Member Reviews
This was a fun, modern spin-off of P&P. I loved the characters and storyline. I enjoy most retellings/spin-offs of classics, and this was another I could add to the list!
4 1/2 stars
Throughout her childhood, Georgie had had a crush on the boy next-door, Wickham Foster. When he began attending the same school as her after her brother, Fitz, went to the West Coast for college, Georgie gravitated toward him because the Darcy’s weren’t known for their socializing. Wickham, however, was not who Darcy thought he was and her world imploded. Now, George is back for the following semester after the incident, facing the backlash from fellow students who call her a narc and from her bandmates who resent her for their loss of their best trumpet player. And thus begins Accomplished by Amanda Quain.
Accomplished is a fun little novel with a poor little rich girl who is socially navigating a high school world without her big brother, Fitz. Although, as written, Fitz probably wasn’t that good at high school socializing either. Georgie’s first thought, which she realizes is a completely Darcy thought, is to throw money at the situation and hope that it begins to become better. She soon learns that people seldom appreciate that.
Despite initial skepticism, Georgie finds that one of her friends from the previous year, another trombonist, Avery, is still friendly toward her. Throughout the novel, their friendship grows until it becomes more. With Avery’s help, she begins to understand herself and find herself. But it’s only when another implosion seems imminent that Georgie begins to really find out who she is, what she wants, and what is truly important.
I enjoyed Accomplished. I thought Amanda Quain did a great job of portraying Georgie as the poor little rich girl when circumstances might have made her unlikeable. But Georgie’s naivete and social obliviousness work in her favor and show her vulnerability.
The romance between Georgie and Avery was very sweet. Avery is not slick, not a bad boy, nor out just for himself. He’s kind, cute, and caring. And, frankly, it’s always nice to see a nice guy romance in a world of bully romances.
A fun, escapist novel with just the right amount of angst that left me wishing someone I knew would offer up Mexican catering at the drop of a hat . . . or baton.
I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Going in, I didn't realize this book was a modern-day retelling, but I liked it so much! Georgiana Darcy was a great character to follow, and the P&P references were so fun to pick out. I actually really liked that this wasn't a straight up P&P retelling. It made it feel fresh and fun.
I was a little surprised to find that I was actually enjoying this story a fair amount. The portrayal of the relationship between brother and sister Fitz and Georgie is sincere and touching. It was interesting to see the minimally explored, magnificently privileged character of Georgiana Darcy portrayed as a sort of loner, relatively unhappy and struggling to connect with peers. From Austen's original work I always imagined her to just glow with joy and divine favor. The mirroring of elements from the original story, such as "Fitz" being responsible for Wickham crossing his sister's path was quite good. One of my few complaints, and it's a minimal one, is that Georgie's misdeed being "illicit reselling of prescription medication to classmates" to be a little... artificial? Easy? I would've liked to see it be something a little more unexpected, as that offense fell a little flat, in my mind.
I thought I would love this book, I wanted to love this book….but I didn’t. The first third, possibly half of the book was slow and Georgie was a whiny self entitled brat who only obsessed about herself. Fritz was also super uptight. But, I did like the updates of everyone else. The back half of the book picks up and was more enjoyable. Also felt like Georgie & Avery got their happy ending way to speedily.
**Thanks to Netgalley for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review. **
Full transparency, I have never read Pride & Prejudice. But after reading this book, I want to.
This novel is a modern day reimagining of Pride and Prejudice from the viewpoint of Mr. Darcy's sister Georgiana. In this iteration, Georgiana is a high school student who has had some, ahem, troubles. She fell for a boy who ended up getting her in a lot of trouble and caused a lot of mistrust between her and her brother (and only remaining family) Fitz. Georgiana is frustrating at times but also I found myself rooting for her nonetheless. Georgiana is a teenager who desperately wants to make her brother proud and live up to the Darcy name.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It was a slow start for me, but soon enough I was rushing through it to see what happened. I can't wait to see if this is a series!
4 stars
You can read all of my reviews at Nerd Girl Loves Books.
This is a cute YA contemporary retelling of Pride & Prejudice. Georgiana Darcy is a Junior at an elite prep school in upstate New York. She suffered an "Incident" with Wickham Foster at the end of her sophomore year that would have cost anyone else besides a Darcy expulsion. But, with her brother living back in New York near her and suffocating her with rules and oversight, Georgie needs to figure out a way to forget Wickham, win back her prep school and make her brother relax and realize she can take care of herself.
Enter fellow band geek Avery. He's recently been elevated to the marching band's drum major and is still in good with the band. He agrees to help Georgie with her reputation problem, even agreeing to help her in her efforts to push her brother Fitz and Lizzie Bennett together so he will finally find some happiness. It doesn't matter that Avery's muscles seemed to have finally filled out over the summer and he seems to accept her for who she is, right? I mean, it's the same ole' Avery. Right?
This is a cute book and although Georgie was a bit neurotic I liked her. Her screw ups were pretty tame, were way overblown and could have been explained in less than a minute, but I understand the author needed to cause conflict to move the story forward. I liked Avery and his chemistry with Georgie was really cute. Having been a band geek myself, I loved the band geek references. Lizzie Bennett and goofball Charles Bingley add humor and lightness to the story. This is a light, fluffy friends to lovers retelling that you can read in one sitting. I recommend you pick up this gem right away.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley and St. Martin's Press, Wednesday Books. All opinions are my own.
i will eat up anything related to Pride and Prejuidice. I loved this one! I loved Georgina and i was excited to read this! I loved a modern twist on a story and i think this will be a great read for anyone who loves a good retelling
This is a different take on the classic Pride and Prejudice where the main character is Georgie, Mr. Darcy’s little sister. It takes place in the present at a prestigious boarding school where Darcy attends and is over shadowed by her brother’s accomplishments. During her sophomore year she gets caught in a scandal and was saved from expulsion by her last name. Now it’s junior year and Darcy just wants to make everything right.
This was a quick read. I loved that Georgie was the focus in this retelling (both Mr. Darcy and Lizzie Bennett did make appearances), and I’m a sucker for books that take place at boarding schools. It was fun seeing Georgie grow as a character and overcome the aftermath of the scandal from the previous school year. I really enjoyed it.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.
Thank you NetGalley and Wednesday Books for the ARC!
So, this book went from a 3 star read, to 3.5, then by the end I was definitely invested, so I bumped it up to a 4.
A modern-day take featuring the characters from Pride & Prejudice, with Georgiana Darcy as the lead. This one started a bit slow for me, and was overwhelmingly frustrating for a bit (as Wickham can be), but as Georgie found her way, I quite liked the story.
The side characters were super fun, especially Charles and Lizzie. I adore their college-selves. They were both quite amusing. Avery was a fun addition into the story as a drum major crush for Georgie, and he was very sweet.
Read this one if you miss the classic characters, but want some marching band, private school, teenage-drama thrown in as well.
Title: Accomplished
Author: Amanda Quain
Genre: YA
Rating: 4.5 out of 5
It is a truth universally acknowledged that Georgiana Darcy should have been expelled after The Incident with Wickham Foster last year – at least if you ask any of her Pemberley Academy classmates. She may have escaped expulsion because of her family name, but she didn’t escape the disappointment of her big brother Fitz, the scorn of the entire school, or, it turns out, Wickham’s influence.
But she’s back for her junior year, and she needs to prove to everyone—Fitz, Wickham, her former friends, and maybe even herself—that she’s more than just an embarrassment to the family name. How hard can it be to become the Perfect Darcy? All she has to do is:
– Rebuild her reputation with the marching band (even if it kills her)
– Forget about Wickham and his lies (no matter how tempting they still are), and
– Distract Fitz Darcy—helicopter-sibling extraordinaire—by getting him to fall in love with his classmate, Lizzie Bennet (this one might be difficult…)
Sure, it’s a complicated plan, but so is being a Darcy. With the help of her fellow bandmate, Avery, matchmaking ideas lifted straight from her favorite fanfics, and a whole lot of pancakes, Georgie is going to see every one of her plans through. But when the weight of being the Perfect Darcy comes crashing down, Georgie will have to find her own way before she loses everything permanently—including the one guy who sees her for who she really is.
I completely enjoyed this story! Sure, Georgie’s lingering obsession with Wickham was more than a little annoying, but I loved seeing how she grew and changed as she learned to stand on her own two feet. In the end this was a fun read—and I think Austen would have enjoyed it, too.
Amanda Quain lives in Pennsylvania. Accomplished is her debut novel.
(Galley courtesy of St. Martin’s Press in exchange for an honest review.)
Accomplished is a fun modern-day spin-off of Pride and Prejudice. Georgianna Darcy is the main character, and our other beloved P&P characters make appearances as their modern, college-aged selves. The story focuses on redemption, self-worth, and sibling relationships.
Set at a prestigious boarding school in New York, Georgie is trying to redeem herself after an unfortunate incident the previous year almost got her expelled. She wants to prove to her peers, her school, and especially her brother that she can be the perfect Darcy. As she starts to get in over her head with her plan, friendships begin to reemerge and she learns how to ask for help and to count on other people.
I enjoyed the story, and thought the characters were all very well-written. The only complaint I have is that Georgie's self-deprecation gets to be a little much after a while. Most of what happened wasn't even really her fault, and little things tend to really set her off down a wormhole. But other than that I loved the story, her redemption arc, and seeing the other characters we love from Pride and Prejudice on the fringes of Georgie's story. I thought it was a fresh, fun modern take that was not a retelling of P&P, but still had the same character names and relationship dynamics. This book may appeal more to high school/college age readers, but as an adult I really enjoyed it as well. If you are a Jane Austen fan and you like (or don't mind) reading books with high-schoolers as the main characters, I would definitely recommend this book!
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the e-arc in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are entirely my own and given freely.
This YA novel is essentially Pride & Prejudice fan fiction, wherein the story of Mr. Darcy's younger sister Georgiana is both expanded upon and modernized. A huge fan of retellings, I read this in two sittings on connecting flights. While I enjoyed it, I wasn't totally on board with the way the author changed Jane Austen's characters' (Darcy and Georgiana's) natures in the interest of moving the plot into modern America. That said, I'll recommend it to my Austenite friends and to fans of contemporary YA romances.
I rarely DNF a book but I’m really struggling with this one. I’m a huge Pride and Prejudice fan and love retelling but I am not connecting to these characters at all. I find them really shallow and vapid. Normally I would push through to provide a complete review but it has taken me days to get to 25%. I am not going to complete the read but I also won’t post this review on any public platform. I hope the publisher understands and knows that I do not take the decision to not complete a review lightly. I appreciate the opportunity.
⭐️ rating: 4 STARS ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
📖 genre: YA, austen retelling
read if you like: Pride & Prejudice, Emma Lord, Pride & Premeditation
Okay, so I might be a little biased here because Darcy & Lizzie are one of my OTPs, so I like Pride & Prejudice a little more than your average person - but this book was a true delight! I really loved being able to see growing up as a Darcy from a different perspective.
Other things I liked:
✨ Georgie & Avery's banter = 10/10
✨ I liked that I kind of had NO IDEA what was going to happen with Avery's character. Since he doesn't exist in the original tale, his storyline was full of mystery.
✨ Having been a band geek myself, I really liked seeing those cliques & dynamics play out on the page
✨ I liked how Quain both captured Georgie as a stuck-up teenager & as a lovable individual. You could really feel her age in her speech & overall demeanor.
✨ It was kind of awesome to see Darcy & Georgiana on the outs rather than the lovey-dovey siblings you see in the novel and the film. With him having taken over the father-figure role, you would have to guess that there would be a decent amount of friction there. And this novel showed that really well.
Things I didn't love:
✨ I know it's not about them, but I wanted more Darcy & Lizzie! I wish we could have seen more of their dynamics - even if it was just Georgie spying on them more. Because, come on now, she clearly was.
✨ Now, I did this as an audiobook & ebook combo, so maybe if I'd just read it it would have been more clear - but I wish there had been more indication of when Georgie was having a flashback and when she was in the present. Especially where Wickham is concerned.
Highly recommend!
I was really interested in the concept of this novel, and the modern retelling at a boarding school was a fun, interesting conceit. Ultimately, Georgie was one of those characters whose blind spots don't make much sense—she comes off as intelligent and self aware, except in some blindingly obvious areas, where she makes the same mistakes several times without seeming to learn much from them. I also thought reducing the age gap between Georgiana Darcy and her older brother, but still making him her guardian was a pretty weird move, because it didn't make much sense and it didn't do many favors for the background Darcy/Jane romance—Georgiana as a fifteen year old makes perfect sense as a YA heroine, but I thought the traditional Pride & Prejudice romance didn't work very well aged down. On the other hand, I did really, really like what they did with Lydia!
Pride and Prejudice gets a modern-day spin, all from Georgina Darcy’s point of view.
✨ Book Review: ACCOMPLISHED by Amanda Quain ✨
📖 Synopsis: Georgie Darcy has had a rough summer. After nearly being expelled from her posh high school, Pemberly Academy, for being involved in Whickham’s drug scheme, Georgie is out to prove herself to her brother Fitz, to her school, and to herself.
Read ACCOMPLISHED for . . .
🎼 Sweet high school marching band romance
🎼 A fun, modern take on PRIDE AND PREJUDICE
🎼 Coming-of-age revelations, growth, and friendships
🎼 Georgie Darcy’s long overdue story
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫(4.5/5)
😍 This novel was such fun! Highly recommend for YA and PRIDE AND PREJUDICE fans!
What I liked:
-A Pride & Prejudice inspired contemporary ya that focused on a secondary character (Georgiana Darcy) instead of Darcy & Elizabeth.
-Marching band practices and performances were so fun.
-The Georgie/Avery friendship & relationship build up.
-Wickham being an absolute sleezy idiot.
What I didn't like:
-Georgie's decision making was...dramatic and impractical and reckless.
-The fact that literally no one besides Avery believed that Georgie was innocent in regards to Wickham's shenanigans.
-Darcy being a jerk to Georgie and never allowing her to explain anything.
Overall, a pretty fun read! Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the digital review copy!
Content: language, teenage drinking & prescription drug abuse, emotional abuse/manipulation
this was an interesting new take on the p&p story! i liked following georgie and found it really interesting to explore the perspective of such a limited character from jane's work. definitely a fun contemporary read!
What's it about (in a nutshell):
Accomplished by Amanda Quain is a YA Contemporary story inspired by Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen. Georgiana Darcy is a junior at an upstate New York boarding school. Her father has died, and her mother has taken off for parts unknown. All Georgie has is her brother, a sophomore in college, at a time when she really needs adult guidance and love. He tries to give her everything she needs, but can he keep her out of the trouble she seems determined to get into?
Initial Expectations (before beginning the book):
I immediately saw that this book is called a Pride & Prejudice retelling, so I was instantly sold on it. The cover looks light and fun with a cartoonish mix of graphics that remind me of the 1800s and components that reflect today. I love that it's a story told from Georgie Darcy's perspective. I think this book will be a fun modern-day take on my all-time favorite book, Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen.
Actual Reading Experience:
My actual reading experience was just as I expected. It was a fun, sometimes poignant, story about a contemporary Georgie Darcy. I don't know that I would call it a retelling, though. Instead, I would say that it was inspired by the original characters, and I could thoroughly buy into it as such.
I love that Georgie Darcy is brought to the forefront and is the star in this book. She is a delightful support character in the original novel, so seeing her and exploring the new contemporary version of her story from her own perspective is excellent. I think the story really sticks to the main themes found in the original: the theme of the impact of nurture vs. nature in developing character and the theme that social standing and wealth are not necessarily an advantage in getting along with others. Those themes also run strong in Accomplished.
I also loved that I found the story to be incredibly relatable. I have worked with many teens like Georgie who have lost their way and are unsure where they fit in. That feeling of being socially awkward is something that burdens more teens than you'd ever expect. It's a natural state of being when you're a teenager. I just wanted to take her under my wing and help her find her way throughout the book. I absolutely adored her for all her flaws.
Ultimately, I loved this book simply because it made me smile. I laughed at many points in the book and was incredibly moved by others. Eventually, I closed the book with a massive grin, and there were not enough stars for that feeling.
Characters:
Georgie – the main character – shows so much complexity and layers. She is delightfully developed and easily drives this character-driven tale. Her pain, guilt, awkwardness, and desire to belong are all reflected in everything she does, good or bad.
The side characters are great. I felt that they worked as a possible contemporary version of their original selves and are developed enough that I could see that.
To Read or Not to Read:
If you enjoy stories inspired by Victorian classics with relatable characters, you will enjoy Accomplished. It's sure to put a smile on your face as well.