Member Reviews

Thanks to NetGalley for giving me an early copy to review.

A Lady for a Duke has been high on my TBR since I heard about it this last January. Not only because of the author, who I’ve never read before but have only heard good things about, but also because the premise was right up my alley. To receive an early copy was very exciting (especially since this is the first ARC I’ve requested 🥺).

This book follows Viola Caroll who, two years previous, fought in the Napoleonic Wars and was presumed dead at Waterloo. She used her disappearance as an opportunity to leave her old life behind and live as her true self. Only now, she has received word that her oldest friend who fought alongside her in the war, the Duke of Gracewood, has been living in grief and depression since Waterloo. She has to decide if she really wants to leave her past completely behind – and what to do with the feelings she has for Gracewood when they reunite.

This book was a joy to read. It had a great sense of setting, which the writing style (wry, witty, and Austen-like) helped establish. And it showed, in its own way, how queer stories belong throughout history. It didn’t shy away from some of the hardships that queer people have had to face in history, but this particular novel had a very optimistic spin and hopeful tone (obviously, as it’s also a romance lol).

This last aspect was probably my favorite part of the book. Viola’s character arc was, at its heart, about learning that she deserved every single joy and happily-ever-after that she’d been denied and told she couldn’t have all her life. Every time she expressed that a certain experience wasn’t for her, because she’d missed out or society wouldn’t let her, the narrative showed again and again that she didn’t have to limit herself. Or let herself be limited!

The romance was very sweet, also for that reason. As Alexis Hall said in the afterward, Viola being trans was important to the story/romance, but wasn’t the source of conflict. Gracewood was very understanding after he realized what being trans meant. I liked this, as it showed how right their feelings were for each other and how uncomplicated their romance could be. A large part of the novel is Viola and Gracewood trying to understand their own pasts and confront them, while moving forward to a much different future. I think this really worked with how their romance unfolded!

However, for me, it also meant I was a little bored once I got past about the halfway point. It’s this weird case where I understand exactly why Alexis Hall chose to pace and structure the novel the way he did, buuuuut. I just wasn’t as interested after a certain point. Without spoilers, it felt like it took the whole second half for the characters to truly move forward, which made some parts drag a little – even though character development and the plot was still happening.

I think part of it was also due to the characterization and dialog. I liked their characters, but for some reason, I didn’t feel as emotionally connected to them as I expected. This may be because Viola and Gracewood don’t have many flaws or make many mistakes? Which isn’t necessarily a bad thing,… but I like seeing characters goof up and then beg for repentance or whatever. And honestly, even more so in a Regency romance… [looks toward Mr Darcy].

Meanwhile, as Gracewood and Viola got closer, I felt like their dialog got soooo corny. I know this is a huge personal preference, since I’ve read several books where I’ve had this issue before while none of my friends felt that way at all. It really put me off, but I think most people won’t notice and some will like this aspect!

All in all, this book is probably a 3.5/5 for me, but I will definitely be recommending it to anyone that is drawn in by the summary or anyone that loves a queer joy romance. This was that to a tee!

Was this review helpful?

A radiantly unique historical romance by Alexis Hall, 'A Lady For A Duke' tells the story of Viola Carroll, a transgender woman, and her childhood best friend, the Duke of Gracewood. It is a swooning, delightfully brooding novel with all of the queer heart of Hall's other books, but it takes itself more seriously, and for good reason. Hall is aware of the high stakes of getting transgender representation right, and while I eagerly await reviews from trans critics and readers, I found Viola's characterization deft, moving, and unforgettable. Alexis Hall is one of the best romance writers out there, and 'A Lady For a Duke' shows his impressive range. This book would be incredible on its own right; that it makes history makes it even more special.

Was this review helpful?

As a fan of both historical romance and queer romance, I have absolutely adored the recent trend in queer historicals. When I read the premise for A Lady for a Duke, I knew it was going to become a new favorite. Viola is a beautiful, funny, and heartwarming character, unapologetic, mischievous, and loving. Watching her and Gracewood navigate the complexities of all they’ve meant to each other over the years as they fall in love and fully accept each other and themselves was a delight. I also adored all of the side characters, from Badger and Louise, to Little Bartholomew and Lady Lillimere. I would highly recommend this tender portrait of queer love to fans of Cat Sebastian and anyone who loves Regency romance.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to Forever Pub for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!

I want to start off by saying I'm a huge Alexis Hall fan. Although it was really wonderful to see trans and LGBTQIA2S+ rep in regency era romance, the pacing felt off, and the book was too long.

I enjoyed parts of it, but I found myself skimming scenes that just weren't necessary. Alexis Hall generally writes 'long' books in terms of the romance genre, but this was the first one that felt unnecessarily long. I still really enjoyed it, but it's incredibly slow going, and I think at least 100 pages could have been cut.

I did still really enjoy it, but don't expect it to be fast paced and do expect lots and lots of slow burn.

Was this review helpful?

4.5
Thank you to Forever Publishing for a copy of this book to read and review. I adored this book. I loved seeing a transgender main character in a historical romance setting. It was done so well. Hall also incorporated loss, mourning and trauma into this story and it really gave the characters such meaningful layers. I've only read one other book by Hall, but I could tell from the tone and humor alone that it was his. There were so many beautiful moments between Viola and Gracewood and I loved the open conversations, the vulnerability and the genuine love and understanding each of the characters had for one another. The combination of humor and seriousness was well balanced and I really enjoyed these aspects while reading. A Lady For a Duke was an absolutely monumental book and I highly recommend reading this one!

Was this review helpful?

Confession: I didn’t fall in love with this book, and I spent some time thinking about why not. I love the author. I love the couple. Every scene between Viola and Justin makes me ache about how much they should be together. They’re open and vulnerable with each other. They challenge each other to see the world differently and never feel lonely.

Yet I didn’t fall because the side characters annoyed me. And I accept that I’m in the minority but find them at times aggravating. There’s one woman who sexually harasses other women, but since she’s a woman and not a man, I’m supposed to find this charming or liberating. The villains weren’t interesting and so stupid.

This review is based on an advanced reader copy provided through Netgalley for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The love I have for this book is unbelievable, and it will remain a staple on my favorites shelf for years and years. Alexis Hall crafts a story full of grief, heartbreak, and pure trans joy that is so beautiful and irreverent that I have implored all of my followers to read at the time of its release.

There’s so much about this book that I enjoyed, from the prose to the romance to the representation. Hall’s prose is at once both poetic and simplistic, offering up stunning lines that cut deeply into the emotions of the reader while remaining unconfusing. The way that he crafts his descriptions is expert, and I highlighted many passages detailing the stone walls of Morgencald or the softness of Viola’s hair. I think, when it comes down to it, the writing was one of my absolute favorite parts of this book.

The romance itself was sweet and, while made complicated with grief and years of tangled friendship, full of so much love and kindness and understanding. Seeing a trans woman so fully and steadfastly loved by a man like Gracewood, who was so willing to move Heaven and Earth not just to be with her but to make her feel safe and accepted entirely, made me so incredibly happy. I cried on so many occasions as Gracewood time and again showed Viola exactly the kind of man he was, and even when he himself didn’t believe he could be worthy of anything much less her love, Viola was one hundred percent sure in his goodness and in his strength. The way that Viola loved Gracewood so wholly and completely was beautiful, how she consistently strove to get him to see himself the way that she saw him.

This book could easily have been full of harmful tropes against Viola’s character, especially with the rise of transphobia in both the UK and the US, but on the contrary it was full of nothing but love and understanding. I think that it’s so important for there to be a trans character portrayed in any genre portrayed in such a kind and delicate light, written with the utmost love and care. Viola is such a strong character, who holds onto her convictions and her sense of self in a world that would rather see her abandon herself completely in favor of what society deemed acceptable. She’s hilarious and sarcastic, kind and loving, strong and stubborn. The fact that Viola was so many things, her character so well-rounded and absolute and her transness portrayed as not all she was, brought me so much joy and happiness.

The side characters were also all absolutely fantastic. Louise is a rather managing and unwavering woman, who at first glance seems shrewd and observant but turns out to be a person that feels everything deeply and cares for those she loves so much. Badger, her husband and Viola’s brother, while not present very much in the story, is shown to be a loving husband and brother who accepted his sister’s identity entirely and never once wavered. Lady Lillimere is also a side character that meant so much to me, being a sapphic woman who damned society the second her husband died in favor of living her life both authentically and with abandon. Lady Miranda, Gracewood’s sister, made me so happy. She’s entirely her own character, full of both so much joy and so much grief for a life she never got to lead because of forces out of her own control.

The only few complaints I have, and they are few and reaching, happen to be things that I’m sure will be fixed upon publication that have to do with editing. A few sentences that need restructuring or a couple of grammatical errors. The fact that the only complaints I have regarding this book happen to be entirely nitpicky and to do with grammar is a testament to how amazing it is. This book is going to be so special to so many people, offering not only representation and the concrete idea of a trans woman being wholeheartedly loved in her entirety but also a loveable cast and an emotionally stirring conflict. I can’t wait for publication.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. I'm truly in awe of this book. It's soft and tender, full of hope and unconditional love, with just the right amount of angst. The dialogue is sharp and clever and I loved the supporting cast of characters! This book balanced so many things so delicately and was a pure delight to read. Alexis Hall is incredibly talented and I'm hoping for more books in this world with some of the supporting characters! Thank you to Forever and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Alexis Hall’s ‘A Lady for a Duke’ is everything I want in a historical novel. It’s filled with the accoutrements and social mores of the day, while also subverting said mores in interesting and inventive ways. And its love story is one for the ages. Viola and Gracewood are forever going to be one of my favorite couples in literature.

Viola Carroll has lived her life without people seeing who she truly is. After being presumed dead after Waterloo, she has the chance to live authentically for the first time; and Viola grasps the opportunity with both hands, even though that means she has to leave her best friend behind. In the two years since Viola has been presumed dead, her best friend, Justin de Vere, the Duke of Gracewood, has been bereft. When Viola has the chance to help him, she does, even though doing so may put her very existence at risk.

Hall’s approach to Viola’s character was so wonderful. That the main conflict of the story is not the fact that Viola is trans is such a breath of fresh air. How Viola and Gracewood interact, as friends, and then as lovers, are some of the most beautiful, emotive passages I have ever read. Ever. The unfolding of their affection and love is the best kind of slow burn. Their union is definitely worth the wait.

The ways in which Hall addresses the way Viola and Gracewood both feel in terms of identity and in terms of mental health are also vital. How do you give voice to something that hasn’t been talked about or named? How do you accept those parts of yourself when you feel dissociated and isolated from others? There are so many wonderful themes to explore in this book, and reading it has enriched me in ways I would not have anticipated.

‘A Lady for a Duke’ has just made its way to my top ten books of the year. Readers are in for a treat with this one.

A sincere thank you to Forever and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A deeply romantic and affecting historical romance, filled with heart, healing, and hope. Alexis Hall’s prose sparkles here — there’s an exquisite balance between angst and humor, which Hall navigate deftly, often carefully shifting in tone from one paragraph to the next. I found this trans romance to be handled with sensitivity and awareness, never othering Viola or her experiences. This second chance romance balances the past and the present thoughtfully in a way that highlights the profound and lasting connection between the romantic leads, but without ever straying into territory that could be traumatic for trans readers (i.e. no excessive deadnaming or misgendering, though there is some of both present early on in the text. The author’s note contextualizes these). Similarly, I found Gracewood’s disability to be handled with care and empathy. While this book is on the higher end of my personal angst reading scale, I never found the story to be bogged down in hopelessness or despair. There’s a core of love and comfort threaded throughout the story that only makes you believe more strongly that everything will end happily for Viola and Gracewood. Their HEA is hard won and well deserved. Without a doubt, I will return to this beautiful friends to lovers romance again and again for future rereads.

Was this review helpful?

The 1991 classic Beauty and the Beast is the best Disney movie ever made. It might possibly be the best movie ever made. period. It’s dreamy and charming and romantic. It has high concept and high stakes and it’s all wrapped up in golden silk bow.

However, in romance, the B&B trope is so filled with ableist tropes (and just plain ableism) that I tend to avoid it out right. So imagine my surprise when this book snuck past my defenses (I mean look at that cover! what could I possibly have been thinking thinking this was??).

What it was, however, was dreamy and charming and romantic, all wrapped up in a queer bow of golden silk and liberation. It’s childhood best friends, mistaken identity, beauty and the beast (duh), and queer as all get out, with a trans heroine and a disabled, addict hero. It’s longing and desire and grief and a whole hell of a lot of heart. It’s about people who love each other profoundly and unboundedly and put in the work to love each other well.

This book is perfection. It is a fresh, queer, trans, disabled take on a tale as old as time, reminding us that queerness and trans ness and disability are also tales as old as time, and that this kind of aching, infinite love is too.

Thanks to NetGalley and Forever for this ARC.

CW: addiction, transphobia, dead naming, kidnapping, gun on page, PTSD, war

Was this review helpful?

Did you hear that?? That was me screaming at the top of my lungs for this utterly charming and heartfelt book by Alexis Hall.

A Lady For A Duke</em> is the book I didn't know I needed to read.

Viola Is a fantastic trans heroine whose strength and compassion really make her character shine in this lovely romantic story. Hall does an amazing job really making the reader feel for her. She had everything in her old life, wealth, family, security. But nothing compared to being truthful with who you are. Even if that means leaving your best friend and forever crush behind.

Little did she know, the man she left behind mourned her too, convinced his best friend died on the battlefield.

I love all the things about this story. It’s so deeply romantic and hones.

What wouldn’t you give up if you were able to live your most truthful life?&nbsp;

Justin is so heartbroken and lost. I instantly felt for him and his intense guilt. He felt so responsible for his best friend’s death, having carried his grief with him since the war.. It was such a satisfying transformation to watch him trust again and yes, even love again. 

>And always, Hall’s writing is solid and on point with just enough humor to effortlessly blend genres of historical romantic comedy with underlying truthful and real challenges of his dramatic characters.  The author also writes sensitively and compassionately about his main character and all of the unique and heartbreaking challenges she faced, especially given the time period. There's some sex (it is an adult romance book remember?) but it's more of a slow burn romance than a hot steamy sex book.

It is incredibly heartwarming and sweet and I think fans of Hall will not be disappointed!

Was this review helpful?

Alexis Hall delivered exactly what I wanted from this book after first reading the synopsis. Estranged best friends meet again after spending several years apart and there is so much mutual pining and angst—it’s great.

Viola Carroll and Justin de Vere—the Duke of Gracewood—meet again after not having seen one another for two years. Justin believes his best friend died on the battlefield in Waterloo during the war they both fought as soldiers. What he doesn't know is that he never truly knew his friend as the woman she had been all along, so he doesn't initially recognize her when they reunite. Upon their reunion, they fall in love, of course, but both main characters have their own reasons for keeping the other at a distance, which causes a whole lot of angst and pining.

Neither main character feels like they deserve the other’s love—Viola because she is transgender, and Justin because he came out of the war with a disability and is plagued by what we would now call PTSD. What matters most, though, is that both Viola and Justin love each other so dearly. Their mutual pining and desire build up gradually and tenderly, and the emotional pay-off was so incredibly worth it for me. It’s been a while since I’ve read a romance novel where I was rooting this much for the main couple.

Aside from the main couple, there’s a cast of interesting side characters I couldn’t help but love. One of the main themes within A Lady for a Duke is definitely the way different characters deal with societal expectations around traditional gender roles, and I loved seeing how different characters dealt with this in their own way, especially Viola’s sister and her good friend—both of whom are women with personality traits not generally acceptable for women in the early nineteenth century. Justin’s sister, too, is a central figure in the book, as part of the plot revolves around her debut in London society.

And then, of course, there is Viola herself, who grapples with what it means to be a transgender woman in a time when the concept of being transgender did not exist as it does in society nowadays. As a trans reviewer, I believe Alexis Hall explored her identity in a way that was respectful and not inappropriate for someone who’s not a trans woman to write about, although I’m not familiar with the transfeminine experience specifically and will thus be on the lookout for reviews from transfeminine folks.

One thing I didn’t quite understand about this book is the final twenty percent or so, in which an external conflict emerges that I didn’t think fit the rest of the book in tone or content. It wasn’t bad, per se, I’m just not sure why it needed to be included. In my opinion, it could’ve easily been omitted from the book, also making the book slightly shorter in the process, which I wouldn’t have minded. A length of 480 pages is slightly on the long side for a romance novel, in my opinion.

Nevertheless, I really enjoyed this book, its characters, and most of all, the central romance. Seeing a trans character getting her happy ending in a historical romance made me so incredibly happy, and I’m hoping we get to see more trans historical romance in the future, especially written by trans authors. I highly recommend this book, especially if you like mutual pining and estranged best friends falling in love.

Was this review helpful?

My goodness, this was absolutely lovely. Alexis Hall is so masterful in his ability to weave a story, giving intention to any details mentioned, and creating a sense of angst and longing in his words. The characters have so much personality and wit, I'm envious and wish I had a fraction of the eloquence they all possess.

Regency romance can be hard for me to get into right off the bat with its particular verbiage and overall vibe, but this was written in such an accessible manner yet still maintaining the tone of the era!

I loved the dialogue, the quotable moments, and the pining! So much heart wrenching and heartwarming pining! Although it might be a bit slower paced for those new or unfamiliar with the genre, I highly recommend this to any fan of regency romance.

Was this review helpful?

What a fantastic read! I had this on my radar since the MC is trans, and this book didn’t disappoint. I’m so excited that I got to read it and am very excited to get it on release day. I can’t rave about this book enough! The characters, the setting, the second chance romance!!

Was this review helpful?

4.5/5 stars

This was an absolutely fantastic book. I had heard great things before I picked it up and I was not disappointed. This book not only has a great romance plot, it's embedded with plots of grief, loss, and understanding that complement and contrast the romance perfectly.

I usually struggle with books that centre around a 'big lie' (ie that character A knows something/is keeping something from character B). While I did struggle with this a small amount, I understood the need for the lie (or non-truth) and could move past it with ease. I also appreciated that Viola was never misgendered in the present, only ever in the past.

I won't lie, I thought this book was going to be over at about the 50% mark. I was pleasantly surprised by the remaining plot but it did feel like two plots pushed together.

Overall, I highly recommend this book to anyone with a love of historical romances, it fits the bill completely.

Was this review helpful?

“What a marvel it was. What freedom. To be a woman unabashedly in love beneath a multitude of stars.”

I will never not be impressed by the masterful way Alexis Hall crafts his stories. They are put together with such care and precision that you can’t help but fall in love every time. Honestly, at this point, publishers should just give him free rein to write any and every thing he wishes; I assure you that readers will come running to get their latest fix. A Lady for a Duke is no different. This is Alexis Hall at his very best and most profound.

The true strength of this story is the incredible cast of characters.After being presumed dead at the Battle of Waterloo, our heroine, Lady Viola Caroll, decides to reinvent herself and finally live as she truly is - giving up her titles and closest friendships. Through Viola, readers are treated to an empathetic and exhilarating depiction of a trans woman in regency-era England. And yet, that is not the primary focus of this story - it is simply just another part of Viola’s life. We follow her reintroduction into proper society and renewed relationship with her childhood best friend, Justin de Vera, the Duke of Gracewood. After being shattered by the loss of his best friend, Gracewood suffers physically and emotionally from his own experience in the war and blossoms when Viola re-enters his life. Together, you believe their chemistry and history and root for them to defy odds to be together. They are just Viola and Gracewood, in the end - nothing else matters.

The other side characters are just as lovely. I’m particularly fond of Louise and Little Bartholomew - they added just the right amount of AJH zaniness that I’ve grown fond of. Louise is protective and unconditionally supportive of Viola and her happiness. Gracewood’s sister, Miranda, was also an incredibly fun addition to this cast - and I’m, not so secretly, hoping for a sequel following her story! Even the “villains” were dynamic and interesting, despite being truly terrible at times!

Hall’s writing is simply breathtaking. From his empathetic descriptions of Viola’s transition to Gracewood’s PTSD and disability, everything is written with an abundance of care and love. There were whole pages that I highlighted because the lyrical prose took my breath away. The love scene is tender and heartfelt and a unification of the build up leading to that moment. There is so much angst and tension woven throughout, I genuinely felt my stomach clench in anticipation. The mutual yearning slow burn feels like torture at times in the best way possible.

(view spoiler)

My complaints/critiques are extremely minor and didn’t detract from my enjoyment of the story. I think that it was a little too long, and feels it, at times. Especially in the first half - it’s a slow crawl getting to the point where the characters are comfortable with one another again and I felt like some of that could have been condensed - though it does just amplify the angsty slow burn effect. Once I reached the midway point, I devoured this story!

This may be Hall’s most important work to date. THIS is the type of romance that the world needs today - uninhibited diversity and heart. Especially in light of the US’s recent legislation designed to restrict and harm trans youth. Hall brings these wonderful, historical queer characters to life in technicolor and allows them to just be. They’re accepted for who they are with no questions asked - that’s how the world should be. With stories like this, we take a step closer towards how everyone should be treated.

I cannot wait to see what else comes from this world - I would happily read about any other side characters just to be re-immersed in the magic. Thank you so much to Forever publishing and Netgalley for the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

A magical and honest romance that I just.... :') Wow.

In this stunning friends to lovers romance comes the story of Viola, who is trying to right her missing piece of the life she left behind. She'd never say she was wrong to make a very important, significant choice for herself... but there is something she has thought about since she left.

Gracewood is haunted by the war he once fought in. He lost a lot of men but most importantly, he lost his best friend. Years go by and he has drowned himself in drink after drink, losing his ability to clearly think more often than not. When Viola learns about his misery, she ventures off to see if she could help him... at the figurative shove of her friend. When she gets there, she finds it just as easy to speak to him as she once did... but she has changed and Gracewood might never understand.

A Lady for a Duke was a patient and glorious story of a woman being unapologetically herself in a time when it was not so common for her to do so. She made a decision that would solely improve her own quality of life and not one person will make her feel as though this was wrong of her.

I loved. I loved so much. Alexis Hall has nailed it time and time again and this was another knockout. Our characters were written so wonderfully... there's not much you could think to dislike about it. I LOVED IT.

Was this review helpful?

So Alexis Hall (@quicunquevult) is one of those authors for me where I don't feel like I need a lot information to pick up and read his books. I saw the cover and the name and thought oh cool, queer historical romance - love it. I was not prepared to love it as much as I did. The main characters were easy to root for, the angst was deliciously good, and the swoony love story hit all the right marks for me. 5⭐️ and am definitely picking up a physical copy when it is released.

✔️ Childhood friends to lovers
✔️ Just a hookup
✔️ Nurse back to health

This was a delightful historical romance that delivered on everything I love about the genre - lots of longing and pining and late night meetups by candlelight and using dancing as an excuse to hold each other close. Emotional scenes, outdoors on beautiful grounds where no one overhears the outbursts of emotion or difficult conversations.

I'm not always a fan of friends to lovers as sometimes it's one person pining and the other is oblivious. This worked because both people pined and I am here for it! The representation was terrific as well (trans heroine, MMC struggling with PTSD and physical injuries from the war). This book reminded me of why romance novels can serve as a reminder that we all deserve happiness for who we are.

Thanks to @netgalley and @readforeverpub for early access to this book. I

Steam 🔥🔥
Banter 🗣🗣🗣
Swoon 💕💕💕💕

Was this review helpful?

A Lady for a Duke is one of those wild game changer books that I (hope) rocks the world of romance. Written by the rising star Alexis Hall, it is a regency romance about a transgender girl and her childhood friend who thought he lost her in war. In truth, Viola narrowly escaped with her life, choosing this moment to live as her authentic self and throw away her claim to her family name. When the two reunite, he is a shell of his former self, and Viola takes it upon herself to look after her friends heart.

I tried to look up trans regency romance, and if other books like this exist, they are very niche. A Lady for a Duke is, in the mainstream at least, kicking off the idea that we can play with history where trans characters are involved. While I am aware of the growth of the MLM and WLW regency genres, this one struck me is very unique. The couple in this book is straight. Viola is a recently transitioned girl, and not even her closest friends recognize her.

Many are very accepting of her when they find out about her secret. The book asks you to forget about the complications of transitioning before a period of trans liberation and acceptance, hormone support, safe surgery, etc. It instead allows Viola (while she IS in hiding) to confidently be the woman she is and connect to the people in her life without experiencing trauma or bigotry related to her identity. I am glad this book is going for fantastical history, because as an escapist fantasy at its core and it just feels so fucking good. Alexis Hall puts so much into Viola's character and manages to make her identity meaningful without asking trans readers to consume yet another book about trans suffering.

The romance is gutting. Gracewood, Viola's romantic interest is a traumatized war vet that deeply misses his best friend (her) . Watching Viola being forced to lie to him about who she is while consoling him makes for some epic tension. These two are burning with chemistry, and while it's not a particularly slow burn, both characters holding back parts of themselves while spiraling into love is an absolute treat.

I do not like regency romance, but A Lady for a Duke added something to the genre; taking modern "fanfiction" tropes and blending them seamlessly into a regency setting with lovable characters and a steamy romance giving us some incredible representation in the process. This is a treat for anyone, but will hit especially hard with romance book lovers who have also been waiting to see themselves represented in a traditional romance structure.
3 likes

Was this review helpful?