Member Reviews

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 3.75/5
Spice: 🌶️ 1.5/5


Tropes/Topics:
Small Town Romance ✔️
Rom/Com ✔️
Grumpy/Sunshine ✔️
Slow Burn🔥✔️
Opposites Attract ✔️

Hallie fell hard for Julian at 14 & ever since, her heart has belonged to him. Now, he's back in town to focus on writing a novel but it's impossible, when Hallie ( the eccentric & chaotic gardener) is around. Each time, she shows up on his family's vineyard, he feels off kilter. She's his complete opposite yet he can't seem to stop thinking about her. Even when he finds a letter sent by a woman from his past, signed.. Secretly Yours.


H A L L I E:
is my CHAOTIC CURVY QUEEN👸🏼!! & I'm here for it! 🥰 She's 100% my spirit animal & the THINGS that would come out of her mouth & her inner thoughts?! It had me CRACKING UP!
But there were OTHER sides to Hallie as well,.. & those sides were the ones that gave MORE to her character.


J U L I A N
He didn't need STRUCTURE or SCHEDULES. He needed SUPPORT & his FAMILY. I wanted to tell him that he will find someone that would LOVE him, FAULTS & ALL💔 . That all he would need is, to give in to a little mayhem. & when he DID? GAWDDDDD 😩!!! The way he lost his composure just to KISS her?! 🥵
The way he wanted to do ANYTHING just to see her HAPPY?! S W O O N I N G 🥰


H&J
Hallie = CHAOS & Julian = CONTROL
They both KNEW that they were complete opposites & UNDERSTOOD that they DIDN'T make sense, together. But that PULLLLLLL? 🥰

While I enjoyed it & some parts had my heart EXPLODING with JOY.. I felt like it was missing SOMETHING.

What I NEEDED:
- love letters.. (there wasn't enough!) 🥺
- MORE Natalie VOS (Julian's sister had me cackling & I love her ALREADY!)
- AN EPILOGUE!!!


Tessa Bailey had me laughing, giggling AND giddy! Secretly Yours is a SWOONY & SWEET romance with some light S T E A M.

Was this review helpful?

Secretly Yours is the exciting new slow-burning romance from author Tessa Bailey.

Secretly Yours follows the story of Hallie and Julian. Hallie is a bit of a hot mess, trying to find her place in the world, now that her grandma has passed. She gets into a lot of shenanigans, but her heart is in the right place. When the object of her affection, Julian returns to town, he turns her world upside down in more ways than one…

Overall, I thought this book was a really cute read. I loved the premise of it. I loved how over-the-top and messy Hallie was. She has a heart of gold and isn’t afraid to stand up for the things that are most important to her. She is the complete opposite of Julian in every way, but you know what they say, opposites attract 🙂 Julian is a reserved and grumpy professor. He likes to have everything in order and isn’t sure what to make of Hallie. Everything about her should make him want to run in the other direction, but somehow, Hallie pulls him out of his shell and he can’t fight the pull he feels toward her. I adored the slow burn between Julian and Hallie and loved watching the two of them try to figure things out.

As much as I adored this story, I did have a few issues with it. The first one being a personal issue, I still very much struggle with the third-person point of view. It’s not my favorite and is always something that takes me a while to adjust to. My other issue with the story was the pacing. It started off a bit slow in the beginning and the slower pace made it feel like forever before anything happened.

Even though I had a few issues with this story, I still found it to be a delightful read. The characters are full of life and you can’t help but want to get to know them more. This story has entertaining shenanigans and light drama for the most part. But, don’t be fooled, this book has all the spice one would expect from this author. I think this series is off to a great start and I can’t wait for the next book in this series!

Was this review helpful?

First, let me say I literally cried when I got approved to read this one. Tessa is a romance powerhouse and she never lets me down.

I don't want to give anything away about this book but DANG, I was sucked in from the first page and couldn't put it down till I finished reading it at 4:00 am this morning. Julian and Hallie draw you in from the first page with their totally opposite personalities and lives and they don't let you go. Honestly, they may be my second fav couple written by Tessa behind Fox and Hannah. Plus, as someone who loves wine what could be a better novel setting than Napa?

Since I don't wanna give anything away here are some general things I loved about this one
- The character development of both Hallie and Julian. They both had so much to overcome but they did.
- How much I relate to Hallie, (my husband even lovingly (I think) calls me f5)
- How far each character is willing to go for what and who they love.
- Julians possessive side that's only there for Hallie
- Again, the setting of the book. LOVE LOVE LOVE
- Pretty much everything lol

I cannot wait till this comes out so I can pick up a physical copy and annotate tf out of it! 5 out of 5.

Was this review helpful?

Before I started this, I was seated firmly in a rom-com binge era. Afterward, it was brought to a screeching halt because it felt like nothing would top it.

Good lord, do I love when TB gets heartfelt.

I absolutely adored this. I’m not sure if I loved it *quite* as much as Hook, Line & Sinker, but it’s pretty damn close. Hallie & Julian stole my heart SO fast. I loved the depictions of Julian’s mental health. I loved the contrast of his strict order & routine up against her warmth and chaos. But this book really did feel like more than a rom-com to me. It was about healing and learning to trust yourself, to love yourself despite your flaws. To realize that if you can adore the messy parts of someone else, you can certainly learn to love them in yourself.

There was a moment where I found myself head scratching over the 3rd act conflict, but then as it went on, everything actually just made sense. The pacing was perfect. The romance was swoon worthy and touching. And it’s Tessa Bailey, so you know she is going to deliver on the spice. Not to mention, I am completely obsessed with this entire cast of characters. Lavinia’s dry British humor, Natalie’s rough edges, the charming older Lorna and her wine tasting shop. All of this against a stunning backdrop of wine country, and I couldn’t get enough.

In conclusion, I literally read this in less than 24 hours, and I was smiling goofily most of the time. Thank you so so so much to Avon& Harper Voyager for this eArc, I genuinely squealed when I got the approval. Now to begin the countdown to Natalie’s story!!

Was this review helpful?

I DEVOURED this book! It's no secret that I love everything Tessa Bailey writes. But I really, really loved this one.

Julien is an up-tight, play by the schedule, type A personality to a tee. Hallie is a literally human tornado in sunshine and flowers form. It's not secret from the beginning of this book that Julien and Hallie are all kinds of wrong for each other, but that's what made them perfect together. They both force each other out of their own comfort zones, pushing one another to be brave, take risks, and basically grab life by the gonads.

The story was entertaining. I loved the dual POV for this one, and loved reading how they are both being affected in so many different ways by falling back into each others lives as adults. The witty and sassy banter was hilarious, and the spice was spicy. But I expect nothing less from Tessa Bailey.

Julien Vos can literally wine and dine me any day. Already added him to my newest book boyfriend obsession after finishing this book.

A huge, huge thank you to NetGalley and Avon or Harper Voyager for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Secretly Yours is set to release on February 7, 2023!

Was this review helpful?

Secretly Yours started out so strong and I was here for it. Compared to my absolute favorite Tessa Bailey novel, It Happened One Summer, I was giddy as I saw the tropes falling into place.

Hallie is a chronically late, plus size, chaos woman who owns her own floral shop. If that is not absolute goals, in all her flaws, I do not know what is. Jullian, the object of her desire, is the complete opposite of her. He is collected and organized, the opposite of everything Hallie is. Despite their obvious chemistry, Jullian's heart and mind are at war over whether he can actually commit to her.

There was something missing, though, and I can't put my finger on it. I loved the love letter aspect. Tessa Bailey has a way with dirty talk that has me closing my book to gather myself. Those moments shined like Hallie's personality.

Ultimately, I really enjoyed this book. It was the perfect read to get you into that spring time, world awakening, love is in the air feeling that we are all missing in the winter. Hallie's demeanor is contagious and Jullian only wanting to make her smile and have her light directed at him made me swoon time and time again.

Was this review helpful?

Will preface by saying that this just wasn't for me. But since you require a review anyway: It just wasn't my favorite Tessa Bailey. I think Hallie is one of my least favorite Bailey heroines; sweet and femme to the point of caricature who the reader is supposed to buy as fun and quirky, but it just missed the mark for me. Julian is stale, and watching him watch Hallie wasn't insightful or riveting as much as it was just perverted.

Was this review helpful?

First big thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this arc in exchange for my fair and honest review.

Normally I absolutely love Tessa Bailey’s books. Did I enjoy this book? Yeah. It has some great parts, but it wasn’t really my favorite.

This book is a story of polar opposites attracting. Julian is an orderly everything is planned down to the min professor who is currently on sabbatical from his ivy league job and is back at his family’s winery trying to work on a book. Hallie is all about sunshine and flowers and getting messy, with her life and her gardening.

Sometimes the trope was a bit much and made the conflict seem silly. But Tessa does pull out the hotness between these two and it’s easy to get swept away in it.

Overall, I enjoyed the book, but I don’t know if it’s one I really need to read again which is why I am giving it 3 stars. However, the setup for the next characters in the series has me salivating to read Julian’s sister’s book.

Was this review helpful?

This book was as wonderful as I knew it would be. It was sweet and spicy. Hallie and Julian were an amazing couple to follow. I loved Hallie's haphazard personality, and how she pulled Julian out of his rut. He was so straight laced and regimented he needed to learn how to color outside the lines. I flew through the book and did not want it to end. I have read so many by Tessa Bailey, and I have never been let down. The book is 3rd person, but you get both characters thoughts and feelings. I definitely can't wait for Natalie's book!

Was this review helpful?

This book exceeded all my expectations. The characters were well-developed, and their romance was believable. It was a fun sizzling romance, and I can't wait to read the sequel.

Was this review helpful?

Tessa Bailey is typically an auto read/buy author for me but this one is glad I won't be purchasing. While the grump and sunshine trope is a favorite of mine the execution of this story was a bit all over the place between the shifting perspectives and inconsistent side characters. In the end for me the repetitive use of the word "folds" made me skip over a good chunk of the steamy scenes.

Was this review helpful?

If a romance novel has the grumpy/sunshine trope, it’s pretty much guaranteed that I’ll love it. This one was no exception! Add in a charming Napa setting, a dysfunctional family, a cast of perfectly imperfect characters, and mental health and body positivity topics, and this book becomes a home run. Hallie, our female MC, is a lovable, disorganized gardener in Napa harboring a 15 year old crush on Julian. When anxious,, structured Julian returns home to his family’s vineyard, he can’t seem to stay away from Hallie, even if she brings too much chaos to his routine. Secretly Yours earned 3.5/5, rounded up to 4 stars from me. For the sake of not providing spoilers, I’ll just say that it didn’t get 5 stars because a couple of plot components weren’t quite right to me. However, I’d still recommend this sweet romance to most lovers of the genre.

Was this review helpful?

Tessa Bailey does it again!

"And if nothing comes from this, your main takeaway should be that someone out here thinks about you, in the best way possible, even on your worst day."

Gah! Sign me up for swoon-worthy love letters. "Secretly Yours" adds one whirlwind, impulsive gardener and one buttoned-up college professor to create a love story that I couldn't put down. It also takes an honest look into a male MC with anxiety (so often we see this in the female leads, so I really appreciated the switch up).

Miscommunication in a main storyline is a consistent pet peeve of mine. However, this one wasn't too distressing, and the characters were level-headed enough (and likable enough) that it didn't really bother me. I can't wait for Natalie's story next!

Many thanks to Netgalley and Avon & Harper Voyager for the advance copy. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I've been a huge Tessa Bailey fan for awhile but this book completely sealed the deal for me, auto buy author for the rest of time. Hallie and Julian will officially hold a special place in my heart forever.

There was so many things to love about this story: anxiety representation, the secret admirer letters (yes I did send one of these back in the day), the side characters, family, clashing personalities, and the growth that was shown throughout the book. The banter had me smiling and laughing at my phone and the steam, as always with Tessa Bailey, was just right.

Read this if you like:
- dual POV
- opposites attract
- protective/possessive MMC

Thank you to NetGalley and Avon for allowing me to be an early reader.

Was this review helpful?

It's really no surprise that I loved this book. I've loved every Tessa Bailey books I've gotten my hands on so this one was a no-brainer. Actually, this might be my new favorite Bailey novel, which is saying something considering how much I've loved her others.

Bailey has a way of creating and developing characters that are both unique and extremely relatable. Their backstories make so much sense in showing the reason they are the way they are today. Also, Bailey isn't afraid to make imperfect characters that make crazy choices and do ridiculous things. Characters that are still working on being better people and have to change throughout the book.

"If she's upset, I'm upset. And I don't think you want that."
Can I take a second to express my love for Julian Vos? He was this grumpy, time-obsessed, anxious man, that deserved all the love and happiness in the world. And, coincidentally, that's all he wanted to give Hallie. Happiness and smiles and sunshine. I couldn't get enough of him especially when we would get a glimpse into his thoughts and fears. He was the cutest and spiciest man and I really hope I get to see a little more of him in Natalie's book!

Hallie was a lovely ray of sunshine that gave me secondhand embarrassment in the best possible way. I simultaneously wanted to be her best friend and steal her man. And the poor girl had 15 years of pining under her belt. She deserved a trophy or something for holding out for so long!

On top of my love for the characters, the writing was top-notch. The way Hallie and Julian described their emotional and physical feelings was visceral and beautiful. I don't know how Bailey continues to find the words to write such beautiful and romantic books, but she does and she does so well.

Overall, this was a great reading experience, and I'm beyond excited that the second book featuring Julian's sister, Natalie, is also being released this year! Catch me fangirling until then.

Was this review helpful?

Due to the controversy over this author I will not be continuing to read this story. I do hope that nothing further happens with this author and that she can say something to mitigate the situation.

Was this review helpful?

This one was just okay for me. Loved the grumpy/sunshine. Napa setting was all right. I usually love seeing anxiety represented in my books because I can really connect with it, but Julian's version of it fell a bit flat for me.

Thank you too Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for my thoughts.

Was this review helpful?

First off thank you NetGalley for giving me an ARC of Secretly Yours by Tessa Bailey.
I want to say that I love Tessa Bailey. I really love Hallie and how much of a opposite Julian is to her.
I will say that this book isn’t one of my favorite Tessa Bailey books. Julian rubbed me wrong, some of the things he said about Hallie gave me the icks! Also the smut wasn’t spot on for me it was different. I really had high hopes for “Secretly Yours” but it kind of flopped. I will continue to read all of Tessa’s books though!

Was this review helpful?

SO. GOOD. Pacing was perfect, with the smut being INCREDIBLE and done with charm.

These characters are so loveable. The setting so vivid.

This is my favorite by Tessa Bailey so far!

Thank you NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for giving me an ARC copy of this book to read and review. All of these thoughts and comments are my own.

First I want to say that I love Tessa Bailey. I could read her books all day. She just has a way to right cute, funny, and steamy romance novels.

I really love how corky Hallie is. I love how much of a opposite she is to Julian. She’s outgoing, crazy, and so unorganized and Julian suffers from awful anxiety to cope with it, he is very to himself and so organized to were he is literally on a schedule. So, mix them together and you just get this big, fun mess of a couple lol.

I will say though that this book didn’t impress me as much as the others. The plot was lacking in some places and the way she wrote some of the smut in this book made me cringe. They way she would switch to G rated words to R rated words didn’t really make sense to me. Like you already said cruse words and gave sexual descriptions, why switch back and forth to child-like words. Also how she would have Julian sexy talk Hallie in some parts just wasn’t it. I wasn’t a huge fan of how he constantly pointed out that she “jiggled”. Idk it just didn’t rub me the right way. I don’t think she meant anything by it at all but I just didn’t like the way it was worded I guess.

All in all I did enjoy the book. It was fast pace and I read it in one sitting. I’d give them a good 4 stars!

Was this review helpful?