4 out of 5 stars - If you ask me, I'll tell you to read it.

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine, Dell for this advanced copy. All opinions are my own.

This is the story of Marnie, owner of Wish & Co, a personalized gift buying service used by the wealthy. She researches the gift recipient to find the best gifts for them. Until it all goes wrong and she accidentally sends gifts to the wrong people, a customer's wife and mistress.

I have always loved the idea of being a personal shopper for someone. I like shopping and helping to find the right thing, but I never considered the moral issues that could come up!

I enjoyed getting to know the characters of this story. I will have to keep my eyes open for other books by this author.

This was a super light-hearted and easy read. The book was a bit shallow but I think that is fine for some books. It felt a little like a hallmark movie to me. I do think the story could have wrapped up sooner but I still enjoyed reading it.

OK, so the whole premise/plot of this book involves infidelity, both the discovery and forgiveness of. If that is a trigger for you, this is not your book. Also, what is up with that cover? I know "flat" artwork is popular but the dude's face looks like a kid drew it. Anyway, I found it a bit hard to get invested in the main characters. I liked the setting and the author's style of writing though. I would definitely read another book by this author, even though this one didn't quite land for me.

Thank you to the publishers and NetGalley for the opportunity to review a temporary digital ARC in exchange for an unbiased review.

With Love From Wish and Co. by Minnie Darke is a charming story about someone who has a knack for finding a person their perfect gift and the people who hire her to do so. One mixup might ruin her, but she has a plan to fix her mistake and learn what she really wants in her life!

Thanks to #NetGalley and the publisher for providing a free copy in exchange for an honest review.

Marnie Fairchild has wanted one thing her entire life: to own the building that housed her grandfather’s store and to make it her own. When she has to rush off to get details on its sale, she makes a life altering mistake. She switches the gifts for Brian Charlesworth’s 40th wedding anniversary to his wife and his mistress’s birthday. Her premier gift buying service will take a hit for this error, and she can’t afford that with the building finally up for auction. And to make matters worse, she’s falling in love with Brian’s son, Luke.

With Love From Wish & Co. engaged my attention from the very first page until the end. Warm, full of emotion and drama, with like able quirky characters and humorous situations, I was entertained completely.

This author is new to me and I was really excited to read this one. i enjoyed it alot! Thank you so much for the opportunity to read and review this one. Can't wait for the next one!

I received a copy of this story from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

DNF: 25%

This cover looks so cute and the summary seemed like a lighthearted romance. Yes, it was clearly going to tackle some serious subjects like infidelity, but it didn't seem like a heavy read.

Unfortunately, it's TOO light. I got a quarter into the book and didn't care about any of the characters. I couldn't justify sinking more time into this story. It took too long to get to the pivotal incident - did we need that Luke storyline before the anniversary party? - and it was trying to do too much.

As many people have said, the chapters and their breakdown are weird. It's terrible to see that the next chapter is going to be 40+ minutes long when you're already struggling to stay interested.

This one isn't for me.

Marnie Fairchild opened Wish & Co to help clients get a personalized shopping experience. But when her most prized customer, Brian Charlesworth had her preparing TWO gifts - one for his wife and one for his mistress, she knows she might be in over her head.

After a disastrous gifting error, a complicated bid for a new storefront, Marnie feels lost. That is until a new love interest pops up…

Minnie Darke writes complex characters so well you can help but find yourself rooting for them. “Readers will have no trouble rooting for these flawed but lovable characters to learn, thrive, and find love.”

This is a light, fluffy and comfy read about love which was very predictable however, it was very sweet to read. This is a good one to take to the beach or sit in a comfy cozy corner while it's raining. Overall this is a good read and I enjoyed it. I would buy it for my friends and go to the beach. Thanks to the publisher and NetGally for the opportunity to read this book and provide my unbiased opinion.

Marnie is an entrepreneur who's most recent venture is offering gift buying and wrapping services to wealthy clients who have complicated lives in a small town in Australia. With a whopper of a mistake that threatens the lifeblood of her business, Marnie struggles through the ordeal with valour and turns it around to once again be helpful to those in her community. Then a new relationship comes into play with complications that could lead to more unhappiness for a certain family. The characters are rich, the story sweet and an overall good read. A great break from my usual murder & mayhem. Got to love a story in a small town with colorful characters and the intimate look at how friendships work together for the good of the community.
Good job, Minnie Darke!
Thank you to Random House Publishing and NetGalley for an ARC of this book.

2 stars

I enjoyed this book but I didn't absolutely love it. it felt very middle of the road for me, I don't remember much of what actually happened in this book. I Kind of feel like the book was a little too long. The characters were just ok, I didn't really connect with them, I also kind of feel like we ended up in a not-so-great cycle with Marnie and her gift buying for Brian, I just didn't care for the process.

I think I would be more likely to recommend this if you like books that don't have a lot of depth and are just looking for something easy to read.

Thank you to Netgalley and Random House Ballantine for an eARC in exchange for my honest thoughts

In this novel, Marnie runs a personalized high end gift buying service. But when she accidentally mixes up the gifts intended for an important client’s wife and mistress, her plans for her business are endangered. Interspersed with Marnie’s viewpoint are chapters from the POV’s of the client, Brian, his wife, Suzanne, and his son Luke who has a bit of a meet cute with Marnie. So this book has work drama, family drama, and romance as well.

This is the third book by Minnie Darke and the third I’ve read by her, and I really enjoyed all three. Her books are sweet and cute, light and fun but with emotions too. Sort of like an Australian Sophie Kinsella or Marian Keyes, perhaps.

I really love Marnie's job. In fact, it was the best part of this book. The way she goes about things and her relationship with Luke is the worst part of this book. Luke is just mean. #sorrynotsorry they made the worst couple because of it and I didn't forgive and forget as easily as Marnie. Because of this, I give this book ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Thank you NetGalley and publisher for this ARC publication for an honest review.

With Love from Wish & Co.
by Minnie Darke
Pub Date: 16 Aug 2022

I am going to be honest, while there was nothing wrong with the writing. I found the idea of a professional "gift giver" interesting, I think the fact that our heroine, Marnie, buying for the wife and the "other woman" just felt wrong. There were definitely some cute and romantic moments between her and Luke, but overall, the book was just okay for me. I think it truly was "it's me" not so much the book. I would still read another of her works.

I love a good rom-com, and With Love, from Wish & Co., by Minnie Drake, has all the ingredients for a delicious story. There's the career-driven 30'ish woman and her friends who have all paired up. There's a hunky furniture builder who still hasn't found true love. But, I also found lots of unique elements that aren't usually found in this genre. As much as this is a story about 30-somethings finding love, there is also an older married couple who are trying to come to grips with their marriage. Along with many happy times, there are difficulties, and betrayals that must be addressed if they want their relationship to continue. And it's not a simple question of whether or not to forgive. The author never judges the characters, and this helps to make these people actual humans, with lots of problems. Each of the characters has their issues, and their charm. I really enjoyed this novel for it's gift-giving advice, as well as it's romance. And, even though it seems at first to be following a formula, there were lots of twists and turns that kept this book a real page-turner. I highly recommend this book.

What I Liked:

Characters:

Marnie is a successful business owner who is always working. She runs a successful gift-giving service, mostly for wealthy men who don't have the time (and don't want to be bothered) to shop for gifts. She genuinely loves what she does. But this doesn't leave much time for a social life. Even when she's off the clock she is doing research by scouring social media for gift giving ideas for her clients. But she is really driven to prove to her father's family that she is an upstanding, hard-working person. There's a whole history to this that I don't want to spoil. But it makes for a compelling motivation on Marnie's part.

Luke is the son of Marnie's most important client, and she has been "buying" gifts for him for years. When they meet IRL, the sparks fly! Even though it feels to Marnie that she already knows him, there are parts of his life that he hasn't shared on social media. He's just found out he has a daughter. What will his parents think? Should Luke get to know his daughter, or is it too late?

Suzanne and Brian are Luke's parents and are going through a VERY rough patch. At first, I would say that Brian is pure evil, but as the story progresses, we begin to see his motivations. I would not say his character ever became completely likable, but I certainly didn't think him the as the devil incarnate by the end. Suzanne, far from being the sweet little stay at home mom, has lots of fire left in her. If Brian wants to stay married to Suzanne, he's going to need to work for it.

The Art of Gift-Giving:

Since Marnie's business is all about gift-giving, there are many interesting takes on what a good gift is, and how one can go about finding it. There are many great tips that I intend to try out for myself, as Christmas approaches. Don't know what someone's interests are? Look on their Instagram and Facebook accounts to see what they're talking about. Don't have lots of money? Create an experience for them that is unforgettable. I loved this!

But, all fun aside, I really enjoyed that the author took the time to really make Marnie's business interesting. You could really see someone having a business like this. Rather than making this just a quirky detail of the character, it actually enriched the story.

Marnie Fairchild is a professional gift buyer. She has a knock for buying the perfect gifts for her clients. That is until one day, she has amajor mix up. Brian Charlesworth’s anniversary gift to his wife gets mixed up with the birthday gift for his mistress. In order to save her business, she come up with an idea to help Brian try to win his wife back.
This was a light-hearted, easy read. It didn’t have as much of a romance storyline as I would have liked. I felt that the romance with Marnie and Luke was just all of a sudden happening without much buildup. What I really loved was the concept of Marnie’s business. The fact that she can figure out the perfect gift for someone just by “stalking” their social media pages. It’s honestly a brilliant idea and I’m surprised I haven’t heard of this being a real business. This is told from the point of view of several characters and it gives you great perspective on exactly what’s going on with everyone, instead of trying to guess. Overall, I enjoyed the book and love the idea of Marnie’s business.

The recommendation for this book arrived from the publisher way back in April and me being me assumed I'd have PLENTY of time to read it before it was published.* But then I didn't read it early, we got a puppy and I started school, so yeah needless to say it took me a lot longer to read than expected.

Thankfully it wasn't the writing or the story that forced the long delay! For the most part, the story kept me engaged and moving forward with only a few slower spots or wait what moments.

With Love from Wish & Co. Is the story of Marnie Fairchild, a professional gift buyer who makes a HUGE mistake that causes major drama for her business and her best client. There wasn't anything groundbreaking about the story, you could see what was coming when it was coming and why it was coming from miles away. And I'm not talking just about the mistake, but the love interests, the family store, it was all very expected, but that didn't take away from Darke's writing or storytelling.

The one unexpected curve ball was Luke's surprise (the main love interest). That one definitely caught me off guard and I felt helped shape and grow his character even though we didn't really know him before the big reveal but learned more via flashback. I could've done with less of the client story, but it was intricately tied to Marnie and Luke. I'll even say the mistress being included added to the overall story and Darke's decision to use her as the epilogue and not the main protagonists worked and left the core story in a good place and provided growth and movement for two minor characters.

The best part of Darke's writing was the setting for me. The way she had Marnie describe her grandfather's store at various times really sold the story and Marnie's motivations for the entire story to me. There were other characters including Marnie's mom and Luke's siblings that paled in comparison to the character of both Wish & Co. (Marnie's current store) and Fairchild's (her grandfather's store).

Recommendation: This was a delightful read. There were a lot of characters and sub-plots but thankfully they were all unique and I was able to keep them separated. Darke could've simplified the novel significantly, but in the end, they all tied together and were resolved and each augmented the others. I'm not sure I'll seek Darke out in the future with so many MM Romances out there, but I'd definitely recommend her to others.

With Love From Wish & Co was a thought-provoking, entertaining read. As the book is set in Australia, I enjoyed learning new cultural references and slang. I admit, there were a few things I had to look up to understand the reference. I enjoyed my first book by Minnie Darke & will be adding her to my list of authors to pay attention to for new releases.

It took me a minute to get into this book. I don't know why really, in the end I loved it and was sad when I realized the next day I had finished it. Minnie Darke has a way with words.

I absolutely loved this story, in the beginning it was a bit of a slow start, Marnie sure did ramble quite a bit. Once it got going it was a nice flow and a great story. Marnie is owner of Wish & Co and really, really wants to buy a building that was once in her family, owned by her grandfather. It has been left to fall apart, was even partially ruined by a fire but rather than her uncle sell it to her and let her keep the family legacy of running a shop there he'd rather let it go. A series of unfortunate events (which I don't even understand how it happens!!) leads to trouble for Marnie right when she is on the verge of getting everything she wants.

Luke is the son of one of Marnie's best customers and recipient of her gifts. He doesn't feel like her service is as wonderful as Marnie's customers though and doesn't hesitate to say so. He has his own issues but of course things lead Luke and Marnie to spend more time together and secrets are always bound to come out ...

I feel like this story was well written. It's a tough topic and not everyone would agree with how the story goes but even though I'm one who would originally say - NEVER! It works. I found myself cheering on the story and enjoying all of the characters involved and really would love to read more. I would definitely read another book in the series if there is one. This is the first book I've read of Ms Darkes. I will have to look for others. 5 Stars for me.

Between 3 and ½ and 4 Stars.

A huge thank you to NetGalley and Random House Ballantine for my advanced copy of With Love from Wish & Co.

Things I Enjoyed-

✨ The Audio- With Love From Wish & Co is narrated by Zoe Carides. She did a fantastic job. She also narrated The Younger Wife by Sally Hepworth.

✨ The Writing- Minnie Darke's writing is very engaging. Especially the way she writes her characters.

✨ The Characters- I was invested. All of the characters were realistic and flawed.

Why This Wasn't a 5 Star-

The infidelity. I just can't get down.

Overall- a good read. I look forward to reading more by this author.