4.5/5.0
What an incredibly unique and creative story! It inhabits a bit of so many genres, from historical, to fantasy, mystery and romance so seamlessly and beautifully that fans of each can relish every word! From the first chapter to the closing page, the story grabs the reader, immerses them in the world, the characters and the intrigue. It is wildly creative, as well. A spirit that inhabits the very walls of a house is the means for all kinds of crazy shenanigans - of which it abounds! Yet, all the fun is superbly tempered with an evil that lurks and grows as the story progresses.

At first, the writing might seem a bit confusing and disjointed, as the author explores two completely disparate people, in completely different countries. But, it isn't long until the genius of why this is needed comes to light and the story-line gels into a right rollicking mystery/suspense! In fact, this book is a resounding 5 star read right up until the very last page!

But.... it is on the last page that it loses it's absolute perfection. The story ended without Hulda ever speaking her feelings where Merritt is concerned. After an entire book of those feelings growing, and after Merritt laid his heart out so beautifully for her, I closed the last page extremely unsatisfied. And I hated that! The rest of the book was so perfect, why leave us without the cherry that tops such a wonderful story? There were a few threads left hanging at the end, as well, such as whatever happened to Myra? Her actions were relevant and consequential enough to require some sort of explanation.

SO.... nearly perfect story, slightly disappointing ending. Overall, however, HUGELY recommended read!!

This book is another superb example of Holmberg's world building and character development. Somewhat darker than her Paper Magician series, and yet reminiscent of it. The magic system in this book seems a little more thought-out and there is the potential for more books in this world. I loved this book and absolutely can't wait for more!

Charlie Holmberg is one of the most versatile writers I know. She writes everything from fantasy fiction to romcoms, and does it all so well.
Not all of her genres are my favorite, but this book falls into a category I adore - magical fiction. If, like me, you loved the Paper Magician series - this book is for you. Here in a fictional Boston, Holmberg has created yet another magical universe with its own rules and attributes, in 1800s America.
I had a little trouble getting into the characters at the start, but by the end, I’ve found much to love about both Merrit and Hulda. There’s also an evil magician, and an enchanted house. Themes include family, love, letting go, and second chances. The plot moves along well and the characters grow and develop (growing on the reader as well) as the plot progresses. I can’t say too much about the enchanted house without spoiling anything, but suffice it to say Holmberg does such a great job of writing in fun little quirks of magic. I hope there will be more to this magical world!