Member Reviews

Gretchen McNeil, author of the #murdertrending series, has created another intriguing, engrossing, and morally compromising situation in Dig Two Graves. Neve stands out from the crowd with her retro pinup style, but also stands apart from the crowd thanks to the very public betrayal of her best friend Yasmin. Licking her wounds, Neve heads to a summer camp devoted to girl empowerment. What she finds there is a latent talent for the stage and a fast, all consuming friendship with fellow camper Diane. Back at home, Neve must decide how far she is willing to go to cement her friendship with Diane and if she is willing to make the even exchange that Diane expects.

Was this review helpful?

After a traumatic semester, Neve is sent to a girl's empowerment camp to get her confidence back. Here she meets self-assured Inera, shy Charlotte and the seemingly perfect Diane. But everything isn't what it seems with her new friends and Neve has to figure out who to trust. This is a great read for McNeil fans who enjoyed the #murdertrending series. McNeil write great LBGTQ characters; she creates fully dimensional characters that go past tokenism. Her mysteries are always very engaging; we have a hard time keeping them on the shelves! This book feels more upper middle school (8th grade) than some of her others so I am excited to have a title to share with my middle schoolers and not just high schoolers. The book covers themes of bullying, toxic female friendships, gaining confidence, and LGBTQ.

Pairs well with: You Owe Me a Murder; Strangers on a Train; With Malice

Was this review helpful?

I loved this updated murder mystery/film noir in which the main character is self aware enough to consider herself a "final girl" but who dresses in 40's styles and quotes film noir. During a visit to a girls camp, Neve begins to come into her own and find friends who she feels she connects with. By the last day of camp she finds herself unwittingly part of a murder pact, and one of the murders have already been committed. The book acknowledges that it is using the plot from Strangers on a Train, although it does veer away from being a total copy cat, and does a nice job of keeping the reader on their toes.

There are allusions to characters being LGZBTQ+ and the main character actually comes out as bisexual, which is important because it lends credence to her connection to someone who the reader might realize is fake and not trustworthy. But Neve is young, and has romantic feelings for her, which clouds her judgement.

Overall, I found this to be a compelling, fun and scary read. I will recommend to any of my teens who like true crime!

Was this review helpful?

This is like an LGBTQ version of Strangers on a Train....kind of like that movie "Breaking the Girls" but with a different plot and a similar premise. While I liked the story, I didn't feel like the characters were fully formed and the writing wasn't as strong as some of McNeil's previous work. I did, however, read it in one sitting and found myself wanting to put the pieces together even though it ended up being *somewhat* predictable.
**Special thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for the advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest feedback.**

Was this review helpful?

This book is pretty dark and intense, with a very serious plot. That said, it is a book a lot of older kids will love. After a very chaotic year at school where her social life was basically ruined by the cool kids, Neve goes off to a camp for girls and meets Diane. On the last night of camp, Neve and Diane joke about getting rid of each others' problems back home. When Neve returns to school the following school year, she walks in to a hallway of crying kids. It turns out the the girl who ruined Neve's previous school year was found murdered, and Neve is now the prime suspect.

Neve is just as shocked as anyone, only things get worst when her cell dings with a text from an unknown number saying "Your turn." Is it possible Diane really went through with what they had joked about? Is there any way Neve can clear her name when she had every motive to actually get rid of her former best friend turned rival?

This book will keep you guessing and the surprises don't stop until the final chapter. I loved this book, just like I have loved every book Gretchen McNeil has written. I will definitely be recommending it to my students!

Was this review helpful?

Rounded up from 3.5 stars. A thrilling, fun read, but I was a bit dissatisfied by the ending. Bisexual, and lesbian rep, but a weird obsession with the lesbian/plaid stereotypical pairing throughout.

Was this review helpful?

After being betrayed by her best friend, Neve goes to summer camp and gets swept into a questionable new friendship. Though the general set up a little unrealistic, it works for the sake of the story. The twists and turns are a fun ride, even if you can see them coming.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to netgalley for this early read.

This was a quick read. The story moved at a fast pace but I don’t think it really helped the story. It could have benefited from more details.
For example, I had an easy time believing Diane’s evil side but had the author spent more time developing the friendship between she and Neve, it would have been easier to see her manipulation.
The story was easy enough to follow until the introduction of the Boston characters and then the story got muddied.
Overall, this was a quick and easy read but nothing more than another book to add to my end of the year reading goal. I’ve read other books by Gretchen McNeill and this was not one of my favorites.

Was this review helpful?

This novel had me at the edge of my seat all the way through. I thought I had it figured out early on, but there were several twists throughout the story. I loved the main character, she was very quirky and I enjoyed her style. I would recommend this book to any mystery lover, it is a must read!

Was this review helpful?

Dig Two Graves is an intense thriller for YA and Disney books fans.

Thank you Lyssa, Disney Hyperion and NetGalley for this e ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This was like... a 1.5 rounded up to a 2 star read. Gretchen McNeil has been pretty solid in the past for a quick, entertaining read, even if the plots aren't the most groundbreaking--and that's okay. But this one didn't do it for me at all, unfortunately. It read as if it was written for a much younger audience, and I know that I'm much older than the typical YA reader as well, so that isn't so much a criticism as it is an observation. I think there's plenty of readers who will like this!

But as for me... I hated Neve. She was aggravating to read, the "not like other girls"-isms were unbearable and the book was FULL of them. She was constantly internally monologuing about how different she was and how much better she was for it. The film noir references also didn't add a whole lot, and felt shoehorned into the dialogue in a way that felt awkward. Also I HATED the twist. It felt gross and didn't actually contribute anything.

It was VERY quick to read, though! I got through it in two-ish days, spread across both afternoons. So definitely easy to read. So unfortunately a miss for me, but hopefully other readers enjoy it.

Was this review helpful?

Deliciously thrilling, wonderfully Hitchcock-esque, and impossible to put down. Dig Two Graves may be my new favorite Gretchen McNeil book (though I love everything she likes). Teens are going to devour this one- the characters are relatable, the pacing is superb, and the length is perfect for both regular and reluctant readers. The twist ending is just the cherry on top.

Was this review helpful?

This wasn't my favorite YA mystery/thriller, but I didn't hate it. It was predictable at times, which is a problem I find myself running into with many other books in the genre. It wasn't the strongest that I've read, but I don't think it was a complete flop.

Was this review helpful?

I’m usually pretty good at figuring out plot twists in suspense/mystery books; Not this time. McNeil did a great job of keeping me on my toes, with twists and turns throughout the book (but not so many that it made it confusing). Definitely an ode to film noir and mystery buffs.

Was this review helpful?

Neve has been a bit of an outcast all her life. After her best friend betrays her, her parents send her to a summer camp to make new friends and fix her self-esteem. She meets Diane there, and then Diane strikes a deal with Neve: get back at her ex-best friend in return for a favor. While Neve thinks it's a joke, Diane certainly doesn't.

This book was fine. There was a lot happening, but it was somehow boring in the beginning.. and I found that I didn't care what really happened in the end. THAT IS NOT A GOOD SIGN WITH SUSPENSE! I think that the writing wasn't amazing, and the random mentions of the noir films was a little annoying; they didn't add anything to the style or character of Neve.

I would still recommend this to younger readers who are getting into the thriller genre. It's definitely not for everyone, though.

Was this review helpful?

It is a given that I live a YA mystery qnd I am always looking for good ones for my classroom. Gretchen McNeil’s book Ten has long been a classroom favorite so I was excited to get this new book by her. This book did not disappoint, full of full boil references and very cool protagonists this murder mystery developed over tome and had a surprise ending for sure. When Neve meets Dianne at camp she falls in love with her, until she realizes that what she thought was playful banter was actually a pact to kill each other’s enemies! In a Strangers on a Train reference this murder plot isn’t all it seems. A great read!

Was this review helpful?

Ever wished someone was dead? Yasmin is dead and Diane killed her. Who's next? Who's laughing at the joke?

Gretchen McNeil did not disappoint with her book, "Dig Two Graves." She is one of my favorite YA authors, and her characters always manage to keep me on the edge of my seat with suspense! Just like her Agatha Christie retelling in "Ten," Gretchen McNeil masterfully weaves a retelling of Alfred Hitchcock's "Strangers on a Train" into her newest novel, "Dig Two Graves." Everything will keep you awake at night, and reading

Was this review helpful?

As the new girl befriends her, Neve thought she was so lucky. Neve is a bit eccentric and loves old films and just doesn't make friends easily. So when Yasmin shows up and the two seem to hit it off, Neve is thrilled. Until she isn't. Because right before the summer of their junior year, Yasmin betrays Neve. Neve's parents and grandma convince her to go to a girl power camp over the summer, to work on her social skills. There, she meets a whole crew of new girls, including the beautiful Diane. And that's where the mystery/thriller aspect of this book comes in (which took way too long to get to, if you ask me).

I found the book boring and far-fetched. I really enjoyed McNeil's #murdertrending series, so this one was a disappointment. It dragged on and on in places. Also, he way Neve talked about her dad and his mental health problems was off-putting.

Was this review helpful?

Author Gretchen McNeil sets up the relationship between Neve and Diane in a very believable way.The relationship between Neve and Javier seemed a little forced and desperate. The concept of strangers on a train for this reader, was a little stretch. Having said that, the story really picks up at the end of the book and was a page turner at the end. The ending was a surprise and made up for the premise that someone would kill someone and the reciprocator would just blindly kill because of casual statement. Fans of McNeil, will overlook the premise and find this satisfying. Not one of her strongest efforts but worth a read on a cold winter night.

I received an ARC ebook from NetGalley and the publisher, Disney Publishing Wordwide, Hyperion , in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this title from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own and were not affected by the free copy.

Our main character is Neve, film noir buff and outcast extraordinaire. We meet her on the day her life falls apart. Skip ahead, her best friend Yasmin has betrayed her, so her mom and grandmother send her off to a girl's empowerment camp. Enter, Diane. Seemingly perfect, beautiful and charismatic, Neve gets sucked into Diane's plot, and jokingly agrees to murder Diane's stepbrother in ex. At least, she thought it was a joke; at least, until Yasmin is found dead. And everyone believes that Neve killed her.

Gretchen McNeil's #murdertrending series is one of my favorite YA mystery thriller series, so I was so excited to see she had a new book coming up. The book blurb includes this line: "In this twisted game of cat and mouse, the reader never quite knows who’s telling the truth, who’s playing games, and who is going to end up dead." Sadly, this book did not live up to my expectations. I saw all of the twists coming. The pacing was a little awkward, but was not a deal breaker. The plot was a bit cheesy, but I honestly expected that. Our villains are truly unlikeable and Neve is mostly likeable (I did get a little annoyed by her constant whining about not having friends and her thoughts about her forced independence).

As someone who has never watched any of the films that were mentioned in the book, they felt like odd interjections that added nothing to the book. It might mean more to others, but for me, it just felt awkward.

I absolutely love the cover! I may not have loved the book, but I will be recommending it to YA mystery thriller lovers.

Was this review helpful?