Member Reviews

Beautiful and heartbreaking. This story with this point of view could not have been easy to write, but it was masterfully told.

Was this review helpful?

There are not many authors who could write a book like this and have it be so full of humanity. What a great book!
well written and totally absorbing. I read this in 24 hrs and loved every minute of it. Such a great author!

Was this review helpful?

When reading All The Broken Places, I realized that I did not enjoy John Boyne’s writing. I never connected with the characters, didn’t like the structure and felt that it was bland. Come to find out there was a reason for that: I didn’t like his first book.

I did not realize this was a sequel to The Boy In The Striped Pajamas until I was researching it and as a history major I do not enjoy that book because it, in my opinion, trivializes the Holocaust and says that not all Nazis were bad. I agree that some soldiers were not “all evil” but the commandants of the concentration camps were vile and evil and trying to humanize them is not what I enjoy reading.

All The Broken Places is not a good book because I felt it continued the problems of Striped Pajamas: unlike able characters and a bad story.

Overall I did not enjoy this book and probably won’t read anything else that Boyne writes.

Was this review helpful?