Member Reviews
Thank you NetGalley and Crown Publishing Group for an advanced copy of this book.
Ben Macintyre's "Prisoners of the Castle: An Epic Story of Survival and Escape from Colditz, the Nazi's Fortress Prison" is a masterful work of historical storytelling that will captivate both history enthusiasts and casual readers alike. The book is a remarkable blend of thorough research, accessible writing, and fascinating details that bring the Colditz Castle, a symbol of wartime captivity, vividly to life.
Macintyre's meticulous research is one of the standout features of "Prisoners of the Castle." The depth of his investigation into Colditz Castle, a high-security Nazi prison during World War II, is evident on every page. The author has combed through a vast array of sources, including personal letters, diaries, and official documents, to provide a comprehensive account of the prisoners' experiences. His ability to piece together disparate bits of information into a coherent and engaging narrative is a testament to his skill as a historian. The detailed background on the castle's layout, the daily life of its inhabitants, and the various escape attempts offers readers a rich understanding of the historical context.
One of Macintyre's notable strengths is his talent for making complex historical events accessible to a broad audience. "Prisoners of the Castle" is written in a clear and engaging style that avoids overwhelming readers with jargon or excessive detail. Macintyre’s storytelling is fluid and compelling, making intricate historical and technical details easy to grasp without sacrificing accuracy. The book is structured in a way that allows readers to follow the narrative effortlessly, even if they are unfamiliar with the intricacies of World War II or the specifics of Colditz Castle.
What truly makes "Prisoners of the Castle" shine are the intriguing and often surprising tidbits that Macintyre weaves into the narrative. These small details not only enrich the story but also provide a glimpse into the personalities and ingenuity of the prisoners. Whether it's a daring escape attempt involving elaborate disguises or the clever use of everyday objects in ingenious ways, these anecdotes add depth and color to the historical account. Macintyre’s eye for these captivating details helps to illuminate the resilience and resourcefulness of the individuals involved.
In conclusion, "Prisoners of the Castle" by Ben Macintyre is an exceptional work that combines thorough research, clear and engaging writing, and captivating historical details. It offers a profound and entertaining exploration of one of World War II's most intriguing prisons and the remarkable stories of those who endured and escaped its confines. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in history, survival stories, or the human spirit's capacity to overcome even the harshest of adversities.
Mr. Macintyre has once again given a fantastic history that reds like a novel. He is on my must read list whenever something new comes out I must buy it and read it.
Prepare to be captivated by the extraordinary world of espionage and intrigue with Ben Macintyre's "Prisoners of the Castle." This enthralling historical account is a tour de force that transports readers back in time to one of the most dramatic periods of World War II.
Macintyre's meticulous research and masterful storytelling come together to create a gripping narrative that reads like a thrilling spy novel. "Prisoners of the Castle" unravels the astonishing true story of a daring escape from a high-security Nazi prison, and the individuals who risked everything for freedom and the Allied cause.
The book's strength lies not only in its riveting plot but also in Macintyre's ability to breathe life into the characters. Each individual involved in the escape, from the prisoners themselves to the brave men and women who supported them, is portrayed with depth and nuance. Their fears, hopes, and unwavering determination resonate throughout the pages, forging a powerful connection with readers.
Macintyre's writing style is both engaging and evocative, immersing readers in the tense atmosphere of wartime Europe. The book effortlessly weaves historical facts and personal accounts, creating a comprehensive and captivating portrayal of the events that unfolded.
In addition to being a thrilling tale of escape and resistance, "Prisoners of the Castle" also sheds light on the bravery and ingenuity of the individuals who defied the odds and risked their lives for a higher cause. The book serves as a powerful reminder of the resilience of the human spirit and the unwavering commitment to freedom, even in the darkest of times.
Beyond the thrilling narrative, "Prisoners of the Castle" is a testament to Macintyre's skill as a historian. His attention to detail and ability to provide context and background enrich the reading experience, making this book not just a thrilling adventure but also a valuable historical account.
In conclusion, "Prisoners of the Castle" is an exceptional work of non-fiction that reads like a heart-pounding spy thriller. Ben Macintyre's impeccable research and compelling storytelling elevate this book to the highest echelons of historical literature. If you're a fan of gripping, real-life tales of heroism and espionage, this book deserves a prominent spot on your must-read list. Prepare to be spellbound by "Prisoners of the Castle" – it's a triumph of storytelling that will stay with you long after you've turned the final page.
Like many of my other favorite authors, I begin to wonder if Ben Macintyre can even write a book that I do not love. I originally thought it would be hard to equal Operation Mincemeat, my favorite Macintyre book. However, Prisoners of the Castle comes awfully close. The Germans should be vilified for their role in trying to eliminate the Jewish people, and to claim that some did not even realize it was happening was ludicrous (For example, he houses next to Dachau are literally feet away from the camp). However, at this prison, the captors seemed to remember their humanity, an unusual account in WW2 stories. But it is the prisoners that are the focus. The sheer level of attempted escapes makes this a book that you cannot put down. Take a chance and read this book, I am certain that you will be glad that you did.
This was supposedly an escape-proof prison. The walls were yards thick. The location was one of the most isolated areas in Germany. The castle was surrounded by sheer drops of many feet on three sides. There was no place to go if a prisoner did manage to find a way out of the building complex. Colditz Castle was the prison for the incorrigible ones who were not "German friendly", not a good thing to be during WWII.
This is nonfiction that reads like fiction with much detail about people and how they behaved, escapes successful and otherwise, and how the events of the war affected the people who stayed at the castle. A good read for a WWII buff.
Quick take: Perfect for fans of WWII stories and “daring escape” stories.
It’s a dense story, for sure—you will get your fill of descriptions of the infamous Colditz castle, allllllll of its parts and architectural nooks and crannies (very important for the story), and the various ways the prisoners try to exploit the weaknesses of the structure to escape. The prisoners’ dedication to escaping—the sense of duty to keep trying, as their part in the war effort—is fascinating, and the descriptions of the feeling of being apart from the war, while wanting to be a part of the war, and the sort of macho futility they were forced to suffer is a real window into the past of Western society. Unintentionally amusing, perhaps, was the remarkable ineffectiveness of most of the British attempts to escape--the French, the Poles, and the Americans fared much better overall—all while maintaining their firm sense of superiority.
There is such a sense pressing in around this story of all the untold stories left by war. The figure of the old Polish woman who ran a sort of underground railroad for escaped prisoners was a story I wanted to hear more about—a woman who helped men for a long time, and then just disappeared. She slips like a ghost through this story—almost seen, then forgotten.
A New Look at Colditz
Colditz was a World War II prisoner-of-war camp run by Germany. It was the place incorrigible escapers and special political prisoners were sent. It is one of the best-known German POW camps, thanks to one escapee, P. R. Reid. Postwar, he wrote a book about his exploits, giving birth to a genre of escape literature about Colditz castle.
“Prisoners of the Castle: An Epic Story of Survival and Escape from Colditz, the Nazis’ Fortress Prison,” by Ben MacIntyre is the latest edition to the canon. MacIntyre takes a fresh look at the castle adding new research to previously published sources. Can anything be added to the story? The answer is yes.
Time has distanced us from the events at Colditz during World War II. The participants are all dead. The Iron Curtain, which separated those writing about the story from where the story took place, has fallen, allowing free Western access to Colditz castle. MacIntyre takes advantage of all of this to provide an unparalleled look at what happened.
His story is less British-centric than the earliest books, written by British escapees like Reid and Airey Neave. While these writers mentioned the Poles, French, and Dutch contingents, they served more to provide color than as central players. MacIntyre provides a more central role for the non-British contingents.
He also integrates German accounts of the prison with the Allied story. It becomes easier to see the events as a whole, understanding the moves and countermoves on both sides. MacIntyre also expands on other aspects of the story. He brings the political prisoners at Colditz into the mainstream of events there.
More interestingly, he reveals an Allied espionage ring being run out of Colditz. At least one prisoner established relations with a German resistance ring (including a romance with a pretty local woman). It sounds like a mash-up of a bad espionage novel and “Hogan’s Heroes,” yet it happened.
He also reveals the unvarnished side of the Colditz story. The personal and less-desirable foibles of the participants are revealed. Snobbery and class-consciousness was rife, complete with the establishment of a Colditz branch of the Bullingdon dining club. (Douglas Bader comes off particularly badly, blocking the early repatriation of his orderly for selfish reasons.)
If you thought you knew the Colditz story, read “Prisoners of the Castle.” MacIntyre provides a book filled with fresh revelations in a tautly-written and exciting history.
“Prisoners of the Castle: An Epic Story of Survival and Escape from Colditz, the Nazis’ Fortress Prison,” by Ben MacIntyre, Crown Books, 2022, 368 pages, $28.99 (Hardcover), $13.99 (Ebook), $40.00 (Audio Book)
This review was written by Mark Lardas, who writes at Ricochet as Seawriter. Mark Lardas, an engineer, freelance writer, historian, and model-maker, lives in League City, TX. His website is marklardas.com.
As someone who majored in history and has learned/read a lot about WWII I could not believe I had never heard of Colditz before reading this book. I’m so glad to have found it and will be recommending it to all the non-fiction readers at my library!
I enjoyed how the book was broken up by year during the war and allowed us to see the desperation of the men grow as it became clear Hitler was losing the war. What would happen to the prisoners of the castle if the Reich knew they were falling? Would they be ordered executed rather than turned over to allied forces?
It was fascinating learning about all of the escape attempts and how on the one hand each nationality represented in the prison had to work together in order to not be found out by the guards yet they all were still working on their own escapes!
I especially enjoyed the appendix at the end that let the reader know what befell all the main characters mentioned throughout the book after the war ended. I read this in print form and feel it would make a really compelling audiobook!
Ben MacIntyre is a brand, and every time I open his new book, I eagerly anticipate reading it. This book didn't disappoint either. The story of Colditz, famous for its WWII reputation for being impenetrable is fascinating on its own but reading Ben MacIntyre has its own special appeal. It is not just a recitation of historical events, it's the authors view and interpretation that makes the book memorable. Great read for the WWII books fans, thrillers and spy stories enthusiasts as well as for people interested in reading about social customs. All those who appreciate wit and humor will also enjoy this book.
Sorry I wasn’t approved until after the publication of this book as it’s a fascinating story, well written and a page turner.
Colditz, a forbidding German castle fortress, was the destination for Allied officer POWs, and some other high-profile prisoners. It’s important to know that Colditz was different from POW Stalags for enlisted men run by the often brutal Gestapo and SS guards. Colditz was staffed by Wehrmacht (regular army) personnel who generally complied with the Geneva Convention. According to the Geneva Convention, captors were allowed to set their enlisted prisoners to work—but not officers. As a result, most of the prisoners at Colditz were at the leisure to go stir crazy, unless they thought of other ways to keep their minds busy—like dreaming up escape plans.
There were dozens of attempts from 1941 to 1945, and Macintyre chronicles them in all their variety, inventiveness, and risk. Despite what you might see in old movies, it was rare that an escape was successful and, even when they were, the escapee still had to make his way across hundreds of miles of hostile territory to get to Switzerland or another border. Few did, but you can imagine the spark it gave to the prisoners when they learned of a successful escape.
The book isn’t just about the escape attempts, though. A closed community tends to have intensified social dynamics. On the positive side, the prisoners threw themselves into cultural pursuits, including putting on concerts, skits and plays. Hilariously, the British chaplain was appalled at prisoners dressing up as women for some of the plays and skits they acted out in the castle’s theater, thinking that even these ridiculously ersatz women would stir the men’s passions.
At Colditz, there were various nationalities, primarily British, French, Dutch and Polish, and they didn’t always work well together. There were also problems with class conflict, racial prejudice, and anti-Semitism among some of the prisoners. Sadly, there were prisoners who shared many of the same fascist and racist attitudes as the Nazis. Some prisoners were communist sympathizers, which foreshadowed the Cold War conflict. These differences caused problems in themselves, but also served to further divide the prisoners when some suspected that there were moles among them tipping off the Germans to escape plans.
A special intelligence operation in the UK, MI9, came up with dozens of ingenious ways of smuggling contraband and information to the Colditz prisoners. MI9 wisely equipped flyers with many hidden escape aids, in case they were shot down and captured. When you read about some of these bits of spycraft, you won’t be surprised to learn that their inventor inspired the creation of the Q character in the Bond films. Amazingly, Denholm Elliott, who played Q, was a POW of the Germans in WW2 (though not at Colditz).
As always, Macintyre’s book reads more like a novel than a history. His research is deep and detailed, but he weaves it smoothly into his storytelling. Just as I hoped, he includes a postscript describing the postwar lives of the most notable characters. This factual story is more gripping and entertaining than any fiction about Colditz could hope to be.
Prisoners of the Castle: An Epic Story of Survival and Escape from Colditz, the Nazis' Fortress Prison is an interesting read. I am giving four stars.
My thanks to both NetGalley and the publisher Crown Publishing for an advanced copy of this history on one of the most famous German prisons of World War 2.
I was familiar with the story and history of Colditz Castle and its denizens during the Second World War more from biographies of some of the inhabitants or from overviews of the war. I knew that is was a prison for Allied soldiers, but thought it was more famed for the many escapes and derring- do or as in inspiration of many movies and television shows. The real stories, the stories of imprisonment, the escapes, the lives of the internees in general turn out to be far more interesting and in many cases sadder than the boy's own adventures that I was familiar with. Ben Macintyre a chronicler of many true World War II stories and tales of espionage has brought his outstanding skill in research and writing to this tale of both prisoners and captors in Prisoners of the Castle: An Epic Story of Survival and Escape from Colditz, the Nazis' Fortress Prison. This book tells the real story of what happened behind the walls, where men did their best to survive the psychological toll and physical pains of capture, and how many tried to keep fighting even behind concrete walls.
Colditz Castle was a Renaissance castle that in the early days of the war with German advancement into Europe so swift and sudden, found themselves with a lot of enemy combatants to keep track of. Originally the castle was for all Allied troops, French, Polish, English and others, before becoming strictly a prision for English officers in 1943. This is where the troublesome prisoners went, the constant escapees, or the high valued prisoners, nephews and cousins of kings, ministers and the like. To the British with their history of public schools and class status the prison soon was a reflection of their society, aides for the officers, clubs based on society standing, book discussions, religion classes, discrimination for Jewish and Indian officers, and yes constant attempts to escape. The escape stories are fascinating as are the stories of espionage that prisoners would pass on in letters, or that they would receive in Red Cross Package.
Being a book by Ben Macintyre the tale is well- written, well- told and well- sourced. I look forward to anything that he writes for he has gift of telling a story and explaining things so well the reader never feels lost or confused. The book is told chronologically which gives the book a good flow, with what is going on the the world, along with what is happening to the prisoners, mingling well. I had no idea about all the work that went into getting equipment and supplies to prisoners for escape or for spying on the enemy. The escapes are so well sketched a book or a miniseries could be developed just from that. An interesting story of men in difficult situation who rose to the occasion, failed in every way or were destroyed by the enormity of it all.
For readers of World War II stories, well it is Ben Macintyre, but still a different look at the war, and the price of capture on those who longed to fight or die for the cause, but instead found themselves in a cage. For all the stories of escapes or gliders that were built in the prison, it is the personal stories that really make this book. From the weight of not escaping after numerous attempts, being discriminated against for their heritage from his own side, even a few men who turned traitor, this book is filled with personal stories that gives a real sense to what happened to these men. Recommended for historians, and readers who enjoy well- written nonficton.
It is always a treat to dive into a Ben Macintyre book. This one was quite different from his other work, but reads the same. Instead of focusing on a singular story through an event or person, it focuses on a location [Prison} and all the characters that interacted with it. The book is essentially a timeline, navigating the years of WW2, with each chapter focusing on either a character or event that occurred in the prison. As always, Ben does a delightful job of storytelling the wild stories that took place.
If Ben Macintyre wrote the phone book I would pre-order it. He's that good at finding the most interesting aspects of a story and Prisoners of the Castle is no different.
Admittedly, the story of Colditz in World War II gives him a lot to work with. Macintyre slowly builds out the entire world of the prison without losing the main narrative around this small little story in the midst of a world war. There are multitudes of tales that are funny, serious, heartbreaking, but always human. Macintyre also doesn't shy away from a huge nuance that is often ignored in World War II stories. Not all German soldiers were murderous Nazis.
This book is great from beginning to end and I highly recommend it even if you are not a World War II buff.
(This book was provided as an advance copy by Netgalley and Crown Publishing. The full review will be posted to HistoryNerdsUnited.com on 9/13/2022.)
This is another wonderful narrative nonfiction from Ben Macintyre. I was unaware of the detailed history of Colditz prison. I had read about it in passing in other WWII books, but the focus on it here is well done. This is a compelling read, full of interesting characters that will be enjoyed by fans of Macintyre's, WWII, adventure, and intrigue. This is a solid, engaging pick!