Member Reviews

Lovely book that validates the students fears from a lock down drill but redirects them to coping strategies such as being with others, finding peace/beauty, hobbies, nature.

Was this review helpful?

It is a great book for young elementary school children! During these difficult times of school shootings and worries about school safety, this story highlights the feelings of a child who had a lockdown drill at school. I think many young children are feeling the same way but don’t know how to verbalize their feelings.

This could be used as a whole class lesson that opens up a class discussion about feelings and school safety. If there is a child who seems withdrawn or worried, this might be a good book to read one-on-one.

It also might be a good book for parents to read with their young children. By sharing this story, children can learn that sharing their feelings with an adult can help them feel better.

I would highly recommend this book to teachers and parents. If you read it, please let me know what you think.

Was this review helpful?

A very timely story done very well. Grandpa picks Ava up at school. He has an afternoon of painting in the park planned, but Ava doesn't feel like it. She admits that they had a lockdown drill at school. It scared her. He tells her about drills they had when he was in school. The world is both a beautiful and scary place, but he is always there for her. She can talk to him about anything.
This book should be shared with all school aged children. Unfortunately these have become all too common in schools these days.

Was this review helpful?

Cute story with nice graphics. I like how it shows respect for a child's feelings, not forcing the child to tell the feelings, but instead allows the time needed. I'd recommend this to parents to read to their child.

Was this review helpful?

I love the spirit of this book. This picture book addressed the stress that young people must be in due to the idea of school shootings and the drills they must do to prepare for them. I think the execution of such a deep topic is not where it needs to be, however. I get that this is meant to open the door to communication and that most parents would like to have control of what they tell their children, but I still feel that there could have been more substance to this book. It doesn't need to go into detail on the subject, but it does need to be impactful. I don't think children will find this impactful and I also don't think it will make them question things. In that aspect, I do believe this book has failed in its objective. I do, however, give it points for trying this objective and I do think we need more books tackling this sensitive subject.

Was this review helpful?

I didn’t really like this book at all. I thought it was dismissive of Ava’s feelings and the experiences of students who have either been in a school shooting or a drill to prepare for one. It was weird from the get go that when Ava expressed sadness, her grandpa didn’t ask her why, but rather pushed her to do something she didn’t want to do. The book is 30 pages but only 5 of them actually really address school shootings. And even then, the grandad is sort of dismissive and they don’t have a conversation about how to help her through her fears or that her fears are not only real but important.

Was this review helpful?

One Thursday Afternoon is a special read aloud book. The story focused on Ava’s reaction to a lock down drill in school, a place where she had felt safe in the past. Her grandfather listening to Ava and allowing her to address her fears made the book a perfect way to open the discussions about how to help student’s fears.

Along with the wonderful words is a story in pictures that highlights the specialness of the words. Ava’s expressions and thoughts were well documented and her grandfather was a great listener for Ava. Ava and her Granddad painting outside enjoying nature helped her face the world.

One Thursday Afternoon was a great read that really would be a good addition to any school or town library.

Was this review helpful?

Such a topic, that we should not have to be writing about, yet, as a member of a public school system, we do have lock-down drills, just like fire alarm drills. This book, by Barbara DiLorenzo, fits the bill. A child, coming home, out of sorts and a wise grandfather, who offers quiet, nature and his peace to give her strength and security. I will be recommending this book for our classroom and others. The illustrations are beautiful. Thanks to NetGalley, Flyaway Books and Ms DiLorenzo for the preread in exchange for an honest review. I look forward to seeing the book as a paperback vs the e-reader copy which I read.

Was this review helpful?

It's unfortunate that this book is necessary in today's world. However, I loved how the story was delivered. It spoke about feelings, and how when you are upset, how one should focus on all of the senses as a distraction. It's comforting for a child to know that an adult they trust also feels scared at times, but to focus on the beauty in life. The message was good, and I would recommend this to children who are going through *that* phase at school

Was this review helpful?

As a mom and a teacher, this is a must read book. Children are hearing things all over the news about school shootings. This book takes the Lockdown Drill and breaks down through a sweet story with a grandfather and his granddaughter. Grandpa talks about how he was scared when he had “Duck and Cover” drills when he was little. Ava shares how scared she was in school during the drill.
This takes a scary subject and shows children that yes, the world can be scary, but there is also beauty in it. A great follow up project would be to have the children draw a picture of something that is beautiful to them.
I want to thank Flyaway Books and NetGalley for a complimentary copy of the book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.

Was this review helpful?

This is a good read for schools. It touches on emotions kids are facing far to often. It can help open conversations for parents and teachers. It shows kids it’s ok to feel sad, scared and how talking and doing activities can help you feel better.

Was this review helpful?

A real nice book with soft warm colors & illustrations.....that young & old(er!) can appreciate. And a good story & advice to go along with it. It's a real well done book.....it might help start some good conversations between parents/grandparents & children. I'd say this would be a good book to have in any library.
I received an e-ARC of this book from publisher Flyaway Books via NetGalley, & in return I offer this my own fair & honest review of it. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

This book thoughtfully addresses lockdown/active shooter drills in schools today with the little girl's reaction to her school's drill earlier that day. Her grandpa is patient and thoughtful and he validates her feelings, all of which are very good ways to address traumatic experiences. I feel that the comparison to Duck and Cover drills was a bit out of touch. I also wish the author had asked a licensed family therapist about advice to give parents about recognizing the signs to bring their children to get help for the anxiety and trauma that these drills can cause.

Was this review helpful?

A sad but necessary book. The illustrations are beautiful and the loving relationship between the girl and her grandfather is lovely. Although this book cannot provide total comfort or answers--who can for this terrible reality?--it should be helpful to both children and caregivers to see that they are not alone in their fears and that talking about and listening to the concerns is important. I'll definitely buy this book for my library and recommend it as needed. Many thanks to Flyaway Books and NetGalley for an e-ARC of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Great picture book for lower elementary students talking about the scary reality of students having to have lock down drills and no longer feeling that school is a safe place. This book could lead to some important conversations in the classroom as well as reminding students of the beauty of the world. Lovely illustrations. I would definitely use this with my second grade students.

Was this review helpful?

It is really sad that this book has to exist, but I am glad that it does. It is well written and gentle with what could be a really harsh topic. I think it would be great to read in the classroom before or after a drill or for parents at home as a way to begin a conversation with their kids. I loved how the endpapers changed. In the beginning they are a scene from Ava's classroom and at the end they are a calm scene of the nature trail they were on, showing the change in Ava's thoughts and emotions by the end of the book. Ava's grandfather is adorable and he demonstrates the importance of being kind and listening to each other.

Was this review helpful?

A gentle, subtle story that would work well as a read aloud. A great conversation starter and wonderful modeling for children and caregivers on how to provide space and quiet to express feelings. I will be recommending this especially for children who don't naturally talk about feelings easily.

Was this review helpful?

I wish this book didn't have to exist, but here we are. Children have been doing some version of safety drills for years but in this environment that we currently find ourselves in, the drills feel so much more important...and terrifying. As a parent and former teacher, I have seen first hand what these drills do to kids and have seen the look of panic in there young eyes. In this story, I appreciate how the grandfather validates Ava's feelings instead of brushing them off and it offers a suggestion for when you are feeling overwhelmed (get in nature, create, talk to someone). I think this would be an appropriate book for all elementary school classrooms.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This book hits the crux of all our fears about the violence that is permeating society. Not just schools but shopping malls, churches, grocery stores and other places large groups gather there is the potential for attacks. The author has taken a difficult topic and approaches it in the best way possible. Just listen. We all need to hear that. Thank you Ms. DiLorenzo for writing this book.
I received an advanced reader copy for free from NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving my review.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley who gave me this ebook in exchange for an honest review. Lockdown drills are scary, especially with the dramatic increase in school shootings. It is heartbreaking that children have to endure the trauma of lockdown drills. This timely book does an excellent job of describing what lockdown drills are like and how they can affect children. It's too bad we need books like this. Smart teacher will give students a chase to talk about their feelings. While lockdown drills will continue to be scary, hopefully it will help children better understand. This is a must read book before the first lockdown of the school year.

Was this review helpful?