Member Reviews
Short and sweet review time.
I’m a big fan of @ambergarzaauthor and really enjoy her storytelling. This one was no exception –– a slow burn with some excellent twists, wild revels and nothing as it seems.
Fast paced and filled with secrets and regrets, this one kept me turning the pages late into the night.
My thanks to @_mira_books_, @htpbooks and @netgalley for the opportunity to read this book before its publication date.
Valerie is a mother who now lives a quiet life alone. Her daughter is married and her son hasn’t wanted to spend time with her in years. But a medical condition makes her think that having her son Hudson move back home with benefit both of them. Trouble is a cloud has hung over Hudson for years and soon Valerie wonders if he is the child she loves or someone she should fear.
This one has plenty of twists and turns as we get to know Valerie and what happened all those years ago when her children were growing up. Most of the story is told from Valeries POV and probably the only thing that at times pulled me out of the story were some of Valerie‘s questionable decisions( chalk that up to her possible medical condition though). I saw part of the end coming but was still surprised when all the cards were laid out on the table. This one kept me flipping the pages to see how it would all turn out. 3.5 stars.
Disjointed storytelling plus unlikable characters made for a very meh experience.
Valerie is having memory issues, and since her own mother had early-onset Alzheimer's Disease, she's pretty sure that's what is going on with her. Her adult daughter Kendra is busy with her husband, baby, and attending nursing school, so Valerie invites her adult son Hudson to live with her to help her out. He's had some problems recently so he is in need of a change of scenery. Then someone in their neighborhood is murdered, and Valerie remembers another death in the past. Could Hudson possibly be involved?
I had so many issues during my reading of this book. The storylines are scattered all over the place, and some things are brought up and then abandoned, never to be seen again. Valerie was a terrible mother when her kids were growing up, and I didn't really care one bit about her, even though she was the one we are supposed to root for. She takes risks and does things that no one would do, and then she covers things up until it's impossible for her to do so anymore.
About 80% into the book the narrative jarringly switches from Valerie's first person perspective to someone else's and it took a while to figure out who was narrating at that point. It happens a couple of other times as well. The book also goes between past and present without any sort of indication that this is happening so it's a matter of playing catch-up every time to try to get back into the flow of the story.
This could have been a decent novel if the random switches in time and narrator were fixed, but for me it was just too disjointed to get into the flow of the story and appreciate the twists as they are revealed.
I’ve read all of Garza’a books and this is BY FAR her best one! My hand kept flying to my mouth in shock! It has more spins than the teacup ride at Disneyland! I love the first person perspectives and the nonlinear timelines! Two of my favorite things in books! Days later and I can’t stop thinking about that ending!
I did not expect where this story was going at all!
Synopsis: Valerie is suffering from memory lapses and fears it's due to early-onset Alzheimers like her mother had. Needing help, she asks her son Hudson, who fled town right after high school, to help her out at home. At first, Valerie is determined to repair their relationship. However, shortly after Hudson's arrival a local woman is found murdered and she begins to question everything she knows about her son.
Overall, this was a fast-paced and twisty psychological thriller that did the unreliable narrator trope well. I liked how the author highlighted how sibling tension, careless parenting and childhood mistakes can impact the present and dived into that internal dilemma of what to do when you think someone you loved did something wrong. The one negative is that there were a ton of sudden shifts in the POVs and timelines without a font change or chapter break. This got confusing and had me rereading often. If you typically listen to audiobooks, this is one where I'd say skip the listen and read.
Pub date : 12/13
Really liked this one. Also using this as a place to show my support for the Harper Collins union. Thank you to Harper for the gifted ARC my honest review.
The structure of this eARC was quite messy in my opinion. The book was mostly written from the main character Valeries POV. Her past to present switched really abruptly and I had a hard time following for a while. The transitions were really unclear and by the time I got the the end of the book I realized that I may have been missing POV changes from Valerie back to her son, Hudson along the way. I’m hoping this won’t be the case once the final copy is published. This book started out with a pretty creepy paranormal element but then it fizzled out and popped back up at the end. For me, I could have done with out it. I really didn’t dislike this book, the twists were pretty neat and I didn’t see them coming but there were a lot of unanswered questions at the end. What bothered me was that the police work wasn’t convincing. I was super obvious that things were missed or overlooked and a really unrealistic way. I’m looking forward to hearing more about this book once published because I believe it has the potential to be better. I feel that I would have enjoyed the story a lot more if it wasn’t for the structure.
Thank you netgalley for this eARC
With a slow start and an astounding finish, this book surprised me with its unexpected twists and the backstory that accompanied them. The plot was tightly woven and the story was fascinating. Valerie is a mother who is suffering from memory loss so her son Hudson comes home to be with her. Her daughter Kendra is a nurse so delegates herself to reminding her mom to take special vitamins to help her memory. Nothing, not one thing, is as it seems it this book. The deception between the characters is as real as that that the readers face. I enjoyed getting to know the characters and all of their many layers. It seemed that once I felt as though I understood a character, there was another revelation that made me question my assumptions. The plot was equally multi-layered, with a lot of secrets hidden and methodically revealed. I would call this domestic suspense and recommend it for those who want to solve the puzzle of the family relationship that never quite got off the ground.
Disclaimer
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255, “Guidelines Concerning the Use of Testimonials and Endorsements in Advertising.”
Ms Garza’s books keep getting better and better!
I don’t want to spoil, but I definitely did not see the twist coming! On the surface of domestic, psychological thriller, but also a fairly deep look at motherhood, family, and loyalty.
Definitely one of my favorite thrillers this year. Easy five out of five.
What a whirlwind, this fast paced tale had me turning page after page, Here you have a story about a mother named Valerie facing concerning health problems that have her questioning everything. Valerie’s adult son Hudson returns home to help and is at odds with his sister Kendra who is also involved with Valerie. When a murder nearby starts dredging up deaths from the past, everyone is a suspect, especially Hudson. The death toll climbs and doubt is around every corner. I love how this tale mixed in the past and the future and different character perspective. This one truly kept me guessing right up until the very end.
I was gifted an ARC of this story from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Although I adore Amber Garza's writing style, A Mother Would Know was too slow for me. I almost gave up on the book numerous times. Things heated up 85 percent into the book. It was a good ending which is reflected in my rating. Thanks for the advance review copy.
A son moves back home to help watch over his mother. The neighbor across the street has blamed him for killing her daughter for years. When she and another woman in the neighborhood end up murdered, Valerie searches for proof her son is innocent.
I kept trying to guess who was the killer and then there was that moment like Ah-Ha! I still second guessed the culprit, and I still wasn't right. This book took me in a few different directions but it kept me on my toes.
I didn't feel any connection with Kendra and Hudson seemed to be the prodigal son. Valerie seemed lost in her memories alot but that could have been her regrets surfacing.
Overall, I enjoyed this book although it seemed to start off a little slow. Thank you NetGalley, Harlequin Trade Publishing and MIRA.
When Valerie’s adult son, Hudson, moves in with her, she’s happy to have her boy back. He is there to help her with her early-onset Alzheimer’s. Her neighbors are not happy because they blame him for a past tragedy. When a young woman is murdered in the neighborhood, the blame falls on Hudson.
This is one you definitely want to avoid spoilers. There’s a pretty big twist, which I did not figure out so I loved the surprise! The ending was a bit more “told than shown” but it was still an a-ha moment that kept me on the edge of my seat. I liked how all the characters, especially the main character, had flaws.
“Forgiveness. The rising sun bringing a new day. Most things can’t be righted. Except for death. Once someone is gone, that’s it. There are no more opportunities.”
A Mother Would Know comes out 12/13.
Slow Burn That Becomes Twistier And With More Crossings Than A Mountain Road Between A Railroad Track And A River. Let's get the elephant out of the room up front: Through around the 2/3 or so mark of this 300+ page book - so for roughly the first couple hundred pages - this book is *slow*. So slow that it does in fact struggle to keep the attention at times. But then, Great Gatsby was *so much worse* in that regard and is regarded as one of the greatest books in American literature. This particular book will never be in *that* conversation, but like Gatsby it does have the moment where suddenly, it begins getting *so much better* and actually becomes a truly solid book by the end. Indeed, that back third - that last hundred pages or so- really is going to remind you of driving down a 2 lane mountain road between train tracks and a stream - there are so very many twists and crossings that it can get rather dizzying trying to keep track of who is crossing who and for what reason now. And yet it is this aspect of the book that is executed *so* well and almost *had* to have the slow buildup it got. Some of the stuff here is utterly horrific, others of it more simply extremely creepy, and in the end you will be left breathless. Very much recommended.
Amber Garza you have a new fan.
A Mother Would Know is a page turning book that grabs you from the beginning to the last page.
If you like dysfunctional families, unlikeable characters and one that you just have to cheer on despite their bad decisions this book is for you.
Valerie is having memory problems and her prodigal son Hudson comes home to look after her.
She thinks she knows her children very well like all mom's do.
Does she though?
Bodies are mounting up and the pages fly by.
I have preordered this for my daughter .
Cant wait to read Amber's other books.
Thanks to NetGalley and Harelquin Trade Publishing Mira for a compelling read.
Based on the blurb, I thought I'd love this book, but it was a miss for me. The pacing was way too slow for the genre, and things didn't begin to pick up until about halfway through the story, which was a bit too late. I found the police hard to believe (for missing such obvious evidence). There's so much telling vs. showing, and as a result, I couldn't really connect with the characters or plot. I did enjoy Bowie, but that was one of the only positives for me.
Valerie's mother passed away with early onset of dementia Valier herself is starting to have memory issues and fears she's destined to suffer the same early demise. After a bad break up with his girlfriend, Hudson finds himself with nowhere to go. What perfect timing! Valerie invites him to move back with her, hoping hell help should she fall ill. Her dauther Kendra offers to have Valerie move in with her and her family. But Valerie is determined not to leave her home. She is sure she will be well looked for. But will she? Lots of great twists!
3.5⭐️ This is my second book by this author. I definitely liked When I Was You more but this one was pretty good as well! This is about Valerie, Hudson and Kendra. Valerie wasn’t the best mom, her career in music came first and now she may be suffering from the earlier stages of Alzheimer’s so her son, Hudson moves home to help take care of her despite Kendra already doing this. Hudson has all the traits of a psychopath and a neighbor ends up dead shortly after he arrives. Mom is starting to believe that Hudson might be capable of killing and could have done it before.
What a fantastic read! I thought I had it all figured out until the very end and then everything changed! This was a page-turner for sure and the duel timelines with the twist was done so well. Definitely give this a read if you’re looking for a good mystery/psychological thriller. This will be released December 13th.
A Mother Would Know is a fast paced thriller full of twist and turns. How well does a mother truly know their children? Valerie thinks she knows them pretty well till her son Hudson, moves back home. When Hudson returns home a lot of forgotten things are stirred up then a young woman is found murdered down the street. Valerie has to face the fact that she may not know her son at all. I really enjoyed the twists and turns in this story. I thought it was interesting to read how far a mother will go for their children without crossing a line.