hold to this day, of the whitewashed stories of cowboys and the wild west. Black cowboys truly are the embodiment of everything we are taught in schools. American grit, self reliance, and working nonstop rain or shine to get stronger and better.
The stories are rich and beautiful. Every single cowboy in here deserves so much recognition. This book is an unearthing of a hidden history, one that everyone should read and start digging for more. These cowboys shouldn’t have been erased in the first place, I’m glad that someone took the time to help keep their stories alive.