Member Reviews

As an avid reader of nonfiction, I was excited to delve into this book. While the subject matter intrigued me and I appreciated the author's extensive research, the writing style fell short of my expectations. The prose was excessively embellished, lacking the straightforwardness I prefer in nonfiction.

Moreover, the numerous grammatical and idiomatic errors were a noticeable hindrance to my reading experience. Nevertheless, the book shines when exploring the intricate details of the fire's origins. The author's dedication to thorough investigation deserves recognition.

Was this review helpful?

I was not the intended audience for this book. I love Seattle and the PNW and gravitate towards books from places that I love to visit. Although this was an advanced copy of the book, the initial grammatic and idiomatic errors were distracting. A lot of research was required for the writing of this book and I'm impressed with the author's efforts. I hope that a sufficiently edited edition finds an audience.

Was this review helpful?

I think I might have been the wrong audience for this book. While I love nonfiction and learning when I read, which I did, the writing in this one was not quite what I was expecting. It was more flowery than I would like for nonfiction. I like my facts to be straightforward and, at the same time, entertaining. This was writing that others may appreciate but was lost on me. Also, this book could do with a lot more editing. There were so many grammatical and idiomatic mistakes that it really took away from my enjoyment of the book. I did, however, really enjoy the details surrounding the fire and what caused it. A lot of research went into the completion of this book and I applaud the author's efforts. This just wasn't for me.

Was this review helpful?

I was given an early copy of this ebook in exchange for an honest review. This book is exactly why I love historical fiction.! I learned quite a bit about Americans history that I never even heard of before,, little romance is included as a side story..Several characters to follow throughout the book makes it cohesive. These are just a few of my favorite things. The fire itself was accidentally started but once it got burning, there was no stopping it. Special thanks to #NetGalley, #SkywayPress, #jordanKidd, andSeattle’sGreatFire for allowing me to review early. I would definitely recommend this book.two arms up!

Was this review helpful?

This book is about the Great Fire and not about the Great Fire. This is a fictional account of the settling of Seattle with a focus on the indigenous people of the Duwamish tribe. The book spans several decades of friendship between the Duwamish chief (Chief Si'ahl, namesake of Seattle) and David "Doc" Maynard, a white settler and doctor. Decades before the Great Fire, the chief has a premonition of a fire, but more than one fire will have wide ranging impacts.

I adore historical fiction books like this where many of the "characters" are well known and the events and dialogue are speculation but also entirely plausible. I enjoyed the mix of writing styles, parts were written with beautiful descriptions of the people and places and parts were written in a very modern style with modern idioms and phrases.

If you are interested in learning more about the Duwamish people and the early days of Seattle, I highly recommend checking this book out. I have lived in Seattle my entire life and I definitely learned something new and it piqued my curiosity to learn more.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful book. This book will never let you think of the Pacific Northwest in all it's splendor the same way again.

Was this review helpful?

I feel that I've learned something new from reading this book. I never knew that this happened including how the fire started.
All because of carelessness. I was floored. Not as bad as the Chicago one but bad enough.
I loved how Seattle got its name. After Chief Seattle!
This is why I love historical fiction!
I did find myself looking up these historical events and reading more into them.
This author has definitely done her research well.
The only thing about this book i didn't really like was in how it was written. Sort of of like a narration or diary form if you will.
I will still highly recommend though. This is an interesting book and you'll not want to put it down.
I gave this book 4 stars bc of that.
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?