(I received a free ecopy of 'FilmQuake' from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review, so thank you NetGalley and thank you Quarto Publishing Group - White Lion!)

I've been thinking a lot about canonicity lately (the idea that certain books, movies, works of art etc. are superior, timeless and representative of culture) so I was interested to read 'FilmQuake: The Most Disruptive Films in Cinema'. To be clear, Ian Haydn Smith does stick to the brief, discussing "disruptive" rather than "great" films, though he often seems to interpret "disruptive" as "new", justifying many of the entries by citing whichever technique or style revolutionised the form and set trends. As a result, the usual suspects of "canon" films show up, like Citizen Kane, Birth of a Nation and 2001: A Space Odyssey. He explains his technical terms and breaks the book down into sections by decade so, from a film history point of view, this would definitely be a useful primer. I also liked that each subsection includes a little timeline of key historical events to put the movies into context.

I would have liked more detail on what he means by "disruptive" and more reflection on the ethics of some of his choices. For example, Smith includes Birth of a Nation due to its impact on the history of cinema and race relations. He's very clear about the film's heinous racism and real world impact, clearly demonstrating that movies and popular culture matter and influence real world behaviour, ideology and politics. In that way, I suppose, it was "disruptive", both in terms of its technical innovations and the boost it gave to the KKK. But should it really still be taught and included in books like this? Does its inclusion validate and elevate it (and by extension its ideology) as a piece of art? What about directors who are/were known to be abusers or sexual predators? What message does it send to film students (and future film makers) that we still admire and teach their work? Does it normalise abuse? These are important questions and it's a shame Smith doesn't explore them. Acknowledging and discussing the ethical issues surrounding his selection process would have strengthened the book overall, especially if it is aimed at students.

That said, I appreciate that Smith clearly was trying to be inclusive in the films he features and side panels handily highlight important ideological shifts and movements in cinema (i.e. feminist film, LGBT film, Black cinema etc.). I hadn't heard of some of the older feminist films and directors he mentions (I'm not a film expert), for example, so FilmQuake is definitely a great resource in that sense. And its clear, chronological presentation and Smith's succinct, readable entries make it an accessible read, whether or not you're a film buff. The glossary and further reading section at the end is also very handy for both film students and fans (like me!). It has definitely given me a list of movies to check out, in any event!

Overall I enjoyed reading this book. The author presents an overview of the history of film through experimental and ground breaking films. The author explains why each film he has chosen deserves inclusion. Some of films are well known, while others deserve to be. The book is a quick and informative read.

This was definitely an interesting read. It looks how the film making practice and peoples changing views on what they want to watch including great cinematic controversies. Starting from the very first films. Also looking at the change in sounds and technology used. I enjoyed the layout of the book. I thought the time line at the beginning of each chapter was very useful. Which looked at key events that occurred during that time period. I enjoyed learning about the different introductions of technology, and changes in film use and different director's.  However,  I didn't really know many of the films that were included and just wanted to learn more from each one. Just as it started getting interesting it moved on to the next film. I would class it as an introduction to films that cause quakes in the visual art of cinematography. I also really would of loved to learn about films that caused great controversies and feedback from some critics or from people who watch them. I finished the whole book and did learn quite a bit from it so that is always a good thing and im glad I experienced the book. I was just left wanting a bit more information.  That is just my opinion and I am one person. I always recommend that you try a sample of the book to make up your own mind or get it out from your library and give it a go as I'm sure other people will love this title more than I did.  Many thanks to the author and publishers for producing an Great insight into the changes in world cinematic.

The above review has already been placed on goodreads, waterstones, Google books, Barnes&noble, kobo, amazon UK where available and my blog https://ladyreading365.wixsite.com/website/post/film-quake-by-ian-haydn-smith-quarto-publishing-5-stars
Under either name ladyreading365 or lady Reading365

Extremely interesting look into the history of film. From the very beginning until today. I definitely enjoyed learning about all the old movie stars and how film has evolved into what it is today.

Interesting book that I'm sure reads better in its physical form. Like any of these books, it's not really meant to be read front to back and I was more interested in the post- '70s chapters than the early ones. I'd recommend it for fans of film.

A book that provides for a wonderful look at cinema history, or at least of its more notable, press-worthy and water-cooler moments. It is constructed around fifty more noteworthy films, but I was helped in defining it as a history not just in the chronological order, and the context-giving timelines available, but because you only get the one film and then you're reading an aside about female directors – a part of the general overlook, and not the singular moments. Three films more, and its German Expressionism that is the subject of a further, gap-filling aside. So nothing rests in isolation, but becomes a part of a bigger picture – the growth of sound, the emergence of propaganda classics, and so on.

This then is a great way of discussing cinema, and the author is great at doing it, both for the whole artform in a flowing history and film by film. Fifty films as a canon really does allow for much argument – no Lean, Lynch or Leone – but those small windows onto the big screen provided really do show the progression of it all, with of course the obvious, post-Covid question as to its survivability as a medium to close. If big screen projection really is in closing-down mode, it's been a hell of a ride. And with this having the scope to include films I'd never heard of, this is a worthy tribute. Four and a half stars.

My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher Quarto Publishing Group- White Lion for an advanced copy of this book on film history.

The effect of art is sometimes hard to register. A portrait, a poem, a song, a book, and a movie can appear and fade from the mainstream quickly, but to those who pay attention, or are lucky to find it, the ground might shift and the world might not be as dull as it was earlier. Sometimes the public might notice, censorship might be threatened, public trials and public burnings scheduled, and again those paying attention can be seismically shifted forever.

FilmQuake: The Most Disruptive Films in Cinema by Ian Haydn Smith is a series of fifty essays on fifty films that made the Earth shake, at least according to the author. Books like these are very much in the pen of the beholder, but are fun because of discussions they raise, and the points that they validate in their arguments. Movies on war, love, sexuality, history, racism, are discussed from around the world from the origins of film to today. The directors are familiar Sergei Eisenstein and Luis Buñuel, and new , Jordan Peele and Bong Joon-ho. All share a singular vision in telling their story, which are described in essays telling of film, making of and reception and controversies.

The writing is very good, and the illustrations feature behind the scenes, influences, posters and other ephemera. A perfect gift for a burgeoning cinephile, or for someone who just loves to read about film like myself. This book reminds the reader why films do matter, and why as a movie lover we love sitting in the dark and watching the pretty pictures.

I wish this book had been around when i was doing my film degree!
This book is fascinating!!! I really enjoyed this, and learnt a lot too!

I love how accessible this book was, despite it being a very academic book.

I think this would make the perfect gift for any film buff, film lover, or film student!

I appreciated the wide range of films featured in this book, curated over time and described with clarity. A wonderful resource for cinephiles.

As someone who is well versed in the history of cinema, a book like FilmQuake is definitely more helpful to someone unfamiliar with film history. Ian Haydn Smith's writing is simple and straightforward, chronicling the major changes in cinema through 50 landmark films, including not only beloved classics like Citizen Kane or Do The Right Thing, but also feminist and queer films like Wanda, Atlantique, and Paris Is Burning. Having seen all of the films already, the book did not give me anything new, but it was still a pleasant watch, and it can be very rewarding to anyone who is yet to discover these gems and their context in the history of cinema and the world.

3.5/5

Haydn Smith takes us on a cinema trip through film history with fifty films that shook the world… An enthralling examination of those worldwide films and cinematic styles and that dared to be controversial from the late nineteenth century to now.

Since the inception of film and cinema, to paraphrase a song, individual filmmakers film content didn’t mean to change the world. Films didn’t set out to create new ways of thinking for a time or place. But both films and their creators often did just that. Filmmaker’s productions on then topical and societal topics challenged different countries’ beliefs and often made those then generations think in a new and different way. These then in time impacted other countries and cultures more uniquely.

Historical controversial topics such as homosexuality, capital punishment, war, mental health and transvestites were explored in films of all genres. This through their then eye-opening plots, then contemporary film styles and movements – such as New Hollywood and auteurs – and the use of sound and colour. These were seen in British films such as Victim (1961) and The Paradine Case (1947) and the American movies Apocalypse Now (1979), One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (1975) and Some Like it Hot (1959) respectively.

In Ian Haydn Smith’s book FilmQuake The Most Disruptive Films in Cinema we are treated to an extensive history of film at its most “disruptive”. The author reflects on those films that challenged audiences, as he transports us back in time and then in short – but information packed – chapters analyses his wide selection of films. This is through his choices of fifty films and in his in-depth analytical discussions, he adds many more. He additionally illuminates and enlightens about then film directors, movements and styles from the turn of the 19th Century to the present day.

The 208 paged book has a simple but effective cover of a greeny-blue seismograph on a black background. A seismograph records the activities of an earthquake recording and from its source reduces in size and effects as its impact is felt worldwide. This picture is then an apt visual representation of film history as a “resting” continuum where the seismic waves symbolically indicate films or film movements which shook up our then thinking seen as graph waves and which increase or reduce in their impact worldwide.

The book starts with a short introduction that informs us that throughout film history, controversial cinema has been viewed differently for worldwide cinema audiences. Since 1895 and the introduction of film and then cinema, the medium of film has highlighted and then directly or indirectly helped to change or modify those attitudes. Their film content has then left their historical mark on society by challenging then ideas and times for the better and it’s important that these films and their content must be seen in the context of that time and place.

The development of film is explored from the beginning of filmmaking and the inception of cinema. This was when audiences were shocked by “action” in film and

“movie images that captured our world, which could be replayed over and over again and eventually be manipulated in ever more imaginative ways. “

Provocative scenes and films faced censorship in the late 19th Century and this is aptly illustrated with an example as the 18-second film, The Kiss (1896). Haydn Smith outlines how this then sexual content was condemned and questioned by the Roman Catholic Church. Then as film methods evolved over time, more risks were taken in both content and style.

Haydn Smith outlines more recent evidence in the censorship of films, advocating that this also occurred in the last century. This was with the now outdated American Hays code from the 1920s to the late 1960s. Then in 1980s Britain, “video nasties” came to the fore when more provocative films were banned for high violent or sexual content. Nowadays, he argues film streaming companies have made films with challenging content material more widely available.

The changing nature of controversial films over this timeline is important to remember as you read this book. Many films described from the early days which shocked back then because of their material to then audiences, would not be as shocking now in our more permissive society. Yet, in this book, Haydn Smith illustrates how a number of films released more recently highlight today’s topical issues such as black matters and terrorism.

An example could be the gratuitous use of sex and violence in the ending of Warren Beatty’s Bonnie and Clyde (1967) as part of the New Hollywood film generation, which shocked cinema-goers of the time. This film compared with the now, with blood-splattered scenes which are accepted as “normal” in Tarantino movies eg 2019’s Once Upon A Time in Hollywood. Another example is Easy Rider (1969) which highlighted the rift in generations of Old and New Hollywood in a motorcycle western which contrasted old and new ways of living.

In his book, Haydn Smith set out to

“offer a balanced overview of the most impactful aspects of cinema and its most disruptive tendencies”.

The book content is divided into year groups and content is explored in a linear way. Each year group covers a specific time period in history such as 1895-1930,1960-79 and 2000 – Present. These have enigmatic titles such as The Shock of the New, Breaking All the Rules and The Future is Unwritten.

After a short introduction to the chapter content, Haydn Smith adds a timeline listing important historical and film-related events again in chronological order. These happenings beautifully set the context and then generational, historical and film worldwide experiences from the time. These often inform the content of those films and film movements explored. Events include the first use of colour and sound in films and the relocation of the American film industry from New York to Hollywood.

Chapters within these time periods include individual chapters on controversial films from that time, these titled with compelling descriptive titles the film year and director. Films include Reservoir Dogs (1992), Jaws (1975), Psycho (1960) and Citizen Kane (1947). These films are is analysed more deeply as Haydn Smith outlines the plot and the then influences which originated the film. He discusses the director styles, film processes used and the controversial themes within the movie and during the making of the film. He also writes on the effects of these on the audiences.

A wide variety of films, film movements and genres are reviewed and listed with this book. There is also a selection from worldwide directors and films, and Haydn Smith honours all of these with their original language title and the English translation. He also adds original stills and film posters. And these include Soviet Cinema and German Expressionism.

Individual film movements which evolved during these times are also illuminated in chapters, such as avant-garde cinema, auteurs animation and art films. These terms are explained with examples of films in these categories. Haydn Smith supports all his writing with pertinent and supportive quotes from filmmakers, critics and acting talent. After he concludes the content. he provides a bibliographical list of these sources.

A wide range of stunning often unique photographs and film posters – in both colour and black – and white adorn full pages. Smaller ones are mingled effectively with the text with descriptions that enhance and reinforce the text. Haydn Smith also adds relevant quotes from critics and filmmakers to support his content. It is clear that Haydn Smith has a passion and deep knowledge of this subject and this is seen and felt in his choices of film, with pertinent discussions and pictures throughout this book.

After reading this valuable reference book telling of the evolution of film. I believe this author more than adequately met his own challenge as the selected fifty films and just as – if not more – many film movements to illustrate the inconstant nature of controversial film.

Although Haydn Smith calls this book a “glimpse”, this word is only reflected in this book’s number of pages. This book is like a TARDIS in that Hayden Smith has found room to extensively cover much film history with the most beguiling commentary. And it is a book, I now treasure as a film blogger. The page number only proves that less has more.

This book is one to inform rather than surprise you, although you’ll find some unique entries have moulded our present-day mores and beliefs as different countries uniquely and collectively worldwide. Or their provocative impact can be compared with the earthquake recordings seen on the cover. The U.S. Geological Survey site aptly describes an earthquake’s impact.

Throw a rock into a pond or lake and watch the waves rippling out in all directions from the point of impact. Just as this impact sets waves in motion on a quiet pond, so an earthquake generates seismic waves that radiate out through the Earth.

This quote illustrating the effects of an earthquake could easily be compared to a controversial film’s effect throughout the World. To conclude, often just reading their entry into the worldwide history of film and their then impact on us as individuals in you will never think the same way about these movies again. And through Haydn Smith’s analysis on your favourite film be it Fitzcarraldo (1982) or Jaws, you can now empathise and understand just how these films rocked the boat.

Having studied for a degree in film, I am obsessed with anything to do with movies - of old and new. Any bit of trivia or opinion I can learn improves the viewing experience for me. I’m used to reading about the positives and the glory of film, so I found it an interesting avenue to write a book about disruptive films, and what makes them disruptive, and whether I agree or not.

What I found interesting was not just the idea of a particular film being disruptive, but the exploration that film in and of itself was a disruptive medium.

The layout of this book is easy to read and well defined, with an excellent choice of photographs. Each chapter is well thought out and allows the reader to dip in and out as desired.

It also explores the relatively short time between the advent of film to popular blockbusters to TV series and streaming services. The industry has come a long way in a little over 100 years since the Lumiere brothers showed their first moving picture, and these new advents present these films to an ever increasing audience.

I admit I haven’t seen a lot of the films chosen in this book, but Ian’s written about them so passionately that I might just look them up. I’m glad he chose one of my favourite films - Brokeback Mountain - which is a worthy addition. For all its “disruptiveness”, it is a truly magical movie. But the one thing I will disagree on - quite controversially - is that I don’t believe Citizen Kane is the greatest film ever made, in fact, I thought it was really rather terrible.