Member Reviews

I have read everything Elizabeth Strout has written and I was so pleased to hear the next chapters of Lucy Barton’s life story.

Strout writes with such honesty and she details the minutiae of every day life in such a way that it is fascinating. And this time Lucy is living through the lockdown caused by Covid and we hear how this affects her and those around her. Lucy is the first person narrator and we share her fears, worries, sadness, losses and occasional nuggets of happiness. We learn a lot about her ex-husband William, of Oh William!, as he is the one who takes charge of her and insists she leaves her New York apartment and go to Maine with him, where they will both be safer. But in this isolation Lucy cannot read, or write, and just thinks. She is gripped by her own disbelief that the pandemic, and all that entails, is happening to her and her wider family.

You’d think a visit to the supermarket or stopping at a gas station would be dull but Strout makes self contained stories out of the smallest incidents which, nevertheless, build to create a whole mood. Strout writes in beautiful lean prose. Every word seems to have a place.

Lucy makes new friend. Bob Burgess from The Burgess Boys appears as a kindly sounding board for Lucy’s worries. And another favourite character is there too and I was just aching for Lucy to visit ‘them’ , now in a care home, but it never happened. Next time please.

I read a copy provided by Random House and Netgalley but this had no bearing on my true opinions. One of my favourite authors and highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

When I think about my absolute favourite kind of book, it’s something by Elizabeth Strout.

I loved this book for all the reasons I loved her others - beautiful writing, incredibly-realised characters, moments of reality that take my breathe away.

Just another beautiful book about people and life and moments and feelings. I adored it as I do everything she writes.

4.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

Lucy is persuaded by her ex-husband, William, to leave New York just as covid hits, and to move with him to the coast of Maine. There she recounts the small daily activities that grow to mean so much in lockdown and her feelings of isolation as she misses her daughters and David, her husband who recently died.

It is hard to put my finger on what makes the Lucy books so insightful and readable. The narrative voice is pitch perfect; it could lapse into faux-naivety but never does and the way that Strout widens the everyday to include all or most of humanity is so smooth that it is almost unnoticeable. You just feel its impact.

A very good read and many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for a review copy.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this, as I have loved all Elizabeth Strout novels, but I can't deny that it's a slightly painful love. Like pressing on a bruise. There's something so vulnerable about Strout's characters - their introspection leaving them so exposed - and the feeling that every person in the world is similarly vulnerable is almost too much to take.

When I saw that this was Lucy-in-a-pandemic I almost put the book down, but ultimately, of course, I'm glad I didn't.

My thanks to Penguin and NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely love Elizabeth Strout's books and so was thrilled to get the opportunity to read Lucy by the Sea. Strout's writing style is unique- it flows so well and is extremely authentic. She completely takes you into her character's lives with honesty and realism. Lucy by the Sea is set at the start of the pandemic and the first lockdown- so bear this in mind if you are not yet ready to revisit this time in fiction. At the start of the pandemic Lucy's ex husband William persuades her to spend lockdown at a cottage in Maine by the sea. During this isolating time Lucy voices the fears we all had about death and family. Strout is excellent at friendships and family relationships and I absolutely loved this. It took me a while to go back to 2020 and I initially found it a little surreal. However once I became involved in the novel I was completely immersed over the course of 24 hours. Although this is part of a series of books about Lucy it can easily be read as a standalone. Highly recommended.
Many thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this digital ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Elizabeth Strout once again resurrects the brave and courageous iconic writer, Lucy Barton, and writes movingly and profoundly of Lucy's experiences of lockdown, like so many us not quite grasping initially the implications of Covid 19. It is William in his determination to save her who whisks her away from New York to the Maine coastal town of Crosby, with Lucy having no idea that she will never again return to her apartment. Strout paints an authentic, gentle, intimate, understated and resonating picture of the loneliness, isolation, anxiety, fears, panic, grief, love and loss that Lucy feels, along with the development of her complicated relationship with her ex-husband William, the comfort they find in each other despite their odd irritations with each other, a comfort that leads to them finding their way to each other again, despite his cheating on her in their marriage, something her daughters find more difficult to accept than she expects

Strout exquisitely captures what it is to be human in these challenging times, such as what it means to be family, of being a mother to 2 precious adult daughters with their own issues, Chrissy's miscarriages, the crumbling of Becka's marriage to the poet Trey and its impact on William as he reflects upon and regrets his past infidelities. There is a compassion, non-judgementalism, and a humanity with which the author approaches her characters, many of whom make an appearance from other books, building on old connections whilst there is the simultaneous creation of a web of new connections after having moved to the strangeness of a new place, physically and metaphorically. Lucy makes a heartfelt empathetic connection with Bob Burgess through their walks and socially distanced meetings, he has read her memoir and relates particularly to the issue of growing up in such deep poverty. She begins to understand and see beyond the stereotypical Trump supporters through meeting Charlene at the food pantry, and her sister, Vicky, people living under heavy pressures, part of the troubled communities who have been regarded with contempt and looked down on by establishment circles.

In the darkest of times, Strout provides hope and light in her latest stellar and thought provoking novel, highlighting the time and opportunities available for us to spend in reflections of our current lives, the past, the family, relationships, and growth in developing greater resilience and vital understanding of others who make up our fragile, desperate, and ravaged communities, whilst potentially generating new energies and excitement by moving into new areas professionally, personally and geographically that might have been otherwise unthinkable pre-pandemic. This is a beautiful and contemplative novel that just bursts with heart and underlying wisdom, and a Lucy whose struggles and challenges are a pure joy to follow through the harsh realities and losses of a nightmare pandemic. Highly recommended. Many thanks to the publisher for an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This is the author’s lockdown novel. We see America in the pandemic through Lucy’s eyes. Her familial relationships change as she reconnects with her ex-husband and spends lockdown with him in Maine. She reflects upon her relationships with her daughters and makes new friends.

I enjoyed this beautifully written and thoughtful book and would highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

Lucy by the Sea is Lucy Barton’s third outing, the second in a year. Lucy and her ex-husband, who readers met in last year’s Oh William!, spend the first year of the pandemic in Maine where Lucy’s life, like many others, is changed in surprising sometimes shocking ways.

William is quick to see which way the wind is blowing, whisking the sceptical Lucy off to the coastal town of Crosby. Lucy is convinced they’ll be back in New York in a few weeks but William thinks they’re in for a long haul, ensuring that both their daughters are safely away from the city, too. Things are a little scratchy at first, but they settle into a routine. Lucy misses her daughters, grieves the loss of people she loves and comes to understand herself, William and their country a little better. William, meanwhile, takes on the practicalities of their new life with alacrity and finds his way to an unexpected reconciliation and contentment.

As ever, Strout’s writing is empathetic and insightful. She summons up that strange, unreal time when many of us, like Lucy, didn’t know what had hit us nor had an inkling how long we would remain in the introspective, claustrophobic lockdown bubble before the freedom offered by vaccinations. There’s a more overt political strand than in previous Strout novels as Lucy thinks about Trump supporters and frets about the spread of Covid during the Black Lives Matter protests. Any doubts about Lucy’s third outing were quickly dispelled for me. If anything, I found this a more interesting novel than Oh, William! and My Name is Lucy Barton.

Was this review helpful?

If you were to quote sentences or paragraphs, you wouldn't be wowed, Strout's writing is unadorned and simple, yet she conveys people's complexities, contradictions, flaws and virtues like no one else.

This is the fourth book featuring Lucy Barton, a writer, divorced and widowed, now in her sixties. When the Coronavirus makes its way to New York, William, Lucy's former husband and the father of her two daughters, convinces her to "escape" with him to Maine. They rent a house on the coast. It's a small community, it's quiet, and nothing much happens. Of course, the pandemic affects them mentally, things happen to friends and family members. Remember the ups and downs of that strange period? Lucy experiences worries, panic attacks, grief, and memory loss. Most of us will find those elements familiar, we've experienced them in different ways. Of course, while we were all in the same boat when it came to the pandemic, some were travelling in little boats, while others were facing the storm in luxury, well-built and equipped boats - but that's not the point - this is Lucy's story.

I appreciated reacquainting myself with some "old friends" whom Strout brought back in more or less significant ways. Obviously, she knows that she's got her faithful readers. I'm sure I'm not the only one who feels invested in Lucy's story.

So, have you met Lucy yet?

Was this review helpful?

My devouring of this story was completed last night and I’ve been thinking a lot about Lucy Barton ever since.

After reading this latest instalment of the “Barton” series, I can truly say Lucy and I have been on some incredible journey together. But the thing is, I have no idea what she looks like. She did mention blonde highlights in this book, but that’s a about it. That’s the quality of Strout’s writing – even though I know Lucy so, so, so well and love her to bits and bits. I don’t need to know what she looks like. Skin is, after all just a few layers of protein, carbohydrates, water and gunk that cover each and every one of us – but it’s not who we are, we don’t need to know what Lucy looks like. Strout makes her appearance redundant. The author’s sparse writing – and it is sparse – tells us everything we need to know about this gentle, thoughtful woman.

I feel I know Lucy better than many people I mix with in my own life. Importantly, Strout also allows us, the reader, to fill in the gaps in her characters. She respects us in this way. So, who knows - Maybe my Lucy is different to your Lucy?

It would be a lovely experience to compare each and everyone’s Lucy – you think?

Lucy’s ex-husband, William drags her upstate New York, along with their daughters to get away from the Big Apple during the carnage of the first wave of the COVID pandemic. They all stay at different houses, and all strictly observe requirements of mask mandates, distancing, isolation periods – William (being an obsessive scientist) wouldn’t have it any other way.

I like William too – but he’s a funny bugger, funny as in ‘funny’, not funny, funny. There’s certain gaps in his character I can’t fill in. Maybe he’s a typical bloke? Certain scenes – for example when Lucy wants to describe an event that has happened in her day and he looks up from his laptop with impatience, which quickly turns to boredom. This is noticed by Lucy. Because she tells us by saying “I noticed that”. Oh dear – I know what William did there, I know only too well – the need for the women in our lives tell their stories, the need for blokes to get to the point. Poor Lucy – it’s heartbreaking, but she reflects on these things with such insight and understanding it’s almost superhuman. She will say things like “I understand why he thinks that”, or “I noticed that”.

Lucy doesn’t seem to blame or condone. She just remembers and, says.

How gentle.

There are people they ‘meet’ from a distance, upstate. We get to know their stories too. Also, William’s half-sister comes into his life in a bigger way. We also see relationships change and develop between all the characters, some relationships are created and even lost. The types of variations all of us see and experience everyday of our lives.

Nothing extraordinary, but profound when you think about it.

This is the best. I will remember this story - I want to tell you that.

Was this review helpful?

Elizabeth Strout is a unique writer, her work is conversational, warm, honest, and heartfelt. I’ve enjoyed several of her previous books. Her new novel, Lucy by the Sea, is also wonderful. Lucy Barton has moved to Maine during the Covid emergency with her ex-husband William. As she adjusts to the anxious and slower rhythms of her new life, she comes to terms with past mistakes, both hers and William’s, and worries about her two daughters, Chrissy and Becka who have their own troubles in adjusting to the health crisis and in their relationships.

There were so many powerful truths in this novel, I was often struck by its wisdom. One that struck me was Lucy’s observation that we need to truly put ourselves in other peoples’ heads to have empathy for them. She talks of the divide in America and the antipathy some parts of the society have for their more educated and well-off peers - how the feeling of being ‘less than’ over their entire lives can cause rage. She links this to the people who stormed the White House and who support Donald Trump. Lucy doesn’t excuse the behaviour, but she gives an understanding of its cause.

I read the book very quickly because I savoured being in Lucy’s gentle point of view, hearing her musings and observations. Above all else she loves her family and her forgiveness of William’s past errors and enduring love for him is really touching.

In addition to this, I have always been leery of the idea of a book set in lockdown, but Strout is such a brilliant writer that she pulled this off and made it compulsive reading.

With thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Random House for the advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

Again I had forgotten how Elizabeth Strout’s writing affects me emotionally ,she has the ability to look at tiny pieces of a life and write about them so perceptively that you feel she understands life better than you
This book took me immediately back to my own lockdown and the sad caged on feelings that I had as the world went mad around me .i wasn’t sure if I was really ready to relive this so soon ,I wished I had come across this book a few years from now
Inter family claustrophobia is so beautifully observed as is the feeling an adult woman has about her grown children .i wandered how much was autobiographical,surely some of it had to be .
She has a very distinctive way of writing ,almost a stream of consciousness verbatim record of how we think .I imagine this might not be to everyone’s taste .I suspect she is a bit of a marmite writer not everyone will enjoy this .I also imagine that if I had been in a different mood myself I may have not got into the book as quickly as I did
I read an early copy on NetGalley Uk the book is published 6th October 2022 by Penguin Uk

Was this review helpful?

I have read and loved pretty much everything Elizabeth Strout has written, so it was a real joy to spend more time in the company of some of her most lovable characters. 'Lucy by the Sea' is a sequel to 'My Name Is Lucy Barton' and 'Oh, William!', unfolding over the course of 2020 and early 2021 during the coronavirus pandemic. In March 2020, Lucy's ex-husband William persuades Lucy to leave New York with him and sit out the pandemic in the small coastal town of Crosby, Maine. Lucy recounts the events of this year, including her changing relationship with William, the challenges faced by their daughters, and William's efforts to connect with the half-sister whose existence he discovered in 'Oh, William!'. She also continues to reflect on her impoverished upbringing in Amgash, Illinois, and her brother and sister who still live there.

Strout's novels are frequently self-referential, and seasoned readers of her work will recognise Crosby as the setting of 'Olive Kitteridge' and 'Olive, Again'. The novel also features a number of characters from her other novels, including Bob Burgess from 'The Burgess Boys', a now-adult Katherine Caskey from 'Abide With Me' and Charlene Bibber from 'Olive, Again', as well as a cameo appearance from Olive Kitteridge herself. Some readers might find this slightly self-indulgent (even a quotation from a novel referenced by Lucy turns out to come from 'Olive, Again'), but it is rather moving to be able to see what has become of these characters in the years since we last saw them.

Strout imbues this novel with Lucy's trademark insight, vulnerability and tenderness, and the novel offers a powerful study of the kind of intimacy that exists in a relationship like Lucy and William's. This feels like a looser and more episodic novel than Lucy's previous outings, and the narrative perhaps lacks the same sense of urgency we feel in 'My Name Is Lucy Barton' and 'Oh William!', but this is partly reflective of the way that we all experienced the passage of time during the pandemic.

This novel is also more politically engaged than Strout's other novels, referencing the killing of George Floyd and the Capitol riots as well as reflecting more generally on the growing divisions in American society. Lucy's response is primarily one of empathy for those who feel differently from her, partly borne out of her own experiences of extreme poverty. This is exemplified in her budding friendship with Charlene who has a Trump bumper sticker and refuses to be vaccinated; Charlene values her friendship with Lucy precisely because they don't talk politics. At the same time, Lucy seems to recognise the limitations of her position when she decides not to publish a story which is "sympathetic toward a white cop who liked the old president and who does an act of violence and gets away with it."

There have already been many other novels reflecting on how life changed during the pandemic, and there will doubtless be more to come. However, there is a particular comfort and pleasure to be found in reliving the events of 2020 through Lucy's eyes. Anyone who has enjoyed Strout's previous work will not be disappointed by this novel. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for sending me an ARC to review.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed the book although sometimes the writing seemed a bit dry.
There are a lot of topics discussed in here: pandemic, pregnancy loss, affairs, family relationships.
Quite often I was like: I felt the same during the lockdown. The book seems a bit sad and hopeful in the same time.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the next instalment in the series. This is the first book I’ve been able to read about the pandemic and stay detached. I love the writing and the characters.

Was this review helpful?

A great writer at the height of her powers. The reader follows Lucy Barton and the development of her relationship with William and her two daughters against the backdrop of covid. A deep and insightful work that digs into the realities of old age, loss and human frailties

Was this review helpful?

Lucy by the Sea by Elizabeth Strout

I am a big fan of Elizabeth Strout's writing so I was delighted to get this ARC from Netgalley. This book follows Lucy Barton and her family's experience of Covid 19 and lockdown. I read it while having covid myself for the first time which was a bit strange.

William, Lucy's first husband is a scientist so is ahead of most people in understanding the seriousness of the virus and works hard to make sure everyone in his family is safe. As we are all still living through the pandemic the book is really relatable and it is easy to identify with Lucy and how she feels. As always there is a lot of warmth in the writing and it was lovely to revisit the characters again (Lucy features in My name is Lucy Barton, Anything is possible and Oh, William!) I also loved that the character Olive Kitteridge from Elizabeth Strout's other books is mentioned in here.

The themes dealt with in this book( Covid, family, grief, pregnancy loss and affairs) are not particularly cheery but the book still felt hopeful and it felt like a comfort read.

Highly recommended if you already love Strout's writing and if you haven't read any of her books yet you are missing out!

Lucy by the sea will be released on 5th October 2022. Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

⭐⭐⭐⭐💫

Was this review helpful?

Knew immediately when I received the ARC of the new book by Elizabeth Strout that everything would stop until the last page was read. The highs and lows in the life and of our protagonist Lucy Barton , the narrator, take place from the beginning of Covid . The reader opens the first page of what feels like a private diary of the intimate, truthful and harrowing events, thoughts and tragedies that have stalked her life culminating in the fear and dread of a life threatening pandemic that initially she is unaware; gradually chasing her and ex husband William from New York to Maine , a potential safe haven. Watching events unfold both within her extended family and in world affairs leaves a loneliness that struggles to be understood and identified; a frightening sense of fear and confusion during which we share every memory of lockdown, lack of social interaction and different human reactions when there becomes what appears to be a fight for survival. Beautifully written prose, often poetic descriptions, enhanced by characterisation is such exquisite detail that the book begins to resemble a huge photograph album of places, events and real people in all their fallibility. Every human emotion is experienced often in heartbreaking detail towards a conclusion that is as rewarding as every thought and emotion expressed in print by the sublime Lucy. A story of our time , an unmissable superb read at every level and humbling to read what each one of us has and is experiencing during these difficult times. Thank you so much to this gifted author, the publisher and Netgalley for the joy this ARC has provided.

Was this review helpful?

This book is about a woman who moves with her ex husband to a more remote location in Maine to isolate during the COVID-19 pandemic. I found the pacing of the book slow and it wasn't a very gripping read.

Was this review helpful?

To begin with, I feared I wasn’t going to enjoy this latest Lucy Barton book. Lucy irritated me so much, especially her voice which seemed different from the way I remembered it in the earlier novels. Once I had settled into it and events started to unfold, though, I became as invested as I always am in an Elizabeth Strout story. Lucy continues to analyse her own and others’ actions and motives to death, constantly worrying about people’s reactions and feelings. That is Lucy’s way and I find it easy to engage with her. Towards the end of the novel, and the end of lockdown, Lucy spends much time musing on her life and relationships, on how her childhood shaped her, what she thinks her future might hold - classic Lucy and I enjoyed it all very much.

Lockdown on the coast of Maine seems not so far removed from my own experience, but with a lot more (distanced) socialising. This makes for a small cast of characters but we get to know them all the better for that and several characters from Strout’s other novels make cameo appearances. A joy for her fans and perhaps a lure for new readers to explore her other work.

With thanks to Penguin Viking via NetGalley for the opportunity to read an ARC.

Was this review helpful?