Member Reviews

What an amazing read! I loved the idea of conjuring and magics. Light, dark, elements, and necromancy. There wasn’t a full moment in this book. So many twists and just incredible descriptions. I can’t wait to read book 2.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a bit of a roller coaster ride. There were many moments, especially in the first third of the book, where I lamented the slow pace and feeling like I wasn't making any progress despite reading for what seemed like forever. Despite it feeling slow, the reading experience itself was fantastic, though, because of the interesting world-building, wonderful characters, and beautiful prose. Then the threads of the plot began to unravel in ways I didn't expect, and I was sucked into the story so completely I stopped caring about the length and never wanted to put it down. By the end I had the opposite problem from at the beginning. There was so much going on I had a hard time trying to keep it all straight (but in a good way). There were so many different conspiracies and agendas I lost count, which made for an explosive and complex ending where most of the different factions' plans came to a head all at once.

The story has been marketed as a dark adult fantasy, but it felt much more like a YA crossover. It definitely had adult elements that were quite dark, but most of the tropes and themes were ones I see most commonly in YA novels. All of the protagonists were dealing with coming of age issues and fell into the late YA or NA age range. Personally, I liked the blend of YA themes with the darker elements, but I love YA fantasy in general. So, that wasn't much of a surprise. The story explored how relationships change as individuals grow up and illustrated the struggle young people often have when they initially realize the world isn't necessarily perfect, good, or on their side. Many of the characters struggled to find a balance between fulfilling their duty and creating change in a system that they realized wasn't working. I also loved the author's subversion of the typical chosen one trope and the exploration of how the gods and religious/political figures used their powers to further their own agendas. However, I think the religious themes could have been explored more explicitly or deeply given the contentious relationships between some of the main characters and their gods, which was one of the only major disappointments I had with this book.

I loved all the characters in this book. Each of them felt distinct and well-rounded, and the rotating POVs kept me engaged even when the story was moving rather slowly. My favorite characters were probably Taesia and Nik. Taesia was just a total badass hell bent on saving her brother and changing a system she didn't really even want to be a part of, and her struggle with her moral failings made her such an interesting, complex character. On the other hand, I just wanted to give Nik a big hug. I felt so bad for him as I read this book because all he wanted was to be good enough for someone, his father, his god, his friends. His journey was compelling and brought tears to my eyes at the end. I also want to note that the author did a fantastic job of writing the relationship dynamics between the characters. The rivalry between the heirs oozed from the pages, and the sexual tension was so thick at some points it made my cold heart flutter. lol. I don't usually ship certain characters while reading a book, but I definitely have strong feelings about which characters should get together. I'm hoping to see that happen in future books, and if it doesn't, watch out Sim. ;)

Overall, I really loved this book. It was a great reading experience despite being a bit slow at times. The ending left me with my jaw hanging open for quite a while after, and I really want to read the next book! Therefore, I rate this book 4 out of 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

What an intricate tale Tara Sim weaves. This book has everything you could want; political intrigue, angry gods, half god half humans, LGBTQ rep, magic, religion, multiple pov, violence, love, hate, surprise twists, angry spirits, morally grey characters, family conflict, and so much more. This book has the promise of an epic series and I really cant wait for the next book. This story used familiar tropes in fresh ways that kept me binging the book, whenever I had free time. I received an ebook ARC from the publisher, Orbit, through Netgalley for an honest review. I will be purchasing a physical copy when it comes out on March 22nd 2022.

Will be doing a full review on TikTok on 3/13/22 https://www.tiktok.com/@wontstopreading/video/7074642689047776558?is_copy_url=1&is_from_webapp=v1

Was this review helpful?

Sim's fantasy is engaging with characters that are intriguing and a social structure that lends itself to political machinations, familial drama, and rebellion against the established modus operandi by our main players.

It does not read as adult fantasy though. The parents are only the force behind their children's push for the throne and some are more invested than others. The use of multi-character perspective helps to form the readers impression of the social system within the world as well as helping the character and world building development grow.

The most captivating aspect of this book was the magic system blending elemental magic with newer forms of energy manipulation. The personal interplay between the heirs of the houses was interesting and plays into the structure of the coming danger and eventual outcome both for the throne and the saving of the realm.

Was this review helpful?

I still need time to process everything that happened because this book was LONG. Did I completely understand the politics and worldbuilding of this book? No. Did a lot of the tropes and plot twists feel very familiar? Yes. Did I still enjoy it? Yes. I think the biggest thing that stood out to me in this novel was definitely our 4 MCs and the couple of side characters whose POVs we also got throughout the book. While there is a balance between the plot and characters in this book, it definitely felt like a more character-driven story to me. Seeing Taesia, Risha, Nik, and Angelica's dynamics and relationships with one another as they juggle their own motivations and duties as heirs to their respective houses was super interesting. There have been many instances in previous Adult Fantasy novels with multi-POV storytelling where I've been super confused about which character is who and how they're related to one another, but Tara Sim did a really good job at distinguishing all of our characters--I was never confused in that regard. I also really loved the MC's dynamics with the side characters as well, such as Risha and Jas, Taesia and Julian, Nik and Fin, etc. The sibling relationships were also so wholesome--I love a good sibling relationship in fantasy and Taesia's scenes with Dante and Brailee, as well as Risha's scenes with Saya did not disappoint.

Moving to the rep in this book, I love the casual queerness among our cast of characters and Risha's background as a desi necromancer. Overall, I definitely adored the desi rep in this book (the self-insertion as Risha was a little too real lol) and I can't wait to see where her character arc goes next in Book 2--she easily my favorite character.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book! The first half was somewhat slow as the scene was being set and the world and magic system explained the second half had me completely hooked. I was dismayed when I realized it would be a part of a series and would have to wait for the next book to come out. I loved that the characters are all so flawed and the dynamic between them is incredible. The twists kept coming until the very end and like I said I will anxiously be waiting for the next installment.
Thank you to NetGalley for a copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

First, I would like to thank NetGalley and the publisher for an arc of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I'm going to keep this review brief because I'm going to post a more detailed review on my my YouTube channel. This book follows the heirs of the Four Realms: Life, Death, Light and Darkness. These heirs all have the power of their god in their veins, which gives them powers. However, a long time ago, the gods cut this city off, and their city is dying because of it. These 4 heirs must work together to save everyone living here.

I really enjoyed this book. I will say, one thing that really confused me is why these people's parents weren't who this story followed. But that's neither here nor there. I thought the characters were all incredibly thought out. We have 4 very different personalities with very different motivations, but all ultimately wanting the same thing. I loved that some of the characters did bad things and made the hard decisions. I really felt like the stakes were high in this book. The plot was fast paced, if not a little confusing at times, but by the end I felt like I was fully in the loop and understanding.

I will get more in depth in my YouTube review! I would definitely recommend fantasy readers preorder this book, though.

TW: abusive relationship, alcohol, animal abuse, attempted murder, blood, bones, bullying, death, demons, emotional abuse, famine, fire, gore, hospitalization, murder, occult, racism (fantasy), skeletons, snakes, spiders, cannibalism, terminal illness, violence

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Orbit Books for providing me with an advanced copy. All opinions are my own.

DNF at 58%.

I really, really, really wanted to like this book. In a lot of ways, I actually DID really like this book. After over a week of reading this just to barely pass the halfway point, I’ve hit the point where I just can’t power through anymore.

First, let’s start with what I loved: most notably, the characters. The four heirs were fascinating, all both foils and compliments to each other. I loved how the author portrays how differently they deal with the weight of their duty and I love how well rounded they are. Risha is just so wonderful, and I would’ve happily read a book just on her. Nik is so endearing, a contrast in vulnerability and quiet warrior strength. Angelica may have been the most complex out of the big four, though I wish she’d been tied a bit more to the other three who already had such strong bonds. Taesia, though—Taesia stole the show for me. Even without finishing the book, I’m obsessed with her. Her arc is so, so interesting—the sudden responsibility thrust upon her, the grief, the corruption arc. I could write a glowing review on her alone.

On the other hand, the romances are a bit less strong, though I really did appreciate how they aren’t the main focus. The initial established relationship is so sweet and endearing. But it ends a little too easily, and one of them moves on way too quickly with someone she’s met twice. Now, I didn’t read far enough to know for sure they’re going to get together, but it absolutely seemed that way.

The plot, despite everything, actually is really strong too. I really did try to power through because I want to know so badly how everything goes, how everything ends. The world is fascinating and the different magic systems are each uniquely cool as hell and intriguing. Taken at a high level, this book has so much potential and really didn’t fail on execution, all things considered.

In a word, this book is just too over ambitious. The amount of POVs is my broadest issue. Had it just been the four heirs, it would’ve been manageable, but having 7 just felt like too many, especially when two of them were from the same House. Once the POV switches within chapters started, it just got even worse. It was hard to follow to begin with, and really I couldn’t have cared less about the characters outside the main four. There’s no reason to give them POVs. Clearly, a fifth is going to be a major player either at the end of this book or for the rest of the series—but this book didn’t need his POV to prove that. The POV switches within chapters starting in Part 2 turned a hard to follow story into a frustratingly hard to follow one, and made her chapter headers pointless. Shorter chapters? Fine. POV switches between the seven POV characters within the chapters? Unnecessary.

On top of the seven point of views making this overly complicated, there are five separate and unique magic (and corresponding religious) systems too. Taken on their own, each magic system is really interesting and ultimately well crafted, but it’s just too much for one book, especially when there’s no overlap between any of them. It’s such a cool concept, it’s just way too much for one book. This isn’t helped by how incredibly long this book is, either.

I think the timeline has some major issues too, but I don’t want to get into that too much as it’s likely just personal opinion. The immediacy of the realm’s problems just didn’t match up with how many CENTURIES ago the Sealing occurred, nor did the characters’ reactions to the Sealing and its effects.

Overall, as much as I wanted to love this book, I just couldn’t do it. For all intents and purposes, it’s not a bad book, and it rests on very solid characters and a very strong premise. In my opinion, where this failed for me is just in that the book attempts too much and couldn’t possibly accomplish it all clearly or effectively.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book in a trilogy and sets the stage for an epic fantasy. I read and loved Sim’s Scavenge the Stars duology and was eagerly awaiting this book since it was announced. Since the world is so big in this series, you have a lot of characters and things to remember. It did occasionally feel like I should be taking notes. I loved learning about the four heirs and the four realms. The magic in this is really cool and the world building is great. I didn’t give a full five stars because the pacing was a little slow for my taste but it’s still worth the read. I know the author has stated this is not YA but a crossover however it read more YA to me. I had hoped it would be more adult but perhaps the other books in the series will be.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I requested a digital copy in order to sample the prose on my phone (since I don't have a eReader) before requesting a physical copy for review. I will update Netgalley once I read & review a physical copy.

My review will be based on the physical ARC I read.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

The City of Dusk was one of my most anticipated releases of 2022 and I hate to say it was a letdown, but it was.

I won't bother recapping the plot because the summary does a pretty good job but boy do I have some opinions. Since I can't think of a better way to structure this *extremely scattered* review, I'm just going to list them below.

- This was probably specific to the ARC, but including a map would've been a huge help in understanding the geographical and cosmological structure of the world. Sim has really created something interesting in the way the mortal realm (for lack of a better term) connects with divine realms but it was super hard to conceptualize without a visual aid. I'm sure this will be fixed in the published edition though.

-Before the story even starts there is an overview of the different houses, a poem inspired by the events preceding the book, and a prologue. That is a lot of shit to get through before the story even begins and is kind of a red flag that the rest of the text will be far more extra than it needs to be.

- Similarly....the length. GOOD GOD, WHY WAS THIS SO LONG? THERE WAS NOT ENOUGH GOING ON TO JUSTIFY THIS PAGE COUNT.

- The City of Dusk is, ostensibly, an adult novel, though the main characters are all young adults. I have no problem with this except two of the characters (*coughTaesiaandAngelicacough*) are basically your standard YA Fantasy MCs. Risha and Nik both read as slightly more adult, but I will say this book could've easily been categorized as YA or NA.

- Some of the MCs, I won't say who because spoilers, are okay with using a type of magic that is almost universally maligned in the society and culture they've lived in their whole lives. This makes no sense to me. Like, wouldn't they at least have some trepidation about exploring a type of magic that is universally taboo in their world? I know that no thinking person subscribes to cultural norms 100%, but it does seem like these characters have culturally anomalous beliefs for no other reason than advancing the plot.

-Speaking of the worldbuilding, it was unique and cool but also felt very YA to me. The best part of the world is in the multi-cultural nature of the city, and I particularly liked the aesthetic of House Vakara. Unfortunately, the magic system felt straight out of any YA novel to me and lacked the complexity I was craving from a magic system so closely tied to religious beliefs.

-Risha was literally the only character I cared about. She was smart and stable and reacted to things in an understandable way. She was also the character who felt in line with an adult fantasy MC, IMHO.

- One strength of this novel is that the different MC's POV sections do have their own vibe. Risha, for example, read very differently from Taesia, etc.

- Soooooooo many info dumps.

- IF THE SEALING WAS SUCH A BIG DEAL AND HAD SUCH A NEGATIVE IMPACT ON THE CITY OF NEXUS WHY ARE ONLY 4 TWENTY-SOMETHINGS TRYING TO FIX IT?!?!

- This book was very inclusive, which is nice, but the information wasn't provided to the reader organically, and it kind of felt like the author was going down a checklist. Queer characters, check. Trans character, check. Every skin color, check. I prefer inclusivity that blends in so seamlessly it's barely noticeable, which is not the case here. That could be a personal preference though, so others may have a totally different view on this.

- This is largely a pet peeve, but the first four chapters are broken up between the four POV characters. So, as the reader, my brain went "The POV changes with each chapter, cool." NO. Starting in Chapter 5, there are POV changes in the same chapter, indicated only by a blank line in the text. It was kind of jarring after the earlier structure of the POV changes.

-For me, Sim's writing shone the brightest in Risha's sections. "The path was not smooth, nor was it straight. It ran in gentle serpentine curves, paved with jagged stone and glittering fragments of peridot and onyx." See? Beautiful.

- Some of the scene transitions were awkward, but this might be smoothed out in the published version.

- I seem to be very much in the minority here but I loathed Taesia. I think she was meant to be snarky and fun but I just found her to be a petulant child who doesn't give a single thought to the consequences of her actions. I think her sections are a big part of why this novel didn't feel very adult to me.

Oh well, some books work for you and some don't. On to the next.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC from the publisher and am voluntarily posting a review. All opinions are my own.
The City of Dusk is the first in a dark queer fantasy series by Tara Sim. While it does have its flaws, as a first book in a first adult series, there’s a lot to enjoy and a lot of potential for growth and development.
The setup is really cool, what with it being about these four characters who are all heirs to godly Houses and them making their way in this complex world, being abandoned by their gods. I will say the world building does feel a bit too vague at times, as the sense of place isn’t super well defined. But other aspects make up for it, particularly in how Sim’s writing builds up the aesthetics, especially in how culture is used to differentiate between Houses.
The characters are all interesting (albeit to varying degrees), especially given each comes from a noble House with its own complex family dynamics. While the book is divided more or less evenly among the perspectives, Taesia is no doubt the star of the show. She’s fierce and headstrong, a bit morally gray, and protective of those she loves.
Risha is very sweet, and a sort of dependable, family-focused, surrogate-parent/older-sister figure. She could easily have been boring to follow, but she isn’t, as she still has room to grow.
Nikolas carries a lot of grief and baggage due to his home life, not to mention the expectations placed upon him due to society. While this is a very “typical” archetype for young heroes in positions like his in fiction across genres, I liked Sim’s take on it and what she did with him.
Angelica has a lot of potential, dealing with both her mother’s ambition and her own self-doubt. She doesn’t have as fleshed-out of an emotional arc as the others, and I feel she was the character who suffered a bit from the favoritism of Taesia.
Overall, I liked this book, in spite of the small caveats, and am curious to see what Sim does with the story going forward. If you’re a primarily YA reader looking for an adult fantasy, this might be a great crossover book to start with.

Was this review helpful?

Ooooh boy. I want to start by saying that early on, about 10-15% into the book, I really wanted to rate this more highly. I was really enjoying the worldbuilding and the characters. I had just read Atlas Six, and I was finding this faster paced and more engrossing, but similar in the edgy cast of characters and hidden mysteries.

And then…what happened. I became so so bored with this story. And yes it picked up again, and there were still really interesting elements with the worldbuilding. The characters are likable and unique enough…but I swear absolutely nothing significant was happening for a good half of the book, between the first initial big plot moment and then the final rush to the end.

I just think there were too many characters in the cast, with not enough planned plot. It felt more like the characters simply were the plot, as everything built to this one moment that was endlessly foreshadowed. I kept waiting for other significant plot developments…and none came.

I am giving 3 stars for potential because the elements are there. The writing potential is there. The fun potential is there. But was it in this book? No.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a solid read. It gave very classic fantasy vibes. It has some dark themes and the world-building, though little on the heavy side, I felt was needed as it is in most first novels in a series. A lot of interesting twists. I would defiantly read this to a fantasy reader.

Was this review helpful?

This book has everything I love: forbidden magic, necromancy, a diverse cast of characters, and things going horribly wrong. I truly adore everything Tara writes!

Was this review helpful?

Instant reaction:
** Holy moly ALL THE TWISTS!!! Should have seen that coming, why didn't I see.....wait......wait.....WHAAAAAAT!??!
** Boy, this was just fun to read!
** Nik and Fin are my ship, they must be together and this is the hill I will die on.....

The City of Dusk is a wonderful, complex fantasy world that I thoroughly enjoyed getting swept up in. Everything about the world from the different types of magic wielded by each of the houses, to the political battles and characters that I really wanted to spend time with. Throw in shadow and light companions, twists that honestly did surprise the heck out of me, and I am in!!
In the city of Nexus, there are four noble houses each descended from a god and possessing divine powers that exist in a loose alliance with the king. The houses represent Life, Death, Light and Darkness and each heir is trained and prepared to battle the others for supremacy. But Angelica, Risha, Nikolas, and Taesia have another option,: work together to save their kingdom from destruction and set it on a new, more equitable path for all. The world building for each house and their type of magic was fantastic and all of the secrets, rituals and changing relationships keeps the story humming along. Can't wait to get book 2 and see where this tale goes from here!!

4.5 stars/5. Thanks to Orbit Books and Netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I have a lot of feelings about The City of Dusk, not all of them great, but not all of them bad either! COD was definitely way too long IMO, and also even though it is supposed to be Sim's foray into adult fiction, it still definitely felt YA, and can also definitely be read by YA readers as the singular sex scene doesn't get graphic at all. I think a lot of time could be better spent developing the characters, because when your story's structure is the character's involved, but you spend all the time in the plot, you're not going to care about the plot. It took me until the last 30% of the book to actually be invested in what was happened, because twisty turns started happening. This felt like two books packed into one, and again, I think it was because the characters felt half baked. Overall it was written really well, and I love Tara Sim's worlds! But it left me a bit emotionally disconnected, which kinda sucks because Scavenge the Stars had really enticing characters.

Was this review helpful?

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Plot: The beginning is slow, with not a whole lot happening. I needed something at the start to really to engage my attention. I wanted more stakes in the game and a sense of urgency. But I’m so glad I stuck with it because once the book started to take off (around chapter six for me) it hooked me in and didn’t let go. The building tension and rising discord is skillfully designed. There’s mystery I was invested in solving. The plot is multi-layered and the many facets of sub-plots are deftly woven together into the story as a whole. I love that some things we are able to discover on our own and yet some things are tactfully remained hidden. There are so many truly-unexpected twists and turns, like one bombshell after another. A delightfully complex tale, The City of Dusk is riveting and I can’t wait for the next book in this series!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Characters: One of my favorite parts of this book is the characters, and there are many. Each is unique in their personality and motivations, and with the multiple points of view we get extensive insight. There are many groups and relationships that both form and end throughout the story. Having all the conflicting emotions and desires gives the story more depth and makes the characters more relatable. The side-characters’ involvement in the plot is intricate. There are even a few slow-blooming intimate relationships that I would love to see come to fruition in the future installments in this series. One thing that really bothers me is that I still can’t get a grasp on the characters’ ages. I don’t know if they are intentionally left vague, but I think knowing this would’ve helped me feel more connected to them and understand them better. This story has so much potential between all its players and I hope to see more of their interactions developing. I feel like we have just brushed the surface of this story and I can’t wait to see how much more it has to offer!

⭐⭐⭐⭐Writing: The writing is flowy and gripping. There are shining moments when a few sentences of backstory and exposition show so much about the characters. And there are moments of brilliance where the descriptive language is gorgeous. Only a few times did I feel like I was being told things just for the sake of it. At first, some of the dialogue feels bland and forced. But once the story gets into a rhythm, I find the banter between characters is fun, engaging, and starts to flow naturally. And who doesn’t love the punchy one-liners?

⭐⭐⭐Pacing: The first few chapters are a bit wobbly for me, but then the story seems to get into a flow and really take off. There are some scenes throughout that I feel don’t really serve to further the plot or character development that could’ve been cut to make the pacing a little stronger in places. By chapter six, the stakes are upped and I was super invested. The ending didn’t quite pack the punch I was hoping for, especially considering how much tension is built up by that point, but it’s still action-packed and sets up really well for the next book in the series. Typically, I find that the middle is where a book tends to drag, but in this one I think the middle (parts two and three) is my favorite part.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐POV: I enjoy seeing this story unfold from so many different perspectives. You’d think with so many that it may get confusing, but actually, each character’s voice is strong and unique and I never second-guessed whose perspective I was reading from. Props to the writer for accomplishing this so well. I also love how we as the readers are able to get different pieces of information from all the characters and start putting them together to solve the puzzles even before they do.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐World-building: The richness in lore and complexity of the magic system is fascinating and immersive. I love how mythology and science-fiction are woven together to create such a masterpiece of magical fantasy. I do wish some things had been explained a little more clearly up front, because it took me a little while to really wrap my head around the story world. It felt a little convoluted at the beginning trying to grasp the names, rules, and places. I know there’s a fine balance to strike so you aren’t simply info-dumping at the beginning, but I needed just a little more background as a knowledge basis for what was happening. The captivating story world is one of my favorite parts about this book. Overall, it is an expertly crafted atmosphere that I would love to visit again and again.

Was this review helpful?

Provided by Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

The concept of this book seemed really interesting to me. I love the idea of Gods turning their backs on their creations and seeing how people will react. I also liked the magic themes in this book, such as shadow magic, conjuration, and necromancy. I feel that there are not enough books out there that focus on darker magics like this, so I was really excited to have the chance to read this book early.

However, I did not enjoy this book very much for several reasons. The first issue I had was that each of the main characters, 3 girls and one boy, were introduced very quickly in the story without a lot of character building. I got the girls easily confused as their personalities, voice, and the writing style for each of their POVs were too similar. It was hard for me to remember who was who and what each magic system, God, and faction they belonged to.

I think the initial world set-up needed to be more defined as well. I am of the opinion that each epic fantasy like this needs an info dump at the beginning of the story to help explain the set up to the reader. I know a lot of people do not like this, but I seem to struggle understanding the setting, hierarchy of power, government, Gods and significant events that are referenced in dialogue without an info dump.

The last thing that I really did not like about this book was that there were a lot of references to modern political and social issues that we experience in real life. This is just my opinion, but I really hate when fantasy books do this. I like to read to escape, so seeing references to real-life issues or events really turns me off from the story and pulls me out of the fantasy experience. I know a lot of people do enjoy this in stories though, so if you do, this book might be for you.

I think Tara Sim does have a great writing style. If you are usually a YA fantasy reader and you are looking to get into adult fantasy, this would be a great place to start. The writing is accessible and easy to follow and understand. I think the reasons I did not like this book were just personal preference, so if this concept sounds interesting to you, I would still encourage you to pick up this book when it releases on March 22nd, 2022.

Was this review helpful?

i loved sim’s TIMEKEEPER trilogy and was very excited to hear about her adult fantasy debut THE CITY OF DUSK. sim’s new series features a diverse cast of characters and a world of plotting gods, demons and dark magic, murder, political conspiracy, fast paced action, understated slow burn romance(s), and 20-something heirs of competitive families vying for the throne trying to save their dying world.

unfortunately i wouldn’t call this an adult novel. this is a ya author's adult debut and you can tell. this was a pretty standard gothicy epic fantasy that had the characters been in their teens instead of early 20s, would have been marketed as a ya/na. it doesn’t do a whole lot of new or interesting things with the chosen tropes and character archetypes, but this was still a fun read. the world building and range in the cast are the strengths, even if the execution was a bit clunky.

i’m not usually a fan of multi-pov novels, but i actually enjoyed the different povs, even of the character i didn’t care much for. my favorite character was julian, followed by nik and tae. angelica was my least but i didn’t dislike her, she was just the most stock character and less interesting with her predictability than the others.

on the whole, i enjoy this. it might not be super unique but it's a well-executed fantasy novel that is fun and engaging and i’m definitely interested in the next book.

cw:
from sim’s website: blood, death, violence, detailed descriptions of dead bodies, grief, self harm, parental abuse, murder, suicidal ideation, cannibalism, addiction, drinking
+ graphic scene of police brutality

Was this review helpful?