Member Reviews
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review!~
Characters - 5/10
Imani is the best of the best when it comes to being a Shield, a band of sorcerers. She has control over Iron magic. I overall enjoyed Imani, but initially I could not stand her or her sister. They're both a bit frustrating to read about as they just do not listen! Especially her sister - so hot-headed and stubborn!!! Teha is a big bully and I really am not a big fan of him, while I had no qualms about Qayn.
Atmosphere/Writing - 8/10
Ibrahim's writing really shone in this book, I think it's what kept me propelling through the quarrels between the two sisters. She very descriptive and really immerses us into the world she was building.
Plot - 8/10
I found myself invested in the plot nearly from chapter one for this one. I really love Djinn as a concept so you will find my diving in head first, without looking back, into any book that includes them. Add in a secret map and a girl's journey out into unknown territories with her sister and a near stranger all to find a family member that's gone missing? Absolutely going to be a win from me. Unfortunately, I do wish we could have seen Imani working her magic a little more and have less bullying and arguments going on..
Intrigue - 7/10
I like the world's Ibrahim creates and definitely have an interest in reading more of her work!
Enjoyment - 7/10
Glad I picked this one up - I may even do a reread of this in the future!
This was a wonderful YA fantasy read filled with Arabian mthyology! The world-building and plot were spectacular. I loved reading Imani's growth as the story progressed. Can't wait to read the sequel!
I very much enjoyed this book! The world build was probably my favorite part and all those lush descriptions! I do think it needed just a little more character development
Oh boy am I a sucker for Arabian-inspired settings! I did not know this was book one of a trilogy, but I am so excited to see more world building and middle eastern-mythology in future books!
While I do not care for the whole, "I'm not like other girls" trope in most YA fantasies, this book covered many important topics. I feel like we don't see domestic abuse and confinement and police brutality nearly enough in YA fantasy given all the things going on in the real world now.
I thought the magic system was very unique, I don't remember ever having a fantasy series where tea gives you your abilities. I appreciated that breath of fresh air in YA Fantasy.
The plot was the best part of the story, I rarely get sucked in so quickly to the plot versus the characters, but I am hoping that there will be more character development in the later books. I cannot wait to learn more about this lush world and characters. Here's to hoping for more news on book two!
I honestly love the influx of YA debuts we’re seeing that center non-Western mythology, and even specifically Middle-Eastern mythology! I love myths and fairytales and these sorts of stories, no matter the origin, and it’s so nice to see our idea of mythology, within these sorts of stories, expanding to include more than just the classic Greek gods. However, as with anything, not every new release will be a runaway hit, and unfortunately, that’s true for Spice Road.
This book had a lot going for it, especially in the beginning. I loved the world that seemed to be set up, the magic and myth that seemed inherent in every detail, and I couldn’t wait to explore this magical society further. Unfortunately, a large chunk of this book actually takes place away from this magical society, and since magic itself is rationed out through tea, we don’t actually see that much of it either, at least not consistently. It ended up kind of being a let-down, that as the book went on, we seemed to see less and less magic, and focus more and more on the world outside the magical society the main character grew up in. And while this made sense, for the story that was being told, it also meant that the story had to work a bit harder to keep me as invested in later parts of the book, when all I wanted was to go back to where we were at the beginning of the story.
One thing I did like about this book was Imani’s devotion to her city, to a fault. I’ve read a lot of books where the main character is blindly devoted to a cause or government, only for the curtain to suddenly be dropped, and dark secrets revealed, but it’s very rare to see a main character actually struggle through the change of readjusting your beliefs and your perception of the world after this curtain drops. Spice Road did a wonderful job of showing the struggles that come with this change, and how long it actually takes, and how many horrors you have to actually see, before you accept that a lot of what you believed in wasn’t true or that you were manipulated. It was interesting to see her journey, even if this didn’t always endear the reader to her either. I think this is what stood out most in the book for me.
Unfortunately, beyond this, there wasn’t much else I was a big fan of. I felt like the plot generally was a bit bland, just wrapped in magic so that it took a while to notice how bland it was. I find it difficult to find reasons to keep reading this series, though I will at least see if the synopsis of the second book will tempt me! This is also probably due to me just overall disliking the ending and how certain events feel glossed over, by characters that I wouldn’t think would gloss over them. Depending on how this plays out in the second book, maybe my thoughts here will change, though. Overall, it just didn’t entirely work for me, though I can see myself enjoying future works from this author one day!
Review will go live on my blog on April 19th!
I love Middle Eastern fantasy. Also sibling bond??? I can't wait to try all the foods! Thank you to Random House traditions for the ARC.
An incredibly strong debut by Maiya Ibrahim! The cover, the plot, the characters are all stunning. I need the UK edition in my physical book collection as soon as possible.
The main character Imani and her family live in the city of Qalia. Her home is surrounded by a monster filled desert, but Shields, like Imani, use their magic to protect their people. They use misra tea, or spice, to have a stronger connection to their magic through a unique manifestation. If overused, misra can be dangerous and addictive and its existence must remain secret from the outside world. Imani is on a quest to prove her brother’s innocence after he brings dishonor to their family by stealing misra and the vanishing. Imani's biggest challenge is whether she’ll follow her duty or stay loyal to her family. She travels with Qayn, a djinni whose got many secrets, and Taha, her enemy, the son of the council leader who was tasked to lead the mission.
I was hooked on this book as soon as I learned about it's premise. The idea of tea being a source of power for different magic forms that is unique to the user is brilliant.
The relationships and dynamics are the most important part of any book and is also 'The Spice Road''s best feature (apart from the incredible premise).
Taha is definitely on the 'putting you in the time out corner' for the bad behaviour and all the nonsense he was getting up to throughout the story.
The pacing of this book can be an issue for some and it was for me as well, but the lore and "what's going to happen - I must know" feeling often won out.
This story gives you:
- Enemies to lovers
- Middle Eastern/Arab-inspired fantasy
- Djinn
- Tea-based magic
- Strong family bonds
- An interesting magic system
- Love triangle between three badass characters
- Discussions on colonialism
Thank you so much to Maiya Ibrahim and Random House/Delacorte Press for sending me an eARC!
Stunning! I adored this middle eastern inspired fantasy novel. Imani and her family live in the city of Qalia. Her home is surrounded by a monster filled desert, but Shields, like Imani, use their magic to protect their people. Their powers come from a tea made from misra, a spice particular to their people. After meeting a strange djinni named Qayn, and learning that her brother who had been assumed dead may be alive in the world outside the Forbidden Wastes, Imani embarks on a journey to rescue him. She can't make this journey alone, and course her nemesis, Taha, the son of the council leader, is chosen to lead the mission. Will they reach her brother before it's too late? Read Spice Road and find out.
I really enjoyed this world from the get go. I love tea being the power source for a form of magic, and that it takes a different form for each user. The characters' emotions feel real. Gotta love the enemies to lovers trope too. You just get a glimpse into the lore of this world, and I really hope it's expanded upon in future installments.
First, I am enamored of this cover art.
Imani is seventeen and the youngest Shield in history, defending the people of Qalia from monsters beyond the wall. Taha is eighteen, the second-youngest Shield in history, and apparently Imani’s rival/future love interest.
Spice is made into magic tea via a ceremony which then allows the drinker to manipulate one affinity of the land, like sand or wind, or change shape or something.
The inciting incident is the disappearance of Imani’s younger sister, Amira, and her missing older brother’s horse. Beyond the safety of the walls they encounter evidence that their brother, Atheer, might not be dead and he might not have been a Spice addict like everyone believed, but instead a traitor sharing the Spice with outsiders for a mysterious purpose. They also find a djinni boy about Imani’s age who seems to know something about Atheer. His name is Qayn and he manipulates Imani into binding with him (or binding him to her dagger, at any rate).
Imani forces the council to send her after her brother, but they saddle her with Taha and his companions. Her little sister, Amira, also tags along. There are monsters. Qayne is cocky and mysterious and still a more compelling love interest than Taha, who’s hot-and-cold routine is just not cute. Of course, an ancient djinni who was once a bad king isn’t really a great love interest either. Maybe Imani should just focus on getting her siblings home safely.
Things do not turn out as intended for the party, and it’s an interesting read, but not one that really stays with a person.
The cover for the print version is gorgeous.
I really enjoyed the magic system in Spice Road and how for as long as anyone can remember, Qalia has been kept separate from the rest of the world while they have been tasked with fighting and destroying the myriad types of monsters who dwell in the sands of the Forbidden Wastes. I especially liked learning about the magic system and how each person in Qalia finds their magical affinity with the drinking of the misra tea. I found that of the different types of magics that were introduced in the book, I liked the affinity that Taha possessed, for it enabled him to connect his mind with his animal familiar and take over the animal’s body to perform difficult tasks. I think I liked this particular type of magic the best because as a dog owner there have been countless times where I have wondered what my dog is thinking or trying to tell me, and I feel like if this were something that existed it could make the bond one has between owner and pet that much stronger.
As much as I loved the plot of the story and how it kept the story moving forward, I could’ve done without the love triangle between Imani, Taha and the djinni Qayn. I found that the moments in the story where Imani found herself obsessing over how Taha’s treatment towards her differed depending on whether or not they were alone to be annoying and it slowed the story down for me; while Imani’s slow burn feelings towards Qayn made me want to shout at her “He’s a 1000+ year old djinni, it’ll never work out, move on girl!” The love triangle aside, I did enjoy the group dynamic and seeing Imani realize why the other scouts were chosen for this mission and that they are just as good and capable with their affinities as she is with her.
One of the things that I had been looking forward to most about this book was the middle eastern mythology, sadly there wasn’t as much as I had hoped or wanted in a book that has such creatures as djinnis and were-hyenas. It is my hope that in the next book the mythology be weaved into the book more and that we’ll see even more character development with less of the love triangle. Overall, this was a fun debut and I look forward to seeing what the author does with it.
“If the world is dark and you are the only one with a flame, what do you do?”
“Share it, I answered”
Spice Road by Maiya Ibrahim was a recent @fantasyfrenemies pick that I absolutely loved.
The first book in a new trilogy follows Imani as she sets out in search of her brother who was believed to be dead. However, new evidence leads her to believe he is alive so she sets out with Qayn and Taha in hopes of finding him alive.
I really loved this book! I liked how Imani grew to see outside herself as the book progressed. I was a fan of Taha even though not everyone might agree with me (you have to read to find out why).
I am looking forward to seeing more growth and bad assery (it’s a word 😉) from Imani in book two.
Thank you to @delacortepress and @netgalley for the e-arc.
Unfortunately I couldn't really get into this book... the writing itself was good, but the plot was slow and it felt like nothing was really happening. The magic system is very novel and intriguing but it felt like we didn't learn enough about it. I'm sure this book will be enjoyed by many but it didn't end up being my cup of tea (literally).
I enjoyed readingSpice Road.
I liked the Arabian inspired setting and I found the magic system really unique. This is a debut that was done really well.
The book is very intriguing and has many plot twists that made me more invested in the story.
The characters were realistic and complex (especially Taha) and their family and friendship dynamics were really strong.
The plot of this novel is incredibly compelling. The magical element, in combination with rebellion, adventure, and family really kept me in the book. That being said, the rest of this book was lacking for me. While the plot was interesting, I wanted more world-building. Seeing new worlds come to life is one of my favorite aspects of fantasy and it fell flat here.
That said, I am intrigued for how this story will continue. This is a good debut and I am excited to see how the author grows from here.
Spice Road by Maiyah Ibrahim is my favorite YA Fantasy book I’ve read thus far in 2023. Toward the end of 2022, I started to get a bit burnt out on YA Fantasy, and took a break from the genre because all of the books I was reading seemed to fit the same mold, and I kept finding myself wanting for more out of the story. Not so for Spice Road! I loved the world building, the characters, the djinni, the Spice magic, all of it. Sure, there were parts where I knew a bit where the story was going, but I didn’t mind because it felt fresh. The stakes were high the whole time and it kept me turning pages.
I honestly could have dealt without the romance in this one. I think that it’s a bit of a trap that YA Fantasy authors fall into where they feel like they HAVE to include romance to get readers. Don’t get me wrong, I love a good romance sub-plot in my Fantasy books, but I felt like the romance was a bit half-baked and unnecessary and at points detracted from Imani’s character development. All that said, I’m excited to see where this series goes, and I will DEFINITELY be reading the next book when it comes out. This book was action-packed and page-turning, so I’m hoping we get more time to really peel back the layers on all the characters in book 2!
Overall, a super fun, action-packed YA fantasy with a unique world that I binge read in a few sittings.
Right from the beginning, SPICE ROAD captured my attention and held on to the very last page. I loved that this story dove right into the action and magic. Often times it can be difficult to assimilate to a new fantasy trilogy and the expectation is usually that the first book will be overloaded with information to prepare readers. SPICE ROAD took a bit of a different approach and immersed readers right away with Imani’s story and her quest to find her brother, who was believed to be dead.
Along with the pace of the story, I really enjoyed the way that the magic worked and evolved throughout the book. I thought the concept was incredibly unique and I appreciated how different characters were able to use this magic differently, which kept the story interesting. I’m hoping that in future books we’ll learn more about the history behind the spice magic and the other ways it may manifest.
And then of course there are the characters. I thought Ibrahim did an amazing job creating three dimensional characters that were likable at points, flawed, and ever changing throughout the story. Each character made mistakes or did things that will frustrate readers, but it all came together to build an incredible story.
Of course I’m excited for the second book and thought the ending set it up perfectly to continue on! If you’re looking for a new fantasy trilogy to start, pick up SPICE ROAD!
Loved ever minute of this book! It was such a unique plot and I loved all the characters. Thank you netgalley for an advanced eARC in exchange for an honest review
*eARC provided through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review*
I normally dislike books with long travelling sequences, but I think this was done really well.
Don't know how I feel about Taha, or Qayn, for that matter.
Desperate to know the true history of the Sahir.
Heavy focus on colonization, reminds me of AEITA.
I had so much fun talking to Maiya on my podcast, Raise Your Words. We talk about everything from her character Imani to world-building, writing advice, and book two!! Spice Road is an incredible fantasy novel!!!
Thank you to NetGalley, Random House Children's, Delacorte Press, and Maiya Ibrahim for the opportunity to read Spice Road in exchange for an honest review.
Spice Road is the first in a trilogy featuring middle-eastern based characters in a fantasy world. With a play on the Silk Road, like the Chinese trade route, the Spice Road mentioned in this world is a major route for city and trade connections, though Qalia is hidden amongst the rest of the world, its use of misra tea, or spice, granting the people a stronger connection o their magic through an affinity. Misra can be dangerous and addictive, if overused, and its existance must remain secret from the rest of the world outside of Qalia.
Although Imani has made a name for herself as a monster and djinni slayer, her brother's actions have cast a dark cloud over their family's legacy. Atheer brought dishonor to their family name by being caught stealing the highly prized misra. It is clear that he was obsessed with the power it possessed. Following the incident, he vanished without a trace and was presumed to have perished somewhere in the treacherous expanse of the Uncharted Regions. Despite the pain he caused, Imani still mourns her brother and thinks of him constantly.
When a clue appears, Imani knows she must follow his trail into the world outside of Qalia. Her affinity for iron and prowess with a sword, as well as doing the forbidden and unthinkable--bonding a djinni to her blade--is enough for her to pursue her brother and bring him back.
Imani is tasked with accompanying the councilmen's son, Taha, along with two other shields on a mission to bring Atheer back and bring him to justice. A stange rivalry-turned-romance-turned-rivaly occurs bewteen Imani and Taha, and she has no clue what to think about this hot-and-cold guy. Between monster slaying, survival in the sands, rebel fights, and a prison break, there is quite a bit going on when it comes to Imani's goal of finding her btrother.
This book took longer than expected for me to read, as it is 464 pages. The main story feels a bit dragged out. Imani is highlighted as this impressive monster slayer, though throughout the novel, only one monster battle is present. A lot of the novel is travel and political conversations that have some intrigue to them, but also drag the book a bit longer than it needs to be. I do feel like, as this is a trilogy, there is some good setup for events to come in future installments.
Despite the slow feel, I by no means have any dislike for this book. In fact, I really enjoy the setup of the world and find the relationships between the characters to be something that will continue to develop and make the conflict and plot in books two and three be something to look forward to. I hope to see some more of Qayn, Imani's bound djinni, as well as a resolution to the immense adventure these characters still have ahead of them in their stories. This is a book I would recommend for an avid reader, someone looking for a longer reading challenge, or anyone interested in middle-eastern culture who wants to see the mythological and cultural comparisons between fantasy and reality. Overall, a good book leading up to a trilogy with a lot of promise.