Member Reviews

It's a testament to Jane Austin's story telling skills that so many writers and readers find more and more to love in the characters she brought to life so many years ago. ACCOMPLISHED tells the story of the Darcy family's black sheep daughter and her machinations into restore her reputation. It's targeted audience is younger readers who don't know the world of Austen, but those of us who have been reading the classics for awhile will love it too.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing this read. All opinions are my own.

I love a Jane Austen adaptation, and especially one that isn't so on the nose as to turn off a new reader. Think: Clueless for Emma. This charming little YA novel is a great palate cleanser in between more serious literature. I enjoyed experiencing Georgie's point of view. She's a side character in P&P, so this main character treatment gave a beloved story a fresh approach.

Was this review helpful?

I think this is a great addition to any classroom and have already shared the title with some teachers at my school. It would be perfect along side Jane Austen novels being taught at school and I think students will relate to the very realistic characters.

Was this review helpful?

I love a good retelling especially when its from a popular movie/book and everyone knows about P&P. I requested this one since its based in current times and in a school setting. I was expecting a cute girly book with romance, maybe I just judged the cover to much because that's not what it gave. I know it was hard for Georgiana to come back to school after what happened but still, it gave whinny.
I love reading a good YA book especially after reading a long fantasy book etc but this one wasn't doing it for me.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a huge fan of Pride and Prejudice, so a YA retelling set in college (my favorite setting for YA) makes the perfect recipe for success here. I think that bringing it to the modern day in a university setting leaves so much room to have fun with reimagining the personalities of the characters and making the recognizable but unique.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very interesting retelling of Pride and Prejudice, with the main character being Georgiana Darcy who as you may know is the beloved sister of Mr. Darcy. This is a modern retelling and I liked it, although it has to be mentioned that it is a YA novel and very angsty. I felt a little out of the age range but it was still a good read for me.

Was this review helpful?

This was enjoyable enough, but having the timeline be close to the timeline of Pride and Prejudice was a choice bc I just wanted Lizzie and Darcy's story to be the one I was reading. Even though it is her book Georgie Darcy really feels like a secondary character and her story was not that engaging. The crumbs we got about Darcy and Lizzie were the best and I liked seeing Darcy as an older brother.

Was this review helpful?

To be honest I didn’t really enjoy this one. The characters kind of drove me crazy and Georgianna was probably the most annoying to me and she was the main character. I love P&P so I was looking forward to this little modern day retelling and it really didn’t live up to my expectations. I thought that every flaw of each P&P character was magnified and all of their good qualities totally missed. I finished because I didn’t want to DNF but I just didn’t like it

Was this review helpful?

I love a good Austen retelling, and when it’s my very favorite Austen, even better.

This one is a modernized Pride and Prejudice, though Elizabeth and Darcy are not primary characters. Their love story is a sideline to Georgiana Darcy’s story. If you know P&P, you know that Georgiana had a past with Wickham, and that holds true here as well—he was dealing drugs out of her dorm room at the elite Pemberly private school. Wickham was expelled, and Georgie is now a social pariah, since he was super popular.

This is the story of what comes for Georgie in the following school year. Her brother is her legal guardian, since their father’s death and their mother’s abdication of parental responsibility. And even though Darcy is a stiff overachiever, Georgie loves him and wants him to be proud of her, so she decides to turn herself into the perfect student.

Fortunately, there’s one person left at school who doesn’t treat her any differently, fellow marching band trombone player Avery.

I really enjoyed Georgie’s evolution here. Her intentions are good, but her execution is often lacking. She has a complete blind spot as to just how much wealth and privilege she has, and it causes her to really miss on the execution of her ideas, more than once. It’s good to see her eventually make some friends and learn to appreciate what she, herself, can bring to the table, without her money and privilege.

This does follow the basic plot outline of the original, with those events happening mostly on the periphery. You know things will end for Darcy and Elizabeth, Jane and Bingley (delightfully portrayed as a super buff golden retriever of a frat boy). But it’s seeing how things end for Georgie that is the focus, and it’s a satisfying conclusion.

Possible Objectionable Material:
Swearing, including the F-word. Underage drinking and reference to drugs. Kissing. References to sex. Cheating on assignments. Ostracism. Parental death and abandonment. Dysfunctional families. Same-gender couples.

Who Might Like This Book:
Those who, like me, enjoy a good Austen retelling. Anyone who likes to see characters grow and develop and find their voice.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing an eARC in exchange for my unbiased review.

This book is also reviewed at https://biblioquacious.blogspot.com/2024/07/modern-jane-austen.html

Was this review helpful?

This book was so fun to read! I am always in the mood for a Pride & Prejudice retelling and this one was no different.

Georgie and Avery were *chefs kiss*. Georgie, I will say, is always in her head, which can become frustrating because it's hard to escape her inner thoughts. Wickham, as usual, is always my most hated in every rendition as he should be. He just always sucks as a person.

There were also some unrealistic moments. For example, being able to transfer to AP classes when the person doesn't have good grades. How does that happen? On the other hand, there were many things that I appreciated. I really liked that we were able to still see Darcy and Elizabeth's characters still fall in love despite them not being the main relationship of the story.

Was this review helpful?

Accomplished by Amanda Quain is a fun retelling of Austen's Pride and Prejudice from the vantage point of Georgiana "Georgie" Darcy. Georgie finds herself nativaging her private boarding school, Pemberley Academy, under the watchful eye of her older brother, Fitzwilliam. This novel is a great YA take on the classic novel and all of Austen's characters.

Thank you to NetGalley and Wednesday Books/ St Martin's Publishing Group for the chance to read this novel.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to love this book. I like Georgiana and I think she's an underutilized character in the Pride and Prejudice canon. But there is very very little to enjoy in this book. Georgiana, as she was in the original, is a traumatized and abused person. Being inside her head is depressing. She just feels so lost. And I get that that's important to know. But she continues to make very bad choices and Wickham is confusing for her and it just, I don't know, maybe it rings too true? If that's what this book is trying to accomplish then I guess it did exactly what it meant to do. But I find it very sad and unsettling: her life, her complete and utter lack of self-esteem, her choices, the way she feels like she doesn't belong anywhere. It was a hard book to read.

I did enjoy the conversation that Darcy and Georgiana had together about rich people and if they actually deserve their inherited wealth. It's good to see someone talking about inherited wealth, race, and privilege.

Was this review helpful?

I’m a huge fan of the recent remixed classics, enjoying the modernizing, updating, or showing the story from a different point of view. Accomplished hit all my happy marks; it’s a modern update focusing on Georgianna as an elite private school student forever in her brother’s shadow and in the cold. Seeing the characters from the side and not the focus made me rethink how I saw Georgianna. A definite read for all Pride and Prejudice fans.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book! It's well-written, enjoyable, and a great read. Amanda Quain did a great job of writing in a way that captures the readers attention, and makes you not want to put it down until you're finished! I would highly recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

I have not read and will not read this book for personal reasons. Thank you for the opportunity regardless. It is truly appreciated.

Was this review helpful?

I was introduced to Amanda Quain’s work via her employment at my favorite local bookstore and couldn’t pass up the chance to support a local author. This is a retelling of Pride And Prejudice and I normally stay away from those as the Lizzie/Darcy storyline is often overdone but I felt the focus on Georgiana brought a fresh take. I really enjoyed this read. It felt familiar enough to feel like a retelling but managed to equally be something new and stand on its own as a tale set in modern day high school. However; I’m looking forward even more to her next book because Northanger Abbey is my favorite of Austen’s works.

Was this review helpful?

I've never been able to get into any of Jane Austen's books, but this retelling in a modern setting was so good! The beginning was a little slow, but I really got into the story and devoured this book. Georgie was so much fun to read about and I absolutely despise Wickham. I would absolutely love another book written in this world.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately the story was not for me. There was nothing particularly wrong with it just not my cup of tea

Was this review helpful?

I stumbled upon Amanda Quain's book, Accomplished, and was totally intrigued by a Pride and Prejudice spin-off that focused on Georgiana. Quain's modern retelling of Austen's classic is not only entertaining but also brilliantly thought out. She put in a ton of effort to recreate Austen's world in a contemporary setting, and the characters are both delightful and genuine, yet still reminiscent of their P&P counterparts.
Georgie Darcy is headed back to her fancy private school after a messy scandal involving her ex-boyfriend Wickham, who was caught dealing drugs from her dorm room. Now, everyone blames Georgie for getting the charming and popular older boy expelled. As if that weren't enough, her brother Fitz transfers from his dream university in California to a local college close by so he can keep an eye on her. Determined to prove herself, Georgie tries to fix things and move on from the previous year's drama, but she keeps tripping over Wickham and making questionable decisions.
The modernized characters are fantastic. High school and college serve as a perfect substitute for the rigid social structures of Austen's time, and Fitz is an excellent choice for the wealthy boy who resents leaving his elite school for a more working-class college. The book also touches on wealth and privilege issues and introduces an adorable new love interest for Georgie. Fitz and his new study partner Lizzie are in the background, adding a nice touch. If you're looking for a unique take on Austen's work, especially if you're tired of reading about Darcy and Elizabeth, this modernized Austen world is a must-read!

Was this review helpful?

I really liked the concept of a modern spin on Pride & Prejudice - the Lizzie Bennet Diaries did this remarkably well in the early 2010s - but this one missed the mark for me. The beginning was slow and, when all was said and done, the modernization made it feel a bit flat. It ended up reading like any other YA romance. Georgie's self-loathing also made parts of this a bit frustrating to get through. I think there's an audience for this, but unfortunately I don't think it's me.

Was this review helpful?