Member Reviews

Fake dating between rivals set in a reality TV singing competition – and a Christmas story to boot!

Sadie Hunter and Max Brody are both picked as contestants for a Reality TV country music competition set in Nashville, TN. Throughout the competition they are paired up for a duet where the chemistry between them becomes obvious. From there chaos ensues as the two decide to team up, and start fake dating to capitalize on their perceived romance.

The plot can get a little convoluted at times – both characters have a lot going on in their lives and it kind of took away from the romance between Sadie and Max. The miscommunication between Sadie and Max was so frustrating! Though maybe it was intended for me to scream "JUST TALK TO EACHOTHER” at the book several times? IDK.

Overall – All I want for Christmas is a cute, Christmassy romance novel that is sure to be a solid December read.

Thank You, Net Galley for the ARC of this book in exchange of an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

All I Want for Christmas will be released on October 4th and is for any American Idol and country music fans out there. Sadie and Max are in a singing competition and end up paired up, sweeping America off their feet. This spurs a fake relationship despite the truly contentious nature behind scenes. Can they fake long enough to win and will they have a change of heart?

Overall, the book was generally okay, but the personalities of Sadie, Max and some other ancillary characters weren’t my cup of tea. I love a good competition and music, so those were redeeming factors - you could feel off the pages when they hit that high point of a song together.

The other challenges for me were how closed off Sadie and Max are, their constant communication issues, and the constant assumptions they made about the other that were so inaccurate. It certainly made for tension in the book. It also made it frustrating to read. Overall, I think Sadie and Max had some serious work to do on themselves.

This is the second Maggie Knox book I’ve been meh on, so I think this (pseudonym) author just isn’t for me. You live and you learn!

Thank you to Netgalley and Penguin Books for the opportunity to read this book. The review expresses my own personal opinions.

Was this review helpful?

All I Want for Christmas was a very cute holiday romance novel. I did enjoy reading this, however there was constant back and forth love/hate which I could have done less of. I love the hate to love trope, but I felt it was repetitive and kind of drug on throughout the book. I loved the Nashville setting, being on a country music show, and the highs and lows of being in the industry. I felt connected to Sadie, but not Max. I needed more connection in order to really be invested in their relationship. Slow burn and then, BAM! the ending was all at once and went very fast. I was more intrigued by the additional characters than I was with Max. I know many people who would enjoy this novel and it really was a cute holiday romantic novel, I just needed more spark. Very thankful I was given the eARC to enjoy. I would recommend this to those who love a quick romantic read.

Was this review helpful?

Do you love fake dating trope? What about enemies to lover? Sunshine/Grump trope? Do you love Christmas? How about country music?
If you said yes to the above, then you’ve found yourself your next Christmas read!

We meet Sadie and Max at a country singer’s contest where I was immediately drawn to their angsty, dramatic, and ever evolving relationship. What I love about fake dating tropes is that we usually get loads of miscommunication. In fact, that’s what usually draws me in. You can find me yelling at the book as the story unfolds because all of the MC’s problems usually can be solved by having a sit down and talking through everything. Does this happen? Of course not! Having main characters communicate wouldn’t be half as fun as seeing the drama unfold due to the miscommunication.

This isn’t a happy go lucky hallmark style Christmas read. This one is filled with angst and emotional trauma. And I was here for it! 4 phenomenal stars

Was this review helpful?

I slightly wish there was a little more Christmas, but that wasn't why I gave a 3.5. I felt like the fake dating was very well written, but Sadie had so much going on with her that I felt like it was hard to focus on their relationship. They both were very childish, I could see this with 21/22 year old loves for sure. I just couldn't connect to either of them so that might have turned me off a little too, but for a holiday read, it is cute and very much a Hallmark setting. I wanted to be at the cabin and enjoying the break from real life as well.

Was this review helpful?

Christmas romance stories tend to be on the lighter side, which is great! However, there's often times something missing. I'm not sure if the issue is the pressure to center the story around the holidays or if it's having a theme sprinkled throughout the story. Sometimes it's a lack of chemistry between the two main characters, such as in ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS by Maggie Knox.

Don't get me wrong - this is a fun romance that oddly enough balances the topic of grief well. I know, that sounds strange, but that part of the book works.

Max and Sadie are two people trying to make it in the cold, hard world of country music. Sadie is filled with dreams of stardom while Max is trying to make his own path away from his famous country-singer father.

The two compete on a talent competition show. And that part of the story was okay. But their main trope of miscommunication/misunderstandings made the romance bland.

Lots of misunderstandings or just not letting each other completely get out what needs to be said took away from their chemistry.

However, this is a nice precursor to Christmas to get you in the mood for cold weather and Christmas lights.

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Putnam Group for an e-copy of ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS to review.

I rate ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS three out of five stars.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted so badly to love this book! 😭 I could not connect with these characters at all. And I felt like the story was allll over the place. The constant misunderstandings were exhausting. I feel like at the end of the book, I was asking myself what just happened. I think there was too much going on so every scenario happened/ended so quickly and moved on to something else. There was no.. closure? Or extended conversations? I’m not even sure what I’m trying to say because I feel so confused by this book. 😞

Thank you NetGalley, Maggie Knox and the Publishers for a copy of this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Maggie Knox does it again with a super cozy christmas read. I can't wait to tell all my friends to read this book in the next holiday season. It has the fake dating/enemies to lovers trope, and the reality show vibes we are all here for.

Was this review helpful?

All I Want for Christmas is an enemies-to-lovers rom com between country music contestants. While it’s a cute, easy read, the characters lacked depth and it’s storyline was predictable.

Was this review helpful?

You'll long for the chill to melt between Sadie and Max long before it does in this cute Christmas fake dating romance.

Sadie's an aspiring singer with stars in her eyes, and Max Brody is the son of Nashville royalty trying to make his own career. Both are competing for the top spot on Starmaker, a reality TV singing show. Years ago, Max blew Sadie off at an event, so when she's paired with him in the competition, she's not happy. But their on-stage chemistry is off the charts, and the fans are eating it up. Their agents convince them to fake a show-biz romance. Suddenly, they're #saxie, and the world is in love with their love story.

Spanning from Nashville to the woods of Canada, this is the sort of story where snow falls at critical moments to add to the atmosphere. It's also the sort of book where all the problems could have been solved by the characters talking honestly with each other. From missed proposals to not telling the other about beloved family members dying to tabloid gossip, these two get their wires crossed pretty much every time they see each other. It's one step forward, then two steps back, until the very end. While the climax could have had a little more drama, this was still a sweet story.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the advance review copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun read about Sadie and Max who are both selected as contestants on a reality singing show. They end up being paired together for a duet week and everyone goes nuts for them! The network decides the have to fake a relationship on and off the stage or they are out of the competition. The only problem with this is they can't stand each other! This is a fun enemies to lovers story. They were both full of passion and the story was full of angst! I enjoyed this holiday rom-com, and I think you will too!

Was this review helpful?

the premise of this book really drew me in and I was so excited to read it! strangely though, only about 1/3 of the book even takes place in the country music competition. this was super easy to read and I liked reading about the country music scene in Nashville! however, following the never-ending cycle of miscommunication that Sadie and Max experience got incredibly tiring so quickly. I wish we could’ve spent more time getting to know the main characters both individually and together, as opposed to dealing with the near constant issues they faced.

*thank you to netgalley & penguin group putnam for the eARC, in exchange for a review.

Was this review helpful?

A Christmas novel, set in Nashville with a music contest to bring our love interests together is perfect for me. I enjoyed this book but I wasn't fond of the use of miscommunication that kept our lovers apart for much of the book.. It is a warm and cozy Christmas-themed novel that many people will enjoy.

Was this review helpful?

I don’t care what time of year it is, cute Christmas stories are always fun to read. I loved The Holiday Swap so i was excited when this duo came out with another holiday story!

Who wouldn’t want to read about a music competition, fun holiday traditions, a cute puppy in sweaters and of course FAKE DATING! Sign me up please!!!

This story follows up and coming country singers Sadie Hunter and Max Brody. They are on a new season of a singing competition and forced to pair up. They never could have imagined the stage chemistry they had so they are willing to fake it to win the competition in the end.

I thought that the story was going to be more focused on the singing competition and growing their relationship through there but that part surprisingly wrapped up fast! What we got to see was the more complex sides of both Sadie and Max. They both have a lot they need to work through, experiences to experience… apart, and just find the path they truly belong on.

While there was great banter and fun silly moments in this story there truly was a lot of serious themes throughout this book too. Family relationship struggles, death, self doubt to name a few… but the authors did an amazing job of being sensitive while discussing these themes and making the characters stronger through their struggles. They found their support systems and in turn were able to be a support system for each other.

if you like books about music, especially country, fake dating, and found family… this book is for you!

Thank you netgalley, Putnam Group and Maggie Knox for providing me with this advanced readers copy in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited to have the chance to read another holiday romance from Maggie Knox – I really enjoyed their previous release, The Holiday Swap, from last year. The premise for this one was instantly attractive – a holiday romance set around a reality tv, music competition? Definitely intriguing to me.

I thought the story overall was cute. As mentioned, I enjoyed the premise and I am always a sucker for the enemies to lovers and fake relationship tropes – so I was excited to see those present as well. I really loved Gran in the book, and the whole Nashville music scene angle. I also really enjoyed the cabin retreat. I wished for a bit more development of both Max and Sadie, and in particular in their relationship / time together. I really liked the parts with them together, I just wanted more of that.

While I liked this one, it did rely pretty heavily on a trope that is not my cup of tea – the lack of communication trope. I can handle that in small doses, but in this case it came up a lot, which took me out of the groove with reading. Still a cozy, fun holiday read, that I’m sure many will enjoy. I look forward to the next Maggie Knox book 😊

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Maggie Knox, and Penguin Group Putnam/G.P. Putnam’s Sons for providing this e-ARC in exchange for my honest review.

A super cute romance set in Nashville around the country music stage. I enjoyed the festive magic that this story brought. I read in the middle of summer, but I was definitely getting in the holiday spirit. I loved the Holiday Swap last year, so I was super excited for this one and it did not disappoint. I cannot wait to read this one again during the holiday season!

This review will be posted to my Goodreads and Amazon accounts immediately and to my instagram account (@ginganinja333), and to my newly created bookstagram (@paulas.book.nook) upon publication on 10/4/2022.

Was this review helpful?

NetGalley, thank you so much for the ARC of "All I Want For Christmas," the new holiday romance by Maggie Knox. It's easily as adorable as "The Holiday Swap."
Set in Nashville and around the stage of a music reality tv with sprinkled-in trips to a cabin in Canada and other places, the story of aspiring musician Sadie and legacy golden boy Max is very romantic and christmass-y. Like the previous novel, it creates these really idyllic and atmospheric worlds to enjoy the love story in. I hope the authors will create a playlist for pub day because I kept wondering what #Saxbie sounds like, and what their influences are!
Two quick things though, why doesn't Sadie have any friends? She has her gran, and she becomes friends with an older musician who's also her mentor, but there still was a bit of a mysterious void there. If she really doesn't have friends, it should be incorporated into her sense of loneliness and her questioning where she belongs. Also, there is so much snow in Nashville in this! With climate change advancing the way it is, that felt a bit off-key to me. For most of us, we need to adjust our expectations of where and when we can hope for a White Christmas. Other than that though, I totally would recommend. Sweet story and super seasonal!

Was this review helpful?

This book really called to me with its enemies-to-lovers and fake dating trope. And it was cute. I just didn’t feel much chemistry between the two main characters. I mean the book was sweet, I just wanted more. I wanted to feel the heat between the two main characters, but it seemed most of their time was spent misunderstanding each other. I do realize that’s all part of the enemies-to-lovers theme. In my opinion there could have been more description of simmering want and need for each other. My favorite part was their time spent in Canada and I would’ve enjoyed reading more of that.

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group Putnam for this ARC in exchange for my honest opinion. #AllIWantforChristmas #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

All I want for Christmas is a little more Christmas in this novel! The romance was sweet and I loved the setting of Nashville and the description of Max’s winter cabin in Canada. But overall this was just an average romance read that left me wanting a little more festive magic between the pages.

Thank you to Net galley and Viking for this arc in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

I looooved The Holiday Swap last year so I was excited for another holiday story from this author duo. Unfortunately this one did not have the charm and cute holiday winks that I was hoping for.

All I Want for Christmas gives you Max and Sadie, two singers trying to make it on their own in Nashville. Their paths cross while on a singing compeition and the chemistry is undeniable. They both have some baggage that leads their relationship to see saw back and forth all year long. Finally, Christmas rolls around again and they have to figure out if they're going to make it big or not.

You had a smidge of enemies to lovers and fake dating but you didn't get to know the characters enough to root for me. Max was so back and forth on his feelings you couldn't keep track of what he was feeling page to page. Sadie, the heroine, I enjoyed more and maybe could have just done with only her point of view throughout the story. I wanted more holiday charm and to feel more Christmasy but with only some of it taking place in a snowy, cabin I didn't really feel that Christmas magic I wanted.

Overall, I'll still keep reading their holiday books but this one fell a little flat for me.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?