Member Reviews

This book is the cutest book I've seen this year! There are so many great recipes and, among them, there are pictures of the author's family in black and white. The illustrations of the recipes are simply magnificent, and very well idealised. The book overall is very minimalist, and it's simply perfect. The recipes are very well explained and I'll definitively try out some of those, they are super interesting! I definitively recommend this book to any soup lover. Rating: a big 5/5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

This was a beautifully written story. As someone who lost a loved one to cancer, it’s interesting to read about those who have suffered the same face or have been diagnosed with cancer in their lifetime. This was eye opening but the author herself made many different aspects of this story come to life, her hope, her integrity and her character. But of course, soup is universally loved, one of the best food items to exist? Of course! This was eye opening and a beautiful insight. And I’ll definitely be trying out these soup recipes inside. This was amazing and one of the best books from 2021. 5 out of 5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

Lots of illustrations which I like in a cookbook. No nutritional information which spoils this for me. Liked the Persian Herb and noodle soup, and cream of mushroom soup. Easy to follow instructions.

Was this review helpful?

This a beautiful and fun cookbook! It's soup season so the title caught my attention. The photographs throughout the book are beautiful and artistic and I have several soups I want to try starting with the thanksgiving soup!!

Was this review helpful?

When I can't find a single recipe to make - that's sad. If it doesn't have soap (aka cilantro) & cumin, it's got kale, chard or something along that line. I was hoping for more variety.

I didn't like the pictures & stuff. It was that had to be added to increase the size of the book. I realize they might be interesting & important to the authors journey but I don't need to pay for the paper.

Was this review helpful?

If you want a book about soup, this is the one I would recommend. So much love and testing and dedication and varied recipes went into it. I was very impressed by the sheer number of things to find here, and The explanations as to how to do things and why it is done that way. I also liked there was a section on instant pots, tecopies tweaked to fit as an alternative short on time method, but most of all I loved that this book wasn’t calling in for stock all the time, because I do believe there is nothing as frustrating as having to make that before you can have a good soup. While I love the stock recipes using leftover carcasses and vegetable peels, I work full time and I have 2 small children, I don’t have time for this, nor the energy to make basically two soups. Great book, especially the vibe of it which is all about caring and sharing and eating good soulful dishes.

Was this review helpful?

I had high hopes for this cookbook. The recipes seem simple enough but the photos of the food could be richer, more enticing. I know that sounds crazy but one thing I’ve learned is that food that beckons to be replicated is beautifully presented.

Was this review helpful?

I am a huge fan of soup and was excited to review Soup Club. This cookbook has a slew of different soup recipes. Some of them are so unique and sound so good! But I was disappointed that there were really no photos of the soup, just watercolored illustrations. Those a beautiful, but I really want to see photo images of the soup. The photos that were put in the book (mostly family pics) were black and white.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this book was going to be all about and only about soup! So imagine my surprise when scrolling and then “Wait! There’s bread!?!?!” Only to continue on and go “Wait, is that A COOKIE RECIPE?!?!?!?” Followed by ‘SALAD?!?!?!” Absolutely lovely. I may not be the biggest soup fan, but you can bet your bottom that I copied several of these recipes out to try!

Now you know you are dealing with an American cookbook (ignoring the fact that she tells you right off the bat she’s from Seattle…) when cooking by weight gets involved… fortunately she puts the rough equivalent in cups and vice versa depending on how she is measuring things out, making it relatively easy for anyone to follow the recipe without too much hassle.

Most soups are not overly complicated with recognizable ingredients you can pick up at your local grocery store. Most. There are a few items in there you might not be able to find on a regular basis if you are from a smaller demographic area in the middle of nowhere. You should be able to find substitutes for almost all of these less known ingredients...I think.

Also note that this book has a bit of a story and a journey to it. There are several chunks of book that are just a few pages of black & white photos of what I am assuming is every day life with the author, her family and her friends. If that's not to your likening, feel free just to skip those pages.

ALSO, these are all plant based soups and stews. Says so right in the title...

The Soups & Stews
Some of her staple ingredients are Beans, Onions, Water (obviously), various types pf peas, and nutritional yeast.

I do enjoy that all of her recipes are right from scratch. Yes, they do take longer to make as a result BUT as she puts it “you don’t feel like you are having to make a soup before making a soup” by having to cook up a broth first. It’s all built right in. Or however she said it. Point being, you don’t have to mass make broth and then freeze it or buy the cr*ppy store bought stuff in order to make these soups. You literally only need what the recipe calls for. And the majority call for onions. So stock up on onions…and beans. Beans are pretty popular too.

A lot of these recipes are vegetarian (obviously) and I bet a lot can even be made vegan if they aren’t already (I think they are? Depends how seriously vegan you are cause everyone know a tomato plant likes a good dead fly now and then). Very few have any sort of meat in them, though a few recipes note what kind of meat you could put in it should you want to. Not many though. These are veggie and bean based soups, in case the title or everything above didn't already make that clear enough.

The Breads & Cookie
There aren’t a lot of these recipes. I think there were...3(?) bread recipes and one cookie recipe. Be warned, these recipes make a lot of dough. The bread calls for some interesting equipment, such as a spicy grinder and a jar blender. I’m sure you can find a reasonable alternative if you tired. I, for one, might break out my mini food processor and try that in order to make the dinner bread!

Salad
Okay, these salads are…involved. Far too much washing and drying and chopping/tearing for some lazy soul like me to do on a regular basis. BUT they would probably be great for a fancier dinner, like a family get together or a friend potluck or something where you decide to be the dude who shows up with salad…this won’t be a disappointing salad if you use one of these babies!! Heck, I had to look up what tahini was! Do keep in mind I live in hickville. Please, don’t judge me. Lol

Instant Pot Variations
Some of the same long recipes, but for insta-pot, which obviously cuts down the cook time by quite a bit! They do seem very involved though. You really have to know how to work your insta-pot. I have a cheaper knock off that doesn’t have some the required features so I kind of just scrolled from recipe I wanted to try to recipe I wanted to try to see if any of them were appliable to what I have.

Pantry Items
These are just ingredients needed for some of her recipes that you can make at home. Most have store bought equivalents available.

Conclusion
If you love vegetable and/or bean soups, this book will be right up your alley! Fairly simple, and made from scratch.

Was this review helpful?

I have always been a huge fan of soups. I am that person who can eat soup in any season. So I like to have a soup recipe on go every time. This book gave me new recipes to try everyday and I kind of liked few.


Thank you NetGalley for the ebook copy.

Was this review helpful?

As the weather already starts to turn cool, this book is an inspiration. The soups sound delicious, with lots of diverse, fairly easy recipes (most with an instant pot equivalent). If you want to step it up a bit, there are also recipes for homemade spice mixes. There are a couple bead and salad recipes to help you finish the meal. Great resource for vegan or plant-based folks. Easy add on options for more carnivorous folks.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review an advanced reader's copy of this book. This in no way affects my review, all opinions are my own.

I love soup. I could eat it almost daily. I do find I get into soup ruts though and this book could be my way out! The recipes themselves seemed fairly straightforward and easy.

The drawings of the soup are great, but a real picture of something other than people would have been better. I look for cookbooks to have pics of food, not children. 80 soup recipes should not take 180 pages.

Was this review helpful?

This is a lovely, quick read about the value of soup to Caroline Wright and community at large. The recipes are all plant based, and as a person who is generally pescatarian, this excites me!

There wasn’t a ton of writing in the book in general, just a quick snapshot of the author’s story and some of her tips. The recipes themselves were broken up by soups, a few breads, a great cookie, and a few salads. She also includes instant pot adaptations.

A few soups that stuck out to me: tomato and quinoa soup, Moroccan vegetable stew, split pea soup with roasted kale, and chunky garden vegetable.

This is a book that would be perfect for anyone interested in eating for healthfully! The recipes themselves would be perfect for a beginner cook.

Was this review helpful?

I was not the audience for this. I expected to learn a lot about making plan based soups as the title mentioned but it felt very biographical and the images were in black and white which I found odd. I wish the title would have been The Cancer Survivalists Journey with Plant Based Soups or something like that so I would have known it wasnt for me. (I don't read cookbooks with a story .. I do read survivalists stories .. i just like them to be two seperate entitites)

Was this review helpful?

Soup has always been compared to taking delicious medicine and this book will help elevate the idea. The author, a cancer survivor, goes through her history with her words and personal photographs. She discusses her finding comfort and healing in making delicious soups. What was interesting about this cookbook was the photos of the soups were all illustrations. They were lovely to go through. I can't wait to try so many of these recipes.

Was this review helpful?

This is one of the most beautiful recipe books i’ve ever seen!
Each recipe is accompanied by an amazing watercolor illustration of the soup. The book is also filled with beautiful pictures in black and white.
The recipes seem delicious and they are very specific (the author decided to give measurements about the salt as well). Some pages are even about baked goods like biscuits and at the end there are variations for the instant pot.
The story behind it is inspiring and I will definitely look for other recipes from the same author!

Was this review helpful?

This is a gorgeous book, full of amazing sounding soups that are made with very simple ingredients with influences from around the world. Beautiful photos and the soups themselves are shown through hand drawn art and look absolutely delectable. If you love soup, I can't recommend this book enough!

Was this review helpful?

Working my way through this book full of beautiful soup recipes, photos and stories.

I love a cookbook that gives you a since of life, home and love and this does just that. The story of the soup club, the information about ingredients and the recipes all make for a great read and more fun and soul-warming meals for cold winter nights.

I have made a few of the soups so far and plan on making more over the coming weeks and months. YUM!

Favourites so far are Teddy's Black Bean Soup, Kinda Tortilla Soup, Cowboy Chili and Cream of Mushroom Soup (so far). This book brought back so many memories of my younger days, mum cooking soup and the smells that permeated our home.

Thank you and love it.

Was this review helpful?

Soup Club is full of art! Various kinds of art which I’ll describe below.

Most cookbooks I look at are sort of boring. Recipes dictate a cup of this with two tablespoons of that. Photos. Blah.

But Soup Club! Love, love it. Some art examples:
Watercolor paintings of the soups.
Black and white photos around the house.
Haiku or word poems with each recipe.
Plus the author’s style of writing!
A background story on how the Soup Club came to be.
While she was battling cancer, soup was placed in a cooler on the porch. It was a magician’s box. Soup went in the box and hope came out.

Recipes give leeway according to your own preferences. There are suggestions on pleasing carnivore friends. She recommends a Dutch oven or stock pot, but also gives instructions if you prefer an instant pot. She doesn’t tell you to make stock or broth before you make the soup. This is great! When I was undergoing chemo last year, one of the cookbooks for those with cancer had a complicated recipe for stock before making various recipes themselves.

This cookbook is a gem because of the jewels in it. Thanks to Netgalley!

Was this review helpful?

OK, so there is a story behind this collection of soup, broth and stew recipes, which I know is going to be important to some – especially the creators – but I care not to bother with that here. I guess just mentioning it first, as opposed to, you know, the recipes, is evidence there is a lot of extraneous guff here. And yes, this really is eighty recipes, spread over two hundred pages, and spread very thinly at times, too – I swear the beginning gives you two recipes, then four whole pages of boring black and white photography, before getting back to what we actually came for. Oh, and every soup gets a haiku or similar three-line verse.

All this makes this book a little hard to like, although for me the vegetarian nature of all this kind of did that already. I seldom like anything too exotic in my veg, and blend anything that threatens my soup with its lack of meatiness. But even if you came to this with all the will in the world, and even if you could forgive the routine full-page painting (yes, painting) that each dish receives, you would find it hard to even locate your new favourite on first browse. Persevere and there are things such as Ethiopian lentil soup, a borscht with yellow beets and a whole lot more to completely confound Count Arthur Strong's soupover friends (obscure af cultural reference alert).

But then we make things to have alongside soup, and cookies. And then we're on to salads, and you think you might well have been mis-sold this completely. But then we're back to soups – the same batch as before, but refashioned for one of those American Insta-Pot things. It's going to warm the hearts of many, but I just could not include myself as one, what with the needless bulking-out and fripperies it carries. If it finds an audience then that's fine and dandy, but I can't pretend this volume was to my taste. Serves one and a half stars.

Was this review helpful?