As a huge fan of The Italian Party, I was curious to see what Christina Lynch would do next. Her sophomore effort was almost a tale of two stories. I now know why I saw several reviews from readers that refused to finish the book. I was not a fan of the first half, but came around in the second.
Sally Brady has a rough start to life, as an 11 year old in the Depression sent off by her parents to find work in California. As luck would have it, she’s adopted by a film star. The story quickly moves to prewar Italy. Sally is a gal with the ability to land on her feet no matter the circumstances.
The story is told and alternates between 3 perspectives. The first is Sally’s, who has gone on to become an impossibly young gossip columnist. Lapo, an Italian writer and farmer, whose writing Mussolini takes a fancy to, and his son, Alessandro, aged 17, an anti-fascist but still of draft age. He ends up in the Italian army in Prague.
It’s obvious that Lynch was trying to balance the humor inherent in the idea of a young gossip columnist caught in Italy with the horrors the Italian government visited on their country. But the first half of Sally’s story comes across as trite and silly. To be honest, I initially found her irritating in the extreme. “I was careful to wear my red arm band, even when it clashed with my outfit.”
I was much more interested in Lapo’s and Allessandro’s stories. Here, Lynch doesn’t attempt to be silly. These two are allowed to bear serious witness to what’s happening. “Alessandro remembered one of his professors saying that as societies collapse they spend more money on wars, police and prisons.”
The story is slow to start, taking ages to get to what I would consider the “meat” of the story. Once it did, though, I became more engaged. Sally becomes more real, not quite so silly. In essence, she grows up.
Elise Roth is the narrator and captures Sally’s devil may care, perky manner. She’s less successful on the parts of the story concerning Lapo and Alessandro. In fact, her attempt at a voice for Felice Pappone made him sound like a boy, not a 6’2” bruiser of a man.
My thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin’s Press/Macmillan Audio for an advance copy of this book.

3.0 stars

Thank you to Christina Lynch, St. Martin's Press, and NetGallery for the opportunity to read this book!

First off, I think that the title and description of this book are not quite on point. It was NOT an Italian adventure and a lot of it takes place during WWII. Some of the book takes place in Hollywood, then Rome, and then finally in Siena. The part in Hollywood was just to set up the book and the time in Rome was about typical socialite parties and good times. When the book really gets into WWII and the hardships and difficulties of the Italian people under Mussolini.

The book jumps back and forth between the three main protagonists which made it hard to follow at times. Also, some of the characters - are just not believable to me. I cannot imagine some of the things that happened in this book really happening, but who knows? It just didn't ring true to me.

VERY lukewarm recommendation

This story had so much depth I don’t know where to begin. There is humour, which might seem weird in a book about the war, but sometimes humour makes it easier to cope. I loved following Sally as she grew.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advance copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

A story told from three points of view, starting in the USA in the 1930s and then on to Italy, leading up to and including much of WW2. Although much of the story has a serious tone to it, when Sally's parts are told, there is some humor injected into what's going on. There were sections that seemed to drag, making me want to hurry along, but then it would pick-up and be more interesting.
I received an ARC copy from NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions are my own.

In 1931, at 11 years of age, Sally is sent by her family, struggling on a farm in Iowa, to LA to try to find a job in order to send money back to them. By chance, she ends up being “adopted” by a Hollywood actress which leads her on an adventure in Italy as a socialite/anonymous gossip columnist. Then the Fascists take over and World War II ensues. Meanwhile, Lapo, married to an American wife and owner of a dilapidated farm and castle, finds himself the attention of Mussolini while his son, Alessandro, is conscripted into the army.

The story is told in three POVs, Sally’s, Lapo’s, and Alessandro’s. As strange as it sounds, to me, Sally was a bit of a comic character and her part of the story was almost a light hearted look at the atrocities of WWII. Hidden in the text, however, are important lessons for today’s world. The dangers of a cult of personality and conspiracy theorists who seem ridiculous until they start running for offices and winning…how strange it is to “live in an era when things were going backward”…the hatred and intolerance that lead to Fascism…one person who says he alone can fix things….the role of women and how many men, especially authoritarian, try to subjugate them. One thought I found especially relevant in our time was when the question is raised as to whether our senses of right and wrong are formed by the stories we hear.

Although it had a bit of a farfetched plot, I found the book an enjoyable read. It may not be to everyone’s taste; it has a somewhat different take from typical WWII historical novels. I appreciated it for the sparks of humor, satire, and profound insight.

Insightful and entertaining. I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I liked learning more about Italy during the war
Many thanks to St. Martin’s Press and to NetGalley for providing me with a galley in exchange for my honest opinion.

I was surprised to see the changes in narrators, but greatly appreciated the switching from first to third perspective. It gave me some of the feels that the Storied Life of AJ Fikry

A dual storyline that brings us to Italy during the war. We see numerous characters that bring depth to the story. 1930/40s Italy is a an era I love reading about, This novel does not disappoint.
Thank you NetGalley.

I love historical fiction and this novel by Christina Lynch provided a ton of information about Mussolini’s fascist takeover of Italy and its affect on the lives of their people. It was more than just historical events, but she lightened up the tale with the story of Sally Brady, her abandonment by her parents during the depression years and how she was adopted by a movie actress and introduced to the high living of Hollywood and later Italy, when her adopted mother Elsa whisked them both off, living the high life of expatriates, until the war started.
Christina Lynch is a wonderful storyteller, with her riveting descriptions of the castles, parties, and glamour of the party scene! Her characters are interesting and she manages to throw in some familiar characters to add authenticity to the story.
My thanks to NetGalley, the author and St Martins press for the ARC. It’s definitely four star worthy.

Ugh. Did not finish and I will suffer through most books. It was slow moving and couldn't figure out all the points of view. I will say the first chapter or two grabbed me but it was all down hill from there.

Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC.

Unfortunately, I didn't love Sally Brady's Italian Adventure. The first half, though slow, was better than the second. Who doesn't enjoy reading about 1930's Hollywood, the parties, high society, and movie stars. The second half of the story delved more into WWII and Sally's "adventures" in Italy after she is unable to return to America during the war. Some of the events seemed far-fetched, there were characters that were too frivolous for the times and plots that seemed too humorous given what was going on in the world. I felt it hard to really develop a connection to the characters and it wasn't the type of "adventure" I was expecting to read about. Thank you to NetGalley for the Advanced Copy.

1 "light, trite, stale, vapid" star !!

Thank you to Netgalley, St. Martin's Press and to the author (not for this book but her wonderful melodrama The Italian Party). This will be released June 2023. I am providing my honest review.

I decided to dnf this at 33 percent. This started at three stars and was slowly trekking downward and I wanted to have a few positive feelings about this author's first book...the Italian Party.

O how I loved the Italian Party...stylish, funny as fuck and lots of playful romantic melodrama...my 7th favorite read of 2020 and a whopping five stars !

Sadly Sally was another case whatsoever....unbelievable, silly, stale, so NOT funny and lots of cliche....this was one of the biggest letdowns ever !

So I am not going to finish this and keep that wonderful Italian Party at the forefront of my mind as I want to continue believing that Ms. Lynch is a talented writer. Is she? Her third book will be my deciding factor.

Thank you to @netgalley and the publisher for the #AdvanceReviewCopy

Summary: This Historical Fiction story set in Italy during WW2 follows Sally’s adventures as she’s forced (by her parents) as a little girl to leave her childhood home in the USA in search for a job to help feed the family. While homeless, Sally meets a woman who takes her in and they travel to Italy where Sally grows up to be a secret gossip columnist writing about the rich and famous. Sally’s life is full of parties, exposure to designer things and secrets, but when Italy declares war on The USA, as an American, her life changes.

My thoughts: I LOVED this book. I loved Sally and her wit and charm. This is a multiple POV story with Sally in the forefront; her chapters are told in 1st person whereas the others are 3rd person. This distinguishes Sally from the rest of the story and enlightens the fact that the others are there to set the stage and help move the story along. When the characters’ stories converge, you’ll already be at the edge of your seat, hoping, willing and rooting them on.

This is is a beautiful story you’ll get lost in, learn from, and truly enjoy.

Sally Brady’s Italian Adventure lives up to its title in surprising ways. Sally is a plucky and persistent heroine, sent away by her family to make her own life as a young person. While no stranger to struggle, she also becomes very familiar with luck, getting informally adopted by a movie star and wrapped into the world of bourgeois parties. This life takes her to Italy, where her keen observation and sharp social skills helps her caregiver complete a gossip column about the rich, famous, and royal. As Mussolini comes to power and Italy’s growing fascism threatens their safety, Sally must find new ways to both be hidden and seen, deepening her competence in survival.

Sally is not the only narrator, as Lynch also introduces us to Lapo, a writer turned farmer in the Italian countryside and Alessandro, his son who searches for purpose and morality in a moment in time that challenges everyone’s sense of humanity. While giving us a similar character depth as Sally, Lynch also uses these voices to keep the reader engaged with the history of the moment. As someone who didn’t know a lot about Mussolini’s time in power, she manages not to be heavy handed with it, but rather present it in context with the character’s realities.

Lynch balances a lot with the novel and is successful with its multiple effects on the reader. The historical context asks the reader to consider their own morals and empathy, to question how political and social pressure might change who they think they are. At the same time, Lynch is a writer who ultimately wants to give the reader a full adventure: the excitement, joys, and panics of being in unfamiliar places and situations that force us to grow.

**this review will be on Goodreads, Instagram, and developing other promotional content directly with the author.

Thank you to the author and publisher for providing me with a digital ARC of this tile via Netgalley in exchange for my honest review.

I was not familiar with this title or author before coming across it on Netgalley. It was not what I was expecting, but I found it to be an ok read.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the advanced copy. I love this book! Christina Lynch has written a wonderful book with characters to fall on love with. Historical fiction at it best.

Wow, what a great story! Definitely loved the Italian influence in this book. The character was an amazing addition to this storyline and pretty much made the whole book. Must read!

From the Dust Bowl in America to European boarding school to Italy under Mussolini. Wow= this book covers a big journey. This is a satisfying historical novel.

Sally Brady's Italian Adventure provides a different take on WWII history following Sally from Dust Bowl America to Musollini's Italy. I found the story very charming and overall it was a very quick read that I enjoyed, The characters pop off the page and provide a side of WWII fiction.

I seem to be on a WWII kick lately. Loved this tale of Mussolini's Italy filled with wit and humor (which is hard to come by). Abandoned as a dust bowl orphan and eventually sent off to boarding school in Switzerland, Sally Brady lived the dream when all of sudden she was an enemy in a war torn country. The plot lost me a bit but overall I enjoyed it!