Member Reviews

Sarah Adams is my favorite author! I love everything she writes--Noah and Amelia are no exception! They have such great chemistry and the slow burn romance is captivating. I read When In Rome in less than 24 hours, which is how I am with all of Sarah's books. I loved all the side characters and hope to hear more of their stories! The small town of Rome was so charming and made me want to live there.

There was a lot more swearing and more spice🔥 than I'm used to with Sarah's books but overall it was a fun read!

Was this review helpful?

From the very beginning of this book, I knew I was going to be hooked. The writing style, along with the characters were so easy to fall in love with.

It’s a very slow burn, small town romance, with a grumpy pie shop owner and pop star that will be tugging at your heart strings (and hair, with how stubborn both of them are!) and begging for more before it’s even over with.

Amelia was so easy to relate to with her inner battles, and falling in love with Noah was impossible. The chemistry of the two will have you reading the entirety of the book before you even realize you’ve reached the last page.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to Netgalley and Random House Publishing for sending me an ARC!

4.5 Roman Holiday stars! ⭐️

Sarah Adams has done it again! I loved The Off Limits Rule, The Temporary Roomie and The Cheat Sheet, and When In Rome did not disappoint!! This book is very easy to get into and I did not want to stop reading.

When I tell you I stayed up until 4:30am reading this book, I mean it. The characters were so funny, Amelia is an absolute sweetheart and Noah is the definition of grump with a soft side😫

Tropes - grumpy x sunshine, celebrity romance, small town romance, MUTUAL PINING!

Content warning - mild language, mentions of death of parents, sick loved ones, heavy kissing/make out, some scenes I did skip because of hinted s*x

What age do I recommend this book for? I would say 17/18+

I loved this book so much! Take me to Rome, Kentucky so I can find me a Noah!😭

This book releases September 20, 2022! Thank you again so much Netgalley and Random House Publishing for my first ever ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I’ve read a lot of Sarah Adams’ books, and they’re all so cute and cozy! I liked the slow burn romance and grumpy/sunshine dynamic a lot. I wasn’t a big fan of Amelia’s word vomit because it made me outwardly cringe a lot, and I kept wondering what the odds are that someone who works in the public eye is truly so awful at speaking to others. I really enjoy classic romance movies and loved the nod to Roman Holiday. I’m going to continue looking out for more from Sarah Adams!

Was this review helpful?

**Review will be published Sep. 15th on Blog/Insta, etc!**

SARAH ADAMS DOES IT AGAIN.

I will never get tired of reading Sarah Adams’ books. They are EVERYTHING I love about contemporary romances and her unique and joyful spins on each story make me love every written word. I once again devoured another of her stories in a day and can easily add this to the list of romances I’d recommend you must read.

This story took some deep turns between Amelia and Noah. There was a lot of exploration of self and finding stable ground to move forward. Their meet-cute had me chuckling and all of the antics put a smile on my face. From learning to make pancakes, wearing matching pajamas, and meeting friends turned family, there’s much goodness to be had here.

The plot is a mix of fast and slow and I am so happy that all necessary resolutions were solved by the end. I love a happy ending that’s filled with everything needed to truly be HAPPY. This smile inducing story will just make you feel good.

I really loved the way Amelia and Noah found ways to love each other. The longing looks and subtle touches. And oh my goodness, the endlessly swoony and passionate kisses. Melt my heart perfection. I fell in love with this tiny town myself and all of the characters that I ran across. I BEG of someone to please provide stories for the other siblings (MUST HAVE) because Rome, Kentucky has plenty more to give.

Overall audience notes:
- Contemporary Romance
- Language: a little
- Romance: closed door
- Trigger/Content Warnings: loss of parents (off page but discussed), a grandparent with Alzheimer’s, mental health discussions, past cheating

Was this review helpful?

Ahhh! My heart is all warm and cozy from this adorably sweet book. I caught myself smiling so much.

Incredible pacing, characters, and plot that kept me hooked. I absolutely fell in love with both Amelia and Noah. This book had all of my favorite things…grumpy sunshine, slow burn, and small town romance. Not spicy but there is definitely tension. If you were a fan of It Happened One Summer, I would recommend this for sure.

I am dying for Noah’s sisters or James to get their own stories!

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

i absolutely loved this book, it was so cute and sweet i think i'm going to have to pay a visit to the dentist soon. i don't really like to describe books by tropes but this one was grumpy/sunshine excellence, amelia and noah were the cutest! other than the romance, i enjoyed reading all the scenes with emily, madison, and annie (noah's sister), and how the author was able to create the perfect small town atmosphere. this book was just pure delight and cuteness and i just couldn't put it down!

arc provided by random house publishing group - ballantine in exchange for an honest review.

i posted my review on goodreads on 30th april.

Was this review helpful?

Lovely, entertaining romance including stuck with you and sunshine meets the grump, famous girl meets the ordinary boy tropes with lots of “Roman Holiday” and one and the only Hepburn references!

Amelie a.k.a. Rae Rose, Princess of soulful pop, in her mid twenties, needs a break before her upcoming concert tour after millions of rehearsals, costume fitting seances, public appearances later!

She misses her estranged mom who tried to take advantage from her stardom status. Her demanding agent can be intimidating by intervene everything in her life. She is turned into a fake girl who is always polite, always smiling.

One night she’s inspired by Audrey Hepburn, watching Roman Holiday. Just like the movie, she feels like a princess who needs to take a break from her extra stressful life. She cannot fly to Rome as the princess did at the movie but she can drive through Rome, Kentucky, staying in a B&B, laying low, thinking about what she did wrong in her life.

But she finds herself stuck in her smoking broken car, at the front lawn of a very charming, intimidating, grumpy man: ladies and gentlemen, let’s get introduced to our brooding, kind hearted, isolated, pie-maker hero Noah Walker.

Noah reluctantly lets her stay at his guest room. He knows he is in real trouble as soon as the woman in distress walks in her house. Because she’s famous, she’s beautiful and she’s gold hearted, lovely woman! His heart has already been broken by another city girl a few years ago. He cannot let that happen again.

But it seems like her car’s repairing will take at least two weeks. Mabel, town’s bed& breakfast owner insists there’s no vacancy at her place. So they stuck together.

Noah who doesn’t use cellphone and also doesn’t have Wi-fi in his house, likes his own privacy but all the townies start prying his love life and excited to have a pop star visiting their place. How will he resist the charm of that adorable woman?

And Amelia, who already becomes friend with Noah’s lovely sisters, already adapted in her life in Rome. How could she go back to her old life when nothing has happened! How will she resist the charm of brooding pie-maker?

Overall: it’s sweet, heartwarming, entertaining romcom I highly recommended to the genre fans.

Special thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing for sharing this amazing digital reviewer copy with me in exchange my honest thoughts.

Was this review helpful?

When is Rome is Sarah Adams at her best. The vibes and the feels this book could elicit are everything.

The Characters are lovable from page one and my love for them only grew as i discovered more of them and fell in love all over again when i saw their journey as individuals and as a couple.

When in Rome is a story of discovering yourself as much as growing as a person. Both the Main Characters are so amazing i can't even pick a favourite. Commoner and Celebrity isn't a trope i am normally fond of but i can gladly make this an exception.

Was this review helpful?

I love this book! It’s a great read from start to finish. Noah and Amelia have a chemistry that doesn’t feel forced.

It’s a slow burn romance featuring a grumpy pie shop man not wanting to do anything with a sunshine-y, albeit burned out pop singer. Noah and Amelia have a chemistry that doesn’t feel forced.

I’m really hoping the supporting characters (James and the Walker sisters) get books as well.

Was this review helpful?

@authorsarahadams knows how to write a rom com! All of her books come to life and have you wishing the movie was already being made. When in Rome tells the story of Amelia, a burnt out pop star in need of a break, who finds herself inspired by Audrey Hepburn and winds up in Rome Kentucky. Amelia’s old car breaks down in Noah’s yard and everything changes for the better.

Noah is the perfect fun-loving, grump who’s incredibly caring but also very guarded and rightfully so. All of Noah’s hesitations were completely valid but couldn’t prevent his heart from falling head over heels for Amelia and wanting to be with her. Amelia grew so much from her time in Rome, she regained control of her life and found a home, a family, and an incredible love.

When in Rome is a fun rom com read full of ridiculous nicknames, small town busybodies and siblings, and lots of pancakes making it the perfect read when you need something to brighten your day!



Thank you @authorsarahadams and @randomhouse for this eARC in exchange for my honest feedback.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you SO much NetGalley and Random House!
I’ll be posting this pretty much immediately (hope that’s okay) on good reads.

Yes, I squealed when I saw I was approved for an early copy of this book.
Yes, I finished this book in one day.
Yes, it was better than I even expected. (Major Audrey Hepburn fan, and major Sarah Adams fan=I had pretty high expectations)
Yes, I got all the feels and girly giggles.
Yes, I will now go back and reread all her romcoms (some for the third time lol)

I loved Rome! Mabel!
Best of all-Amelia and Noah were perfect! From beginning to end. I love that it wasn’t just a relationship I saw change and grow, but they individually grew-and not into someone new, but who they were before whatever hurt happened.

Was this review helpful?

Sarah Adams has done it again. This book is just a perfect grumpy/sunshine, small town, famous person romance. I enjoyed reading this book and devoured it in 24 hours. Sarah has a way of getting you to relate to the characters and finding yourself in them. This book is a pure delight to all romance lovers.

Was this review helpful?

I am genuinely upset that I have to wait for September for the physical copy of this book! I cannot wait to have it on my shelf. Sarah Adams did it again.

If you like a good grumpy+sunshine, you definitely need to pick up this book. Also what is it about men who bake and are big softies for the ones they care about?

This book made me laugh, cry a little, and overall just happy (I kept finding myself smiling while reading). I loved all the characters in this book, and hope maybe there’s room to go back to Rome, Kentucky and be back in this world!

I will be talking this book up to everyone and making everyone read it! I loved it, and can’t wait for the next Sarah Adams book!

Was this review helpful?

I did not like When in Rome as much as I liked the Cheat Sheet, but I still really liked it. It's another romcom book, this time between a famous pop star, Amelia and a small town pie shop owner, Noah. Noah is a strong but tender man (; and I bet if he was my boyfriend he would make me a gluten free pie everyday. He's also a man with sisters, men with sisters are always better. I think this book accurately portrayed how stressful the life of somehow famous can be, this book had me biting my nails every time they had to hide from the paparazzi. I really liked the background characters and how the townspeople would try to conspire to get them together. It was a really cute read. Not too spicy, mostly fade to black. I'd recommend if you like the cheat sheet or romcoms that aren't super smutty but still sexy.

Was this review helpful?