Translation is an important art. It makes other forms of art accessible to people more. This poem born out of the effort of a writer who translates one can see how delicate language is. It is why it takes time to translate books because a person is not just translating, he is conveying emotions and one wrong move could spell disaster.

I enjoyed reading this poem. Many of them are so relateable and wonderful that even after reading, your mind wanders back to it. A testament of the wonder of Ananda Devi's genius.

Loved this one. I really enjoyed the way the text was presented with the original poem and the translation. The whole process of translating poetry is so fascinating - how do you translate something that's so personal to the poet? How do you leave no trace of yourself in the translation? Should you even attempt it? - and I know just enough French to be able to really appreciate the work Ali has done here. I will admit that Devi's poetry was a little abstract for my personal tastes, but fans of Rupi Kaur, Nikita Gill, Trista Mateer etc will eat this one up.

I rarely read translated books but this one really got to me. I enjoyed that the original text was beside the English translation, that felt like a smart move. Both ananda devi and kazim ali are intelligent.

'Your ears strain to hear
The voices of those absent
Until the night at last
Agrees to speak to you.'

Such a visceral, vivid experience this collection was.

I know a poetry collection has touched me when it ignites my own need to discern the words, to dive deep into them and emerge as something different, someone new. The author created something abysmal here, connecting complex, thought-provoking images with rough, ferocious words. There is sadness behind them, but there are also rage and vehemence.

'You point your finger and the world bends
You focus your gaze and life itself kneels
But an equal stake you are denied.'

The author doesn't explore a single topic, but rather tangles multiple important ones in this complex web of emotions. I loved the majority of this collection, but the bits about writing probably touched me the most.

'without poetry you would have under your fingers only the skeleton of silence'

I would highly recommend this one! I'm glad I had the opportunity to experience these words.

'When the night agrees to speak to me
It is with its back turned'

Very lovely group of poems. Also, I loved the translation from French to English. The imagery was beautiful throughout.

When the Night Agrees to Speak to Me by Ananda Devi and translated by Kazim Ali is a collection of poems originally written in French. As someone who is learning French, it was interesting to have the juxtaposition of the original French work next to the translation. Along with this, the inclusion of the short note on translation and an interview between the translator and the author at the end of the book enhanced the experience of reading the works of poetry.
The only problem that was a hindrance while reading was because of the digital format. The formatting was off. On some instances, a paragraph of French prose got mixed in with the English translation.
Additionally, it would be helpful to have a few trigger warnings, or a mention of the themes addressed in the poem in the synopsis.

When The Night Agrees To Speak To Me is a striking and profound collection that delves into the heart of human experience with a raw and unflinching gaze. Ananda Devi’s poetic voice is powerful and evocative, masterfully capturing the complexities of identity, exile, and longing. Her words flow like a haunting melody, resonating deeply as they explore themes of love, loss, and the ever-present shadows of night.

Kazim Ali's translation preserves the intensity and lyrical beauty of Devi’s original work, making the poems accessible to a wider audience without losing their emotional depth or cultural richness. Each poem is a meditation on the human condition, often exploring the darker facets of existence with a sensitivity that is both unsettling and deeply moving.

Devi’s ability to blend the personal with the universal gives this collection a timeless quality, where the night becomes a metaphor for the unspoken and the unseen, a space where truths emerge in whispers. The imagery is vivid, often stark, yet there is a subtle tenderness woven throughout that invites readers to sit with their discomfort, to find beauty in the darkness.

When The Night Agrees To Speak To Me is a remarkable work of poetry, offering a window into the soul of one of the most compelling voices in contemporary literature. It is a must-read for those who seek poetry that challenges, provokes, and ultimately transforms.

Thank you, Harper Collins India, for the copy.

I actually love the entirety of this poetry collection. I am someone who knows and sees the void of emotions in women around me resulting from the trauma of everyday experiences.

This poetry collection describes exactly this and this collection needs to be read more. I feel this collection is very UNDERRATED!

For fans of Rupi Kaur and K.R. Meera, this is your perfect next read.

The translation is the best!

This was absolutely gorgeous. Thank you so much to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to experience this book for free. I will definitely be acquiring my own physical copy because I can’t see myself not thinking about a few of these pieces for a long time. Sincerely and genuinely, I loved reading this and I highly recommend it.

*This review is also posted on Goodreads

Poignant poems that require rereading and where meaning can be found again and again as the poems reveal more each time they are read. I love poetry that pulls from me even as it leaves it's mark behind and that is what Devi does here.

My first encounter with Ananda Devi’s work, and it was truly remarkable. Devi's poetry focuses on the colonial past of her homeland, Mauritius, evoking a wide range of emotions that mirror the surrounding waters of Mauritius.

This was an interesting collection of translated poems; I loved some and disliked some. The themes were appealing; and while not all of the poems flowed easily and somewhat felt rigid, others were simply great.

Thank you NetGalley for the advanced copy/early read opportunity!

A collection of poems with their translations, notes by the author and an interview with the author.
The themes of being a woman, vulnerability, politics, and rage appealed to me.
As for the writing style of the poems, I enjoyed some a bit more than others.
The length was ideal, though I am eager to read more by Devi on the same topics in other books.

2.5⭐ Thank you NetGalley for this arc. I enjoyed the smaller poems, but the longer ones felt too wordy, and they were a bit of a bother to read.

I didn’t enjoy the poetry in this collection. The pieces felt rigid and didn’t seem to have an easy flow to them. I understand that with translations, things get tricky to get every word over with the same meaning and feel, but if you read the two side by side, surely you’d notice the flow isn’t the same. I was looking forward to reading this collection but I couldn’t get myself to even like it.

it’s been a while since this was on my shelf and i finally got to read it. thank you so much for giving me this arc!

Gorgeous poetry! I've been trying to branch out with more poetry from other countries and this is brilliant. I have limited knowledge of French so I couldn't comment on the translation.

I would love to thank HarperCollins Publishers India, Ananda Devi and NetGalley for this ebook in exchange for an honest review.

I read this one last year in November and I appreciated that at the end we get to see a conversation with Kazim Ali, who translated this book in english for more people to read it. This collection had a big impact on him and he wanted the world to know about it.

The poems were strong and powerful, but something felt like missing for me. However, I recommend this one to readers that enjoy raw and honest poetry.

Thanks to Netgalley & the publisher for providing me with an E-Arc in exchange for an honest review!


4/5 Stars


I loved how we got the original poem next to the translated one, I really do, but some of the longer poems and texts have therefore some rather questionable formating choices. Not the books fault, but figured you might want to be aware of that.

Besides that, the book is really great. A lot of metaphors and symbolism and beautiful language to talk about sometimes not so beautiful things. There’s also a very long afterword that one shouldn't miss out on.

Good poems but they did not follow any theme that I could discern. The ebook was hard to follow in some places. I love that the French and English versions were included, but the longer poems switched back and forth from English to French mid-line/mid-paragraph, which really impacted the readability and flow.