Member Reviews

I was excited to see a new book about Rainbow Fish. The storyline of a fish who tells tall tales as if they were true. At first, I wondered if this book had a political slant, but it resolved without one. The layout and typography of the book looked dated. The beautiful illustrations could have expanded into a few pages that were white with text.

Was this review helpful?

The colors of the pictures in this story are so vibrant and beautiful. Rainbow Fish is also a good story with a lesson for young children. In this instance, Humbert is a fish that tells the other fish fantastic stories. When they realize his stories are to scare them and aren't true, no one wants to play with Humbert. But, then Humbert is all alone. So, Rainbow Fish asks Humbert to use his storytelling for good. Sometimes Humbert exaggerates, but the fish bring him back to reality. All the fish enjoy Humbert's wonderful stories.
A good lesson not to lie and to tell stories that are lies, but instead weave stories that are interesting and true.

Was this review helpful?

A cute and timely addition to the “Rainbow Fish” collection, “Rainbow Fish and the Storyteller” tells the tale of a fish, Humbert, who tells untrue, yet frightening, stories to the other fish with hopes that they will let him protect them. Rainbow Fish believes one tale for a brief moment but the other fish don’t even give the stories a second thought. In one instance, the fish use facts to dissolve Humbert’s wild tale but for his other tales, they just simply don’t listen. I wish there had been more examples of how the fish used logic to negate Humbert’s tales as I think that could have been a great teaching moment for little listeners. Equally, it would have been interesting to dive a bit into why Humbert felt the need to tell these frightening stories in the first place. Was he lonely? Misinformed? Expressing his own fears? The story resolved quickly and nicely, as expected, and the illustrations were beautiful as always, but I think the overall messaging could have been more impactful than it was.

Was this review helpful?

Rainbow Fish is an enduring children's favorite. The new addition to the line-up will be enjoyed by preschoolers and early elementary students. The illustrations are bright and sparkly and really draw one's eyes to the pages.

Rainbow Fish has a new friend named Humbert. Humbert's stories are fantastical and more than a little hard to believe. Rainbow Fish and his friends swim away and leave Humbert all by himself. Then Rainbow Fish has an idea - why not let Humbert tell his stories as tall tales! Humbert becomes known for his excellent story-telling skills and his tall tales. And Rainbow Fish and his friends get to hear all the great stories. Did you know there is a plug at the bottom of the ocean? Hmmm, true or tall tale? You read and decide.

Was this review helpful?

I remember when the first Rainbow Fish book was published and arrived in the library, it was such a popular series and the kids loved it as the rainbow fish was multi-colored and had the most amazing scales that the children could touch and feel the differences. It was also a good story and the book became quite popular. Over the years, the author grew the Rainbow Fish books by introducing new characters and new adventures. When I saw this one on Netgalley, I was excited to give it a read as also the "storyteller" part captured my attention as I love books about books and stories. One day Rainbow Fish meets Humbert, another fish and he tells Rainbow Fish a scary tale. She believes him and rushes to warn the other fish and nothing happens. As the book goes along, Humbert continues to tell stories and soon the other fish get annoyed with his lies. Humbert starts to feel dejected and lonely as no one wants to hang around him due to his stories. Rainbow Fish feels sorry for Humbert and helps him put his imagination to use by putting on a show for the other fish and becoming their entertainment as a professional "fish" storyteller. Like the other books, this was a cute read and had a feel-good ending, and shows the readers that sometimes we just need a push in the right direction to discover what our talents are.

Was this review helpful?

My kids love Rainbow Fish and this story did not disappoint. We loved learning about Herbert and I also liked the message about not telling lies. They encouraged Herbert to instead turn his imagination into something positive like storytelling.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this picture book would be a typical “boy who cried wolf” fashioned story, but I’m glad I was wrong. This is a sweet story about a fish, Humbert, who tells wild and untrue stories to the fish population. In my experience, people tell elaborate and untrue stories because they are lonely and this is one of the only ways they know how to make friends or make themselves important. The fact that the other fish were kind to Humbert and gave him another outlet for his stories and became friends with him was a nice ending to me. The illustrations were beautiful and wonderful. Overall, I liked this story for its message of compassion.

Was this review helpful?

"The whole story sounded strange and a bit unbelievable." Is the phrase that sticks out when I think of Humbert. Humbert is a fishThis story would be greatly used in a social lesson about telling the truth. The illustrations we're pretty like in other Marcus Pfister stories. This story is recommended for children.
I found this on #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Rainbow Fish meets a new friend, Humbert, who often tells elaborate and sometimes scary stories. Eventually, Rainbow Fish realizes that while the stories may be exaggerated, Humbert has a knack for storytelling and encourages him to use this skill in a gentler, more welcoming way. We loved this story about identifying tall tales as well as friendship, open-mindedness, and storytelling. Thank you, NetGalley, for the ARC! My kids (ages 1, 3, 5, and 7) and I loved it!

Was this review helpful?

I received an advance reader copy of this book to read in exchange for an honest review via netgalley and the publishers.

Rainbow Fish and the Storyteller is a beautifully, sparkly, illustrated children's book about a delightful Fish called Rainbow Fish. Rainbow Fish gets tricked into believing another fish, Humberts far fetched tales. After Humbert tells him there's a plug at the bottom of the ocean that another fish is going to pull and empty the sea of water, Rainbow Fish swims off to tell his friends. They're not tricked as easily and after a second tale about a big scary whale the fish are left shaken. They find a solution to this and the story ends on a positive note with a lesson to be learned for children.
This was a great book but I found the text very small and a little too much and long for the age group of children the book is aimed at.

Was this review helpful?

I have loved the Rainbow Fish series since I was a child and I am thrilled that there are new ones being released. I think this one had a great message for kids about exaggerating and telling white lies. The illustrations were beautiful and eye catching.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with the ARC!

Rainbow Fish and the Storyteller is a great story for children with the underlying message how to trust sources. In today's world there is a great amount of misinformation and children will have to learn how to navigate tall tales, lies and the truth. This picture is a great start for this conversation with children.

In the book, Rainbow Fish meets a new friend, Humbert, who tells a lot of stories. There was, for example, a big plug that would drain the ocean! But is this plug really there? Did someone really pull it? Humbert tells other tall stories and Rainbow Fish and his friends are not sure if they should believe him anymore.

Was this review helpful?

Rainbow Fish and the Storyteller is a sweet story of the classic Rainbow Fish and his friends. Together with his friends they help another fish and learn lessons along the way. This is a cute story that I think parents and kids would like to read together! The illustrations of Rainbow Fish are beautiful.

Was this review helpful?

Rainbow Fish and the Storyteller was very cute! I think the point will get across to young children through the storyline, dialogue, and relatable problems the characters face. Rainbow fish and his friends aren't sure what to think when Humbert tells wildly made-up stories that don't seem true but are scary none the less. Eventually, the group doesn't want to hang out with Humbert anymore and he becomes lonely. Rainbow fish and another friend decide to make a deal with the lonesome Humbert, that he is welcome to be part of the group if he tells friendly and positive stories. There are many conversations with kids that could stem from this story-making good judgement calls when meeting new people/making new friends; how to compromise; how to forgive and move forward; the importance of truth-telling over exaggeration. I would love this book in my classroom!

Was this review helpful?

Rainbow fish is by far the most iconic illustration for any and all childrens books.

This new rainbow fish did not disappoint and honestly just keeps the legend alive.

Was this review helpful?

Although I had high expectations for this book (mostly because I recognized the rainbow fish from somewhere), unfortunately, I didn't enjoy any aspect of this story. I think the point that was coming across was way too simplistic (yes even for the target audience) I think the story is not told in a way as to be engaging for kids (which is ironic because it's a story about a storyteller) and even the illustrations are, although beautiful, oddly static and devoid of life. I know this is harsh, but there isn't anything inherently wrong with this. It would be a perfectly serviceable story to tell your children, but in a world where there are so many exceptional children's picture books why would I recommend just average?

Was this review helpful?

This will be a fun addition to the Rainbow Fish family of books. In the traditional, colorful style we've come to expect with Rainbow Fish, Marcus Pfister has come up with a book that storytellers themselves will be happy to share with kiddos. The message will also strike a chord with grown-ups helping their preschool-aged children navigate the differences between truth and fiction.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun, yet quick, story about telling the truth. I think this could be a nice story to use during lessons on being honest. It did seem really quick and I got to the end and wanted more. I think my students would absolutely love to read and listen to this story.

Was this review helpful?

This was really cute! I read this before bed with my three year old and she absolutely loved it and was mad when it was over! I’ve always loved the Rainbow Fish illustrations and this was no different! Such beautiful artwork and it was just such a quaint cute little read! Highly recommend if you have little ones, or just love picture books, that you check this one out!

Was this review helpful?

Years ago when I was an elementary librarian, I remember reading first Rainbow Fish book. The children loved it and I as well. Who could resist the colorful pages, glittering scales and the sweet story. Now with this book, children can revisit their friend and enjoy a heart touching story again. I loved that Rainbow Fish took time to listen and help Humbert. It takes time to make friends and to help him be a friend.
I enjoyed the book and would recommend it
Thank you to Net Galley for allowing me to read this book. The opinions are entirely my own.

Was this review helpful?