Member Reviews

While I tend to think of myself as a fantasy reader, I've come to really appreciate Ms. Moreno-Garcia's incredible flexibility in writing across so many genres. A re-telling (re-imagining may be a better word) for the sci-fi classic, The Island of Dr. Moreau, this novel follows his daughter in the wilds of Mexico. The writing is beautiful and lush and really teleports you to the setting. I also love her characters-- the female characters in particular are always so relatable to me. Carlota here is a young woman who comes out of her shell, going from a dutiful daughter to a strong woman who speaks up and questions what she has been told or raised upon.

I will continue to read all of Ms. Moreno-Garcia's books and support her pool of endless creativity.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting take on the Doctor Moreau tale, as always Silvia Moreno-Garcia does a wonderful job with her descriptive and evocative language. She gives an interesting perspective on the story coming from the viewpoint of a PoC, placing Moreau through the lens of colonialism. Very cool!

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book I've read by Silvia Moreno Garcia, but it won't be the last. There was a time in the middle where I couldn't see where it was going, but it came together nicely. Readers would benefit from some background on the history of race in the Yucatan region. I think all women will identify with Carlota in many ways.

Was this review helpful?

The Daughter of Doctor Moreau is a reimagined telling of The Island of Doctor Moreau but set in 1800s Mexico in the Yacatun peninsula. Carlota Moreau was raised in a seemingly idyllic jungle home, along with the animal-human hybrids created by her doctor father. Grumpy British majordomo Montgomery Laughton oversees the hacienda and is sometimes a friend and often a frustration to her. She loves her home, adores her father, and sees the hybrids as family. When the son of the Doctor’s patron comes for a visit, everything is turned upside down. Faced with the prospect of marrying and leaving her home, Carlota is torn and begins asking questions, finding that her father has been keeping more secrets than she could have ever imagined.

With the backdrop of war mixed with gorgeous descriptions of the land and her people, this story gives in turn love and heartbreak, promises given and promises broken, loyalty and betrayal, and at its heart a young woman who is desperate to find herself and keep her loved ones safe.

I loved Mexican Gothic by this author, and I loved this book even more. Five stars, I would absolutely recommend it to anyone.

I received a complimentary copy of this book to read and review. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing- Ballantine for the opportunity to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

4.75/5 stars
I was lucky enough to receive an ARC of Silvia Moreno Garcia's new book and I was not disappointed! Silvia Moreno-Garcia is a beautiful story teller especially when it comes to weaving together metaphors and imagery to build her worlds to comment on themes such as colonization, class, what's deemed civilized and proper and perfection and the impossible search for it. Themes of power and advancement bring the question of when it stops being for the greater good and becomes more about playing God. The characters were well developed and I loved the protagonist Carlota. I love a protagonist who becomes a strong mujer que no se deja and Carlota did not disappoint! I also now need a telenovela of this book or movie filmed like an old black and white movie because I kept picturing it as one while reading.

Was this review helpful?

the daughter of doctor moreau is an exciting historical sci-fi that has the characteristic silvia moreno-garcia flair, but lacks the intrigue and stakes that i've grown to expect from her. overall, while i did enjoy this book, i didn't feel like it was one of her best.
starting with the positives, i loved how the science fiction and historical elements were blended immaculately. i don't think i've ever read a book that melds these two genres together, but this book has left me wanting more of this style. i also really liked the worldbuilding and felt as though i was living at yaxaktun with carlota and montgomery. carlota was my favorite character and i found her arc to be well fleshed out and intriguing, if i a bit slow. eduardo was also incredibly interesting to read about and i do wish we saw more of him.
that being said, i wasn't as invested in the story as i'd have liked and i felt that the twist came about a lot later than i was expected. my main issue was with the pacing: by the time i hit the 40% mark, i felt like nothing had happened except for laying the groundwork of the story. i also felt that montgomery should have had more time to shine on his own outside of his relationship with dr. moreau and carlota.
like i said before, this was a super interesting novel with an exciting climax, but fell short in terms of pacing and characterization.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book so much. Inspired by The Island of Doctor Moreau by H.G. Wells, Silvia Moreno-Garcia weaves an incredible story of science gone awry, found family, belief, and colonialism. This is the best kind of vintage science fiction, shot through with history that only makes the themes of the story even deeper.

I am always on the hunt for great Latinx speculative fiction -- there's simply not enough! -- and I'm so glad that I was able to read this gem early.

Was this review helpful?

I haven’t read the HG Wells novel which introduces us to the eccentric and morally challenged Dr. Moreau. This version was sumptuous, exotic and innocent, just like the hybrids he created.
Carlotta is the doctors daughter, a seemly pampered princess whose everyday existence is so gentle and sedate you almost believe there is little fire in this girls belly. The way Moreno-Garcia writes the first section, you feel like you are visiting a day spa and I could hear calming music and smell delicious anxiety reducing scents. That’s why the scene with the young ones in the laboratory packs such a punch.
The complexities of all the broken characters is delicately balanced with the moral and religious thoughts and how each individual finds there own way to make sense of what they see. You sense the doom that is to come as it seeps through the beautiful paradise Carlotta believes it to be.
A stunning version of a classic tale. Thank you Netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

The story of The Daughter of Dr. Moreau is told from his daughter’s point of view, Carlotta, and his majordomo, Montgomery. The pair alternate every other chapter. There are interesting themes around family, femininity, home and religion. I quite liked the lush descriptions of the house and it’s grounds. I wasn’t sure what Montgomery’s very specifically Eurocentric backstory or the time lapse added to the plot. I was impressed with Carlota’s character development. She liberated herself from successive paternalistic influences. I didn’t find that I connected or deeply identified with any of the characters.

Was this review helpful?

Didn't love as much as Mexican Gothic but very fun retelling / expansion of The Island of Dr. Moreau. Will read anything Moreno-Garcia writes, tbh.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely love Silvia Moreno-Garcia! Her writing just blows me away with every new book I read. This woman deserves an award!
Mexican Gothic and Velvet Was the Night were both such phenomenal reads when I seen another new upcoming novel I prayed Del Rey would approve! 😘 thank you!

The Daughter of Doctor Moreau is an reimagining of The Island of Doctor Moreau set against the backdrop of nineteenth-century Mexico. And man if she didn't do the damn thing!
A historical and science fiction novel that completely took me by surprise and had me hanging onto every word. I was hooked.
It's fascinating, compelling, intricate, superbly-written that will have her fans wanting more.
An unputdownable novel from an author who can seemingly tackle any genre.

Is it selfish of me to already want/need another book when this one hasn't even been released yet? I just love her!

“I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.”

Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine|Del Rey,
Thank You for your generosity and gifting me a copy of this amazing eARC!
I will post my review to my platforms, blog, B&N and Waterstone closer to pub date.

Was this review helpful?

I'd previously read Silvia Moreno-Garcia's "Mexican Gothic" so upon hearing about "The Daughter of Doctor Moreau", immediately added it to my TBR list. In a nutshell: it did not disappoint.

"The Daughter of Doctor Moreau" follows the events that unfold across the residents of the Yaxaktun region in Mexico, focusing on our protagonist, Carlota Moreau. She's the daughter of Doctor Moreau, the scientist and head of house, who spends much of his time in his lab, creating "hybrids" for their benefactor and sponsor, the powerful and wealthy Lizalde family. The Moreaus are assisted by their majordomo, Montgomery Laughton, an outcast from the UK who has his own personal demons to deal with. Things start unraveling when Eduardo Lizalde, the son of the wealthy Lizalde family, encounters Carlota and the two seem to fall in love... until the layers of truth are revealed and threatens to dissolve the very foundation that everyone has.

I definitely have a greater appreciation of Moreno-Garcia's writing after reading this; the characters felt much more complex vs. the ones in "Mexican Gothic" and I found that there were many more takeaways and major themes that she covered incredibly well here - the ostracization and unequal treatment of different groups of people in society, the expectations held of women, and the complexity and breadth of relationships that can exist today. This felt like such a rewarding read, and I loved the character development of Carlota and the other residents of the Yaxaktun.

Very excited to recommend this novel when it is published in July 2022!

Was this review helpful?

The books The Island of Doctor Moreau written by H. G. Wells (1896), and The Daughter of Dr. Moreau by Silvia Moreno-Garcia (7/19/22) explore scientific, ethical, religious, and philosophical themes. In both of these, Dr. Moreau is a someone who views and treats people and animals as commodities: neither better than the other, and existing solely for his experimental procedures. He esteems himself as the moral and religious leader, never to be questioned or disobeyed: someone who has been chosen by God to perfect creation.

In Silvia Moreno-Garcia’s book, Dr. Moreau has a daughter named Carlota that he has raised on his own teaching her that she is to be meek, gentle, and obedient: just like his hybrids. She is the most precious of his possessions in that her beauty can be used in his quest for further funding for his experiments. The doctor has made a deal with his benefactor to produce workers—the hybrids—for his land. However, he has not given over any of his creations to him, and his funding as about to be cancelled.

This is a many layered novel that is filled with horror, romance, coming-of-age, prejudice, and misogyny. You find yourself wondering: who or what are the true monsters?

This is the third novel by Silvia Moreno-Garcia that I’ve read. What I like is her ability to bring up deep and disturbing issues within a beautifully told story. This is an exceptional and fresh retelling that is respectful to the original by H. G. Wells.

I whole-heartedly recommend this book.

I would like to thank NetGalley and Del Rey Publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

Carlota Moreau is a young woman growing up on an isolated estate on the Yucatán peninsula. Her father, the brilliant Dr. Moreau, has the patronage of a rich man to build a hybrid species to replace menial labor in the area. But to Carlota, the hybrids are family and friends. As Dr. Moreau's funds run out and the rich man's son comes calling, Carlota's fragile world starts to crumble.

Silvia Moreno-Garcia does it again. The Daughter of Doctor Moreau, like Certain Dark Things or Mexican Gothic, flips its parental genre (or story, in this case) on its head and examines the underlying themes of racism, miscegenation, and hubris.

Moreno-Garcia's versatility is astounding. Each of her books I've read has been in a different subgenre and an absolute treasure in its own right. If you're looking to calibrate expectations, I can't help you here other than to say this is certainly worth reading.

Highly recommended, like all of Moreno-Garcia's books.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Random House - Ballantine, Del Rey, and NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

All I have to say is wow! The author has done it again! The Daughter of Doctor Moreau by Silvia Moreno-Garcia is an amazing blend of historical and science fiction that will appeal to fans of the author's previous works. The story revolves around Carlota Moreau, a young woman who lives with her doctor/scientist father on a remote peninsula. But they're not alone. When Montgomery arrives at their mansion in order to become Dr. Moreau's new assistant, he finds more than he's bargaining for.

Here is an enchanting excerpt from Chapter 1:

"As she stepped forward into the room she wondered if they could hear her heart beating, like the song of the clock.
Her father turned toward her and smiled. “Here is my housekeeper with my daughter. Carlota, come here,” he said. She hurried to her father’s side, and he placed a hand on her shoulder as he spoke. “Gentlemen, may I present my daughter, Carlota. This is Mr. Lizalde and this here is Mr. Laughton.”
“How do you do?” she said, automatically, like the well-trained parrot that slept in its cage in the corner. “I trust your trip has been pleasant.”"

Overall, The Daughter of Doctor Moreau is an absolutely amazing retelling that will have you turning the pages for more. I started this book while on a flight, and I could not put it down until I finished. One highlight of this book is how original it is. It's not often that I read blends of historical fiction and science fiction, and the author did it perfectly. I predict that this book will become a classic in those genres. Another highlight of this book are the characters. I loved the action and the romance, but the characters made it all worth reading. I especially liked reading about Carlota's relationships with her friends. If you're intrigued by the excerpt, or if you're a fan of Silvia Garcia-Moreno, you won't regret checking out this book when it comes out in July!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing a free ebook ARC of The Daughter of Doctor Moreau.

I really enjoyed this story, purposely reading The Island of Doctor Moreau before it. It is inspired by the original and not really a prequel or retelling so much as a re-imagining. This story is a combination of science-fiction and romance with a setting based on history. I could see this book being turned into an interesting film.

While I highly recommend this book in general, the issues that I don't mind so much, but I know some people might not enjoy include: a slow start, some slow pacing in the middle, and a drawn-out conclusion.

Was this review helpful?

The newest book by Garcia releases in July. This is a sci-fi/historical fiction novel that takes place in Mexico. Carlota is the daughter of Dr Moreau-a Dr/Scientist who has created hybrids between humans and animals. This is a beautiful coming of age story about Carlotta.

Was this review helpful?

What a delightful read. With a lush setting deep in the Yucatan, and mostly set the vibrant Hacienda Yaxaktun, we are giving a bird’s eye view into Doctor Moreau world. If I say too much it gives the story away about his experiments, and life with his daughter Carlota, and the other strange inhabitants.
The book is very well written, and you can almost feel the oppressive heat beading off the pages. Even though the book is loosely inspired by the novel The Island of Doctor by H.G. Wells, this book takes on a historical journey as well, into the political climate of Mexico, the real fight (The Caste War) that began in 1847 and how it played out for the native Maya people against the Mexicans, that were European-descended, and mixed.
In the end, this book is worth your time.

Was this review helpful?

Great retelling from the daughter’s POV. But, a little slow for my own preference. Loved the details, I actually felt like I was there at times when I got immersed reading. Definitely the reason why I rush to purchase any special editions by Silvia Moreno-Garcia.

Was this review helpful?

Doctor Moreau had to be my favorite “horror” stories growing up, and SMG did a fantastic job telling a fresh story from a different POV, and telling yet a different story and different lessons, as it’s told by the doctor’s daughter, who lives alongside her father’s creations. SMG is one of my auto-buy authors, and this book was not a let down. I actually wished that there were more pages for me to consume. The world building, while slow, is strong and detailed, which pulls the reader into the books universe easily.

Was this review helpful?