Member Reviews
This is a story of a girl who remembers her childhood in war-torn Sarajevo. She remembers little snippets of her life there where she had plans to run away with her best friend at the time but their plan fell through because she never showed up. As she dwelled on her loss years later, she met a guy who reminds her of her best friend and she takes us back to what she remembered and how the trauma and scars had impacted her life.
There are not many deep details shared within this story. A lot of the little snippets left by her helped me imagine what she went through, how she felt and how she came out of it. If you are looking for any historical events and explanation, you will not find it here. Instead, you will be engulfed in her feelings and emotions.
Thank you Netgalley and Guernica Editions for the arc
This was no easy read. Emotionally gripping and intellectually challenging, it made me consider war from the perspective of a child—a daunting task at best. This provides a unique anti-war text without being heavy handed.
I regret to say that I did not get on with this oddly written, impressionistic work. I found the prose vague and off-putting, and I struggled to make sense of it. Expecting a novel that would actually address the Siege Of Sarajevo, I was irritated by the endless fuzzy poetic rambling. The publisher misrepresented this book in the Net Galley description: “The Boy's Marble tells the story of experiencing a war through the eyes of a child.” As far as I got, there was no “story.“ This appears to be an essentially plotless work, and I can’t imagine many completing it.
A girl remembers her childhood in war-torn Sarajevo and her best friend who plotted to run away with her but disappeared. Years later, she meets a guy who reminds her of her long-lost friend. The novel is written in weaving stream-of-consciousness that shows us where memory and imagination meet and how the emotional scars of childhood never leave us.
We’re never given many details in the novel, and the stream-of-consciousness style reads more as prose-poetry than fiction. The language is beautiful, and the images are striking, but I felt as though the book was not marketed correctly. The blurb for the novel and the fact that it’s marketed as fiction led me to assume I’d be reading a story about the Sarajevo siege, but to describe this book in such a way feels misleading. This is far more poetry than prose, and if a person is curious about the war in Sarajevo, this is definitely not a book that will provide any historical information. The book is FAR more feeling than plot. I would go so far as to say that it’s lacking any plot at all. We never learn any character’s name, and we never learn any character’s outcome (though we can guess at a couple of them).
There is definitely an audience for this book, but it’s a very specific audience, and the book should be marketed carefully to find those people. Though I found it beautiful, I personally had to read the book slowly and in very small doses the way I would read a book of poetry (a few poems at a time). It was heartfelt and emotional, and for me it felt more like an examination of a person’s mental health struggles and lingering trauma than anything else.
A huge thank you to Guernica Edition and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
DNF - I had a difficult time trying to read the version given & though the publisher was very accommodating I found myself waning from the story. This remains a book I want to read & I feel confident that I will seek to revisit it via a library, at a later date
Thanks a lot Guernica editions for sharing the e-review copy. I have unfortunately been unable to finish this book due to the inconsistency in format which made it difficult to read on the app. and hence unable to provide review on this book. This in no way shows my feedback for author or publisher.
The rating is sole based on the first 15% of the book I read which showed promising writing by the author and crisp editing by the editor. Looking forward to more collaboration.
In this story, the unnamed protagonist who now lives in Canada meets a man who reminds her of a boy from her childhood in Sarajevo: they were supposed to run away together, but the boy never shows up and she never sees him again. In a stream of consciousness, the narrator goes back and forward between the past and the present, reminiscing how she lived in the Sarajevo war as a child, as well as her escape.
This reading was … confusing at best. Nothing happens, the story arch is practically inexistent, and all we are left with is good writing and too many metaphors and beautiful images. I found it extremely difficult to reach the end of the book, it seemed as reading a very long poem and while I found the writing beautiful and lyrical, the lack of a story in itself ruined it.
4.5⭐
"Everybody knows that the war makes you simultaneously less than yourself and more than yourself. Everybody knows that during the war you can hear steps from kilometres away, but nobody told me that they will stay with me years later or what to do with all these people living inside my eyes."
It has been twenty years since our unnamed narrator was a child in Sarajevo caught amid the Siege of Sarajevo (that continued from 5 April, 1992 to 29 February, 1996 for 1,425 days) in which 13,952 (maybe more) people lost their lives, including over 1600 children. Though she is presently in a city (Montreal, Canada) far away from where she spent her childhood, her memories are easily triggered. In a first-person stream of consciousness narrative, our narrator moves back and forth between past and present as she recounts memories of her childhood home, her parents and grandparents and her plans of traveling to the moon with her childhood friend- a boy who was her companion and with whom she played marbles with – their favorite marble being a blue-green hued marble that held a special place in both their hearts.
She had plans to escape the war-torn land with her friend. However, while she waited on their bench for him, he never showed. In the present day, it has been six months since she has met someone who reminds her of her friend. As the narrative progresses, we see her thoughts drift back to the memories of her childhood, often the lines between past and present become blurred.
The author also incorporates some facts about post-war Sarajevo, especially detailing the memorials dedicated to those who lost their lives. Our narrator describes the Sarajevo Memorial for Children Killed During Siege which features small columns engraved with the names of 521 children who were killed during the siege and a fountain with little footprints engraved at the base. She also describes the Sarajevo Roses, which are craters caused in the asphalt by exploding mortar shells that have been filled with red resin and that remain scattered throughout the streets, often resembling petals of a flower.
“Who would have thought that many years later these wounds would be filled with red resin and turn into flowers? Something broken now resembles flower heads. Who would have thought they would be called Sarajevo Roses? This is what the pain will be eternalized as in history. The holes left by the shells have turned into scattered petals.”
Natasha Nuhanovic’s writing is exquisite. On one hand, while we revisit memories of the devastation and bloodshed of war-torn Sarajevo with the child our narrator once was, we also bear witness to how traumatized the adult remains in the present day. Vividly descriptive and immensely disturbing, The Boy’s Marble requires more than a tad of patience to read through. Every single line of this book needs to be read to follow our narrator’s train of thought. At barely over 200 pages, while this is a heavy and emotionally exhausting read it is also a rewarding and unforgettable one.
Many thanks to Guernica Editions and NetGalley for the digital review copy of this novel. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.
4.5 stars
“I am not sure I know how to tell you about a past I do not understand. I fear I am making it worse. I fear I am making it come back to life before I know what to do with it .”
“In school we learned that if we step on a landmine, it is best to throw oneself sideways onto the ground, the same way a kite would fall after the wind decides it has had enough of playing. The lower the jump, the better. The more horizontally one falls, the less chance of dying.”
The description of this book says it doesn’t hide the evils of war but doesn’t burden the reader. I did feel burdened, though. The above sentences and so many others burdened my heart. War is hard for adults and I found it unbearablely sad from the viewpoint of a little girl. But that’s not a negative criticism at all because with this kind of story, a story of war’s impact, we should be burdened so we feel something of this even though we don’t know first hand. Sometimes with unnamed characters, I find it difficult to connect, but that was not the case here. A girl telling the story is an intimate view of her thoughts of the past and the boy with the marbles. Years later the memory is still alive.
I haven’t read a lot about The Bosnian War 1992- 1995, the Siege of Sarajevo, a couple of novels, perhaps, so I learned from this and was extremely moved by this debut novel, which is beautifully written. It’s about the losses they experience as a result of the the war, not the least of which is the boy’s marble collection, with his favorite marble gone with a mortar representing for me their lives as they knew it before.
I received a copy of this from Guernica Editions through NetGalley.
“Natasa Nuhanovic was born in Croatia. She grew up in a mixture between Croatia, Bosnia, Germany, and Canada. In 1994 her family escaped from Bosnia to Germany admidst the Bosnian war. Eventually, in 1998 her parents took her to Canada. She studied English literature, comparative literature and German literature at the University of Waterloo, University of Toronto and McGill, respectively. In 2010, Natasha published her first poetry collection, ‘Stray Dog Embassy’, with Mansfield Press. She continued to work and the literary field as a translator and interpreter after which she decided to venture into the medium of film. ‘Close the Door’ is her first feature-length movie at is set to play at several festivals. ‘The Boy’s Marble’ is her debut novel”.
The blurb written for “The Boy’s Marble” is ‘excellent’!!! READ IT.
It was from this blurb and Goodreads friend, Fran’s review that set me up —- I knew instantly I was interested in reading this book.
Children growing up in the heat of war — even running from it —is a terrifying thought to contemplate.
Elie Wiesel who wrote ‘Night’ …. a horrifying account from his teenage memories from having been taken from his home, along with his family, to the Auschwitz concentration camp — said:
“If in my lifetime I was to write only one book, this would be the one”…..
He also said….
“For the youth of today, for the children who will be born tomorrow. He does not want this past to become their future” ….
which brings us to another war: the Sarajevo Siege….
…..one Natasha Nuhanovic felt compelled to write about…..through the eyes of a child.
Using a child’s point of view allowed me as the adult reader to understand far more than child narrator—while allowing the child’s (a young girl), voice to flourish authentically.
As the adult — I got a pretty clear experience of how this innocent child dealt with post traumatic stress, loss, and her horrific life disruptions.
It’s a slim book at 200 pages. The writing is non- stop beautiful….almost ‘too’ beautiful. I felt it could have been a 100 pages: still powerful and unforgettable.
By page 139…. after pages of ceaseless —continuous—endlessness—beautifully harrowing—rhythmic lyrical prose …..I was tiring of it — it all began to feel ‘too much’.
This next paragraph is ‘powerfully-sad’ and ‘beautifully-written’, but I was getting drained and restless.
I was ‘already’ saturated with prior beautiful writing.
“The bright colours are seeping into my iris. The spring water is filling up the empty canisters. I am almost there. The colours are getting brighter. Light is bouncing off the water in the canisters and into my eyes. The next person in line comes in. The gate in front of my grandparents’ house makes a screeching sound as a gust of wind bumps it against the side. A vibration flows through the ground and tips the canister. The wind circles around it’s opening and whistles in a melody that sounds a lot like the sound the cylinders with the children’s names made.
The ground is vibrating again and something is pulling at my back. My eyes are opening, but it is getting darker instead, there is no more space in front of me. My eyelashes are brushing against some kind of ceiling. Dust particles are falling into my pupil”.
I’m glad I read this book —(Natasa Nuhanovic is ‘very’ talented making every sentence count)….one that somehow carried the lightness of a fairytale…from being so highly imaginable—and simmering in memories….
but I do admit her delicately poetic style was at times deeply engaging and other times taxing my nerves.
A few more excerpts that ‘did’ really speak to me:
“I want to say something to the boy, but I can no longer speak; the outside air is not reaching me. Both my eyes are turning into marbles with which we used to play almost every day. His favorite was the one with the blue-green river inside until it one day became brown, just like the rivers in our city. I guess nobody needed to ask why. Still, he would hold the marble tightly in his hand hoping next time he opens it, it will look more like he remembers, more like before when the flowers of the river were not yet trying to escape. What is the shattering sound? The marble is broken. There is water in my mouth, my hair is soaked and I have forgotten how to swim. Pedals on my tongue are piling up telling me stories of what they witnessed. Countless photographs of missing people are spiraling around me. Some are smiling. Others look serious, as though they could tell what was coming. On one, a grandmother is knitting an orange sweater with her grandchild sitting beside her. The river is carrying them all away. No, this cannot be, who will remember them then? This one photograph is not enough. I do not know anything about them. I need to know more. I need to know what happened. Why do I feel a pillow behind my head? No, I do not want to wake up. I need to collect all these facts. Each one of them can tell me more than anyone still alive”.
“I am just a stranger to this new place, because the room is closing its eyes, my breath has coated the window and I am trapped inside. Maybe everybody knows that, too, that some things can only be communicated in the dark. The war teaches you how to do that with wide-open eyes. But it did not teach me about the growing abyss that would remain in my eyes after spending years by candlelight and a small nightstand lamp. It did not tell me that one day, when the war is over, a normal light will seem too bright and burn my eye, that’s the address is too big to contract, and there is nowhere else to put all that has happened. I did not know then that years later I would be in a hotel room, making sure not to turn on most of the lights. I did not know then that my people, growing out of fear and instinct for survival, would become a home for everything I witnessed, a home that I know neither how to close, nor how to live in”.
“Everyone knows that the war makes you simultaneously less than yourself and more than yourself”.
“We were only children then. We devised the entire plan. Both of us would sneak out at midnight and meet at our favorite bench under our favorite street lamp halfway beneath his home and mine”.
“I feel like an open umbrella is spinning inside my lungs. I want to lie down inside, because I am tired of fighting and trying to see straight. I want to see everything turn and not have a problem with that. Nothing makes sense anyway. All these fragments inside me can whirl inside the umbrella like invisible dead skin in the air. They can put themselves together anyway they wish as long as they let me sleep only for a moment, as long as they tell me why I no longer see any reflection in the mirrors anymore at all”.
“Centuries of sorrow collect in my palm”.
“I do not usually mind beige, but these walls are ugly”.
And as I’ve said before —-War is war is War is War!!!
Disturbing, dark, hopeless, depressing, violent, soul wrenching, chilling, disheartening!!!
BUT….if I had to read a book about bleakness…the chaos of post war…,
“The Boy’s Marble” is one hell of a triumph of a first novel…with an endearing child narrator.
"There must be a different world somewhere out there and if we try hard enough, we will find it. I believed [the boy]. We were only children. We devised a plan. Both of us would sneak out at midnight and meet at our favorite bench..." "...the more I think of you, the closer I am getting to the moon...I don't think the moon slide would work without my magic slippers. I don't think I can do it without Snoopy's blanket beneath my soles." We were supposed to run away, but you never came.
The Sarajevo Siege which started in April, 1992, lasted 1,425 days, and ended in February, 1996. In first person stream of consciousness, a young girl recounts the cost of war. The writing style allows the reader to examine the girl's thoughts and feelings which seemingly are part imagination, part overlapping memories.
"We had already been counting a long time for the war to end, and we no longer wanted to wait...time to start counting the days towards our escape...tomorrow...the day to run away...I have not seen him since." Where was the boy from the bench? Why didn't he meet me? With fake passports in hand, the girl's family resettled in Canada in 1993. Two decades later, the girl saw a man that seemed to resemble the boy. Is he the boy from the bench?
The boy had a favorite marble. Holding it made the girl feel safe, however, the river inside had turned from blue-green to brown. The boy's marble collection, contained in a chalk circle and left outside overnight, were disappeared by a mortar strike. What about flowers? "I see a lot of flowers right in front of me...they are frozen in the position of their last moment of life...Like an audience that gave a standing ovation, but never sat down again...".
Living in a different city on a different continent...twenty years had passed. The girl still had haunting childhood memories of war's devastation. In her mind's eye, she saw "countless photographs of missing people". And the boy's marble? "Maybe the river inside would be blue-green again [because] everyone would be reminded that the rivers in our city were not always brown...a time when everyone was on each other's side. Maybe the marble may remind grownups that they could stop fighting and play together instead."
"The Boy's Marble" by debut novelist Natasa Nuhanovic is an outstanding anti-war novel. Ruminations on the cost of war are expressed in the young girl's monologue which meanders between the past and present. Highly recommended.
Thank you Guernica Editions and Net Galley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.