Member Reviews
I absolutely loved this book. I knew that this book would be emotional but I was unprepared for how invested I became in their arcs. I have been a fan of Tahir's fantasy work - and I am so excited for more fiction from her.
I have no words to describe how amazing this book was. I sobbed at the end of this book - and I mean like full tears, out loud, snot leaking from my nose. I have read from Tahir before, but as this was her fist experience writing contemporary, I wasn't sure what to expect. But once I got to the beginning of the novel and I began to read the story, I knew I was going to be hit in the feels. This novel has one of my favorite tropes involving multigenerational stories - and I think Tahir did this in a profound and moving way. The stories for all three of our main characters were heart breaking even though the majority of the beginning portion was really quiet. Elements are hinted at or suggested, but the sadness really begins within the middle portion of the novel and grips you from there. Although I am not Pakistani myself, the discussion surrounding an immigrant community and the struggles faced with living in a new country still struck a cord with me. The book does an amazing job tackling these feelings and sharing themes of hope and forgiveness. I implore you to pick up this book because I have yet to read a more impactful book this year. I knew I enjoyed Tahir's fantasy novels, but this was one of her releases that I will never forget.
All my Rage is SO GOOD. I finished this book over a month ago and I still think about it once a day and I'm still hooked on the story and the characters. I have only read An Ember in the Ashes and have not finished the series yet, but I'm calling it now, this is her best book and her most powerful book!
All my Rage is a young adult contemporary book with some heavy-hitting adult themes and SHOULD be required reading in every high school. This has so much to offer! All My Rage follows three points of view and two different timelines - Noor and Salahuddin in the present and Misbah in the past. The voices connect effortlessly and provide seamless transitions in a way that really gives the story even more strength and power. Seeing how the characters deal with grief with the past woven in really adds to the beauty of the story.
There were so many moments when reading this book that I HAD to put the book down and walk away temporarily because of the impact it was making and the way it was making me really stop and think about the story. I heavily related to Salahuddin and his struggle with his father's alcoholism while also struggling to deal with and process his own grief. Noor has a controlling uncle who doesn't want her to leave and better herself and distance herself from Islam. It's in these parental/guardian situations were where I was really able to find a connection in this book has experienced it in my own background. These stories were impactful and emotional.
Before reading this book I didn't have much knowledge on Islam and wasn't sure what to expect, but the relationship shown with Islam was complex and beautiful, even inspiring me to do some more research of my own on the subject. I am not the most faith-based or religious person so I didn't really relate to that aspect perfectly, but All my Rage really spoke to me and impacted me. The feeling of turning to faith or religion when it feels like all other hope is lost really impacted me and I never thought a book would be able to do so.
Sabaa really continues to show us in her stories how one moment or one action by someone can really change everything for you and your life. This book brought me to cry several times. You can feel the emotions and the struggles of the characters throughout the entire story and it inspires you to always keep moving and keep hoping. While All my Rage is a book about anger, grief, and loss it is also a book about love and hope.
This is an incredibly inspirational and powerful book, if you read nothing else I suggest, please please please read this one.
This book is incredible. I read it in one sitting and cannot wait to share it with my students! The story weaves together so many elements flawlessly--love, sadness, grief, dreams. It is fierce but also tender. I will be adding this an option for students to choose in my unit on the American dream and American identity.
This book ripped out my heart and destroyed my soul - please you have to read it. It’s a roller coaster ride of emotions from beginning to end that I couldn’t put down. For all the teenagers who feel like they’re being forced to grow up too fast, this is for you.
There are so many things that I loved about this book.. I think Sabaa Tahir has improved so much as an author and her writing in this story was outstanding. I think a lot of times in books, especially in YA, authors can dump too much trauma on their characters and honestly it scared me a little when I was picking this book up to read.. but I truly think Sabaa Tahir did an amazing job developing these characters and letting them be more than their trauma. These characters gave me a lot of hope.
SPOILER --
My favorite line was when Salahudin said, "her life will forever be divided into the moment before we got pulled over and the moment after". I personally related to this not because my situation is the same as Salahudin or Noor's but I think all of us have a moment that changed us. It doesn't mean that the moment was as traumatic as theirs but I think readers would be able to relate to this and reading about how they both dealt with the situation almost felt like healing and growth for me.
This is a modern YA classic, written in the tradition of classic YA "problem novels" of the past, but with the care and emotion and poetry that only Sabaa Tahir could muster.
AHHHHHHHHHHH (This is not a coherent review, just a lot of thoughts, emotions, and absolute, undying admiration of Sabaa Tahir. She's done it again, and I couldn't be more delighted.)
This was my first time reading anything by Sabaa Tahir, and I really enjoyed it. I also listened to the audiobook at the same time and the narration was perfect for all three of the main characters. This story was definitely not what I was expecting, but once I finally got into it I couldn’t stop listening and needed to know what was going to happen.
YA books are my not so secret vice. Over the years, the tenor of young adult fiction has grown. While I love a good fluffy teen tale, I appreciate that serious issues, societal change, relationships and so much more are now tackled and openly discussed in the pages of a book. As they should be.
Sabaa Tahir's newest novel, All My Rage, is probably one of the best YA books I've ever read. Yes, it's that good. Tahir unfolds her story in past and present chapters, with the present taking precedence. The past is from Misbah - married in Pakistan in an arranged marriage. She and her husband Toufiq have a son named Salahuddin, emigrate to the US and open a motel. Noor is Salahuddin's best friend. They 'get' each other, can commiserate, hope and dream about what they want in life and how to get there. Until the fight. And.....Oh my gosh, so much comes both before and after the fight.
Reader, there are many triggers in this book, but they are not there for shock value. Instead, they depict life and the many stumbling blocks, hurdles and ugliness that are part of our society. Can those triggers be overcome and overwhelmed by the actions, love, faith and strength of Noor and Salahuddin? Their path forward is definitely not straight. I found myself constantly surprised (and worried) by the direction Tahir took with her plotting.
There are 'good' and 'bad' characters that you'll have no problem identifying. Indeed, I actually found myself talking (and shouting) to them out loud many times, with my emotions and thoughts running the gamut. Tears were also involved. Noor and Salahuddin are so very, very well drawn. But my heart belonged to Misbah. Everyone needs to have a Misbah in their life. And on a side note, Tahir's descriptions of food had my mouth watering! Noor escapes into her music and although I knew a number of the bands she likes, I discovered some new ones from her playlist.
Bottom line? This is a gut wrenchingly good book you need to read. Tahir's writing is fantastic. An easy five stars
Sabaa Tahir took inspiration for All My Rage in her own life and experiences.
I’ve never felt so connected to a book while knowing that I will never truly understand what it’s like to be, or go through the things that the characters go through. Thank you so so much to Penguin Teen and Netgalley for sending me an ARC of this book! I don’t believe that there are words to describe what Sabba Tahir did to me with this book. All My Rage follows Salahudin and Noor, as well as Misbah and Toufiq before they came to the US from Pakistan, where they opened a motel, similar to the one Tahir grew up in. This book jumps between different time periods as well as different POVs and it was done so beautifully. I’m not going to say anything else about the plot, as I fully recommend going into it knowing as little as possible. The book is based on a lot of Tahir and her family’s past, and you can tell just how personal the story is to her. Tahir’s writing transports you to a completely different world unlike any contemporary I’ve read before. She spent over fifteen years writing this book, and it’s very clear just how much of her heart and soul she poured into it. My number one takeaway from this book is that it makes you feel something. Really, it made me feel a little of everything, but what’s so beautiful is how everyone is bound to feel different things. At its core, this book deals with hope, family, and, well, rage. The rage was really something I could resonate with, not as a Pakastani, but as a feminist. The way Tahir writes about anger and rage is so interpretable and relatable. That feeling of passion and pride was depicted in such a stunning way. Last night, I went to Tahir’s event, and hearing her talk about the book was extremely moving. Also, I now have a signed/personalized copy of the book, which is now my biggest source of pride. Seriously though, everyone needs to read this book, for many different reasons, but that’s truly what’s so incredible about it.
TW: alcohol addiction, emotional and physical abuse, sexual assault, death of parents, Islamophobia, racism
This is one of those books that needs to be savored on audio because Sabaa Tahir’s beautiful writing is enhanced even more with the excellent audio narration by Deepti Gupta, Kamran R. Khan and Kausar Mohammed.
This story switches between the past and the present and is narrated from the POV of Salahuddin, his mother, Misbah, and his best friend, Noor.
This book gutted me - it has a lot of pain and suffering. There was one point where I was listening to the audio while driving and literally wanted to pull over and throw up because of the devastating event that occurred. That’s how powerful this story is that it evoked such a strong emotional reaction.
All the MC’s especially Salahuddin and Noor felt so raw and real. I wanted to hug them and pull them out of their difficult situations because no young adult should have to go through what they went through.
I can’t express in words how much this #ownvoices story about Pakistani characters meant to me. Thank you Sabaa for writing this beautiful story about love, loss, forgiveness and ultimately hope.
One of the greatest books I have ever read. I was so invested in these characters, the plot was fantastic and the author handled so many heavy topics with just grace and care.
I love Sabaa Tahir and all her writing. This book did not disappoint! I love the cover and the entire book. The book had be hooked from the beginning to end.
My first experience with Sabaa Tahir and good god what a writer she is.
While at times I felt the story lulled a bit, she really pulled no punches and wasn't afraid to get darker and darker with the story she was telling.
Truthfully, the only real "disappointment" I'd say I have is that everything *does* feel like it gets wrapped up in a bow at the end where I wish things maybe had ended a bit messier given everything these characters went through.
But overall? Absolutely incredible.
"Many authors talk about 'the book of my heart.' I tore this book from my heart. It's a story that demanded to be told, a love letter to the desert and good music and tiny motels and the kinds of friendships that save your life." —Sabaa Tahir
This book hurts… a lot. It’s filled with so much pain and grief and hurtful things. But also so many small, beautiful and wonderful things. It speaks volumes. It’s powerful and moving and will definitely leave its mark. It has on me.
I devoured 95% of this story in one sitting. It consistently left me hand-to-mouth gasping, tearful and gut-punched throughout, and by the end, bittersweetly and completely whole. I felt for these characters, longed and grieved with them, hoped for them, dreamed with them. Sabaa's writing is stunning.
Sal and Noor are childhood best friends, both burdened with so many immense, extraneous situations, when a disastrous event rips them apart.
There is a lot of heartbreak and loss in this story - it's devastating and emotionally charged, wrapped up in so much beauty, hope, and healing. It touches on unfathomable things and acute situations that make this a profound and imperative read.
"I see now that you were always two halves of a whole, two hands interlaced, two voices raised to a melody sung in time."
I’d love to get Salahudin and Noor’s next chapter. 🥺🧡
THIS BOOK HAS:
— childhood best friends
— all the classic tunes x fantasy nerd things
— multiple POVs
— young but forever love
— tragedy x harsh realities
— second chances x rediscovery
— family, faith, hope, love
— multi-generational x now & then storylines
Please be sure to check all the content warnings at the start of the book. Potential Triggers:
racism/Islamophobia, drug & alcohol abuse/addiction, child/domestic abuse, repressed trauma, illness, death, tense interactions with law enforcement.
Thank you to Penguin Teen for the e-arc 🧡
This is one of those books that will leave you with a thousand thoughts and linger long after you've finished. The writing is fantastic and has a raw quality to it that really resonates. The book was both heart breaking and hopeful. It was so beautifully written that it makes it message that much stronger. The story of immigrants and their struggles in this country isn't one I can relate to directly but I thought the author did a fantastic job with the portrayal. There are quite a few trigger warnings for this book though, so I would recommend checking those out if you are worried.
I’m a big fan of Tahir so I was very excited to get my hands on her latest work, a change from YA fantasy to contemporary fiction. This book combined a lot of the elements I’ve loved from An Ember in the Ashes while focusing on contemporary issues.
Salahudin (Sal) and Noor are two Pakistani teenagers growing up in a small town in California. They’ve been friends forever, though recently a fight drove them apart for awhile. When Sal needs to take on the responsibility of running his family’s motel, he and Noor rekindle their friendship to get through their last year of high school.
Contemporary YA isn’t always my thing but because this was Tahir, I gave it a go. And it was well worth it. At first, I wasn’t sold on these two characters, and the flashbacks to Sal’s parents coming to the US from Pakistan, but by about a quarter of the book, I was hooked. Tahir does an excellent job addressing issues of racism, xenophobia, domestic violence, and drug addiction. If it wasn’t obvious from that list, this book is heavy. But all the heaviness is handled well and in a way that feels totally authentic.
My only complaint was with the last third of the book when things begin to spiral. It felt more unrealistic than the rest of the story, and perhaps a tad overdramatized. Maybe I just prefer a slightly quieter story. But the characters here are strong and you will definitely feel like they are real people. It’s been awhile since I’ve felt so strongly about two characters!
Sometimes a book just feels like a kick straight to your heart. All My Rage dealt with a lot of extremely tough subjects and really made you care for the characters before tearing them down. And for that I couldn’t help but love it. Any book that can make me that sad and angry is clearly doing something right. The things that Sal and Noor are forced to confront took immense courage and honestly I would not have known how to deal with their circumstances. The writing was beautiful and the characters truly felt real. For me, this was a 5/5.
If you like coming of age during catastrophes, relationships tested to their limits, or need a good cry, this is the one for you.
I received a digital copy of this book free from Penguin Young Readers Group and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
An incredible story of love, mistakes and learning, and growing up. This is an incredible book to adapt into curriculum for students to dissect in discussion.