Member Reviews

this wasn't my cup of tea. i found the whole book to be very slow and repetitive. in many ways the friendships and arcs were very predictable.

Was this review helpful?

This was delightful! Like a mashup of Emma, Pride and Prejudice, and Gossip Girl. Bessie Carter’s narration was spot-on. I just wish I would have been wearing pearls so I could clutch them while feeling astonished and scandalized at all the hilarious impropriety.

Many thanks to Macmillan Audio and NetGalley for the complimentary copy of this work.

Was this review helpful?

Mean Girls in the Reagency Era. Instead of high school drama, the drama unfolds at the various balls and dinner parties.

I thought this book had an interesting twist of all of the things that most books don't touch so dramatically about "polite society" such as all of the boys, drinking and debauchery. It is a bit of a coming of age story for Georgiana when she gets "high society" friends, but some of the same drama seems to be on repeat for a lot of the book.

On purpose of course, some of the characters (Francis, Betty) were over the top annoying. I was glad for the narrator in the audiobook version to keep me engaged.

If you like tons of drama, this book is for you!

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing a copy of this Audiobook for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

What a fun story! Georgiana learns so much about society, life, and love through Frances, who will try just about anything. The situations were funny with a few lessons about different issues that were prevalent in the Regency (marrying for money) but also are relevant to life now (wanting to fit in). There’s a sweet romance thrown in but for me, the highlight was the gossipy humor.

I enjoyed the narration but, at times, had a difficult time distinguishing between the different characters.

Was this review helpful?

You’ve read those books and seen those movies about high school students who were just too cool for school. You know, the ones where they would sneak liquor into high school dances and then sneak out to hang out or pair off? Now, imagine if that clique existed in Jane Austen times, with the upper class ladies sneaking liquor (and other substances) into dinner parties and dances and sneaking out unchaperoned into gardens, and you’ve got Reputation.

Reputation was a fun and ironic reimagining of the Jane Austen style comedy of mannners, which explored what it would be like if a proper middle class lady tried to hang for a summer with the elite of society who were wealthy enough to be outside the bounds of propriety. The trigger warnings/content warnings include off-page rape and on-page attempted rape.

Although, I don’t think I would have liked it as much if it weren’t for the proper British female narrator. She made the book sound exactly like a Jane Austen comedy of manners. She was deadpan for the entire book, which made the improprieties stand out even more and be even more laughable. In that way, it reminded me of the audiobook for Pride, Prejudice, and Zombies, which kept me snickering and chuckling the whole way through.

I received this book as a digital advance reader copy provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest opinion. Now that I have the fabulous narrator’s voice in my head, I’m leaning toward picking up a printed copy to see what that experience is like.

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun Rom-com. You can tell from the cover you are getting Gossip Girl/Mean Girl vibes in a Bridgerton/Austen era.

It was fast paced enough that I kept going back to see what ridiculous things the socialites were going to get up to, and while I anticipated a lot of what our main character Georgiana Ellers would experience and eventually come up against, (peer pressure, lies told to spend time with dubious company and late nights Turing into early mornings before sneaking home) it was a entertaining enough plot to keep me an interested reader.

I loved the modern solutions and attitudes placed withing the historic settings and conversation. It was delightful and engaging. I felt sad that it was over but enjoyed how the story was wrapped up.

Was this review helpful?

This book is like Downton Abbey, if all hell broke loose. Just when I thought things couldn't get any more wild, I was so wrong. While it drug on just a but in the middle and rushed to a conclusion, I still enjoyed it. ⭐⭐⭐ the audio was very well done.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed Reputation, but I have to admit that it isn't what I expected it to be! Going in, I thought I was just getting your run of the mill regency drama, but this book went a lot deeper. It explored modern themes through a regency-era backdrop, which was a pretty interesting way to go about it!

Things I enjoyed:
-It was so witty, I found myself laughing out loud at party.
-BETTY. What a gem.

Things I didn't enjoy:
-Georgiana was confusing at times. She acted completely naive and ignorant at times but then at other times she intentionally tried to make scandalous jokes at the dinner table with her aunt and uncle?

I really appreciated how this book showed some pretty realistic aftermath of a friendship falling out, too. I don't want to spoil anything, but that was refreshing to me. If you like Pride and Prejudice, Mean Girls, Bridgerton, etc...I think you'll enjoy this a lot!

(TW for rape)

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for allowing me to have an early listen in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Snarky fun! A bit of Bridgerton. A bit of Mean Girls. A really well-drawn audiobook narration. I had a lot of fun with this!

Was this review helpful?

This was an enjoyable historical fiction. Georgina who recently moved in with her aunt and uncle meets a new friend Frances. Frances and her friends are all very wealthy and do not follow the rules of Victorian life. Georgina who herself is middle class finds herself at parties unchaperoned and engaging in drugs and drinking until mean girl Frances gets jealous and tries to ruin her life. This book is like the Mean Girls of the Victorian Era.

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting concept. It was a very modern take on a regency romance. I didn’t like that it took so long for the book to introduce the hero, and even then it wasn’t until closer to the end that I was even able to figure out which way the heroine was going. I felt like it needed way more interaction between the two and more steam from them. The book did hit on some powerful topics, which was great. Not sure how historically accurate they would have been. Overall not a terrible read, but also not my favorite.

Was this review helpful?

Well this book is like regency Mean Girls. It is an interesting approach to a coming of age romance that's for sure. This book has all the makings for a lighthearted romance but don't let the cover fool you. This has some difficult scenes and topics throughout the book. Their are difficult friendships, sexual assault, peer pressure, grief, and romance.

This book was a little difficult for me to get into because I really did not like the main character for a majority of the book. She is shy but not quit shy, smart but doesn't want to show it, and overall not a good friend. But she does have a rough home life but it was hard to root for her at times. That being said I did like the main love interest. I felt like he was someone bringing her back to herself throughout the story and he was her touchstone to know when she was losing herself or going just a little too far despite him mainly being a secondary character. I wish the romance was little bit more prevalent throughout the story. But I might just feel like that because I only really liked her when she was outside the friendship bubble.

To me this would not be considered a romance because the main storyline is all about friendship and how far you would go to fit In. Peer pressure to fit in with the "outcasts" or "rebels" of society lead our main character down a path where she starts to lose sight of herself.

Overall, this was a good book. I really enjoyed it toward the end but it was a slow starter to me because I couldn't tell where the story was going at first. Thank you NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to branch out.

Was this review helpful?

Reputation does not - well - live up to its reputation. Though described as a Regency-era romance, I found it to be neither of those things. It isn't at all historically accurate - to the point that I routinely forgot it was a period piece, and romance is far from the focus of this book. The setting felt like a desperate tie-in to the success of Bridgerton rather than a focus of the author, Lex Croucher, when making language and stylistic choices.

Georgiana and Frances are flawed characters - which I appreciate - but I realized that I was never "rooting" for a particular character's happiness or motivation. This made it difficult to become immersed in the book.

I didn't particularly enjoy the manner in which Croucher approached sexual assault/rape. It is disingenuous to use modern language and ignore period-appropriate public mannerisms, yet have a male character go unpunished for sexual assault.

The big win of this book is the acknowledgement that the Regency era wasn't as white as history books would lead you to believe. I do wish that that the two wives of color were both alive and had strong voices, and that at least one of our families of color was portrayed to have a good societal reputation.

All-in-all if this book had a different setting - perhaps a fantastical societal - or did not rely so heavily on modern references, it would have been tremendously more successful.

Was this review helpful?

Oh dear, this book has a mean streak. I wanted to love this. I really really wanted to love this. And it must be said there is character development but wow, some of these people are so cruel and it was very uncomfortable to read. I can't recommend this one. All that being said, this narrator was awesome!

Was this review helpful?

After three hours in and a couple of times trying...
I couldn't connect to the main character Georgiana. She was annoying, superficial, and blah. She's the cliche bookworm who dreams of excitement and, I'm not like other girls. After having one night of fun, she decides that she won't try to befriend anyone else. It's Frances or nothing. Of course, Frances is a hot mess. Where is the romance or Bridgerton meets Gossip Girl part? I'm totally getting the Mean girls vibes but not the others. All we know about the love interest(or who I believe is) is he is not interested in Georgiana and likes to brush his horse. Dreamy. All of the characters are unnecessity mean or clueless. The narrator is great though the story, romance, characters are not there. 2/5

Was this review helpful?

The description of this book is right, it really did remind me of mean girls!!

I went to with the mindset that it was going to be a lighter read that it was so I was surprised. I loved how they really played the idea home that just because you are from a "better" family doesn't mean you are a better person.

And to add bisexual and gay characters in a book for this period and to have this be knowledge to other characters was interesting. Just like Georgiana thought people to see in higher social status are not held down by the same rules and regulations that everyone else is. Add in the fact that history is not as whitewashed as people think it is, I thought it was an interesting reflection on past as well as present.

One of the things I didn't like was the number of characters to keep track of. I am a person who doesn't always do well with tons of POV changes, so keeping track of everyone took a bit of work.

Was this review helpful?

Described as "Gossip Girl meets Jane Austen," I was excited to read this irreverent take on the traditional regency romance. I'm not sure what I think about the result, though. The first third almost had me putting it down, and yet I kept reading despite how much I loathed almost every single character. The writing is quite good, and I actually like how Lex Croucher turned the traditional regency romp upside down. Georgiana is a young woman who longs for friendship and adventure, and when she befriends Frances, the wild child of the ton, she falls headfirst into a world of dazzling parties, handsome men, and illicit assignations. But is this life everything she'd hoped it would be?

The audiobook is what helped me actually get through the rest of the book, because Bessie Carter is a phenomenal narrator. Her wonderful performance brought the characters to life,

Georgiana does eventually find her redemption and gets her happily ever after, but the journey there was fairly terrible. I think if I'd read this ten or even five years ago, I would have found it funny and enjoyable. But I was just bothered by how terrible the ton treated people they believed to be below them. I know it happened but the cuts were vicious, like Mean Girls on steroids.

I would give it 4 stars for the quality of writing, but 2 stars for plot, so maybe it all evens out at 3 stars?

Trigger warnings for rape, attempted rape, drug use, alcoholism, absentee parents, assault

Was this review helpful?

Lex Croucher delivers a delightful, sometimes thought provoking mash-up of modern morals and Jane Austen era trappings. The main character, similar to stories from the early 19th century, is a young woman of modest means who dreams of entering high society. When opportunity strikes, she discovers much more than she'd dreamed of. The mix of strong characters, semi-familiar themes, and enough description to help readers envision a scene without limiting their imaginations creates a sometimes frothy, sometimes weighty tale of romance, debauchery, social norms, with a gratifying ending.

Was this review helpful?

If you liked Bridgerton, you will love this book. I love how charismatic and hilarious the characters in this book were. I found myself laughing out loud multiple times. This book is drama-filled and follows Georgiana's life in the regency era. When they described this book as Gossip Girl meets Bridgerton, I knew I had to read it and I have to admit that it did not disappoint.

Was this review helpful?

As a girl who grew up in the early 2000’s “Mean Girls” is a movie that lives in my mind rent-free. “Reputation” by Lex Croucher brought back all the drama and angst that I have been craving in a book, tv series, or movie for a long time.

A period drama for the ages that is sure to be enjoyed by plenty of readers alike. We get to follow along as the main character Georgiana blooms into herself, learns right from wrong, and breaks the rules of traditional high society.

Through new friendships, betrayal, and tons of promiscuity we are introduced to a unique cast of characters. A character of importance is one Frances Campbell who carelessly oozes impropriety. You love to hate her, but her involvement with Georgiana is essential to the development of the story and her importance can not be understated – after all, everyone knows a Frances.

The blossoming romance between Georgiana and Thomas Hawksley leaves the reader wanting more and yearning to flip the page just to see what is bound to happen next. There are countless ups and downs, embarrassing encounters, and unexpected surprises.

If you love regency drama, forbidden romance, and relatable characters this coming of age novel is a great read. No leaf is left unturned and the character development is noteworthy. The audiobook narrated by Bessie Carter, otherwise known as Prudence Featherington in Netflix’s star show Bridgerton, does a wonderful job, entices the reader perfectly, and helps keep one interested in the story and on the tips of their toes. I cannot recommend giving this one a read, or a listen, more as you won’t regret it.

Was this review helpful?