Member Reviews

Having previously read one of Lisa's books in this series, I was anxious to continue but unfortunately was unable to find adequate time to read. I have it on my list for future reading as Lisa's style is engaging and I find her relating of her subject matter to be well presented and very readable

Was this review helpful?

What a compelling follow on from Signed. A Paddy. Loved the first book and this one does not disappoint. Following the love and life of Rosaleen once more was so enjoyable. Very well written, strong characters and a great storyline is perfect.

Thank you Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

I loved every bit of Lisa Boyle’s debut novel “Signed, A Paddy” and the second book in this series, “Dear Inmate”, did not disappoint. In The first installment we meet Rosaleen, a young girl who is forced to flee Ireland and the famine after her parents die. The author really does a fantastic job developing her character and I continued to be amazed at her strength, courage and perseverance. The author does an excellent job describing the struggles Irish immigrants endured daily, the blatant prejudice and maltreatment, yet no matter what was thrown Rosaleen’s way, she continued to fight the oppression around her. So young and so brave. I couldn’t help but stand by her and cheer!

Thank you to Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advanced readers copy of this fantastic book. Highly recommend for historical fiction fans.

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautifully woven story of friendship, secrets, hope and longing. Each page is a fantabulous addition to the story, and the research that Lisa Boyle puts into creating this story truly stands out. ⁣ I read the first book, "Signed A Paddy" it was excellent. This second book in the series is excellent as well. Set in Massachusetts, 1854 we follow Rosaleen's journey and how the Irish are viewed at that time period. There will be a third novel coming out next year "With Great Sorrow" and I will be waiting for it!!!!

Was this review helpful?

The much anticipated sequel to Signed, A Paddy... he writing was INCREDIBLE! I’ve never highlighted so many sections of a book before, but there were just so many beautifully written passages that I knew I indeed to save to come back to.

Was this review helpful?

Lisa Boyle is an Indy author I found through a book tour and I am so glad I did. In our second book about the life of Rosaleen she is still trying to better he loves of those around her. But at what cost? I will forever be a fan of this author.

Was this review helpful?

Dear Inmate is the second book in the Paddy Series. I love that we get to continue following Rosaleen as she fights for her fellow Irish immigrants and corruption. This book is so rich in historical details. I enjoyed getting to learn more about a time period that I don't know much about.

Book 2 in the series picks right up were book 1 ended. I loved continuing on the characters journeys alongside them. If you haven't read book 1 Signed, A Paddy yet, I highly recommend you grab a copy.

Was this review helpful?

Book two in this series continues to be just as engrossing and as book 1. I really enjoyed following Rosaleen to see where life takes her. Very strong and inspiring protagonist. Historical fiction at its finest. Thank you netgalley and publisher for this arc in exchange of an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Even though it had been almost a year since I read Book 1 of this series (Signed, A Paddy), I feel like I picked up where I left off with Rosaleen, Emmett, Mr. Joyce, and the rest of the crew. Historical fiction was my first reading love, and it was fun to read about a time and place I don't know too much about - the life of Irish immigrants in Massachusetts in the 1850's. I loved that this book had love, mystery, action, and everyday life. The ending was great because it wrapped things up nicely but still left the reader wanting more!

Was this review helpful?

If you haven’t read Lisa Boyle’s book Signed, A. Paddy, book 1 in the Paddy series, you need to go ahead and pick it up, because you will definitely want to read book 2 Dear Inmate. Lisa Boyle has done it again as she brings back Rosaleen, an Irish immigrant living in Lowel, MA.

Dear Inmate starts off with dramatic action and won’t let go of you until the end and will still have you wanting for more. To watch Rosaleen and her friends growth through these two books will have you running through a gamut of emotions. This story will have you asking the question, how do you know who your true friends are and can they be trusted? Not everyone is what they seem.

Lisa Boyle does a masterful job in the telling of this story and the struggles of not only Irish immigrants but the struggle of others too. Rosaleen continues with her secret letters from Signed, A. Paddy and will have you rooting for her success. Boyle also sets the reader up for book 3 of this series so be ready to read them all.

Thank you #netgalley and #victoryediting,netgalleycoop for allowing me to read this ARC. All opinions expressed above are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed "Dear Inmate" probably a little more than I enjoyed the first book in this series, "Signed, A Paddy," as this book had more excitement towards the end. I found the main characters, Rosaleen and Emmet, very likeable, although my heart broke for the Irish living in Lowell and the hardships and prejudice they had to cope with every day. Unfortunately both books had unsatisfying endings. I know that this is a planned series of books but I feel like they probably should have been one book rather than two. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC of this novel.

Was this review helpful?

An amazing book loved the characters and hoe they have developed between the books.
Please note you have to read Signed A paddy the previous book before reading this one else you won't understand anything .the current book starts a few years after the first with both main characters married and rise of extreme anti immigrant parties

Was this review helpful?

Determined to make a difference, Rosaleen continues writing her anonymous Signed, A Paddy letters to spread the word about the harsh, intolerable conditions Irish immigrants and others experience in Lowell and elsewhere. The Irish are being harassed and arrested for questionable reasons, and many end up at the poor farm. When Rosaleen discovers that numbers of people sent to the poor farm are being released under suspicious circumstances, she is determined to find out why those released early are not returning home. Not everyone can be trusted and getting more involved can be dangerous. Reading Rosaleen’s story reminds us of the hopeful proof that one person, then two people, and more, can work to make positive change.

Thank you, Net Galley and Lisa Boyle, for this opportunity to read an advance reader copy of Dear Inmate. My own print copy is on preorder, and I am looking forward to the next book in the Paddy Series!

Was this review helpful?

Dear Inmate is the sequel to Signed, a Paddy and continues the story of Rosaleen, an Irish immigrant who finds work in the Lowell mills. As she builds her life in the US, she sees the benefits and advantages of life in America, but she also sees the holes and gaps that allow injustice to thrive. She takes stands against slavery, the Fugitive Slave Act, and the secret deportations of Irish criminals and poor by writing anonymous letters which she signs as “a Paddy.” Newly married, Rosaleen has the support of her husband Emmett as well as her true friends, but she also makes powerful and desperate enemies who work to reveal her identity and make her pay for the damage she has done to the Know Nothing’s efforts to target and restrict immigration and immigrant rights. At the peak of her success when she has secured an end to the deportations of poor Irish and Irish criminals, she finds herself in desperate need of help, and she can only hope that her friends and allies can help before it is too late.

Dear Inmate is an engrossing and uplifting story of courage and resilience. Rosaleen uses her own past trauma to fuel her generosity and kindness to others. Rather than thinking of her own safety, she places the welfare of others above her own welfare, and she is indefatigable in her efforts to fight for justice. Rosaleen is a character whom readers will love and admire. She is a true role model, and Boyle’s story celebrates her.

While the story is gripping and the stakes are high, there are many subplots and supporting storylines that feel rushed. I would love to have Mr. Joyce’s story developed more fully, as well as the stories of Ina, Nancy and Calvin, Ruth, and so many others. Many of the characters are rich and varied, and each could add more to the story, but the pacing feels rushed and touches on subplots without fully developing them. Similarly, Boyle does not give much background or review of the first volume in her series. She mentions characters like Nancy, Ronan, Ruth, and others in passing, trusting that readers will have read and will remember her first volume. In reality, some readers may not have read Signed, a Paddy, and those who have may not remember the characters. Better introductions and reviews of characters would help readers get even more out of this story. Finally, Boyle’s first volume was originally classified as a young adult historical, but it has since been reclassified as general historical fiction (adult). This book Is even more removed from the young adult sphere, touching on Rosaleen’s first sexual experience as a married woman, and it is peppered with harsher language and mild profanity. Some readers will see the more mature tone shift.

Overall, Boyle weaves a complex story that draws readers in and surprises them with an unexpected ending. I appreciate the strong qualities of the main character, but the story could’ be even stronger if the many subplots were either streamlined or given the time necessary to fully develop them.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really enjoyable read. It was a well researched and well written storyline that was based on some real people/ real events that I hadnt known about, or known much about before this book. If you like hostrical fiction that has an element of mystery then this a book for you.

Was this review helpful?

Set in 1854 Massachusetts Dear Inmate is the second in The Paddy Series, a beautiful series I am so happy to have discovered! The opening begins with a bang and the story contains angst, tension and turmoil throughout with the powerful Know-Nothings group against the Irish and slavery abolitionists. The Irish are not only ostracized but also abused and the Black people are enslaved and forcefully deported. Thankfully the Irish revolt and stand up for those without a voice to fight for freedoms. As the author notes, some characters are based on real people, as are some events. Despair is beautifully balanced by romance, friendships, loyalty and hope.

Rosaleen has now matured into a loyal young lady whose resolve is strengthened by gaining tiny steps in the big war (which is often uphill). Her confidence has blossomed and she and those closest to her take on the crowds and get involved politically, though extremely challenging and exhausting. Who does one trust?

My favourite aspects of this book are the relationships, especially the sweet one between Rosaleen and Angel which is told through letters in which Rosaleen is a mentor of sorts. I was invested in the characters the entire time. The mystery element is also enjoyable as are the Dear Paddy references. Learning more of the Fugitive Slave Law is interesting as well.

My sincere thank you to Victory Editing NetGalley Co-op and NetGalley for the privilege of reading this wonderful book. Though not necessary to enjoy Book 2, do read Book 1 as well for context. I wonder what Book 3 will reveal! What a great entry point for new Historical Fiction readers as well as for those who, like me, have read it for years.

Was this review helpful?