The story was ok. I didn’t really love the writing but it was tolerable. In saying that there was a lot of cringey moments calling private parts “lady parts” and outdated language about bodies and age weren’t really favourable. I did struggle to connect to the characters because of this. Also, the scene in the park with the phone vibrating was just 10/10 nope

In this book, we follow Gemma, a woman who dreams of having a baby despite being abandoned by her husband a decade ago due to fertility issues. Determined to start a family on her own terms, she turns to IVF and enlists the help of an unexpected source—Josh, her brother’s best friend, as her sperm donor. What seems like a simple, no-strings-attached arrangement quickly spirals into a complicated journey neither of them saw coming.

The book beautifully delves into the emotional rollercoaster of infertility, a deeply significant issue today. The author skillfully highlights both the personal struggles and the importance of having a strong support system during such difficult times. The story is poignant, raw, and relatable, making it a thought-provoking read.

Although I’m not an expert in contemporary romance, I found myself wishing for more depth in the side characters' storylines, which could have added an extra layer to the narrative.

Special thanks to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

#JoshandGemmaMakeaBaby #NetGalley

This book was not for me. I unfortunately couldn't get attached to any of the characters and grew bored after a while.

I really enjoyed this book! Josh and Gemma were so much fun together. While a tad predictable, I still had so much fun reading this book. It was my first book from Sarah Ready but it won't be my last.

This book was too cringy to really enjoy. Between the random “kinks”, the comments about “bad” bodies and age, it just wasn't very enjoyable.

It was okay. I was not blown away with the characters and the plot but all fell a little flat for me. I love The cover.

I really wanted to like this book but unfortunately it was not for me. It didn't feel realistic even with an interesting premise

I really wanted to like this book but unfortunately it was not for me. It didn't feel realistic even with an interesting premise

This book was a cute read. I loved the dynamics between Josh and Gemma. I do however like to note that Gemma's backstory for this book was quite heavy and at times was a bit much, as in the sense we (as the readers) were constantly greiving for her and what she'd gone through. With that being said, this book was a fun read and there were a lot of moments where I did find myself laughing a lot at.

This book was pretty good, despite the on the nose title. I do love myself a pregnancy trope and this filled the spot. It was a cute romcom and brother's best friend, I mean, love love love.

Josh and Gemma Make a Baby is a wonderful book which brings to light tough topics without making me feel heavy and I enjoyed every second of reading.

I CANNOT SAY ENOUGH GOOD THINGS ABOUT THIS BOOK! so sweet and romantic and heartfelt and funny and unique.

This was cute even if she did cringingly refer to her “lady parts” several times. There were some weird British-isms thrown in too, like Hoover and shagging (and, well, the name Gemma) that I’m pretty sure native New Yorkers would never say. And Jello salad with carrots and apples

"Josh and Gemma Make a Baby" is a heartwarming and humorous romance novel. Sarah Ready has created a story that is both entertaining and emotionally resonant. With well-developed characters and witty dialogue, The author manages to handle the sensitive topics of infertility and miscarriage with a light-hearted touch, making it easier for readers to connect with the struggles that Gemma has gone through. Ready's ability to infuse humor into such serious subjects adds depth to the narrative while still maintaining a sense of empathy towards Gemma's experiences. Josh's affection for Gemma is apparent throughout their interactions. The story is filled with cute and humorous moments, making it a delightful read. Additionally, the writing style is engaging and enjoyable. I will be reading the sequel.

Gemma is looking to have a baby with her brother’s best friend Josh. She has fertility issues and this seems to be the only way to go about this. TW for those with fertility issues. IVF is involved. And this topic is close to my heart. This is nicely done and humor is done to help this along. These two are great together. This was the first book by this author and I would read another one.

I received this ARC through the publisher and I am voluntarily reviewing this book, opinions are my own.

Very well written book. Really enjoyed this author, would definitely read more by this author and recommend on my book IG

This book was enjoyable! I was not immediately drawn to the characters, but I was interested in the plot, as it contained just enough "trope" to satisfy my itch for something that would be quick and fun. Over time, I grew to enjoy the main characters. One aspect I liked about this title in particular was that it didn't shy away from the "muckier" aspects of becoming a mother, including IVF and miscarriage.

This was a cute read with plenty of swoonworthy moments! I loved the chemistry between Josh and Gemma and found myself laughing out loud at times too. Thank you, NetGalley, for the ARC!

So, I just wrapped up "Josh and Gemma Make a Baby," but honestly, I couldn't quite get into it. Despite the romcom premise, the plot felt a bit too unbelievable from the start.

Gemma's New Year's resolution to have a baby with her brother's best friend, Josh, seemed like a stretch. The idea of making such a life-changing decision in a strictly businesslike way didn't quite resonate with me. The unemotional agreement to create a baby takes unexpected turns, but the journey felt a bit forced, making it challenging for me to connect with the characters. "Josh and Gemma Make a Baby" just didn't hit the mark for me in terms of believability and engagement.

As someone battling infertility, I wasn't sure what I was expecting, but wow! This was fantastic. It was so romantic and quirky and emotional! I couldn't put it down!