First, a big thank you to the publisher & NetGalley for providing a free eARC in exchange for an honest review.

As a huge fan of The Whisper Man, I was really excited to read another book from Alex North. The Angel Maker, however, didn’t quite work for me.

One major pitfall is the amount of characters it follows, paired with the minimal development of each one. I’d have a hard time 1) listing all of the characters, or 2) telling you anything about their personality. There were elements of some characters I thought were very interesting, but not a lot of payoff throughout the book. We also jump around in the timeline, but not in a very cohesive way, and it really made it hard to focus.

Next, the plot is quite convoluted. Trying to decide on a basic plot summary is proving to be a challenge because there are so many different threads, but they don’t all tie together quite as neatly as I expected. Ultimately, a violent event in childhood alters the course of Chris Shaw’s life, and leaves his older sister, Katie, with lingering feelings of guilt. We fast forward to their adulthood, and the siblings have drifted apart. However, their stories get thrown together when Chris disappears & Katie is left to figure out why. Then there’s a plot line with an old serial killer religious fanatic who believes he can tell the future…

There is a lot thrown in the pot, yet the story felt really long and honestly quite slow. There was also a sort of random supernatural element that felt slightly undeveloped and honestly out of place…it just didn’t work for me.

This is one time where I wish I kept to the physical or ebook version, instead of listening to it. While the narration was great, I had a hard time staying focused and I got lost a bit. Even though I know the ending, I think I'd like to read this book again in a few months to fully get the story. (3.5 rounded up to 4)

The parts of the story I did understand, I thought were great. I really like the way Alex North writes. I thought it was a slow burn with good twists. I don't necessarily think it was a thriller though!

This was my first book by Alex North and it won't be my last! I actually bought The Shadows and am so excited to read it! I was lucky when it came to this book, I have so many copies! Thank you to Celadon Books for my physical and digital copy, and to Macmillan Audio for my audio!

“The Angel Maker” by Alex North
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I enjoyed yet another suspenseful read by North. You had the past coming and meddling in the present and causing all kinds of twists and turns that I didn’t see coming. Katie can’t get past the fact of not being there when her brother was attacked years ago so when called he’s missing she’s on the case. Laurence the detective on the case years ago is now on a murder that has some alarming similarities and the history of a serial killer is emerging making him wonder what the connections may be. The weaving of this story and characters is done so well and left with this sense of eerie all the way through that had you racing to finish.

*thank you Celadon books for this beautiful arc.

Well, I had really high hopes for this one but it just didn’t do it for me. It was confusing at times and felt pretty slow for most of the book. It didn’t really pick up until the last 50 pages. It was entertaining but I don’t think it will be one I recommend. Thank you netgalley for my free copy.

Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC of this book. It was my first book by this author and I look forward to reading more in the future! This book was a tad confusing at first with all the timelines, but once I sorted out the characters it was easier to follow. The twists and reveals had my jaw on the floor and I was invested in the ending and the fate of the characters. It was creepy and I was a bit bothered by some of the religious sacrilege but all in all I really enjoyed it and found it to be a good story.

I'm keeping this review short because NetGalley logged me out after I had written most of a long review but before I hit "Send Review" so I lost the review. The Angel Maker was my third Alex North novel and I have enjoyed each of them. This story took place over two timelines, one mid-to-late-1900's and the other current. The two are tied together by a modern day disappearance. I found the two different timelines pretty easy to follow and was equally interested in both. My average rating is due to the lack of enough character development to get me invested in anyone. Lack of development made me question the likelihood of many decisions or beliefs of characters, which kept me from fully immersing myself in the story like I prefer for my 4 and 5 star reviews.

I had high hopes for this one. I absolutely loved the whisper man but honestly this one just didn’t do it for me. I pushed through because I don’t DNF books but this one was hard.

I really enjoyed Alex North's The Whisper Man so I knew I had to read The Angel Maker. I really enjoyed this book overall, but I thought that there were almost too many characters. In the beginning, I was struggling to keep up with who was who. And they were all men besides Katie and a detective, who was hardly involved in the book. I also feel like there was a lot more that could have been involved regarding the father and how his two sons grew up. There just seemed like a lot missing that could have been included to make the story a little more intriguing.

I found myself having a really hard time following along with this one. I struggled with both audio and digital copies. The prologue hooked me immediately but after I was mostly confused with little to keep me engaged or invested. Thank you Celadon Books for inviting me to read this book.

Decent read. I liked the story line. However, initially it was a bit confusing especially the philosophy parts. Thankfully, it did not impair my reading of the book. Also, not quite a fan of the ending. Overall, the writing and characters were good.

When I read The Whisper Man in January of 2020, I was so impressed. It was everything I wanted in a Crime Thriller. It was gritty, eerie, sordid and compelling. That book single-handedly sealed the fate of my future with this author. I would anxiously await and then eagerly pick up all his new releases.

I ended up really enjoying The Shadows as well. Thus, when I heard about this book, North's most recent release, The Angel Maker, I was over the moon with anticipation. Sadly, this one ended up being a complete miss for me.

I listened to the audiobook and starting out, I was so jazzed. The narration was great and I was stoked to be getting early access to North's new book. The next thing I know, I am 20% in and I have NO CLUE what is happening, who anyone is, or what I am supposed to care about. I can recall the very beginning though, that was interesting and it did stick with me.

A teen girl, who is supposed to walk her brother home from school, chooses not to in lieu of spending some private time with her boyfriend. When she arrives home to police cars, lights and an active investigation, she's horrified to learn her kid brother had been viciously attacked.

Katie and Chris were the siblings. Here I am at the end of the novel and those are the only two characters I would be able to talk about with any confidence at all. I cannot name one other character. Truthfully, I couldn't follow this plot to save my life. It apparently required way more concentration than I was willing to give it. I didn't care at all. There were so many characters, none of which I felt were developed, besides Katie. After the 60%-point, I just wanted it to end and here we are.

With this being said, I am very aware that I am in the minority opinion on this one. There are so many people who read this and absolutely loved it. Therefore, do not take my opinion on this one as anything more than what it is: one Reader's jilted opinion.

Please note, even though this didn't work for me, I still think that Alex North is an incredible author and I will continue to pick up all his future novels. Thank you so much to the publisher, Celadon and Macmillan Audio, for providing me with copies to read and review.

I appreciate the opportunity to provide my opinion and look forward to seeing what North comes up with next.

Thank you NetGalley for an ARC of this book. I love Alex North and this book didn’t disappoint. Chris Shaw and his sister Katie are estranged. The last time they saw each other, Chris stole money from her purse. Chris isn’t the man he could be. When he was a child, a man tried to remove his face. Now that man is out of prison and stalking Katie and her family. Chris’ boss, Alan Hobbs, dies in his bed. Was it murder? Why was Chris there? Why did he destroy the video evidence? This book is also one of those timeless books. There is a car. Not a red 2021 Nissan. There is a phone. Not described as iphone 14. This book will likely be a movie or tv show. The creators of that can set it anywhere. Alex North doesn’t complicate things by telling us towns, or streets, or pub names. This is great for an imaginative reader. Be that reader

Alex North is a gifted story teller. I have a hard time because his books scare me, but it’s worth it as long as I only read during the day. I struggled with all the characters in this book. I felt like I was half done and still being introduced to new players. I wanted to know the story badly enough that I just went with it and didn’t try to hard to keep everyone’s story straight. In the end I really end like the twist and the connections. I’m glad I stick with it.

Alex North will always be something I add to my TBR even with the scary nature of his work.

I give this 3.5 stars. This book is very confusing and it takes a lot to remember who people are and how they fit in the story. There are a lot of twists and turns. There is also an element that makes you think about situations in real life and in your own life. I did find the book interesting and it kept me engaged.

I've had Alex North on my radar for awhile, and my first book of his, The Angel Maker is now behind me.

Immediately after finishing this thriller, I headed to GoodReads to find an explanation for my lack of understanding in the plot and my "what did I just read" confusion. What I found in amongst the very positive reviews, were thoughts like mine: the plot and characters were just too much to keep track of.

The prologue had such promise, and it made me wish that I hadn't started this book right before bed! But then chapter one came, and I found myself questioning what was happening, wondering if maybe my eARC was missing a section, because there just seemed to be a huge gap between the prologue and this first chapter. As I kept reading, I continued to feel overwhelmed and as though I was thrown into a story that felt like it was already traveling at warp speed, with too many characters that weren't fully (or easily) explained, and a plot that I just couldn't grasp.

While I read, I was hopeful that the plot, and the many characters would all come together in a twist that explained things and everything would click into place for me; sadly that "ah ha" moment never came.

It seems everyone loves The Whisper Man and The Shadows (both of which sit on my shelf), and I will pick them up in due time, but I'm not sure I'm in a rush.

Thank you NetGalley and Caladon Books for the complimentary copy to read and review.

I absolutely loved The Whisper Man so was thrilled to read this one.

However, I found it to be confusing. I couldn't quite follow the story which was unfortunate because the setting and plot were fantastic. I still ended up enjoying it but found myself frequently taken out of the story to have to look back for plot points.

Will still be an Alex North fan forever!

I usually read thrillers when I need something "easy" or I'm in a reading slump so The Angel Maker was a little disappointing to me because I really had to concentrate. There were some different timelines to keep track of, a lot of characters (mostly characters that weren't fully developed), and the plot was just very confusing. However, once I realized what was going on it was a quicker, easier read and it did all come together in the end. I think if you love thrillers this one would be great, I think my issues with it are mostly because I don't read thrillers that often and when I do I want them to be quick and easy.

Thank you NetGalley and Celadon books for the ARC.

Oh wow how can I do this book justice in my review without giving away spoilers. So I will just keel my review brief and say it was completely and utterly brilliant.

I was so excited for this one. I loved The Whisper Man and liked The Shadows, but was quite disappointed with this unfortunately. Honestly, the first half of the book, I was just so confused. I found myself not wanting to pick it up again and just bored. The last 25% of the book did keep my interest and have a few twists I didn’t see coming… but I kind of attribute that to the fact that I didn’t know what was going on the first half of the novel. I enjoyed the ending and how everything came together, but it didn’t make up for the rest of the story for me.

Thank you NetGalley for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

This unfortunately was a DNF for me. I really enjoyed the writing style but the abuse within the book was too much for me. I made it roughly 30% through before I had to DNF. I will definitely try other books by Alex North but may look into their subject matter a little bit more before committing!