Great Historical Novel with provoking social issues.
I‘m personally not the biggest fan of historical novels but this did capture me and while it took me a while to finish it that had nothing to do with the book itself.
It was very well written and thought provoking.
However at parts the story felt a bit dry and I found repeated typos, which if I notice them have to be pretty bad. So another round of editing might be a good idea.
Furthermore it annoyed me a little that obviously this is a story based on real people but not a lot is known about these people so a fair bit of the story is made up. I’m on the fence wether I liked finding out about this being very far from the reality at the end or if idbhave preferred it at the beginning.

Ultimately this was a nice read just not for me personally and the typos did annoy me a great deal but that’s about it. I’d definitely recommend it to my friends that are more into historical fiction.

This book was very well researched, and a very unique perspective. This book features conjoined twins born in 12th Century. A very insightful read and I really enjoyed this book and the information it provided.

I also want to thank Netgalley and the publisher for the advanced copy for my honest review.

I read this ARC for an honest review
All thoughts and opinions are mine

I have to admit I was drawn in by the cover and intrigued by its title
Absolutely loved this
Wonderfully well researched and loved the way it was written

couldn't put this down

It is rare that historical fiction with a unique perspective comes along. I certainly have no recollection of the genre featuring conjoined-twins so this made for a fascinating and insightful read.

Based on factual accounts of Eliza and Mary Chulkhurst who lived in Biddenden, Kent during the 12th century, the author has researched her subject and has given a voice to these two women.

It was interesting viewing the first half of 12th century society through their eyes. Although conjoined the author did an excellent job at portraying them as individuals. Both voices were distinct and at no point was I confused by which twin's thoughts or words I was reading. She allowed the reader to absorb their personalities through the words on the page and she did this extremely well.

Very enjoyable. I would like to think that Eliza and Mary did indeed have such fascinating and useful lives, albeit rather short. A great reimagining and fleshing out of what little is known of the Maids of Biddenden, a pair of conjoined twins born at the beginning of the 12th century. A good read indeed, and would recommend to others.
Many thanks to the publisher for a review copy.

The Maids of Biddenden chronicles the story of the Chalkhurst twins, Mary and Eliza, who were born joined at the hip, and given to live at Mailing Abbey because it was assumed they were the work of the devil. Perhaps it was hoped that the twins wouldn't survive long, but they did, cared for by Sister Agnes, and confined in a windowless room in the stables. By the time they were 6 years old, the Abbey complained that their upkeep drained its coffers (as they couldn't have other, paying students or guests) and that the girls needed to either pay up or go home. But this presented a problem, as their father had remarried, and his new wife was afraid of the girls--so afraid that she was not above foul play to remove the twins from her household. Resilient as always, the twins survived and grew to be not only accepted, but an integral part of their community, Mary followed in Sister Agnes' footsteps and grew to be knowledgeable in using herbs to heal, while Eliza entertained the villagers with her music.

After the portion of the book in which everyone tried to figure out what to do with the girls, what I enjoyed most was the negotiations between the twins as to how they would divide their time, with one girl always having to participate in the other girl's lessons, study, gardening, or practices. Readers who enjoyed Cheng and Eng will certainly enjoy this account of another set of successful conjoined twins.

An interesting idea but I’m afraid it just didn’t click for me, the writing was just not my style but I’m sure lots will disagree

The Maids of Biddenden is that rare beast which entirely absorbs the reader from page one. Helped by a flowing style of writing, and the immediate and impending danger that the twins find themselves in as six-year-olds, the reader is entirely absorbed in the story, and their fate, so much so that it's difficult to put the book down. That said, it is not just the twins themselves that drive the story - the people they interact with, those with their best and worst interests at heart - are all believable and well written, and there are occasions when the reader will be left frustrated and angered that some seem to face little punishment for their actions. The story has a number of points of view, and I found that they all worked very well - offering a view of the twins as they think of themselves, and also as others perceived them.

The story is effectively split in two; the first 45% tells the story of the Maids as young children. This element of the story is filled with a deep sense of foreboding that drives the story onward and makes the reader fearful for the future of the Maids. The narrative then moves forward a few years, and we see them as young women, trying to make a name for themselves and use their talents for good. At this point, the immediate landscape that the Maids encounter broadens considerably, and we move away from the nunnery and the settlement of Biddenden, into the politics and events of the early twelfth century, that almost consume the lives of the Maids for the remainder of their years - they lived during the time of the tragedy of the White Ship.

The story doesn't so much lose focus here, but because the impending danger has passed, the reader is instead absorbed in how the twins accomplish all that they do. There is a great deal of attention to detail here - both medical knowledge and music - and it's fascinating to see how the Maids' lives interact with known events from the period.

This is a delightful story. I was entirely engrossed and found myself snatching what time I could to carry on reading it - something that doesn't happen all that often. I highly, highly recommend The Maids of Biddenden for fans of historical fiction, and also for those who don't normally read the genre. The challenges that the twins face are well told, and the reaction their appearance sparks are conveyed well, although as the reader you will be offended by the prevailing belief that they are Godless and a monstrosity, and the fact that they were a 'sight to see' as opposed to always being appreciated for who they were and what they could accomplish. The historical notes at the back of the novel are also fascinating.

In a Nutshell: There are some books you read for prose, and some you read for the plot. This is in the latter category. Don’t expect flowery writing. Expect a touching story, though a tad longwinded.

Story Synopsis:
The story is based on the real-life “Maids of Biddenden”, a pair of conjoined twins who are supposed to have lived during the 11th-12th century.
Six year old Eliza and Mary have spent all their life in a local abbey, hidden away from the world because of their physical oddity. The locals have never seen/heard of conjoined twins and their superstitious behaviour leads to this decision. They have only two well-wishers – the prioress Mother Avicia and one of the nuns, Sister Agnes. Circumstances change and the twins find themselves moved to their birth home, where their father and stepmother stay. This transition isn’t easy but soon the twins win the locals over. The book provides a fictionalised version of how these twins might have lived in that irrational age.
The story is written in the first person point of view of the twins and a third person omniscient of the other characters.

Where the book worked for me:
😍 The author’s imagination seems to have covered all possible difficulties of living life as a conjoined twin. I’ve never read any book with conjoined characters, so this felt almost like an eye-opener.
😍 I’ve always seen nuns getting bashed in historical fiction. It was a welcome change to see at least a few positive portrayals of the religious.
😍 The personalities of the sisters are carved so well. Each of them is quite unlike the other and have distinct interests. Not once in the book is there any confusion about who is who. Eliza begins as confident and dominating while Mary is painfully shy. Their character growth happens steadily with every turn of the page.
😍 This is the first book I have read set prior to the 1600s and it was a novel experience. The atmosphere of the time period seems authentic. (I wasn’t sure about a couple of points but couldn’t find any answer to my query online. I’ll let this go as a creative call.) Right from lifestyle to clothes to beliefs to local customs, the book throws light on quite a lot. The patriarchal thinking and blind faith in the church and the king are the highlights. The writing style sounds very contemporary but I suppose this is a blessing as no one today would easily understand the English of that time.
😍 Before I requested this ARC, I had looked up who the maids of Biddenden were. Their story struck me as a combination of inspiring and tragic, but the most emotional part of their lives was how they died. I deeply respect the author for not turning their final moments into a circus. The end was written beautifully.
😍 I found it amazing to see how much of the local healing is similar to the Indian medicinal system of Ayurveda - keeping the humours/elements of the body in balance, using plants and herbs to tackle ailments, balance heat-inducing foods with cooling food and so on. I wonder why this knowledge has been lost over the centuries, leading to a blind dependence on allopathy. I am glad our knowledge of Ayurveda hasn’t suffered a similar fate. (Nothing against allopathy – I do resort to allopathic medicines too, but a balance is always good.)
😍 Don’t miss the author’s note. It explains wonderfully what is fact and what is fiction.


Where the book could have worked better for me:
☹ The book starts off wonderfully but at the midway mark, it becomes somewhat repetitive and starts dragging. The 400+ pages could easily have been condensed without losing any of the impact.
☹ The prose is very simplistic. If you are the kind of reader who looks forward to beautiful metaphors and lyrical phrases, that doesn’t happen here. This one is to be read strictly for the plot.


All through the story, I was wondering whether things might have happened similarly in real life. Would that innocent children have been subject to as much animosity and disdain just because of their physical oddity? I guess so. But whatever might have been the truth, the author has done a commendable job in ensuring that the maids of Biddenden are known to today’s society too. Their legacy still lasts in Kent; now it is known to a wider audience.

4.25 stars.

My thanks to Cameron Publicity & Marketing Ltd and NetGalley for the DRC of “The Maids of Biddenden”. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.

The book is also available on KU.

The Maids of Biddenden is a beautiful tale, and in many ways shows how society when educated can get over its preconceived notions and become more tolerant.

The Maids is the story of sisters that were conjoint twins. After they were born, they were given to a nunnery as their mother died in childbirth. Despite living under somewhat harsh conditions, the girls manage to thrive and are given back to their father and new wife as the nunnery was not able to care for them long term.

I do not want to give the story away, as the book unfolds with a heartful tale about how these girls managed to have a rich engaging life, despite their physical restrictions. The story is inspiring, overcoming obstacles, ignorance, and perceived ideas, and yet these two girls inspired so many. Based on a true story, the Maids of Biddenden were truly remarkable.

Thank you to the publisher for providing an advance reader copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

The Maids of Biddenden is a delightfully human piece of historical fiction, set in a rarely explored era = the middle Middle Ages. Well written and researched (to the point of slightly feeling like like there's a few peripheral characters included just because they existed in real life) this was a really interesting read, told in a compelling way. I loved that the focus wasn't just on how the main characters were perceived by the world, but how they themselves perceived themselves and others. Resilience, tenacity and sensitive to the lived experiences of those with disabilities, I would happily read more historical fiction from GD Harper in the future.

The Maids of Biddenden is inspired by the real-life story of conjoined twins Mary and Eliza Chulkhurst, born in 1100 into a wealthy family from a small Kent village. I was immediately hooked. A fast paced, effortlessly quick read where the pages just turned themselves and I was engaged throughout.

Two young girls sat cross-legged side-by-side each playing with a small rag doll. "As they moved their arms to play with the dolls, each anticipated the other's actions, an unconscious dance performed between them." These two young girls, born in the village of Biddenden in Kent in the summer of 1100, were twins conjoined at the hip.

Eliza and Mary Chulkhurst spent the first six years of their lives at Malling Abbey hidden from view, their upkeep funded by Thomas Chulkhurst, widower and wealthy farmer. It was thought that "they are made comfortable in their confinement...their corporeal selves are hale and hearty...they are of sound mind...minds wholly separate...Mary is quiet, lets Eliza do the talking." Daily, Sister Agnes took them for a walk the length of the abbey walls. Most impressive was Agnes's garden of healing herbs and plants used to remedy the abbey's medical ills. She was "their sole advocate amongst the obedientiaries."

According to Bishop Gundulf, the abbey's coffers were being stretched to the limit by the presence of the now six year olds. Merchants had been forbidden from visiting, thereby hampering commerce. The school to educate oblates and novices had closed, lest the pupils hear "the maids". Would the payment for the maids be discontinued since Thomas Chulkhurst's second marriage? The decision made would ultimately change the trajectory of Eliza and Mary's young lives.

With Bishop Gundulf's protectorate in hand, a hired oxcart drove Eliza and Mary to the Chulkhurst longhouse, Eliza and Mary hidden within, Sister Agnes and Stepmother Gudrun walking alongside. "Gudrun is neither mother nor kin to the maids." Her goals were nefarious. The next hotly contested hurdle was the meeting of the Hundred Court, where the village elders must determine whether the maids could move freely within the environs of Biddenden. "Are we now to shun those whose appearance displeases us?...Appraise others by their character, not the fineness of their features."

Many opportunities were denied to Eliza and Mary, however, unimaginable doors opened. Gifted with a lyre, later a vielle, Eliza became a well respected musician and writer of songs/poems. Mary became a skilled healer building upon observations made at the knee of Sister Agnes in her medicinal plant garden. Upon the deaths of Eliza and Mary, their joint will stipulated that rent collected from their lands, called "The Bread and Cheese Lands" would be used by the church wardens to minister to the elderly and poor. Donations are collected each Easter. This tradition, started nine hundred years ago, still continues.....

"The Maids of Biddenden" by GD Harper is a historical fiction read not to be missed! "When we eat our bread and onion, Eliza gulps always eating faster than Mary, when Eliza is full, Mary says she is too, even if she had only had a few mouthfuls..." "How many children are attached to each other?...That is why everyone cries when they meet us..." "Can two young maids really strike such fear in the heart of stout people?" Not if strong-willed individuals champion the acceptance of those of us who are physically or mentally challenged.

Thank you Cameron Publicity & Marketing Ltd and Net Galley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Inspired by the real life story of a conjoined twin, this historical fiction is wonderfully poignant mad dives quite deep taking its reader with it. I'll re-read this book again!

To say that The Maids of Biddenden was a great story does not express the depth of feeling I have for this book. The true story of Eliza and Mary, a set a conjoined twins who lived in 12th century England, is charming, riveting, full of heartache and joy. This fictional biography follows them from the time of their birth and upbringing in Malling Abbey throughout their life and many adventures with their parents Thomas and Gudrun Chulkhurst. Though there is no evidence that many of the events in this book transpired, it is a lovely tale of triumph over adversity and working together that I think everyone who is into historical fiction ought to read. I give this book 4 stars.

An interesting look at the attitudes of the time towards the two girls who were conjoined.
Also, how the girls were brought up, and how they felt about the way they were treated.
Following them on through their lives, where they shone as separate characters.
A story I knew nothing about, that's made me a bit more historically knowledgeable.

I have only ever read one other book about conjoined twins that I gave 5 stars too, and this was better so 5 stars doesn't seem quite enough. Incredible writing, fantastically gripping storyline and well developed characters that really popped off of the page. I loved it,

A sad and heartbreaking story that is also beautiful because the characters are beautiful souls that have to face the hate and prejudice of those unable to see past their exterior.

It's the story of two real-life conjoined twins, Mary and Eliza Chulkhurst, born in 12th century England, in the town of Biddenden in Kent to a wealthy farmer who could afford to keep them cared for in an abbey for their first half a dozen years of their life. When the girls, joined at the hip by birth, have to be taken from the abbey to live with their father, trouble ensues. First, it's their two-faced stepmother not having their best interest at heart as she pretends, and then it's the townspeople, who, urged on by the town priest, are initially hostile and superstitiously believe the girls are either a punishment from God or a product of the Devil. It takes a while, and lots of work and coordination between the few people able to see Mary and Eliza for what they are, just two unfortunate children not responsible for their condition instead of demonic work, for the girls to get accepted and thrive.

And thrive they do! Both girls show the world to be in possession of talents unique to them: Mary in healing and Eliza in music and poetry. The conjoined twins are so different from each other you can feel their desperation to be cleaved and be separate, but also can feel the deep love and loyalty they hold for each other. Mary, bookish and shy, and Eliza, brash and outgoing, have to learn to live supporting what the other does and wants, even if that means sacrificing their own desires. But they find contentment and earn the love and respect of those who know them, from nobles to peasants, even if there's always the occasional rude person taking it out on them.

Mary and Eliza are also the women who, on inheriting their father's wealth on his passing as his only children, set up the oldest charity in England, which the author says is still active nowadays, nine centuries later. This part was very remarkable.

What I loved the most is the progression in Mary and Eliza's character from childhood to the end of their days. When we meet them, they're six years old, and their POV shows it: both girls "speak" like children of that age in their early chapters; and then, as they become adults, their voice also changes so their respective latter chapters are different in tone. Interspersed in-between are universal narrator-style chapters that tell it from the standpoint of Sister Agnes, the nun who's been in charge of the Maids since birth, and the girls' father as well as some flashes by their stepmother Gudrun, so you get to see it from all angles. I usually don't like POVs that aren't consistently of one style, but I think it worked here, and I loved the girls' chapters best.

This is the kind of disability representation I like: accurate, non-preachy, non-agenda-pushing. Just tell how it's like to have a deformity or a disability, the hard parts and the challenging parts, showing how people are ableist and compassionate, loving or hostile, the blatant discrimination and the subtle ones. It was saddening to see how Mary and Eliza were treated, which makes you realise just how unfathomably hard it was for people with deformities and birth defects and disabilities in the past, when there was no state healthcare, no programmes to assist them, superstititon and wrong ideas circulated freely, etc. Mary and Eliza were fortunate that they had a rich father who was also a honest man and didn't have them disposed of or let them rot someplace like many would have, but imagine how many other children without the Chulkhurst girls' means perished and you feel grateful for the things we can enjoy today, even if not perfect.

It's so worth reading! I loved the story so much I didn't notice anything to criticise, it's been one of those rare books where the enjoyment of the story overwhelms any complaints I might have.

Based on real characters who lived in the early 12th century, the author has woven a very interesting tale about two girls joined at the hips from birth. Not much is known about Eliza and Mary. Both sisters lived their first 6 years hidden in a convent. When their keep got too expensive for the nuns, their father took them in his home. However, before this decision was made, there was much talk about what to actually do with these girls! Killing them was an option, as they were considered devil work.....
What I enjoyed in this novel is that the author adequately outlined people's superstitions, fear of the unknown of those days and the resulting behaviour of the nuns and the community towards the girls. Luckily not all of them felt that way and luckily for Eliza and Mary sister Agnes did nurture the sisters.... Alternating chapters written in the first person reveal how the girls feel towards each other and what they actually physically feel... I also found fascinating to read about how the father and sister Agnes fought to get the disabled girls integrated into the community.... Will they succeed? Will Mary and Eliza enjoy a fullfilled life? I really enjoyed this novel for which I got a digital ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.