Member Reviews

This was an interesting read for me in more ways than one. I am normally not a fan of historical fiction and even though this book was very well done, that sentiment still remains. First of all, I had no idea that there even was a revolution in Romania against their Communist dictator and also the fact that this happened in the late 80’s?? I think that Sepetys did an amazing job at portraying the life of a young teen in this hellscape while still emphasizing the fact that teenagers are still going to be teenagers, no matter the circumstances. This book was a LOT of build up and so it was kind of hard for me to keep reading when it had been two hundred pages and almost nothing had happened, but by the end of the novel, I understood more about why it was written this way. I don’t know if I will read more historical fiction, but if I do, Sepetys is probably the author I would enjoy the most.

3.5 Stars

Was this review helpful?

Another amazing novel from Sepetys. I read this books in just a few sittings and couldn’t bring myself to put it down. The writing was incredible and the characters really sucked me in. The story was so sad and raw and really made me incredibly grateful for my life! I would highly recommend this novel to readers of all genres.

Was this review helpful?

Ruta Sepetys is one of my all-time favorite authors – I have read everything she has written and I absolutely jumped at the chance to read an e-galley of her newest novel, I Must Betray You.

Here’s what I loved:
Exploration of a period of history that isn’t well known
Sabotage + betrayal + resistance + romance
Compulsively readable
Will leave you breathless

Here’s the set-up: It’s 1989 in Bucharest, Romania and the country has been under Ceausecu’s authoritarian rule for over 20 years. 17-year-old Cristian Florescu lives in a tiny apartment with his parents, sister, and grandfather. Queuing in line for basic groceries is normal, radios are forbidden, and informants are everywhere. When a secret agent approaches Crisitan to gather information on an American diplomat in exchange for medicine for his sick grandfather, Cristian doesn’t have a choice.

I Must Betray You is another brilliant work Ruta Sepetys that will have broad appeal for both teens and adults. Highly recommended for ages 12 and up; purchase multiple copies for your library as this will fly off the shelves.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Penguin Teen and Netgalley for an eARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Damn Sepetys did it again. Her writing and books are phenomenal.

I Must Betray You takes us to post WWII Romania where Ceaușescu's reign is still going strong. But the people are overworked, being starved and harassed by Ceaușescu's secret police agents. The country is governed by isolation and fear. When Cristian Florescu is blackmailed to become an informant, he feels even more lost. His choices seem impossible, but when the opportunity to expose what is happening in Romania to the world, he jumps into the revolution.

All of Sepetys's books have taught me something. I love that most of her books have focused on Eastern Europe because US public schools hardly talk about these subjects. Even though I took AP European history in high school, I knew nothing about this. This book takes place in 1989 and focuses on the Romanian revolution of December 1989.

Cristian was an easy character to empathize with. We see the horrible things happening in Romania through his eyes and with his sense of compassion. He is such a cinnamon roll. I loved how much he loved his family, especially his Bunu (grandfather). Their relationship was one of my favorite things in this book. Among all the fear and paranoia, these two were bright stars. The love they had for each other was always palpable.

This is a heavy book, but wow I sped through it. Sepetys is a masterful writer, never shying away from the hard truths, but also doing so in such a way that the characters' humanity is always preserved. My heart hurts so much for 1989 Romania and the people who went through these real life events. Sepetys also weaves in reports throughout Cristian's narrative. So not only do we get his POV, but we see how the Securitate see him. And wow, it was menacing. The environment created in this was so tense and fearful.

There's not a ton of action in the beginning of this. Don't get me wrong, things happen and we get to know all the characters. But the first half of the story really sets in tension and depicting just how awful conditions were for the average Romanian citizen. The juxtaposition is made clear whenever Cristian interacts with Dan Van Dorn, the son of the American embassy delegate. The way the Van Dorns are treated and the access they have compared to Cristian is wild. It really slams home the point of how privileged the American delegates are treated.

I highly recommend reading the historical and author note at the end, it is amazing to see a glimpse of the research process and the real people whose lives have been touched.

Rep: All Romanian cast, male side character who loses an arm, chronically ill elderly male side character, Roma male side character.

CWs: Blood, confinement, death, death of parent, emotional and physical abuse (government to its people), genocide, grief, injury/injury detail, murder, police brutality, stalking, violence. Moderate: torture, gun violence, chronic illness, war. Minor: cancer.

Was this review helpful?

I feel like it’s been all too long since I’ve read a Ruta Sepety’s book! I love historical fiction and, I firmly believe, that she is one of the best historical fiction authors out there!! This one was no exception.

When you think historical fiction, you probably think World War 2. It’s the most common time period covered in the genre as far as I can tell. Of course she’s written books regarding World War 2 but, she’s covered so many other times and places around the world. United States in 1950, Spain in 1957, the Baltic Sea in 1945. In this book, we’re in Romania in 1989. An entire nation is struggling to survive under the fist of communism, wondering if the world knows how bad their life is. I was very young at the time of these events. Too young to understand or remember. So reading this was beyond interesting!

Cristian is a teenage boy living in a one bedroom apartment with his mother, father, sister, and grandfather. They live in fear, their every move being watched, wait in lines for hours for the smallest rations of food, never knowing when the electricity will be turned off, and always afraid to speak their minds. To make matters worse, the grandfather has leukaemia and seems to be worsening every day. Cristian is blackmailed to be an informer in exchange for medicine for his grandfather, forcing him to be one of the people he hates most.

The balancing act of being an informant was fantastic. He wanted to fight for his freedom. His grandfather is one of the most fearless and outspoken people he’s ever met and Cristian too shared the same thoughts. The first hand perspective of a characters inner turmoil kept me reading as quickly as I could. On one hand he had no choice. He was forced to give the government information or else him and his family would be punished. If he gave information, he could save his grandfather. But he wanted his freedom and kept nudging the boundaries of his duties to see what he could get away with and how he could turn the situation to his advantage. Even the smallest and most inconsequential things could force someone you love into being a target of the government. Cristian had to decide if he was going to remain quiet or fight. He had to decide if he was willing to face consequences and if their collective voice was loud enough to be heard.

In all her books, there is a common theme that I love. She speaks of revolutions, suffering, torture, war, and heartache. But, through all of this, she focuses on the fight. The unbreakable human spirit that can’t be contained. Love, loyalty, friendship, and family can overcome anything. People can come together to console and heal. They can also come together to form a voice and generate power.

The author always writes teenagers in a very realistic way. I’m not sure how to explain this but I’m going to try. Normal teenagers worry about things like relationships, school, parents, money, their future, and so on. The characters she writes about aren’t normal teenagers. Well, I mean they are, but they’re living in unusual circumstances. Instead of their worst fear being grounded and told they can’t hang out with their friends on a Friday night, these teenagers are fearful of their lives and wonder when they’re going to get their next meal. At times they seem normal and, at other times, they’re forced to be mature for their age. It’s really interesting to see the things that force their growth and the things that allow them to be a normal teenager.

As hard as it can be to read, I’m happy she’s so I afraid to hold back. This was raw, dark, and painful. An entire nation struggling to hold onto hope and live a life of freedom. There’s intricacies of family and country as well as knowing when to push and pull. I absolutely loved this!

Was this review helpful?

Ruta Sepetys, again, construct historical fiction with such care and nuance, that it’s hard to ever put the book down. This history of Romania in the late 20th century leads readers on a trip that is full of questions and characters that make you wonder where their true allegiance lies. You really don’t know who to suspect and who to trust. I appreciated the historical references to people, places, and items that I didn’t know a lot about and honestly I did not know much about the time period in the book. I highly recommend all of her books but this one is a quick read, yet complex in its discussion about post-Soviet Easter Europe and end of the Cold War.

Was this review helpful?

Sepetys has, once again, crafted a compelling, fast-moving, emotionally complex, and utterly thrilling story that is both compulsively readable while also educational about a time in history/the world that YA readers might not be familiar with.

In truth, the public school system in the US has failed disastrously at educating the true horrors and pain suffered by those living under Communist rule in the 20th century. Sepetys seeks to illuminate readers while providing compelling characters, a tense plot line, and never leaving you enough time to feel like you can catch your breath.

While at times I felt a bit confused about the history of what was happening (which was easily explained away when I read Sepetys' extensive notes at the end), I never for one second doubted that things would be explained and there would be a satisfying conclusion.

As with all of Sepetys' books, she has developed seemingly disparate storylines that all weave together slowly, coming together in a gasp-worthy conclusion.

Cannot recommend this enough and cannot wait to read more.

Thanks to Penguin Teen for my e-arc of this book.

Was this review helpful?

I really wish I could break the rule and nominate this for Library Reads because I find this book every bit as appealing to adults as teens and I will recommend it to both age groups. I have order multiple copies for our library because Ruta's books are so popular and this one does not disappoint!

Set in Romania in the late 1980's during the communist era this book read like a thriller but if you know this author she is a researcher first. I am not a history person and knew little. This book teaches , not just the history itself but the lessons we can, in fact, we must learn from it before we are doomed to repeat it.
5 stars. Read it. Recommend it. Discuss it.

Was this review helpful?

**Review will be published January 25th on my Blog/Goodreads/Instagram/Storygraph**

A UNIQUE & INFORMATIVE SETTING.

One of my favorite things about Sepetys as a writer is her clear effort in researching the history of whatever book she’s writing. I also love that most of her books are from more niche areas of history that I don’t know a lot about. They continually inspire me to look up more information and learn even more about the subject.

A bit slow paced in the first half as we watched Cristian go through the day-to-day life of what it was like in communist Romania. The visceral depictions of fear and oppression was at times hard to read. The short chapters kept the book moving steadily as the tension increased on a country tired of being held back.

I liked Cristian as a main character and his heartfelt desire to do right by his family and also do right by himself. His touching inner monologue of wanting more and suffering because of it, but then finally being able to reach a path that would lead to hope. I would have loved a bit more character development for everyone to really feel attached to them.

The intensity of the second half unleashed the betrayals, the riots and moments of clarity. While I didn’t love how the book ended, once reading the author’s note and history in the back of the book (don’t forget to do that!!) it all made sense as the type of writing choice I Must Betray You needed. Another great and informative historical fiction for Sepetys!

Overall audience notes:
- YA Historical Fiction
- Language: a little
- Romance: kisses
- Trigger/Content Warnings: depictions of poverty, a loved one beaten to death (aftermath is witnessed), murder, riots, mass loss of life, gun violence, near death experiences

Was this review helpful?

I always know going into a Ruta Sepetys novel that I'm going to learn about a part of history I previously knew nothing about. I Must Betray You was no exception! Learning about communist Romania in 1989 was truly eye-opening. Sepetys paints a detailed picture about what life was like living there with all the betrayals and poverty. Unfortunately, I feel like painting this picture got in the way of deep character development and the plot in the first half of the book. While it was interesting learning about Romanian life, it felt very much like going through the motions for too long. The second half picked up a lot though, and it lived up to my expectations of lots of action and revolution!

So while this wasn't my favorite Ruta Sepetys novel, it was still inspiring and taught me a lot about this little-known part of history. I really appreciated the author's note going deeper into the history as well as pictures from that time. An interesting historical fiction!

Writing Aesthetic/Style: 5
Plot/Movement: 3
Character Development: 4
Overall: 4

Thank you, Penguin Teen, for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Students at my school love Ruta Sepetys. They will like this one, too. It seems to be a quicker read than her other books. Plus, the characters are more their age than in other books. Historical fiction is not a very popular genre in my library, but Sepetys has this way of making you care about the characters, and as a result, you learn something about history that you might never have known about..

Was this review helpful?

Oh, Ruta Sepetys! You are a historical fiction author magician! This book blew my mind because it takes place when I was 7 but in Romania, and comparing my life to the tyranny and oppression Cristian and his family faces on a daily basis. Ruta educated me. Schooled me. Whoa.

Was this review helpful?

I'll read anything that Ruta Septetys writes! This book does not disappoint. Set in Romania, 1989, Sepetys tells the story of the Romanian dictatorship and it's hold on the Romanian people through her story. Although communist regimes are falling all around them, Romanian's are kept in the dark by the regime and severely punished if they defy the government. However, the people find the strength to fight back to set themselves free. Based off of actual events, the book is eye opening as to the conditions the Romanian people lived in for years.
#RutaSepetys #IMustBetrayYou #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

I am a big fan of Ruta Sepetys, and this book did not disappoint in telling the story of one of the last and most ruthless totalitarian/communist regimes in Eastern Europe. I don't stock all of her books in my grade 5/6 class, because I don't think they are really ready for some of the scenes in books like Salt to the Sea, or Between Shades of Gray, but I think I will be able to have this one for some of my readers. There are some scenes of violence in which young people are beaten by the police force of the government, but that usually does not disturb my readers as much as say, sexual content.

Was this review helpful?

Nineteen eighty-nine was the year we welcomed a new president into the White House, the World Wide Web was invented, the Berlin Wall came tumbling down, and the game boy made its first appearance. People only knew what the tv and radio told them, no one knew of the true horrors that were happening in Romania. No one knew until the citizens stuck up for themselves and started a revolution. Even though I was young at the time, I remember hearing about these events.

Romania has been a place that I've always wanted to visit. It has such a rich history that I'm fascinated by it. This book brought forth so many things that people around the world didn't know were happening at the time. The events that were taking place in the late eighties were things we all read about in the history books that took place forty-plus years ago. It's devastating. Ruta takes us back to those times and shares a special story from the perspective of a teenage boy named Nicolae.

We are all ones to judge how Nicolae handled certain situations. He was smart, brave, and a teenager in a time of anguish. We make comments on how we would have handled things. It's one thing to say what you would do but you don't know how you would handle this until you're actually faced with these issues. Here, actions definitely speak louder than words, and Nicolae and his friends stepped up to the plate. Ruta makes you feel for the choices that they have to make in order to survive. She also lets you know that these are teenagers trying to survive and that they make mistakes.

This book is so well researched and she stayed true to the horrors that Romanians faced. She also adds a touching and breaking story about a teenager trying to live and break free from communist control. This book certainly hits you like a ton of bricks and I enjoyed this a lot. The story, the history, and the revolt were so amazing. I loved how the author added in actual photos from that time with a little history describing what was going on. It all played out perfectly.

I Must Betray You was an amazing and emotional read. Ruta gives you an experience that you have never witnessed before and I can't believe what I read. It was powerful and gives you lots of hope for the future. This is a masterpiece from a powerhouse author. I can't recommend this enough.

Was this review helpful?

I Must Betray You by Ruta Sepetys is a novel of historical fiction. It takes place in the communist era of Romania. The main character is Cristian, a seventeen-year-old who dreams of being a writer. Cristian gets blackmailed into informing for the authorities. He decides to use his position to his advantage to undermine the dictator. He plans to help expose to the rest of the world what is happening in Romania and help give voice to his fellow Romanians. Cristian eagerly joins the revolution.

This is a powerful book that is so heartbreaking and scary. Ruta Sepetys has written a spectacular story that takes place in such a little-known part of world history. I am eager to go back and read more from Ruta Sepetys.

Was this review helpful?

This author is well-known for capturing and highlighting the moments in history that aren’t commonly taught in educational curricula. She has such a talent for drawing you into a story and making you feel all the things these fictional characters are feeling while also including subtle reminders that the devastation and heartbreak included in her books unfortunately aren’t all fiction. I only started reading her books this year and she’s quickly become one of my favorite authors. I’m so excited to be able to talk about how much I thoroughly enjoyed another work of hers.
I Must Betray You takes place in communist Romania only a few decades ago when the country was under the dictatorial rule of Nicolae Ceausescu. The story follows Cristian, a boy who dreams of becoming a writer but must put these dreams on hold for the safety of himself and his family. When he is blackmailed by Romania’s secret police to become an informant and report on his fellow Romanians as well as the son of a U.S. diplomat, Cristian struggles with deciding between doing what is safe for those he loves and what is right for his country.
This book had such a dystopian feel to it, very similar to the sentiments expressed in 1984, but this is drawing from a piece of reality. I was so immersed through the writing and the internal conflict of the characters. I can’t imagine being forced to live in such a paranoid state all the time. Cristian, his family and friends all had to live by the motto of trust no one in order to avoid punishment from the Securitate, or the secret police.
As with all books by this author, I was left with a lasting impression and she has again accomplished her goal of not letting the suffering or the triumphs of these people go forgotten.

Was this review helpful?

Another masterpiece by Ruta Sepetys! This novel is just contains just the right combination of suspense and historical fiction to hook YA readers.

Was this review helpful?

Ruta Sepetys is an author that I will read over and over again. She knows how to take a true story that not many people have heard about and write it in such a way that you can feel the desperation and fear coming from the main characters. I Must Betray You takes place in 1980s Romania, which is under the Communist regime of Nicolae Ceausescu. The people live In constant fear, whispering in corners, not knowing who they can trust. They are all under surveillance by the government with neighbors, friends, and/or family members reporting on them which leads them to mistrust everyone. In the middle of all this, we have Cristian, a high school student who gets blackmailed into becoming an informer, but he still dreams of living in a free Romania. The fast pacing and short chapters keep the reader engaged while the setting and characters make you feel a part of the story. This is a powerful and well-researched story and I highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

I really loved this book - highly suspenseful and intriguing. I' ve already talked about this book to my students when speaking about figurative language. Beautiful writing!

Was this review helpful?