Member Reviews
I love love love Ian McEwan, but I just have not been in the mood for this book the past few months. I hope that I'll come back and read it again someday, but for now, it is a DNF.
Lessons spans the life of Protagonist Roland Baines and the events that occur in his teenage years that shaped his life.
Longer than his usual novels, this book is slower moving but for lovers of descriptive writing and character development this book will not disappoint.
Thank you Knopf Doubleday and NetGalley for an ARC.
This book tracks Roland Baines from his childhood to old age. The author interweaves Roland’s life with a lot of significant historical events, up to COVID. I had a hard time getting into this book and skimmed part of the first half. At lot of time was spent on Roland’s molestation (at 11) and seduction (at 14 or 15) by his piano teacher Miriam. I so wanted Miriam to go to prison. I also disliked Roland’s selfish first wife, who abandoned Roland and their infant son.
I enjoy the author’s writing style, but it wasn’t until the last third of this book, probably beginning with Roland’s reckoning with the havoc that Miriam caused, that I started to like this book. The depiction of Roland’s relationship with his second wife was both realistic and quite moving, and I thought that the end of the book was very satisfying.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher.
I’m sorry but I DNF this one. I tried but had a really hard time reading it and just couldn’t get into a groove. That’s not to say anything about the content of the story. It just didn’t work for me.
Thank you NetGalley for this advanced copy.
Reading Hearts Invisible Furies was such a wonderful experience, I just had to read Lessons.
It was nothing that I expected at all. The sexual abuse and repeated sexual encounters that were described throughout the book in great detail were not pleasant to experience.
There was great character development and plot development. Parts of the book were very overly descriptive and excessive.
This is the story of Roland and his life from the time he is 14 and in private school until he is an elderly man. He experiences many international conflicts and wars and many changes of life and society. This is a story of complex relationships that keep coming back to you at various stages of life.
I loved "Atonement" and looked forward to another book by McEwan. Lessons covers a long period of time, 70 years I believe, and tells the story of a man's life, his youth at boarding school, his unlawful seduction by his piano teacher which changes him forever, abandonment by his parents and his wife, relationship with his son, etc. I wanted to feel sorry for him but sadly the way it's written this never deeply touched my emotions. It was a long slow read with beautiful writing that at times felt overdone. But, I'm glad I read it and will read anything McEwan writes,
This is an ambitious book my McEwan that is sure to be studied by literature students for years to come. There are many layers and it's a bit meta at points.
Where McEwan truly shines is in storytelling. Roland's story and family history is at points captivating, happy, sad, boring, complex...all things real life can be. It's messy and real. Though Roland is sharing his life from his perspective, McEwan deftly demonstrates there multiple sides to every story, and just as in real life, motivations behind decisions that aren't always clear.
Reading this book feels like sharing a drink with someone you're getting to know intimately. He ambles through his life, in many ways starting from his 'birth.' There are memories and people referenced I was occasionally interested to hear more about, but it wasn't my story. Roland either got there in his own time or instead talked about what he wanted the reader to know. Significant historical events - WWII, fall of the Berlin wall, COVID - all mark time in his life.
I was extremely satisfied with how this tome concluded, and the structure of the last chapter especially. I found myself wondering throughout how much of Roland is McEwan and vice versa due to a small bit of proselytizing. More prominent throughout, however, is beautiful and lyrical prose. These are the pieces I want to keep with me.
I received a free e-galley in exchange for an honest review of this novel.
I need to say it again. ARE THERE NO EDITORS? This well respected author writes the book of life and it dragged. Editing would have helped make this book a solid 5 but sadly, this was not done.
This was an extremely long, difficult read, and to be honest? Not sure it was enjoyable or worth it. Ian McEwan is obviously a genius, but that isn't reflected here.
How do you rate a book that seemed to drag and tempt you with the DNF aura?
So, what’s it all about? Roland Baines, in his eighties now, looks back on the events of his life and surely must have drawn some lessons from his experiences.
This one grew on me at times. I was considering not finishing “Lessons,” it seemed to lumber along and at well over 400 pages I was not sure the commitment was worth it. Roland is taking us on his entire lifetime journey to see what lessons life has taught him. I rarely give up on a book, particularly one by a distinguished author, so I pushed through.
Ian McEwan portrays Roland’s life against the social events happening in his world. Backdrops include the Cuban Missile Crisis, Chernobyl, the fall of the Berlin Wall, everything (everything) through the Covid pandemic. It is epic, but it is a lot.
When Roland was 14 he was seduced by his 25-year-old piano teacher and it progressed to her pressuring for marriage by the time he was 16. What this experience did to him never really gels– he spends the rest of his life puzzled over the effects. Later, another woman in his life, his wife Alissa, walks out on him and their infant in order to pursue what turns out to be a celebrated literary career, a contrast to his frustrating writing efforts. The last important woman in his life, Daphne, dies just as she looks to be the one he finally connects with. These women all have strong, dominating personalities– something sorely lacking in wishy-washy Roland.
Author Ian McEwan has drawn up some great characters and, at times, this novel really moves along. Too often, though, the social and historical passages only serve to slow things down. Roland watches and reacts to these events in much the same way he can only observe and react to the relationships in his life.
As strong as it is in parts, I cannot recommend “Lessons.” I understand sections of this work are semi-autobiographical, but I would have enjoyed a more streamlined novel featuring any of the more riveting female characters we see actually participating in life here.
Thank you to Knopf and NetGalley for providing the advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review.
Ian McEwan's latest in his enormous canon work, Lessons, is one of his most ambitious spanning multiple generations and the historical events which defined them. Despite its length - exceptionally long compared to the typical McEwan - Lessons is a rewarding read.
A wonderful novel about life by a trustworthy and celebrated author. I haven't read all of his books, but this is certainly one of his best.
This book covered 70 yrs of a man's life spanning Post WWII through the Pandemic. It chronicles the life of Roland Baines with the three most important women in his life.
His piano teacher who seduces him at age 11
His first wife who deserts him and their son and becomes a celebrated novelist in Germany
His Second wife who discovers she has terminal cancer the day after they decide to marry.
The author wove various historical events including the Cuban Missile Crisis, The Cold War, the fall of the Berlin Wall, the fall of the USSR, as well as Brexit, Covid-19. the shifting political views in England (where most of the story takes place),. and develops how thee events impact his life.
I felt that the beginning was painfully slow. Roland was not a likable character and I had trouble relating to him. He didn't seem to learn anything from these world events and their impact on his life, but remained a victim of circumstances and his poor decisions. Throughout most of the book, I felt a lack of personality in Roland, and a surrender to circumstances rather than an active attempt to learn from life experiences.
I was disappointed in this book as I have loved several previous books by this author.
I received an ARC from NetGalley and the publisher and am leaving this review voluntarily.
The novel is more substantial than McEwan’s other novels, which are mostly much shorter. But he is a master in prose writing style and the novel flows seamlessly. The main attraction is in the superb character development and, while there could be some autobiographical elements, the life issues facing Roland are relatable to a reader. The only quibble I have is that there is the lack of subtlety and depth in approaching the world events that ran parallel to Roland’s life. While the main concern was to show how they affect him, neither their impact was fundamental enough nor were new insights on these events offered to fully understand their role in the novel. All the same, an immersive read that would appeal to both McEwan’s old-time fans and novices alike.
My thanks to Knopf Doubleday and NetGalley for an ARC.
The Great European Novel, or something like that. “Lessons” follows Roland Baines while he faces two kind of collapses: the collapse of his inner world after his wife’s disappearance and the collapse of the outside world during the Chernobyl Disaster. A series of memories of childhood in Lybia in the 1950s up to the missile crisis in Cuba are triggered in a historical flow presented as a succession of cognitive collapses and readjustments to an ever changing world. An ambitious but not always successful novel that mixes exciting and enthralling parts with other slower and somewhat boring.
Many thanks to NetGalley for the ARC of this work. This author is a favorite of mine. And this new novel will likely disappoint any of his (many) fans. The story is very compelling. It is a quick read in that the reader will not want to put it down. So well-written and such an interesting story. Highly recommended. The story of 11-year old Roland Baines will stay with the reader long after.
This is a difficult one to review. Of course, McEwan’s writing is impeccable. His writing is so divine you can get lost in it. When it’s good, it’s really good, but when it’s not it’s… well… just dull. We follow the life of Roland Baines, and the ramifications of an event that takes place during his formative teenage years. I liked how the novel covered key historical events and the impact these had on our protagonist. There were key moments that were absolutely sublime, but there was lots of extra, irrelevant detail and I struggled not to skim-read in places.
If you’re looking for an epic saga, this is for you. It’s a slow read that you’re supposed to savour.
Ian McEwan is, without argument, one of the best novelists or our time. Lessons might be a blueprint of life, or just a chapter in the unwritten novel of the twenty first century, which Roland Baines, the protagonist, longs to read.
The novel covers Roland’s life, from first memories until old age. McEwan skillfully intertwines the history of the last century into his character’s lives, and those of us lucky enough to have lived through the same events relish the authenticity, factual as well as emotional. Sometimes, it was happening to us. Sometimes we were just distant observers. Along with a fair rendering of time, we are gifted with beautiful prose and fascinating characters. We have the pleasure of growing up and growing old with many of them. I highlighted pages of lines I loved, but as a woman of the age, this was one of my favorites. Describing his widowed mother, Roland says “... she had aged and shrunk, she couldn’t sleep, the skin under her eyes showed deep wrinkles like a walnut.”
This is a book to savor. It isn’t a quick and easy read and will need your attention and time. There are Lessons to learn if we are open to them.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher, Knofp Doubleday, for the review copy. Lessons was published September 13, 2022
Ian McEwen is an international treasure who’s written so many “perfect” works of art that reading a book that isn’t quite as good is a bit surprising. Lessons is such a book for me. The story threads about the main character Roland’s sexual abuse by a teacher, his relationship with his wife, and his single parenthood were so evocative and enlightening and absorbing. The broad recitation of all the major events of the 20th and 21st centuries were less so, and gave the book a Forrest Gump-like feel. It wasn’t terrible to read, but those parts of the book tended to drag things to a flat, emotionless level. Don’t get me wrong. I like emotionally withdrawn characters and feel like that was totally in character for Roland. I just found myself wishing that sections of the book felt less like reading a history book. I would still recommend this book—mediocre McEwen is still superior to many writers—but don’t go in with the highest hopes.
Loved this story - it took a bit of dedication to stick with Roland (dedication his wife lacked, to be sure!) but ultimately I couldn't put it down. What a sad, true, beautiful piece of fiction!