Member Reviews
I snapped up this e-book by Kamysh as soon as I read the title because I am always interested in dark tourism or abandoned places. However, this book was more focused on Kamysh than on the zone and what there is to discover within. Kamysh mainly focuses on his reasons for repeatedly visiting the zone and the sense of peace it gives him to be able to disconnect from society. It was still a fun, short read but I didn't feel like I learned much about others who frequent the zone and the variety of reasons people may have for frequenting the areas, which is what I somewhat expected from the title.
Please see my review at Shelf Awareness here: https://www.shelf-awareness.com/readers-issue.html?issue=1112#m19418
I honestly finished this text just after the invasion started up in Ukraine, I have been worried about this writer ever since....with that said, there is a beautiful poetic nature to Staking the Atomic City that made me want to be a part of his travels. The writing is quite stunning. There are moments in the text that get a little repetitive, but his love for the town and the plant is infectious. He calls it a place to relax...and he tells us of others that at one time were going there regularly to scavenge or to hang their hat. He also speaks about the tourists that go there, which was also a regular occurrence....and if I am not mistaken, there were rumors that a group was taken hostage when Russia took over the plant during the last couple of months...but I don't know that to be true. In a lot of ways, one of the reasons why I chose this text is because it is about dark tourism, which is something I am very much interested in; I read a lot of texts about death and dying.
I am sure now, however, that touring is not taking place very much in Chernobyl anymore...which, based on what I read, is terrible for those who called the ruins home or some form of it.
We are all praying and/or thinking about you, Markiyan...and every one else that has been affected by Russia's genocide.
4.5 stars
Kyivan author Markiyan Kamysh thrives on danger and discomfort, especially when on overnight and multi-night stays at the Chornobyl toxic wasteland. His goal as a stalker is to sneak people in (including tourists) through the barbed wire and past guards, through deep snow and swamps. He gives advice on what to do and what not to do, how to pack (bare minimum) and how to endure stays, mentally and physically. He discusses wildlife including wolves, bears and lynx and atmospheric weather. His passion is abandoned buildings (I share that love with him) but he has no qualms about starting fires for warmth inside or using fences for wood. For him visits are an addiction which is evinced by his countless visits which he prefers alone to experience the fullness of terror and danger.
The author's compulsive writing style is very raw and unfettered, littered with cursing and bragging. After reading the blurb I had hoped and expected to learn more about the 1986 disaster and Russian and Ukrainian history but was disappointed with descriptions of multiple illegal visits. The book contains a lot of angst and grit and talk of getting drunk. I do like the author included a few evocative photographs but the writing often set my teeth on edge.
My sincere thank you to Astra Publishing House and NetGalley.
STALKING THE ATOMIC CITY-Markiyan Kamysh
I received this to my Kindle free for the purpose of review. Admittedly I struggled to read this book because it was painfully honest and frightening to me.
The idea that someone would consider the adventure of being in Chornobyl after it was destroyed in 1986 was just interesting. I understand the idea of people trying to make sense out of Chornobyl and try to get their emotions steady. I understand the adventure of climbing over the fence "just to see" but staying there secretly seems scary. However, I have four boys and given that piece of history would have no doubt been an exploration event for them.
Well written and with our current situation in USA it takes on a new meaning for me. The Ukrainian people people are hiding everywhere and need American help. I found myself down as I read how difficult life is in Ukraine was but now I am seriously saddened by their plight.
Markiyan Kamysh, the author of this unusual book, is the son of a nuclear physicist and design engineer who worked as one of the “liquidators” after the 1986 nuclear disaster at Chernobyl – or, to use the alternative name favoured by Kamysh – “Chornobyl”. Perhaps because of this personal connection, Kamysh is obsessed with the Exclusion Zone that is still in place, spanning a radius of several kilometres around the remains of the Power Plant. Since 2010, he has ventured into this out-of-bounds area on numerous occasions, whether on his own, with friends, or with curious foreigners who appoint him as a “stalker” or guide to the Zone. Stalking the Atomic City is a curious blend of memoir and travelogue, peopled by dubious characters including reckless (and hapless) adventurers, looters, scrap-dealers, vandals, drug-addicts and alcoholics in search of a high. Throughout the book, there is a palpable sense of danger. The author’s own photographs highlight a desolate landscape, a toxic wasteland where wild animals (and police patrols) roam.
The text, rendered from the Ukrainian by Hanna Leliv and Reilly Costigan-Humes, has an idiosyncratic style which needs some getting used to. It veers from poetic (substance-induced?) ecstasy to expletive-strewn passages worthy of a hard-boiled thriller. The results are often original, but at other times maddeningly overwritten and overwrought, with hit-and-miss attempts at humour. Sometimes, awkward switches of tenses (past, present, future) and changes of POV create some confusion, although this strangely fits the discombobulating atmosphere of the Zone. Some examples will give a taste of what I mean:
""We threw our backpacks on the ground and started to climb in silence. At the height of a sixteen-story building, wind blew into our faces and our hands were frozen to the bone, as a frigid thaw stretched its wetness onto the antennas’ rusty skeletons, and my gloves got soaked through. My friend captured the panorama of the expanse of snow on his old phone. You can’t cram a hundred million impressions into two million pixels. Under the vault of those incredible constructions, myriads of drops crashed against the cold metal. Every moment brimmed with new sounds. You can’t stuff myriads of falling drops into millions of bytes of voice messages. Even if Erik Satie played on all the pianos in Prypyat at the same time, he wouldn’t have impressed me as much as those drops, wouldn’t have beaten my hungover memory as hard with a sledgehammer of bright impressions.
…
As a matter of fact, I don’t like taking new people along. Or some of the old ones, either. I have to take them where we agreed to go. To Prypyat, that is. But what if on the way to Prypyat, somewhere after Chornobyl-2, it occurs to me that I haven’t been to the Emerald summer camp for a hundred years and that its little cottages will soon crumble – what then? In short, when you bring someone along for a trip, it’s like you’ve thrown a manhole cover from the ninth floor onto your own head – a manhole cover of obligations and rules.
…
So, I return from the Zone and think to myself: “Here I am, back home, drinking my orange Hike, devouring brand-name chocolate bars, washing them down with Pepsi, and enjoying the spice of life. “ And then I realize that I have a few words to say to the folks criticizing consumer goods of modern civilization. To everyone who hates that you can buy ten kinds of frozen veggies and twenty kinds of cigarettes at the supermarket. You’re fuckers. Just taste a chocolate bar after a two-week trip to the Chornobyl dump; just feel the hazelnuts crunching on your long-unbrushed teeth; just take a swig of soda and only then can you curse having access to a large variety of foreign goods. Fuckers.""
Style apart, I guess that whether you love this book or not will depend on whether you’ll fall for its atmosphere. In that regard, I must say that Stalking the Atomic City appealed to my neo-Gothic sensibilities, the huge antennas and moody ruins replacing the decrepit castles and abbeys of old, the swamps and beasts standing in for the awe-inspiring Romantic sublime, the frisson of danger adding a hint of horror. And although the book is not strictly speaking a work of psychogeography, there are echoes of the genre in its descriptions of abandoned urban spaces, as in Lubyanka, “the oasis of the old Zone” where:
"The ghosts of dead grandmas still floated around…; clocks were in the cupboards, no longer ticking; jugs stood intact; and boots were lined up in the hallways… It still looks like the Zone of the nineties, those turbulent times when you went inside a house and you knew – someone had been living there just yesterday."
Stalking the Atomic City is more than a book, it is an experience. Whether it is to your liking is another matter, but the only way to know is to try it.
https://endsoftheword.blogspot.com/2022/01/Stalking-the-Atomic-City-Markiyan-Kamysh.html
My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher Astra Publishing House for an advanced copy of this travel and regional history book.
The tragedy of the nuclear accident at Chernobyl has been used in movies, books, video games and other media almost since the incident occurred in 1986. Many of the books Voices of Chernobyl by Nobel Prize winner Svetlana Alexievich and Midnight at Chernobyl by Adam Higginbotham are classics not only in their field, but in literature. Most books deal with what happened and the aftermath. This book deals with the grave the area has become. Which makes me as a reader wonder how this book is just not that interesting.
From the Hunter S. Thompson-like subtitle, the use of the word "stalking" borrowed from the Russian movie and novel Stalker, everything in this book seems derivative. The On the Road writing, the ennui of being a guide Stalking the Atomic City: Life Among the Decadent and the Depraved of Chornobyl by Markiyan Kamysh is just there. Not long enough to just give up on, yet not informative to be interesting. I knew more about the author's disliking of warm Pepsi then I knew where he was walking, why he was walking and anything about his companions, if he had any. Things happen, some walking, a line about other people or police, more walking. Nothing really about anything. Well I did learn that fences burn quite well, so you really don't need a sleeping bag.
There are some photos, which are haunting, but again there is nothing to tell you about them, or why the photos were taken. You go in, bring some food, Snickers, a gas stove, vodka, cigarettes, hang around, walk, leave, grab bus go home. I'm not sure if it was a translating problem, or the fact that he wrote for people who live with this radiated ghost city in their backyard and will be more familiar with the whole system. I wanted to know more about the bus drivers, and the police who patrol the area then another story about sitting in some deserted room, cooking tea and wondering why he was there. The book was published in 2015 so I don't know if Beat writing and shoegaze music came to the Ukraine, but that is very much what this book seemed like.
I wanted to enjoy this book, but I learned so little, and found myself not caring at all about the writer, or the people he brought in. He mentions a lot of famous people like to take tours, but do they just come to eat candy bars, burn furniture, and wander around. More "My Chernobyl Romance" than a book that a reader could learn from.
Tries for Gonzo journalism, gets Gonzo the muppet. I was expect maybe some reportage about those who live in and exploit Chernobyl's exclusion zone. Instead I got poorly strung together teenage boasting. The writer has clearly seen "Stalker" way too many times.
Perhaps something was lost in translation, but I truly didn't understand this book. It almost sounded like a manual for illegal backpacking. The pictures were beautiful and spoke volumes and as the author is also a photographer, perhaps his point would have been better served by that. Thanks to NetGalley, the author and publisher for an e-arc in exchange for my honest opinion.