Member Reviews

Sadie and Max are contestants on a country music reality show. The results of the show could make or break Sadie's career and while Max doesn't need the fame winning would bring, he could really use the positive publicity boost. When Max and Sadie sing a duet that goes viral , they're instantly shipped by the public and are dubbed "#Saxie." The producers of the show decide that Max and Sadie must continue as a duo - and a couple - or face immediate elimination. Their relationship is fake, but their onstage chemistry is very real. Pretending to be a couple leads to misunderstandings, insecurities, and mishaps throughout the competition. Max and Sadie must decide if the cost of fame is worth their happiness...

All I Want for Christmas is a sweet, standalone, holiday novel. There were some parts that I liked, but overall it was just kind of slow for me. The relationship between Max and Sadie lacked chemistry and had so many ups and downs it became a little redundant. The journey from competitors to enemies and eventually as lovers felt forced and way too quick in my opinion. Max and Sadie were both very quick to jump to conclusions about the other and assume the worst. It was frustrating at best, annoying at the least.. I wanted to love this book, but it was just "ok" for me...

Thank you to NetGalley and PENGUIN GROUP Putnam, G.P. Putnam's Sons for the ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was an adorable Christmas romance set in Nashville and Banff. Sadie and Max are contestants on “Starmaker” (an American Idol-esque reality singing competition). Max comes from a famous country music dynasty while Sadie feels like this is her last chance to make it big before she’ll give up on her dreams of country music fame and go back home to Wisconsin. When they team up to sing a song for “Duet Week”, their chemistry takes viewers and the internet by storm and the show’s producers see a ratings opportunity in pushing them to team up throughout the competition (and it also wouldn’t hurt if they were seen out and about in public flirting and keeping the public interested). What follows is a variety of romance tropes including enemies-to-lovers, forced proximity, and fake dating.

While the back and forth / push-and-pull and miscommunication between Sadie and Max grows tiring after a while, I enjoyed their connection and chemistry. Overall, this is a nice, easy read for a cozy winter afternoon (or whenever you’re in the mood for a holiday-themed romance!).

Thank you very much to Putnam Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Well, this is lovely Christmas love story with so many heartwarming and sweet chapters and great execution of my three favorite tropes: enemies to lovers , fake relationship and sunshine meets the grump!

The palpable and sizzling chemistry between Sadie and Max makes you enjoy every moment of their evolving relationship. But this sweet, adorable story also include extreme angsty, tear jerking and heartbreaking moments, too.

The book’s beginning at the Starmaker country star singers contest, introducing sweet, insecure but exciting Sadie and brooding, handsome Max who wants to step out of his father’s stardom hooked me up. I loved their hot-cold relationship, their undeniable chemistry and the producer’s efforts to force them fake relationship for better ratings.

Of course it’s obvious faking will turn into something real. They probably win the contest and the book will end with a big HEA. But no! I couldn’t get so wrong!

I was expecting to read something sweet-swoon- soft but at the first third book’s direction dramatically changed. It turned into little heavier and emotional turmoil that approached sensitive issues like grief, mansplaining, alcoholism, abandonment of parent.

The main characters truly pissed me off. I just want to yell at both of them. Because they have serious communication problems!

Misunderstandings and unsaid words affected their chance for HEA! Especially Max acted like a jerk, hiding behind his family baggage, grief, problematic relationship with his charismatic country star father. Sadie was too forgiving, not sharing her own family drama, bottling everything inside.

Their push-pull relationship made me a little exhausted and I still feel like Max should grovel more at the end after things he’s made and said to Sadie! He honestly made me irritated!

Overall: it was still heartwarming, angsty and emotional read! There are so many chapters made me swoon even though the characters tested my patience with their immature behaviors.

I’m rounding up 3.5 stars to 4 all I want for Christmas is shoes sorry you stars!

Many thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Group Putnam for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange my honest thoughts.

Was this review helpful?

It was vey quick and light read for me. I really liked it as it gave me all the buzz and the level of enjoyment. The MCs were mature, raw and super relatable to me that I can’t help but fell in love with..

Was this review helpful?