Member Reviews

The writing style in this book was great. It is one of the only reasons I stuck it out as long as I did. The characters were unlikable and not in an expected way. The plot was just flat for me. But the author does know how to tell a story and the strong writing kept me going.

Was this review helpful?

If you love scandal, lust and affairs you will love to see how one women named Isabel Rosen affair with her married professor changes her life forever. There is a lot going on this book explores a nonconsensual sexual encounter, an affair with a professor, a troubling relationship with her father. It is a coming an age book of what life is like and how small acts can have big effects on one's outcome. I feel the affair was a way for Isabel to take back her sexual power in a way. The book is a page turner if anything you will have a deeper understand of Rosen's life and how she grown from start of the book to the end.

Was this review helpful?

First off, thank you Netgalley and Henry Holt Books for the ARC.

There is something about the way that Daisy Alpert Florin writes that both broke me and healed me in the best of ways. It is an absolutely beautifully written coming-of-age. But that being said, this book does cover some very dark and sad topics,

The story is a reminiscent look back at a young woman’s experience during her final semester at college while grappling with a sexual encounter, an affair with a professor, and discovering and becoming herself while trying to maintain the standards of being the good Jewish girl from her past. While set in the late 90’s, it was very easy to imagine similar experiences for college women now, especially early on with her friend. We as readers are able to get a front-row seat watching her realize her worth, and sense of self and begin to herself first in a way that doesn’t make her a bad person.

This book deals with dark themes and you have to be in a good headspace to read this. I had to put it down several times because I, in fact, was not truly able at moments to handle some of the topics. Additionally, whilst the prose in the early chapters captured me, the plot doesn't take off until later on. But Florin does a lovely job with these topics in a way that I hadn't read before. A really lovely debut and eager to see what else she writes in the future,

A splendid

Was this review helpful?

All my sad girl summer girlies need to read this book!!!
It’s everything I wanted it to be and more.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this book and really enjoyed it. I would say this book is more character focused than plot driven and it reminded me of a mix between Writers & Lovers and Conversations with friends. It follows a woman"s senior year of college and touches on issues of consent, power dynamics in relationships, suicide, and friendship between women.

Overall, I enjoyed getting to know the main character and watching her thought process evolve as she grew up. I do think that the story being told by the main character in the future could have been used in a way where we got more introspective reflection about things she would have done differently!

Was this review helpful?

This is the story of a young girl in her last semester at college. The story begins with a vague "was it or wasn't it consensual" sexual encounter between two may be friends. Although the author writes beautifully, the story line bounces around between flighty friendships, an affair with a professor and a young woman caught between the straight-line upbringing in her father's Jewish home and the freedom the 90's brought to the young women in the collegiate world. The entire novel is steeped in manipulation; the inclusivity of somewhat lackluster friends and the professor that makes her feel seen and guides her to really believe in herself. As always, many thanks to NetGalley and Henry Holt Books for the advance reader copy in exchange of an honest review

Was this review helpful?

This gives us a reminiscent look back at a woman’s experience during her final semester at college. While set in the late 90’s, it was very easy to imagine similar experiences for college women now. We get a front row seat at watching her realize her worth and learning that putting herself first doesn’t make her a bad person. While I highly enjoyed the read, it was difficult to determine how much time had passed from one memory to the next, which became confusing when she would jump further back to earlier memories and then forward to the present.

Was this review helpful?

**Thank you for the ARC. All opinions are completely my own.**

3 stars. Rambling, bleh, and bland. NOT recommended for fans of My Dark Vanessa.

THOUGHTS (No Spoilers): This book fell flat for me. Honestly, I don't know how the author managed to make this story so dull. I quickly became a disinterested listener who was forced to sit through the main character's long-winded internal monologue. Even the historical backdrop of Clinton-Lewinsky scandal was written so blandly.

What happened to "Show, not tell"? There were many intense emotional plot points that would have leapt off of the page if written better. Instead, the ENTIRE plot and cast of characters all felt very monotone and boring.

Someone else stated that this book was like listening to your mother ramble on and on about her college days. I wholeheartedly agree.

TLDR; Totally bleh.

Was this review helpful?

My Last Innocent Year is a coming-of-age novel that tackles the difficulties of growing up and a young woman's task of finding her place in society.. The author does an awesome job of capturing a young woman struggling to find herself., but I was expecting a romance, a love story. but this is not one, at least not in the traditional sense.. Overall, I felt that this book had a powerful message, but it is not a book you look for for plot. It is, at it's best, a book about girls with feelings.
There is SA in this book as well as the sexual manipulation-abuse of a young girl, so if these things are triggers to you then it may be best to skip this one

Thank you so much to NetGalley for allowing me early access to this title in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I cannot stop thinking about this book- it was one of those that once I picked it up, I didnt want to put down at all. I loved that we were looking back on the experience and also seeing Isabel learn how those experiences shaped her- not in a cheesy way but in a deeply insightful way. Definitely deals with a lot of heavy subjects but I could easily read this book over and over again.

Was this review helpful?

Definitely not a light read so beware.

But, it does show how people get sucked into a thing they think they want until they realize the reality of it all.

Also, consent is key. A valuable lesson that should be known everywhere.

Was this review helpful?

For fans of coming-of-age novels with a dark academia vibe. Trigger warning for sexual relations between an older man in a position of power and a young impressionable woman of age.

"Especially when I thought about Zev and the way he pressed his fingers into my flesh like wet clay, the slick of his tongue in my ear, the way he'd rummaged around inside me like a bag of old clothes."


Rating: 4 Stars

I absolutely loved how Daisy Alpert Florin navigated Isabel's journey from early adulthood. She gives just enough of the backstory to get a glimpse as to why Isabel may be making some fairly sketchy choices. As the novel progresses later into Isabel's life you see how her choice to have an affair with her Professor impacted and continued to impact her life and choices. It's dark without getting too gross. This novel does an excellent job demonstrating sexual coercion in a scenario many women have found themselves in and often end up feeling exactly how the author depicted Isabel.

"I'd wondered what he might say when we were finally alone, if he would kiss me again or tell me it had all been a mistake; now I worried he wouldn't say anything at all."

Review posted at: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/4875365796

Was this review helpful?

Drawn to it because of the comparison to the brilliant My Dark Vanessa, MLIY starts with a different premise, in a not so distant past where the social commentary about the Lewinsky affair sprinkles doubt and turmoil in our protagonist. A lost soul in college, stuck between 2 polar opposite friends, she finds her solace in her professor, who delights in singling out favorite pupils for his own pleasure. Whereas MDV gave us an incisive and intimate account of the protagonist’s mental state, MLIY is passive in the way you can only expect a lost college student to be - and it excels at it. You want to shake her and make her see the light, the way her friends manipulate her views of the world, how her affair is nothing more than another check on the list of her lover, but most importantly in today’s day and age: the importance of NO in all aspects of life.

All in all a 4/5: the “bleh” college student mindset makes some of the reading difficult, but the punches are there when needed. Thanks for the ARC!!!

Was this review helpful?

arc from netgalley and Henry Holt and Co.

Content warnings for sexual assault/nonconsent, domestic violence, death, and suicide

It’s hard to describe the plot of this book, but it essentially covers a female student’s final semester of college, including a nonconsensual sexual encounter, an affair with a professor, her father and his appetizing store in the Lower East Side, and a lot of flashbacks to the author’s upbringing.

I thought this was written very well. The author handles time beautifully and with such care, zooming in and out on certain moments, bringing us into the characters’ futures and then back into the moment. I loved the way she wrote about writing and creating—this feels like an area in which the narrator truly learned and grew throughout the novel.

All that said, I don’t think this should be advertised as a book that tackles consent. The encounter at the beginning of the book feels separate from the rest of the novel, and both the encounter and the idea of consent are only brought up briefly a couple more times throughout the rest of the book. We did not arrive at a new perspective on consent; it just felt like the narrator was recounting a thing that happened to her and that she moved on from. This book was strange in that it seems a lot of life-altering things are happening but are just bouncing off the narrator. I didn’t get a sense of how she felt or how she was being impacted.

Midway through the book, all of the plot lines and the things that were being addressed started to feel like they belonged in different stories, but the author wove them all beautifully together at the end. Aside from the theme of consent, an important topic that did not come through here or fit in with the rest of the book, this was a really cohesive and beautiful coming-of-age.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 rounded up. Beautifully written, and although it deals with darker subjects (nonconsensual sex, sleeping with a professor) it isn't insanely depressing. However, this is not a light summer beach read that you idly flip through while sipping on a spiked seltzer.

You definitely have to be in the right mindset to enjoy reading it. This is a book you read before you get your period when you want to feel all the feels. Daisy Alpert Florin has written it so that you find yourself inside Daisy's mind and being able to understand what is going on inside her heart.

I love the way she describes Connelly, her writing professor, even though the relationship is clearly not ideal. "Connolly was wearing blue jeans and a faded black T-shirt with a bleach stain by the heart. I realized as I walked toward him that I never looked at anyone as much as I'd looked at him. If I were an artist, I could've painted him from memory: each wave of hair the contour of his knuckles. He was still the most beautiful man I've ever seen."

I think that this passage really does a good job of getting to what the book is really about: "We were girls in the bodies of women. We bought condoms with our father's credit cards, drink sloe gin fizzes, and slept with stuffed animals on our beds we didn't know how to fold a fitted sheet." The book is primarily about still having the mindset of a girl, but being in the body of a woman and how men interact with that body. The path that Isabel follows is simultaneously fascinating and gutwrenching.

This quote from the book did a solid job of describing how I felt when I was done with it: "I let the image hang there, pressed on the bruise of it, coaxing out the ancient ache. When I was done, I felt different, not lighter, just hollow, as if someone had scooped out my insides, leaving only a shell one flick and I would crack."

The language in the book is just delicious. Read it! Just not at the beach.

Thank you to #netgalley for this ARC of #mylastinnocentyear

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and Henry Holt for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
TW: sexual assault, domestic violence, death of a parent, suicide
It took me a while to read this book. While the prose captured my attention from the first couple of chapters, the story really doesn't take off until a little under 50%. Regardless, this was a beautifully written, well-developed story. Every single word of this novel was not only intentional but carefully placed.
The synopsis for My Last Innocent Year does not even scratch the surface of what this book is about. The writing is as if the main character, Isabel, is reflecting on her last year of college from an adult perspective. I found Isabel's narrative to be captivating and essential to the themes of this novel.
In her senior year, Isabel should be relishing her last few months of girlhood-her life revolving around her friends and campus life, not having to worry about finances, a career, and the daunting aspects of adulthood. After Isabel is sexually assaulted by a classmate, she finds herself stuck in the limbo between girlhood and womanhood. Isabel experiences the beauty of first love as she begins an affair with a her married professor as she witnesses the downfall of the toxic marriage of two professors in her department. This transition occurs amidst the Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinsky scandal which opens Isabel's eyes to how beautiful women are treated American culture.
This is a breathtaking coming of age story about the beautiful, yet bitter, transition to womanhood. I am grateful to have received an advanced copy of this novel as I know it is a story I will continue to think about in the future. I look forward to reading this author's future work!

Was this review helpful?

I received an advance copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. I am incredibly glad that I got the chance to read My Last Innocent Year. This was an attention-holding, relatable and vivid story of a college girl’s tumultuous last semester following a sexual encounter that was less than consensual. She seeks refuge in a male writing professor, and I appreciated the way that their connection was established and played out. The author did an excellent job creating the world of fictional Wilder College and the intricacies of its English department, as well as creating a protagonist to understand and root for. The perspective (told from adulthood, providing occasional glimpses into the future beyond the Clinton-era setting of most of the text) allows the protagonist introspection that I certainly didn’t have in college. It might remind me most of Elif Batuman’s brilliant “The Idiot,” with more down-to-Earth protagonist, and I found myself reluctant to put it down until I was finished. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

My Last Innocent Year” is a fantastic debut novel by Daisy Alpert Florin. We meet Isabel (Izzy) who is in her final year at Wilder College, a prestigious college in New Hampshire. She lost her mother, who was a painter, to cancer, and her father owns a Jewish appetizer store in New York City and has very little money. About to embark on “the real world,” an acquaintance forces her to have sex—whether the fact was rape is something the novel dances around. Still raw from the experience, she enters into a relationship with her Fiction Workshop (and married) professor. But can he be the one to save her or will Izzy learn to save herself?

The author does an awesome job of capturing a young woman struggling to find herself. Izzy, for the most part, was a likeable character (though I may have related because I was also a fiction writer who faced the conclusion of the end of college without any idea of what I wanted to be when I grew up.) The scenes describing the workshopping process—and having your work dissected—brought back a few nightmares, especially when Professor Connelly (Randy) used his love of Izzy’s work as a way to seduce her. I found Randy (a disenfranchised poet) somewhat suspect—he should have known better to enter into a relationship with a fragile student who was reeling from a negative sexual encounter. Also, I liked the author’s use of the setting of a smaller Eastern college. Because the plot was set in the late nineties, the reader (almost heavy-handedly) references the impact of Bill Clinton’s inappropriate relationship with Monica Lewinsky, yet expects readers to make their own conclusions. There are moments in the novel where the author (in her fictional present) reflects back to her past. I would have preferred the author to have stayed in her moments of vulnerability.

Thanks to the author, the publisher and Netgalley for the opportunity to give this novel an early read.

Was this review helpful?

I’m always drawn to this type of story about a young woman in college, because I think that is a pivotal journey and find these to be transformative years. Usually I end up disappointed because the main character is not developed convincingly or is represented as a woman without any power or control of her life. Isabel, however, was complex yet relatable. I was glad that even though some of her decisions were questionable, she ended up claiming her power back. She did not play the role of victim. Enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

2.5 STARS

My Last Innocent Year is a novel with very triggering content and I feel like this novel lacks proper storytelling and character opinions and feelings. I found the relationships to be very superficial and most of the character storylines to be uninteresting. This book had potential to be great, but it was just not my cup of tea.

Was this review helpful?